Discussion Locked

Firefox a threat to security products security?

0 helpful
78 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have been reading several reviews lately discussing FireFox and security.

The most recent was by Andy Dornan of http://wires.ITarchitect.com, with that article titled "No one ever caught spyware from Firefox".
http://tinyurl.com/b24pp

The main point is it seems to be the security VENDORS that are having an issue here because it has the ability to reduce the NEED for so much of IT's spending on security with not using the intigrated, ActiveX using MicroSoft Internet Explorer.

Do you think we are getting a straight feed on the security and stability of alternative browsers from companies that have a vested interest in you NOT switching to a secure browser?

78 replies

by jaqui

getting the straight goods from thier point of view.
if we don't use ie they have to find new jobs so it's better if we do use ie.

any pro ms review is suspect as the reviewer is probably making money off us for some product that only runs on windows.

by jdclyde

First, in the article I sited, he admits that FF will NOT stop every threat out there.

Second, notice the VERSION of FF that was used in "vitalsecurity.org"'s unbiased article. 1.0.1? Would like them to try this on 1.7 that is the current version. (of course, the article was written in March, but how long did it take for a fix, and HAS it been fixed?)

Another question, has SUN fixed their JAVA as that what is the leak here, not the browser?

I walk out with more questions than answers..... :D

by bfilmfan

I agree that FireFox can't stop all exploits due to the holes in Microsoft's code.

I just wanted less-experienced tech support folks to realize that they were not safe from exploits just because they are running FireFox.

My answer to being less vulnerable is to run your workstation OS virtualized (I prefer VMWare) and if you get infected, well you just delete that file and replace it with your backup copy.

by jaqui

proves what I have said before, clientside scripting is a security hole, do not use java, javascript, vbscript or activex, do not have them enabled on your browser at all, ever.

do not put any plugins / addons in to extend the functionality. they all do nothing but create security holes.

by faradhi

This is impractical in the business world. Since end users expect flash with substance. There are a lot of web based apps that depend on client side scripting. Many are specific to an industry. I recently worked with a college that had a library management system that had a web front end. Most colleges use the web for registration. In my current position, there are many accounting apps that use web pages to deliver accounting specific content.

In short, while I would love to do away with all active content and return to the days of static web pages. It just is not possible in the current real world.

by jdclyde

it is just poor thinking to have anything connected to a browser that would be able to make changes to your system.

Regardless of what the permissions the user has, IE should always be FORCED to run as a low end user that can only read and write to a temp folder that is cleared ever time the browser is closed.

Why would ANYONE want a browser to have admin rights?

Also, don't trade "ease of use" for functionality and reliablitiy. Anything that allows a virus/trojan/malware to take over your system or your users systems is hurting reliablity.

Poor design and implimentation is no excuse.

The other problem is coders without a clue that make the "For IE only" pages, that have never heard of something called "industry standards".

by faradhi

It is Common sense that IE shouldn't be run with admin rights. I do not know why MS makes it possible to make system changes from IE.

Additionally, I cannot stand IE only pages. It is not that hard to write pages that look right through most browsers.

I just do not believe that removing all client side scripting is practical. I would love it. I just cannot do it in the business environment I work in.

by jaqui

I have to problems by not having clientside scripting on my systems.
If I run across a site that requires it, I just leave and never go back.

by grantwparks

I laughed when the help desk at Laplink said my problem was caused by a *bug* in Ff, and the solution was to run a separate .reg file. So Laplink thinks the browser should let scripts update the registry.

by jdclyde

use your co-workers for the porn instead of your own! B-)

"and if it gets infected, well you just" use a different co-workers system! :D

(Hey, you can't expect me to be serious all the way through a discussion, now can you?) ;\

by apotheon

It's not client-side scripting that's the security problem: it's the fact that the script execution environment leaks like a sieve in every implementation I've seen for things like Javascript, Flash, Java applets, and so on. Firefox does a reasonably good job of limiting the damage that can by done, by allowing the user to turn off all but the most basic Javascript functionality -- this makes it safe enough to satisfy my tastes, for now. Of course, if it wasn't for the low-hanging fruit syndrome (I'm safe because the exploits are aimed at easier vulnerabilities than that), I wouldn't be so willing to use even this neutered Javascript functionality, simply because Javascript-capable browsers don't do a good enough job of keeping scripts running on them separate from the OS on which they're running.

by jaqui

they don't have much choice. both of them get thier paycheques when I sign them.
{ I am the "Boss", it's my company }

by jdclyde

This wasn't about if FF is the single cure for your blues, it was about if the Security Industry is being biased because they don't WANT you looking for a cure, they want you to buy their product.

Can we trust the keepers of the keys when they have a VESTED interest in keeping us unsafe and afraid?

That is the key to THEIR survival after all.

by faradhi

I have often thought the same thing. Why would suckmantec or McCrappy come up with a system to eliminate the virus threat. The incentive is not there. I have also said the same thing about pharmaceutical companies as well. Oppps that is off topic :)

I have also be accused of being a consipiracy nut job too. (There was someone on the grassy knoll.)

by apotheon

I agree.

There. On-topic.

I have a tendency to avoid posting "metoo" comments, since they don't really contribute much to discussion, but since you asked for strictly on-topic I've posted this one.

by jdclyde

but a FEW would have been nice! :D

A round table discussion about the sources we get our information from, and how to get them to be up front was all I was looking for, not everyone just falling in step telling me how grand I am. (I already know THAT one!) :^O

I guess this is what I get when I walk away from the watercooler and try to be serious.....

by noyoki

:P

For the rest of us that work for "The Man", it's not that simple was all that I meant.

by matthew yurksaitis

The Article about Firefox bieng a threat to security vendors because no one has ever "caught" spyware from firefox is really misleading and written using rose colored glasses.

