Discussion Locked

File ownership won't change after 'save'

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
We use to have a Novell 5 network and file ownership would belong to the creator of the file, then when it was edited and saved by a different user that user would take ownership of the file. In other words who ever saved it last owned the file, regardless of who created it. Now we have moved to a windows 2000 server (was sp2 now sp3) and domain. I've noticed that the file ownership doesn't change after a save. So if a file is created by user 'me' then edited and saved by user 'you' the file ownership still belongs to 'me'. Does anyone know how to correct this situation? I noticed that the same happens on a win2k pro station as well.

6 replies

by dwdino

Correct?

This is correct. Just because a child may take out and have the parents car painted doesn't make it the childs car.

But to answer "How to change owner?":

1) right click on file and choose properties.
2) click on security tab.
3) click "advanced" button near botttom.
4) click on owner tab.
5) Change owner to administrators, then repeat to new user owner.

by timwalsh

Microsoft approaches the ownership issue using a more universally accepted definition of ownership (f I let you use something of mine, like a file, that doesn't mean that you now own it. I have to give it to you first). The creator of a file remains the owner of the file unless:

1. An administrator takes ownership. An administrator can seize ownership of any file/folder regardless of any permissions granted. The administrator cannot transfer ownership to others.
2. The current owner of the file/folder gives the "Take ownership" permission to other users/groups. Users having this permission can then take ownership AT ANY TIME (whether the file was changed or not).

Hope this helps.

by bburdzel

What you say about the car is true, but I believe that the Novell way is more appropriate. We've got Interns scanning photos, slides, and all kinds of things - only to have the professional staff edit and touch up these photos. I guess in your comparison it would be kind of like the car dealer. They did not create the car but they also don't own the car after the point of sale. It blows the whole concept of controlling network space by limiting user quotas and forcing users to clean up after themselves. Our worst offenders don't have a mb to their name, and our interns are definitely not qualified to erase, or archive the information. We also have no way of knowing who to contact about specific projects because all files are in joe interns name. I think Novell's way is much better from the management aspect.

Does anyone know of a 3rd party software that would work to make it more like Novell's?

by curlergirl

Well, you do have a unique situation that doesn't fit into the general definition of how to manage disk quotas. My suggestion would be to set quotas so that the interns don't have any quotas, so that the files they scan initially won't be included in your quota management. Then, you would have to require the professional who is going to work on the file to take ownership in order to work on it. This could easily be done by giving them NO rights to access, open or read the files in their initial location (where they are saved when scanned in). Then, they HAVE to take ownership in order to work on the file. You will need to show them how to do this, and you would need to move the files from their initial location (where they are initially saved and ownership is established and the users have NO rights), to a location where they have Full Control rights, so that they will be able to take ownership. I've never tested this out, but I think it would work. Hope this helps!

This discussion is closed to new replies.