Discussion Locked

Feel unfair for manager's review.

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello forum,

I am new to a big 4 and I finished my first project. This is an extremely difficult project. According to the senior manager and the client, this project is success. However, my manager doesn't like me. Also, I am an ESL and I did make some grammar mistakes in my draft report. Since it is my first project, the writing style was not 100% match to firm's style. But I made all changes she suggested and appreciated her effort. She gave me a formal review saying " the writing did not meet sufficient standard " and the grammar example to support the statement. Thus I got a very low rating as "partial met the qualification". I am really upset about the result since I worked so hard to this project.

I was first assigned to another manager so I was polite to her but not enthusiatic. For internal arrangement, I was transfered to her. I did try my best to do the good job but I am not close to her. Being a young and new manager, she might be offended and feel challenged by the fact I am playing cool. The rating for me seems like a revenge. :) . By the way, I am a female.

What should I do now? Should I let it go or fight for that? If I decide to fight, how to do that?

Thanks.

3 replies

by jdmercha

But don't brun any bridges either. If something is written in your review that you don't agree with, your manager may not remove it but you should be able to add your side of the story. The trick is to do this very tactfully.

Always look at a review as an opportunity to improve. Find out from this manager what you need to do to get a satisfactory review next year. Write down goals that will help you get there. Then on next years review you will come armed with proof you have met the expectations based on those goals.

by jiansec

After some thoughts, I did the similar thing you suggested. Not matter what stories behind the review, I can benefit from it as long as I really get improved. As a human being with pride (ego), it is easier to say than do to be "open to constructive criticism" in most of the time.

Thanks for the input.

by jgarcia102066

Whenever you feel concerned about the way your manager perceives your work, you don't really want to fight back (that shows a level of immaturity) but rather you want to get more details about the issue.

If I had been faced with your situation in this post, I would have asked my manager the following set of questions:

I am really concerned about having the low rating due to my writing. Can you show me where I my writing is deficient? Do you know of any resources that I can use to help me become a stronger writer? Is there a mentor that I can use to proofread my documents and recommend changes so that I can deliver a better end product?

You may ask many more questions along the same lines but the main idea that you want to get across to your manager is that you recognize you need help and that you are willing to change if you can get the help. A good manager will find you the resources you need to help you succeed. This tactic also presents you as a mature worker.

Good Luck.

This discussion is closed to new replies.