Here is a sample vulnerability of Firefox as listed with C.E.R.T.:

-----------------------------------------------
Vulnerability Note VU#519317
Mozilla Firefox fails to properly perform security checks on "_search" target
Overview
A vulnerability in Mozilla Firefox may allow a remote attacker to install malicious code on or read protected information from a vulnerable system.
I. Description
The Firefox web browser features the ability to open a hyperlink in the "search" web panel. Firefox fails to perform adequate security checks on links opened in the web panel. According to the Mozilla advisory on this issue:
Sites can use the _search target to open links in the Firefox sidebar. Two missing security checks allow malicious scripts to first open a privileged page (such as about:config) and then inject script using a javascript: url. This could be used to install malicious code or steal data without user interaction.

Updated versions of the Firefox browser disallow javascript: and data: URIs from being opened in the search Web panel. They also perform an additional security check to prevent privileged pages, such as about:plugins, from being opened in the search Web panel.
II. Impact
A remote attacker may be able to install malicious code on or read protected information from a vulnerable system.
III. Solution
Upgrade

The Mozilla Software Foundation has published Mozilla Foundation Security Advisory 2005-39 in response to this issue. Users are encouraged to review this advisory and upgrade to the versions of the affected software it refers to.

Workarounds

Users who are unable to upgrade to a fixed version of the software are encouraged to disable Javascript in their browsers.

Systems Affected
Vendor Status Date Updated
Mozilla, Inc. Vulnerable 22-Dec-2005
Red Hat, Inc. Vulnerable 22-Dec-2005

References

http://www.mozilla.org/security/announce/mfsa2005-39.html
https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=290079
http://secunia.com/advisories/14938/
http://secunia.com/advisories/14992/

Credit
Thanks to the Mozilla Foundation for reporting this vulnerability. The Mozilla Foundation, in turn, credits Kohei Yoshino with reporting this issue to them.

This document was written by Chad Dougherty and Will Dormann based on information provided by the Mozilla Foundation.

Other Information
Date Public 04/15/2005
Date First Published 04/20/2005 04:52:51 PM
Date Last Updated 12/22/2005
CERT Advisory
CVE Name CAN-2005-1158
Metric 18.90
Document Revision 12

If you have feedback, comments, or additional information about this vulnerability, please send us email.

------------------------------------------------

Who needs spyware when such a vulnerability anllows data to be read? There are numerous other vulnerabilities listed in C.E.R.T. as well as other such tracking systems so Firefox along with all other vendors will keep security Vendors in business for a long time to come, it's really just a matter of how diversified the security vendor is in thier discipline.

by jdclyde

as of Firefox 1.0.3, this was no longer an issue. So that means in 1.0, 1.0.1 and 1.0.2 this was available.

FF is on verson 1.5.

Sounds like they were right on the ball getting this fixed. How long is common for a "fix" from MS? Six months is short on the average.

How many critical exploits have there been in FF in the last year? Compare that to IE. How many of the IE got fixed as quickly?

Next will come the arguement about how FF is only just now becoming a target, and bigger target will equal more exploits being found.

The problem with this, is it doesn't take into concideration the open source.

MS will assign a team to work on a problem as it arises.

Open source has people globally looking over the code on how to make it better and to find and fix exploits. Not on a 9-5 for a paycheck, but all the time (global community, remember) for the social status of being the first to find and fix something.

Which project is getting more man hours spent on it do you thing?
Which project do you think people are working harder on? paycheck or social esteem?

Anyone knows in business that money is not a great motivator over time. If people aren't happy with what they do, and don't have a feeling of satisfaction in what they do, they will do it poorly. (as seen in how many applications got broke simply by installing a service pack on XP, MANY of the applications were MS applications even!)

On a personal note: I was spending about 80% of my time removing malware that made systems unusable until I moved everyone to FF. Now it is down to closer to 5%. Same with virus infection.

by tony hopkinson

I use FF because it has 99.99% of the functionality I need in a browser and it's much safer than IE. Not safe , safeR.

Like JD I have continuing proof that I'm much less susceptible to a wide range of threats using FF, and I have to spend much less time coping with it. That's what counts to me, anyone who told me FF was a silver bullet, I would simply consider an idiot.

by matthew yurksaitis

In one of the previous posts was a discussion regarding the incentive for security vendors to find a fix for Viruses & trojans etc.. and that security vendors have no incentive as this would put them out of business.

Interesting theory - but let's examine this point:

Security Vendors are in existance as a result of a need which comes from the user community wanting more open access, ease of use, complex and robust hardware & software. As a results commercial vendors produces these products, which have defects which can be exploited. Now comes the slighty darker side of our human nature, those who exploit such vulnerabilities as pranks for fun, acts of anger & retribution, acts of opportunity (it was there so I did it - i.e the recent posts on wardriving & legal).

So is it really the security vendors who have no incentive to fix security issues? or is it really the exploitative group of users who have no incentive to work with commercial product & security vendors to fix the issues as then they would no longer be able to "have fun", "get back at someone or some company" or "just prove a point".? - Kind of like the Criminal, The Police and the Legal system - or even the chicken & the egg?

by jdclyde

The DO want to be the one savior to you and your organization, but they also want you using a product that NEEDS a savior.

Right off the bat, not tying the browser into the OS adds security and stability. Not having AcitiveX is another.

This could even go back to the diferences on how exploits are handled by Windows vs Linux.

An exploit in windows is covered by installing a software firewall, running AntiVirus and AntiSpyware.

