34 replies
by admin
but who of us can restore it?
Governments cannot.
Fines cannot.
Law Enforcment cannot.
Business cannot.
Is it a Government, a business, a criminal or a business that makes it unsafe for life? No. It is many little acts by individuals. The captain that cannot control alchohol, the crew member that does not intervene and feeds their family instead for another month. the political leaders that choose destruction, the scientists who pursue pure knowledge without contemplating application and more than anyone, those who live an unexamined personal life and with their personal choices directly pollute or indirectly financially support those who do.
the internet is much the same. it will never lack pollution or be brought neatly under control without one world governing body and most likely not with it either. to me it would be a shame, but to cut ourselves off from the internet as a country and regulate as we do broadcasting would be the way to do this. a country wide network seperated and then enforce controls to keep people from hearing other points of view and those who insisted on this "Information Smuggling" should be rooted out and jailed or publically humiliated, especially if they are artists or actors!
isp's cannot make it conform or clean to any one goverment any easier than they can clean the ocean. they can fine, prosecute and become powerful and rich in the process and then why would they want to fix that which has rewarded them so well?
by tokyopete
And who will police the ISPs? There is no guarantee that the isps themselves won't misuse information that they glean in the course of monitoring what is passing through their servers. This is Catch 22 with a vengeance.
Of course, governments want to control everything and every thought of ther citizens. God forbid that citizens should actually think for htemsleves or have a form of communication that cannot bew monitored.
We are already at the stage where one can end up in an unknown jail, hidden from view for as long as the "authoriies" wish. Just cry Terrorist! Even a 74 yr old Afghan was held in Quatanamo military concentration camp until his release a few days ago.
Sure the Internet is a Wild Wide West type of activity but trying to force the server owners to actively or otherwise try to control what is going on is an impossible task in the first place. In any case, how to control ISPs that are not physically located wthin your juristration. The USA might think it has the right to troll the whole world but there are only 280M living there compared with the several Billion all over the world.
Let the FBI et al do their thing of catching criminals who have actually committed a crime. If we don't curb their excesses now, tomorrrow will be too late for all of us. In the end, we'll all end up with a number tattooed on our foreheads and be monitored from birth to death and brain washed into the bargain.
Is that what any sane person wants?
by sussex pete
by borgesen
Isn't that kind of the same as saying:
"Guns don't kill people - Humans do".
Well that may be true, but only to a certain extent.
I live in Denmark, where firearms are quite severly regulated, and not easy at all to get your hands on. It _can_ be done, but is highly difficult for an ordinary person.
I do recognise however, that the number of gunrelated crimes per capita is way way down compared to countries with less restrictive firearms policies.
So my point is: Yes, people are responcible themselfs for the lack of added security messerures on their systems, but in ISP policy on the matter would help the majority of "ordinary users" not to commit these acts out of sheer lack of understanding.
That was just my five cents.
Borgesen, Denmark
by mkrull
by admin
by gwgert
One argument provided in the body of the primary article asked if we would like telephone companies recording our messages. That is a poor comparison because (a) there are many regulations already in place prohibiting such monitoring without court order or reasonable cause; (b) the crimes committed by telephone are hellacious, but it typically is the ignorant person who willingly falls prey to them; and, most importantly (c) telephone calls can be easily traced, whereas tracing the source of internet crimes, such as an Distributed DoS, is much more difficult, and best done at the ISP level.
While I don't agree with monitoring one's surfing habits, I do agree that ISPs can be much more responsible about the web content of their subscribers.
My five cents.
Incline Village, Nevada
by tomsal
"Guns don't kill. People Do." That's a very popular quote, which at first glance seems kind of clever. But its wrong.
There's been more than one case where a gun "just went off".
In fact in both WWII and Vietnam a couple soldiers died becausetheir weapons "went off" (meaning without a trigger pull).
I know for a fact this happend with German made Lugers (WWII) and rumored has it that the first iterations of the M16 had some "nasty habits" in the early stages of Vietnam. (The only weird thing to the later is plenty of people swore to the realibility of the M16 as well).