An exploit in Linux is covered by re-writting the code that had an exploit.

I agree with the article, that FF, Opera, and others are not looked at fairly because the security industry doesn't WANT you on secure software. They want you scared and buying their package to protect the insecure systems.

by tony hopkinson

but did we want want that coupled with a lack of security. Does ease of use mean a lack of security, personally I don't see why.
Just as a example Outlook's preview pain.
Great idea you don't have to click on an email to see what's in it. However any sensible admin would rip the head off of anyone who had it turned on, so what did we actually get ?

As for the necessity of security vendors well there is an argument that if there were no threats, we wouldn't need them. But the initial threats that got them in business were created by the market they now take advantage of. After all if we hadn't decided some actions were crminal we would n't need the police either.

by apotheon

"[i]Great idea you don't have to click on an email to see what's in it. However any sensible admin would rip the head off of anyone who had it turned on, so what did we actually get ?[/i]"
Good point. For instance, I actually open an email entirely, look at attachments, and so on, even when I know there's a decent chance it's spam, on a system that I have set up in a manner where it's not important whether it gets compromised (for a number of reasons). I do it all the time. I never get an infection, get rooted, or anything else long those lines, though.

The reason this works is simple: I'm using mutt for email, on a Linux system. I'm not using Outlook or Outlook Express on Windows.

by too old for it

1) When virus / trojan horse / back-door hackers first went to work, no one brought the battle directly to their doorstep. (Some of you may have seen my ravings about black ops dragging some kid up from the basement and lopping his hands off at the wrists for writing a port scanner-trojan dropper as a solution. I'm not kidding. This will be a deterrent.)

2) Security (Sarbanes-Oxley, HIPPA, whatever) will be a big concern with major corporations when it can be done in China for the equivalent of 50? an hour on tired old 486-class servers, with 5-9's reliability. Not before.

by dfirefire

It is true that IE is the main target for spyware etc. Because it has the most users, and because M$ has a stupid habit of implementing unsafe all-mighty gadgets in its programs, like ActiveX.
Also, FF has some issues. Chances are that they will be solved quicker than with M$, but the main advantage is that FF users are, for now, a smaller market. But it is to be expected that FF will become the victim of its success. As soon as its market share will have grown sufficiently, spyware and other programmers will target it. And then we'll switch to the next safe browser, like Opera...
Security vendors exist because there is a need. Of course, they are happy with the constant flow of threats, because it's their life line! It might even be that they have virus writers on their payroll. Ever seen the movie 'The Net'? I don't know if it is true, does anyone?

by apotheon

That whole "it's only vulnerable because it's used widely" thing is ridiculous. It has been debunked over and over again. Compare IIS vulnerabilities with Apache vulnerabilities sometime, and notice that Apache is used about twice as widely as IIS without having anywhere near the same league of vulnerability exploits to see what I mean.

I'm getting tired of pointing out the fallacious reasoning that leads to the assumption that some bug-ridden, unsecured, poorly designed, crufty, broken-assed piece of Microsoft crap software is only more vulnerable because it's "popular".

Get a clue, folks. Seriously. This is the first time I've had to say something like this on TR this year, but last year I've had to point this little factoid out more than a hundred times. That is just absurd. Quit drinking the Microsoft kool-aid and learn to think for yourself, folks.

by dfirefire

I said that IE is MORE vulnerable because of it's bigger market share, not that that was the only reason!
It's not more vulnerable because it's popular, but it's a better target for people who want to get their viruses spread. I'm talking about marketing strategy on this matter, not software design. If you read my previous comment again, I also mentioned the bad habit of M$ to implement unsafe, allmighty gadgets. This is about design...
I certainly don't want to discredit FF, I even am a dedicated user for years now...

by noyoki

M$ Kool-Aid... that's just awesome.

Lol. Kool-Aid by itself stains anything and everything, just imagine what it does to your stomach! Now add in M$ viruses that take over your system... Oi!

by matthew yurksaitis

In reading your resplies to my posts I believe that you may be missing the point of my posts. It does not matter what product is out there or available, they all have flaws, defects etc.. and the human factor has the biggest part in the equation, not the actual hardware or software product. So whether it is firefox, or some other product with little or no market presence or one that has significant market presence the need for security will always be there until humans are perfect and always do good, and develop products with no flaws.

Now to a couple of your points. In regard to Firefox and Unix/Linux fixes of rewriting code and the problem is solved. While this may be true - isn't that the definition of a "patch" essentially re-written or corrected code to fix and issue? In regards to the percentage of users affected and percentage of workload to deal with issues - This can easily be attributed to the fact of market presence and penetration, simply put there is not as large user base for these products as there are for others (whether it is windows or something else)therefore the amount of time spent on supporting such issues is less as the opportunity to exploit such vulnerabilities is not as prevalent or noteworthy. So the driving factor here is really how well known & used are the products in the marketplace, if Linux/Unix, Firefox and other such products gain market prevelence then they would also have a significant increase in exploited vulnerabilities and meet the same challenges. So in short - unless the human weakness element dissappears the need for security will remain, the products & vulnerabilites and expolits will change.

My experience in the IT field has provided me with the opportunity to have worked with Mainframe, Unix/Linux (various flavors), Windows, Macintosh, PC-DOS and a wide range of applications and network topologies & protocols. All products have weaknesses and defects in them which can be exploited and one key factor as to the level of exploits attempted or launched is the prevelence of the product as well as the availability and ease of use of the product. Most Linux/Unix products and IT Core infrastructure products are complex and take some time & training to understand them, and are generally not "easy" to use for the average consumer. As a result the ease of opportunity to exploit a weakness is merely a factor of the ease of opportunity in products desgined to meet the consumers demand for ease of use and rich features & functions to make thier lives easier and even more fun.

We still have a need for police as crime is still around despite all the efforts to educate people, and improve society, all products and make things equal. What remains through all of this is human temptation and weakness and the exploitation of opportunities to take advantage of others.

by jdclyde

As Unix servers have been on the internet longer, why haven't they been exploited in the same way Windows has now? Because Windows is much easier to exploit based on the way it is designed.

*nix was created as a networked box, with permissions and security in mind from the start.

Windows boxes started as DOS stand alone sytems with a GUI thrown on it to make it easier to use. Network connectivity was added later, with "ease of use" still the main focus.

Trying to come along years later and add security to these boxes is much harder, because the security interferes with the "ease of use" and if windows loses "ease of use", they lose everything and they know it.

There are many examples in todays internet that prove the "bigger target" argument is nothing more than a myth and FUD.

Apache is a PRIME example of this as it is on more servers world wide that IIS, and is to this day much more stable and secure than IIS. (ask anyone that got hit by Code Red)

As for black hats, which would give more esteam, to be the one to make the first real virus threat to *nix or to be just another Windows virus writer?

As for patches actually FIXING things, MANY viruses are just variations of existing viruses. Modify it a little and the AV software won't recognise it and you are infected. Would this be possible if the MS patch had FIXED the exploit? No virus that is over 6 months old should even be a consideration anymore if this was really the case and you would not HAVE to run AV software as the WAY the virus attacked in the first place would be closed off.

Will some people always fine a way around security? Of course. But just like locking your car won't stop everyone, it will stop most. Same with IE vs FF. Windows vs *nix.

No matter how many times they say security is the main goal, as long as ActiveX can make system changes just because you visited a web site, Windows and IE will not be secure.

by matthew yurksaitis

There are some good points in here and also a good recap on DOS/Windows etc... Thanks! and I agree if a person is really intent on breaking in they will. My main point is that there are proponents on either side of the fence and both are equally as passionate and as long as the human weakness element remains there will continue to be a need for security. There are also good and not so good products/technologies on either side of the fence as well.

In regards to your points on Virus protection and outdated viruses and signatures, again I agree there is room for improvement here as well. One note here - old viruses will remain active as long as older Operating Systems remain and folks do not patch them. - Yet another paradox.

In short there will be plenty of work for all of us as technology evolves and goes through it's lifecycles.

by vidalr

Hi my experience with firefox was at the beginning of good impression, because it had the speed that I wanted, latter was of disappointment because I was smart up by a free browser.
Mozilla or Firefox browser is an open source browser, built, made and release by hackers, the last meaning knowledgeable people.
Regarding your segment, that there is not spyware in Firefox, all those who are familiar with NT or XP know that is easy to place the whole windows system in a mode known only for this particular issue that your system wont receive a virus or spyware, the speed wont decrease, you will be able to listen to music see web cast, your kid be in messenger and not be infected, I still say is wonderful but is normal, to me because of your observation they may have place their browser within this mode , now how they got this information is what unveils their intrinsic behavior , being a share community, and providing to you with a free browser, plus knowing that nothing is for ?free? you and I will share with them regardless we wanted or not; basically information or downloads that you do specially from Microsoft , sharing is two ways, I remember the time that I offer myself to help Mozilla they answer by saying that will like some well written code, they even told me were I can get the download, for each download that I did, their browser have the ability of doing three downloads for themselves, latter I download for me the media player 10 , and when I realized the download was gone, I did the download again this time I noticed that on the bottom left side of the browser a box show up saying your download have started, on the top right side a box show up with the download, but at the moment of moving the mouse from the left bottom side to the right top side the download was gone and I still was having the media player 9 , this did not stop. I opened the Internet explorer and got my media player 10.
Of course that was my end with Firefox or strictly speaking Mozilla, this was one year ago, but the download of Mozilla browser is not joke, because until today my system is read as having Mozilla as my browser, I have done more than tree System recoveries and still my downloads go to the desktop a tip provided by Mozilla. The mode were you are free of spywares or virus is not the safe mode with black screen, is something else, what I wonder is from whom they got the information? And lastly have you ever wonder why is a fox around the world in their icon? How much can you trust the hacker community? Is something that each institution or individual need to answer soberly.

by noyoki

I think I got most of what you are saying...

If you mean it still shows that FireFox is your browser, go to Internet Explorer, into "Tools" -> "Options" ("Preferances"? I haven't used IE in so long I forget) "Advanced" and find where it says "Make IE your default browser". Most likely, you had told FireFox you wanted THAT to be your default.

Firefox saves things to where-ever you set them to in the "Tools", "Options", "Downloads". I think the default is onto your desktop. But you can also have a window pop up with the status of your download (like IE does). That is also an option in "Downloads", or can be opened manually via "Tools" -> "Downloads" (or Ctrl + J). You can run the program/pic/etc from this window as well.

As far as "trusting the hacker community", you would be surprised at the number of "White Hackers". I know quite a few in real life, and only ONE that uses "Black Hacker" skills. The difference being this:

A white hacker finds an exploit in the way company X handles their web-database. He promptly warns the company and will usually (if he can) direct them to the patch or write one himself! (Not asking for money, but for the challenge and the "bragging rights".)

However, if a black hacker finds this same exploit, he is more likely to use it for his own gain, or write an exploit for it. Again, not for money, but for "bragging rights". Usually the only way this runs unchecked, is if the program is proprietary.

BUT! Firefox has millions of people looking at its code.

Lets say one kid decides to go rogue one day and writes an exploit, submits it and hopes it gets added.