I just wanted to comment on that quote - because I heard it a lot and its not 100% true. (I'm just a stickler I guess).
by rhizoned
Is this not wire-tapping everyone??
Guilty until proven innocent?
by scoid
Governments should monitor activities of known criminals, NOT those of the innocent. However, I think we may be missing the point here. We're not talking about MONITORING, we're talking about RECORD KEEPING. Phone companies DO keep records of allphone calls made. However, police cannot obtain these records without a warrant. Warrants require a judge's signature and reasonable cause.
There is a key difference between Internet usage and using a phone. How often have you dialled the correct phone number and been connected to the wrong party? Rarely I bet. How often have you clicked on hypertext or entered an URL and been taken somewhere you didn't expect because of a 'bad link' or some pornographer having purhcased an URL from a defunct 'dot.com' to increase his site's hit rates?
My concern is the potential for courtroom character assassination based on website/ web page names logged with ISPs. Phone numbers logged at telcos don't suggest anything about one's character. You can't create a psych profile out of a list of phone numbers, (well, 1-900s maybe!) You could, however, create an inaccurate profile by looking at a list of site or page names.
And when police obtain a warrant to tap a phone line, they actually hear the bad guy's voice and know it's him! On the other hand, how do you know it's 'me' typng this reply? It could be my kids or my wife using my non-password protected computer, couldn't it? Don't we call that reasonable doubt in a court of law?
So let the ISPs log site and page visits, but impose strict limitations on log use and content. First, determine what types of criminal behaviors occur on the Net and where they most often occur (i.e. chat rooms for child luring and securitiesfraud, hate-mongering sites visited by disgruntled mental midgets, etc.). Have ISPs keep logs on these sites and keep sites containing legal and ethical content off the ISP logs.
by admin
by brokeneagle
Most of the problems of the Internet would go away if the ISPs would enforce their "Terms of Service" (TOS).
Most Internet backbone providers require the ISPs to have TOSs that line up with theirs, so everyone is, in theory, playing by pretty much the same set of rules.
The problem is that when people don't play by the rules, many ISPs , for fear of losing business, do not enforce the rules.
If ISPs would block the traffic from ISPs that do not enforce the rules, those who don't enforce the rules would go out of business.
Play by the rules or don't play!
See http://www.missionsupport.net/blocked.shtml
by admin
by todd
The internet was created to allow communications during the worst possible times, it later became a means of just communicating. I disagree with anything that harms that philosophy. I disagree with allowing businesses to use the net as well.
However, IF we, wish to allow activity other then communication to take place over the internet, I do not see were we have much choice.
ISP's would be no different then the phone company going after or working with the attorney generals office to go after people who would use the phone system for fraud. I don’t see where they would be any different then the postal service going after people who use the US mail to commit fraud and other crimes.
We don’t have a right to be public and have anonymity at the same time. IF you want to do things (even communicate), it can be argued that you have to be willing to stand behind your comments right or wrong.
If the internet does have to be monitored, it would certainly have tobe the ISP’s. Who else could ensure comprehensive coverage.
As with most laws, the thing that concerns me, is who has access to the information and how would the information be used to prosecute criminal activity.
by admin
since different countries have different standards I personally think it would suck. I don't really want a North America\European Coalition approved internet and how else could it be really if ISP's started controlling content?
The thing about the U.S. Postal Service and the Attourney Generals Office is that they are not controlling most of the worlds communication and I don't believe they really should. Without the Internet this year I would have had to rely on the US news services to coverthe election, interests and wars of our president and missed out on the balance of many other nations views, opinions and facts on the subject just to point out one aspect. To me this is a real loss. We finally have a shot at being true citizens of the entire planet and communicate cheaply and effectively worldwide, why would we want to stop being able to get the real facts from many different countries and filter it ourselves as opposed to being spoon fed what someone else thinks we should hear?
My parents taught me to get all sides of the story before acting, I mean, if they would have just listened to my siblings side I would have been in a LOT more trouble! The only way policing will work is if there is a standard, and if it becomes a nationalistic standard then we are reverting to isolationism, and I believe, suffering because of it. :(
by mkrull
by cbrooks
Have you ever gone in a store and immediately had someone come up and ask you what you wanted. You replied, "Nothing, I'm just browsing", and you were followed down each row until your ire reached an explosion peak and you left in a silent rage?