Here's what happens: Mozilla takes the code and puts the SOURCE CODE (*[i]NOT[/i] the program addition*, just the code) online so that everyone can see it with the person's name. A couple hundred people download the code and see what it does.

They all now know that this person is up to no good, and they say so. The code gets pulled down, Mozilla goes in and verifies what the people are saying, then promptly bans the culprit. AND he has just earned himself (among the open source community) a bad name.

That's contrary to what hackers want. They don't want to be known as the lamer that failed. That hurts their social status.

The open source community is self-punishing. You don't need to hold people hostage with a paycheck to keep them honest, in most cases, the esteem of their peers is a much stronger deterrent.

by dfirefire

Get your vocabulary right! A hacker is someone who enters restrictic areas, such as networks, other mens software and so. Open source software are made by many types of people, maybe (probably) even hackers. Due to the open source code, anyone is able to verify the code so that no malicious code can be implemented...

by apotheon

You've just described the media-hype misuse of the term "hacker". Actually, most of the open source community is made up of hackers, in the classic sense of the term -- the truer, purer sense of the term.

From http://www.catb.org/~esr/jargon/html/meaning-of-hack.html
"Hacking might be characterized as 'an appropriate application of ingenuity'. Whether the result is a quick-and-dirty patchwork job or a carefully crafted work of art, you have to admire the cleverness that went into it."

From http://www.catb.org/~esr/jargon/html/H/hacker.html

1. "A person who enjoys exploring the details of programmable systems and how to stretch their capabilities, as opposed to most users, who prefer to learn only the minimum necessary. RFC1392, the Internet Users' Glossary, usefully amplifies this as: A person who delights in having an intimate understanding of the internal workings of a system, computers and computer networks in particular."

2. "One who programs enthusiastically (even obsessively) or who enjoys programming rather than just theorizing about programming."

3. "A person capable of appreciating hack value."[1]

4. "A person who is good at programming quickly."

5. "An expert at a particular program, or one who frequently does work using it or on it; as in 'a Unix hacker'. (Definitions 1 through 5 are correlated, and people who fit them congregate.)"

6. "An expert or enthusiast of any kind. One might be an astronomy hacker, for example."

7. "One who enjoys the intellectual challenge of creatively overcoming or circumventing limitations."

There's a reference to the definition you're using:
8. "[deprecated] A malicious meddler who tries to discover sensitive information by poking around. Hence password hacker, network hacker. The correct term for this sense is cracker."[2]

What you're talking about is a "cracker", not a "hacker". More descriptively, such a person might be known as a "security cracker". Many people branded "hacker" are not only not hackers, though: they are also often not even crackers, but merely vandals using tools created by more-skillful crackers. This latter breed of vandals is often known by the pejorative term "script kiddie".

As a hacker in the classic sense of the term myself (or, at least, I've been called such by others who know what it means, and am proud of the fact), I find the common misconceptions about the meaning of the term "hacker" to be disappointing at best and offensive at worst.

So, armed with this new knowledge, be sure that a lot of the Mozilla code contributors are indeed hackers, but not in the sense you seem to think.

- - - - -

[1] http://www.catb.org/~esr/jargon/html/H/hack-value.html

[2] http://www.catb.org/~esr/jargon/html/C/cracker.html

by jdclyde

In 1978, A religious cult (over 900 poeple) put cyanide in with kool-aid and then drank it killing everyone.

A kool-aid drinker is meant as someone that is fanatical about something and just can't see reason.

http://religiousmovements.lib.virginia.edu/nrms/Jonestwn.html

Just after you were born, so not a wonder you wouldn't know the reference. Sorry to be a downer on this, but thought you should know the meaning behind it and what it refers to.

http://www.wordspy.com/words/drinktheKool-Aid.asp
the way it is meant today.

by noyoki

Didn't some cult or other ("Heaven's Gate" I think?) like that happen in the 90's? (Did they, too, use kool-aide?)

Didn't know about the referance tho, thanks for correcting me.

by vidalr

I did post an article call: Firefox. How much can you trust a hacker Community? I got several replays that stated that , Firefox is a secure browser, the other telling that in Explorer I should go to tools, and disable? firefox , an that, there are black hackers and white hackers, in other words good and bad , and other one telling to get my vocabulary right, plus the definition of what a hacker is and that open source is not a community of hackers.
The last two will be answer first, leaving the first one to the end because it imply Active X and vendors .
Regarding disabling Mozilla, from the explorer browser, I guess that is impossible, the only option is to use a system within windows were the start items are located, and there is the option of disabling it, but news is that Mozilla or Firefox , do not show up in the start items, rationality will explain this event, by concluding that a download of Mozilla browser is a direct download to your hard drive others programs like Read Please, I spell, and Microsoft office are a direct download to your hard drive, I don?t see a problem with that, what is a bothersome is that after one year of not using Mozilla plus tree System Recoveries my firewall, when it alerts me that a sensitive information about my system is going on line, says that my browser is Mozilla, I had to acknowledge that this phenomena can be explain only by saying that this browser download is different than any other one because it stays for good, as well having the acknowledgment that open Source knows more about the NT or XP system than the guys from Microsoft themselves, knowing as well that open source or GNU , in 1985 created an enormous body of software: GCC (C compiler), GDB (debugger), Emacs (text editor), and a number of other tools. Lacking only the kernel which later was done by Linus Torwald giving birth to Linux or as Mr. Stallmant founder and the creator of open source will call GNU+LINUX. All this facts will tell us that to download Mozilla browser is not a joke.
Regarding white hacker and black hackers, I know you are not speaking about race but doing a distinction between hackers and crackers.
About getting my vocabulary right and that Open Source are not hackers I will ask you to do a research of whom Mr. Stallmant, Mr. Linus Torwald, and Mr. Eric Raymond are, because they had and have much to do with the Open Source philosophy. I used the word hacker in my article in the way of having knowledge not implying stealing. I will give you a page on the history of open source:
http://www.openknowledge.org/writing/open-source/scb/brief-open-source-history.html
And lastly regarding vendors more secure because their more secure browser does not install Active X I do not find the rationality in the account but a tendency to promote Mozilla. Spywares and virus are not of much relevance in the NT system, now to know have to use the tools within windows to get rid off the formers, what a person needs is knowledge.

by jdclyde

from him.

Hey, he is posting from Canada, so you have to cut him some slack! :) Maybe some frostbite from going out hugging all the trees? Who can say? :D

by tony hopkinson

FF is not a secure browser it's a more secure browser.

A Hacker in hollywood is nasty person who steals all the money from your bank account, in the programming community it's someone who's capable of such a feat.

ActiveX (and other client side executors of foreign code) are the single biggest security threat out there. As for it not being a problem under NT, well it's less of a problem, if you aren't logged on as admin, you have a proper firewall, and up to date adware and virus tools.
Note the firewall stops (as long as it's not that windows crap) the executable dialling out. The virus checker and adware blockers stops any recognised virus being executed on your machine. A lot of this stuff is still trying to do you bad and it's still attempting to do you bad because it's getting on to your system through client side execution, which is what activeX was designed to do !

Try and get all these facts you've got in some sort of order will you, your coming across very badly.

by noyoki

It sounds like you're comparing Firefox to malware.

I SAID:
"If you mean it still shows that FireFox is your
browser, go to Internet Explorer, into "Tools" ->
"Options" ("Preferances"? I haven't used IE in so
long I forget) "Advanced" and find where it says
"Make IE your default browser". Most likely, you
had told FireFox you wanted THAT to be your
default."

I did not say to disable anything, and if it were malware, it would not give you the option to do so anyway. (Sony anyone?)

If it is not showing IE on your desktop, it is because YOU (or someone using your computer) deleted the shortcut.

If you go to "Start" -> "Run" and type in a website address, and it opens in Firefox, it means that YOU (again, or someone using your computer (I'll give you the benefit of the doubt)) set it to be the default program for opening web addresses. AKA, your default browser. If you go to IE, find the "Set as default" bit, and check that, it will fix that problem. Going into Firefox ("Tools" -> "Options" -> "General") and find where it says "Firefox should check to see if it is the default browser" and uncheck it, it will no longer open by default. It will instead open in IE by default.

Of course, you COULD just uninstall the program if you are so unhappy with it, but for some reason.... I smell a troll.

ActiveX is a Windows "thing", built into IE and exploited by Black Hackers. This is fought against by the White Hackers of the community. There are what, 10 programmers on M$'s team? (And yes, by your definition, M$ programmers are hackers too.) Well there are thousands of programmers on Mozilla's team. Where do you want to place your bets?

Oh, and I think you mean Stallman. Not Stallmant.
And Torvald. Not Torwald.
At least spell the names right if you are going to quote them as the "All mighty words of god".

by jdclyde

trying to win over someone like that with sound logic. What could you possibley be thinking of? :D

Anyone that doesn't know how to change which is their default browser is NOT someone that will understand anything but what they have seen on the latest MS flier. (ok, understand is a bad choice. Blindly take as gospal? Much more like it.)

by vidalr

PUSHING THE ENVELOP.

All that I said was that I have a windows XP that is secure, fast, and very reliable. The gathering of information, research, testing, is my own property.
Because Got tired to try to sell the information and I couldn?t doe to my lack of connection I tried to give it for free trough the TECH MAGAZINE.
I have received feedbacks like:
. I haven?t read something that bizarre.
. Say?what
. You are sitting in a gold mine etc (Matthew Forgive for telling you do not replay).
So I will give you my address 66.222.170.196
I?m giving you, more specific information. I?m using an apple or Linux wall paper.
At your end all you have to do is:
1. Described and tell me the wall paper.
2. What I have in my Favorites in Internet explorer.

Any damage to my system doe to my handling to you my domicile is entirely my responsibility and I assumed all losses. I swear before the Canadian flag and the bible that there is not trickery on my end but what I believed to be the most secure system in the world.
And as well swear before the Canadian flag and the bible that not one person will be accused of breaking on my system.
Every person has only one shot and receives help only of one outsider.
Waiting for your speedy replay
Ruben.

by tony hopkinson

is not more vulnerable due to the number of users. There are more vulnerable targets out there, yes, but that's simply gives the bad guys a higher return on their investment, it does not make the amount of effort to research and make use of an exploit any less difficult.

by matthew yurksaitis

While users definitely want ease of use, there is not and should not be an expectation that this comes at the sacrifice of security, that was not my point. That bieng said, as commercial product vendors develop products for ease of use and feature rich vulnerabilities do increase as a result despite efforts to keep them in check. This happens as we as humans are not perfect, and therefore our work refelcts this despite all our best efforts. My point simply is that as products gain prevalence and vendors attempt to meet demand vulnerabilities an defects increase as well. It is the darker side of our human nature which results in some folks exploiting these vulnerabilities & weaknesses for pleasure, fun or out of anger & retribution and it is this factor which is the catalyst behind the security industry, this has been this way even since the day's when Unix was a prevalent player in the market (prior to the prevalence of the Home PC, DOS, and Windows). For anyone in the IT community who has been around to see this market transition they remember when security was needed on unix systems due to the lack of security on the O/S as well. (This is still lurking out there as well)