Have you ever gone in an electronic store and touched a piece of merchandise and had alarms go off? Have you ever been concerned that you are being photographed hundreds of time a day at banks, stores, street intersections, on the freeway, in restrooms,?
I have.
Do you truly believe that a government, with the capability to drop breadcrumbs on your virtual paths, would not use this information except to look for criminal activity?
When people are disenfranchised at voting booths, and are told to "get over it and get on with their lives …
When we no longer elect our presidents but have them appointed by a supreme court that seems to have a political agenda …
When the government says I no longer have no right to demandprivacy about information related to my bank accounts …
When I make a purchase at a hardware store with my credit card, and they ask for my ZIP code …
I get this pain …
When someone says they want to track every move I make onthe internet, I suddenly have a strong affinity for the people who rioted throughout the world during the 60' and 70's. I identify with a character in a movie who went to the window and yelled, "I'm mad as hell and I'm not gonna take it anymore".
When some entity parses my email for key words, can’t discern context, but based on some binary decisions mechanism can brand me a criminal, I feel my heckles raised, want to bare by fangs, go out and kill some virtual bear. If the ISP copparsed this, and found the word "kill," I would probably hear knocks on my door in the middle of my nightly bag of popcorn, and be dragged off to some gulag.
Do I want an ISPs p
by samlowrey
>Have you ever gone in a store and immediately >had someone come up and ask you what you wanted. >You replied, "Nothing, I'm just browsing", and >you were followed down each row until your ire >reached an explosion peak and you left in a >silent rage?
No, but I have seen petty thieves steal and there are groups that practically tie the hands of store owners who should be able to stop them. I've seen stores looted.....
Blame those who lack morallity to behave properly. They are driving the Police State.
>Do you truly believe that a government, with the >capability to drop breadcrumbs on your virtual >paths, would not use this information except to >look for criminal activity?
No, but I see people constantly looking to the government for answers - why so you think it has grown to the monstrocity it has? The Constitution died long ago. :-(
>When people are disenfranchised at voting >booths, and are told to "get over it and get on >with their lives ?
>When we no longer elect our presidents but have >them appointed by a supreme court that seems to >have a political agenda ?
Funny how you just now think courts have an agenda? Ever hear of bussing - court decree - one judge!
Bush won the popular vote in Florida....again, and again, and again.....
>When the government says I no longer have no >right to demand privacy about information >related to my bank accounts ?
Again, people looking to government for answers and a handout created the illegal tax code we have. That was used as a justification for the government looking at your bank account. That is what happens when you open Pandora's box...... There are always unintended consequences. But all we hear are the weepy emotional pleasfor a new government program - never the many ways it will become a monster.
by ron mcnew
by pingpaul
Having a for-profit entity police the Internet is bad public policy. Nowhere in the United States is the police function outsourced to a for-profit company. That is an unequivocal statement of public policy.
Because of the potential for abuse, police power must be granted carefully.
by darrylha
So this discussion revolves around a few Key Points:
1. Privacy.
2. Human Rights.
3. Responsibility.
1.
Privacy is a word and like so many words in the english language it's meaning has changed over the years. What we call privacy today is not privacy but rather secrecy/security/non-disclosure of our personal/private/confidential lives and information. Think about it... You have a Bank account, Electrical account, tax number, e-mail address, ID Number, etc. The government pobably has your fingerprints on file somewhere. the list goes on and on and on.... What we should be fighting over is the confidentiality of that information not the collection of it. The collection is inevitable and unavoidable. Risking starting another conspiracy theory how do know what Big Brother collects?
Secondly I have absolutely no objection to the collection of this information. The reason basically comes down to crime etc. If the government had a DNA sample of every person the chances of you being caught for a crime become very high. I think the best analogy I ever read was it's a bit like living in a street with lots of lights. Would you live in a street with lots of lights and security guards patrolling the streets or in a dark street where anything could be lurking in the shadows? I want the street with lights, for me, for my kids, for my wife. The fact is it is impossible to have the level of privacy you had 10/15/20 years ago (unless you drop out and go live on an island and don't tell anyone where you are).