With all the press and talk on Linux (various flavors) bieng ready for the enterprise it appears that what is really happening is that Unix is making a come back to the day's before DOS and Windows. With this postential transition on the horizon the number of vulnerabilities and defects in these products is increasing and so are the exploits for them as the article at the following link discusses: http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1885811,00.asp While FireFox may be the latest in efforts to develop a product to address security concerns it is just that, another product - only difference it's from a commercial product vendor and not a security vendor, but it has it's own vulnerabilities and weaknesses as well. So what this appears to be is a nice marketing effort by Mozilla for FireFox which has gained some support but the full story is also not bieng given fair weight. Here are some more articles on this: http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1898253,00.asp , http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1888953,00.asp , http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1862659,00.asp , http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1857322,00.asp , http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1838261,00.asp , http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1836310,00.asp , http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1814056,00.asp , http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,1774091,00.asp

Not to mention the vulnerabilities reported to organizations such as C.E.R.T, bugtrack etc..

So while FireFox appears more secure and the current security and admin solution, and it may be at this point in it's product life it is not free from vulnerabilities or defects, and as the user audience & demand grows and the open source community scrambles to meet the demand will the product continue to meet the "more secure" higher standard or if the demand for features, functionality and performance will impact this product as well. As one of the articles in the links provided above shows, it was as recently as March of this year where "FireFox" was headed in the wrong direction and was stated that it would eventually fail if it did not change direction. In short FireFox as a sound, stable and long lasting product / solution remains unproven, while some of it's security features have benefit the product maturity is not there yet.

The security industry will be around for a long time, not because of commercial vendors lack of concern or incentive, but primarliy because of the human element which exploits vulnerabilities and defects. True if we do not call certian things, crimes then we would not need police - but if we call nothing a crime - then chaos disorder would ensue.

by tony hopkinson

honest who cares?. If a more secure product comes along I'll switch to it. If an as secure but more functional product comes across I'll switch to that.
As a user I'm simply happy that at least one software creator has paid attention to the requirements of those who have a greater concern for security than the majority.

If FF dies, I'm sure there'll be another option, who knows could be a bunch of us off TR knock up something called TRowser and a ad line of 'Don't get caught with your pants down'.

I'm not particularly sure how impartial your source articles are, may be it's my bias creeping in and not theirs but there are some very loaded comments in the articles.

A claim from the author that they are attempting to evangelise FF, where as Mozilla's mission statement is to 'create the most secure browser'.

Still I suppose the guy had to say something, claiming they were demonising IE would have been silly, given the fact it's red with pointy horns.

by jaqui

"Don't drop your TRowsers" ]:)

"Chastity TRowsers, for secure web browsing"
[ padlock and key not included ]:) ]

Though if we could talk TR into making a version control system available it could actually be fun to do.. create a browser designed to be secure, and to tell you when you are engaging in "at risk" activities.. like the website is not using 128 terabit* encryption in it's ssl mode. website trying to run this clientside script [display of code not intended disp0lay from site designer] this is not secure activity the company that owns the site are trying to infect your system with malware.

no support of "addons" / plugins.
no activex, no flash, no javascript.
basic http website has a red wash over it cause it's not using https.
3rd party cookies cause red wash
3rd party content [ adspace.net** ] cause red wash

* yes terabit, even though it's not created yet.. push for that level of encryption. ;)

** adspace.net, doublclick.net etc do not check for malware code embedded in the images they serve. I'm sure most have seen the sliding / popup windows from the javascript embedded in some of thier advertisements.

by matthew yurksaitis

You raise a couple of good points here which I agree with:

1. It is always good when a vendor responds readily to customer needs and requirements.
2. Having a selection of good, mature products is also good.

In regards to switching as soon as something else comes along, unless there is really a good sound business case to switch products or technolgoies as compared to the cost incurred by switching over (cost including employee time, training, etc..) the incentive will simply not be there to swtich instantly to the newest, latest & greatest.

In regards to the articles I provided for reference, this was really to illustrate that thre are proponents on either side of this and both are equally as passionate and have good points to consider. In the end balance and due dilligence are really the key drivers and decision points.

by vidalr

Hi jody and clyde.
I have receive several feed backs:

-It has been a long time since I read such a disjointed and bizarre posting.
- He is from Canada.
- Hum....
And one good one from Matthew.
I did not know that this tech site were so open to the open Source philophy + the fact that the majority were GNU+Linux users.
This welcome to my post + the braging of severals profiles was enough for me to figure it out, how my life will be here regarding interchange of knowlege.
I use Linux as well, the boot disk MOVE from O'really, and plan to buy a box to install the full fedora version, only for study porpouse.
I don't like GNU+Linux user interface, something not to be overlooked, a home user will be lost using GNU+LINUX system so it just not click on the interface, the majority of vendors do not want to do nothing with Gnu+Linux system, Best buy, Droug Mark, Future Shop, Radio Shack now know as the source, to mention few, have a "We hate that system" actitude.
I wonder why? Wondering is something that stops once you gather the principles, the history, and todays impact.
Regarding the Open Source Community, a person just need to download Mozilla to know their intrinsic philosophy " If you don't want to share, you will share anyway" So they do in the background. I guess I understand more Mr. Allmard introduction "Free software does not mean that is free" You can see his speech in google video I can give you my web site it has google video on it as well several TV STATIONS. So when you feel musical just go to:
http://radiotvsignal.blogspot.com/
I guess this will be my last post, and I'm out of here.
The post that I made was not bizarre, neither was the lack of knowledge, Yes it has grammar errors, but maybe it was good to be just like that.
Not waiting for a replay
Ruben

by jdclyde

we know how the frostbite can affect our neighbors in the "great white north"! :D What else would explain jaqui and OZ? :^O

Sorry, I forgot what an insult that can be taken as! I retract completely the slanderous comments about posting from canada. didn't mean to use such harsh language! VEry unprofessional and I am sorry to have offended you. B-)

j

by jaqui

it gets colder where you are than where I am.

It's already spring here in this part of Canada.
My insanity isn't from frostbitten brains [ that's everyone outside of the lower mainland ] it's from waterlogged brains. :D

by apotheon

I love the TRowser idea (or whatever we'd call it), but . . .

Rather than "no support of plugins", I'd say we should just have a modular browser, with all modules of it that are available through a central site being extensively tested and so on before being released so that we maintain a "known good" set of pluggable modules.

I certainly agree with no ActiveX, but Flash and Javascript are sorta necessary. Rather than making them unavailable, we should simply implement properly encapsulated "runspace" for them. The major problem isn't, for example, the presence of Javascript functionality: it's the fact that the Javascript functionality can affect things outside the browser's display. Besides, without Javascript, the only person that would use the browser is Jaqui.

Better custom cookie handling and site-blocking than currently implemented in any browser is a definite must. It's a serious, intolerable pain in the arse to have to search through the list of cookie-handling exceptions in Firefox (for instance) without being able to just type a search string into a box and hit the Enter key to find it. Instead, you either have to know where to find the config file for it, or you have to look at the list of cookies one at a time to find the URL you need. Full regex-configurable cookie handling heuristics would be nice, too.

by jaqui

required.

they are nothing more than holes in security.

[ whatever you do, don't read my reply to Tony below ]:) ]

by apotheon

. . . for the new browser to fill a purpose that isn't already filled admirably by console-based browsers with image support. If you don't want a fully-functional browser, don't use one.

There's no reason Javascript, Java, and Flash can't be implemented securely through a browser. ActiveX, on the other hand, is a vulnerability by design.

by tony hopkinson

Your browser should not need locking out of your system, it shouldn't be a way in ! The original idea was a window on to the rest of the world not a f'ing door anyone else could use to get into your stuff.

by jaqui

that was actually a refference to chastity belts. :P

whatever you do, do not ever check the catalog at neosteel.de you might blush enough to fry bacon on your face. ]:)

~whistling innocently while wandering away~

by jdclyde

It was like a bad accident. No matter how bad it got, I couldn't help but look! :O

Oh, but I LOVED that blue suit in the gallery! woo woo!

Wonder if Mambo will be able to stay away? There would be a blush going! ]:)

by vidalr

PUSHING THE ENVELOP.

All that I said was that I have a windows XP that is secure, fast, and very reliable. The gathering of information, research, testing, is my own property.
Because Got tired to try to sell the information and I couldn?t doe to my lack of connection I tried to give it for free trough the TECH MAGAZINE.
I have received feedbacks like:
. I haven?t read something that bizarre.
. Say?what
. You are sitting in a gold mine etc (Matthew Forgive for telling you do not replay).
So I will give you my address 66.222.170.196
I?m giving you, more specific information. I?m using an apple or Linux wall paper.
At your end all you have to do is:
1. Described and tell me the wall paper.
2. What I have in my Favorites in Internet explorer.

Any damage to my system doe to my handling to you my domicile is entirely my responsibility and I assumed all losses. I swear before the Canadian flag and the bible that there is not trickery on my end but what I believed to be the most secure system in the world.
And as well swear before the Canadian flag and the bible that not one person will be accused of breaking on my system.
Every person has only one shot and receives help only of one outsider.
Waiting for your speedy replay
Ruben.

by jdclyde

IE vs FF has nothing to do with people coming and hacking you. It is about when you use those products to go out to web sites, how THEY are vulnerable.

Your firewall will NOT save you when ActiveX runs scripts on the page YOU went out and got.

Completely separate issues. One has NOTHING to do with the other.

by noyoki

are you spamming the same post in two different threads within the same topic...?

by noyoki

that any mis-understandings are due to the fact that we can't... well... understand you? Neither Firefox nor IE will let someone hack you unless you are dumb enough to surf to a site that installs a back door.

However, I toss this challenge back to you:

Find a site with malware. Surf to it. TRY to give yourself a virus. Test it with both Firefox and IE. See which one is easier.

That is all that this topic was about. Hacking into your system was never a part of it.

by apotheon

Maybe (s)he/it means to say "push the envelope" or something like that. I really don't know.

What I do know is that this isn't the only place this has been posted. In fact, vidalr is really beginning to be annoying, the way (s)he/it is carpetbombing TR with this incoherent, cut-and-paste gibberish.

by jdclyde

If this was correct, then provided I have a system that is patched as soon as an update is released, I shouldn't need to run av and anti-spyware software, correct?

You would not believe the night and day difference switching my users over to FF made.

by tony hopkinson

FF suits me. I use IE at work but that's in a very sanitised environment so it's weaknesses don't show up as much. There are a lot of reasons why you might want to stick with IE at a corporate level, if someone says one of them is security I'd have to have extreme doubts as to their competency.
Interestingly a lot of the counter arguments put forward by IE proponents run along the lines of since FF isn't secure you might as well stick with IE. I don't mind people missing the point but I don't like being taken for an idiot.

Short of fundamantal changes in MS business practices IE will never be as secure as a browser which treats clientside execution as suspicious and doesn't have a direct pipeline into your OS.

by cybersecurity

It would be nice to read replies without the old, outdated sources that some feel the need to post.
FF has a new rev level get with it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.