Continued...
by darrylha
2.
Human Rights. Now this one can get me worked up. Personally I believe that we have too many rights. We have the right to beat our wives, kill those who don't follow our god, deny those not of our race/colour/creed the things we expect for ourselves. Prisoners/criminals who have chosen to go against society have rights! Please, this topic makes me sick. America has so many rights and laws protecting those rights they are almost rotting from the inside. Don't get me wrong I DO believe in Human Rights but I also think there is a limit. MODERATION. Human rights is still a topic where we are swinging between extremes. I am not a communist or socialist but it cannot be denied that under dictatorship/socialism/etc there are some benefits.
3.
Responsibilty for policing should fall on us first! When you see someone in need (being mugged, beaten, etc) you don't help do you? By your lack of action you have condoned the crime/wrong doing (don't worry I am not picking on you, I am guilty too). Ultimately we must ALL play our part from you and me to the ISP to the Police and government.
We cannot expect the ISP to carry all the load small bussiness does more for a countries economy than large bussiness so to kill off 50 small ISP's would be devistating. Ignoring the fact that this would head us down the road to monopoly by the large ISP's. Anyway if I was a crime syndicate I would just buy my own ISP and forge the data (no database is 100% secure).
Continued...
by darrylha
So finally my feelings are bring it, but I want to know what information they are collecting about me and be able to view it on request.
I think we should be going to the governments with recommendations not waiting untill they dictate to us. And maybe the hacker community can actually help here... any white hats want to help, you guys know more than the rest of us.
MOST IMPORTANT I think we should all keep our heads. Heed the warnings of Orwell but don't become obsessed by them. Man has a habit of creating something to solve a problem and with the solution comes more problems and so the cycle continues. We must shape the world not our leaders, they are only our spokesman, and yet at times they should dictate to us.
Balance/Zen/Ying andYang.
God Bless and Peace to U ALL.
(Sorry this was so long, but I have a lot of opinions on this subject and they only give 1930 chars)
by paulaaaaaa22
by spider
Johnathan gets an A+.
The Internet has become the bastion of free speech.
This is, of course, unacceptable. Governments worldwide, are no longer concerned with "the needs of
it's citizens", the lame excuse often given for getting out and voting for the "lesser of two evils".
Their only concern is self-preservation, and if this is at the expense of the citizens, so be it. Unassailable fear and paranoia are the tools of the expert, and in the last two years, have created the perfect pipelneby which to "remove excessive freedoms", therby "protecting" us...from what? From ourselves, from criminals, or worse yet, from the truth? The real shame is that by forcing ISPs to monitor net activity, the common man will no longer be able to afford it, the criminal will prosper, the goverments will find new ways to make us criminals and eventully, the ISPs will have a form of absolute power. The law of human nature already tells us that "absolute power corrupts absolutely", which would putthe ISPs in direct conflict with the purpose of, you guessed it...goverment.
by jnoble
The internet is not a right.
The Internet is a utility.
Rights that we (US Citizens) have are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness. We have a bill of rights, and nowhere in that document does it say we have a RIGHT to free and public Internet.
The Internet is a utility. Like your phone services, gas/electric services, driving a car, flying an airplane, etc. There are rules for all of these... and there are licenses and guidelines for the purchase, sale, usage, and security on these as well.
We should remember that the Internet was created for communications during wartime, not to create some utopian dream of world peace and world conscience. The internet has turned into a place where businesses can send data faster, cheaper and better, to allow more free trade, and has improved communications.
These improvements do not come without a price. If people wish the internet to become a cesspool where open combat (cracking), disease (virii), and banal pleasures(porn), are allowed to flourish freely for the sake of "freedoms", then we haven't learned from our own history. Those people who believe the internet is the dawn of a utopian society need to remove the blinders and face the facts. The internet iscurrently diseased. It has cancer, heart problems, can hardly stand, and certainly can't fight. If we don't perform the surgery soon, we won't have anything left to discuss. But you must realize, that to remove this disease and fix the ailments, that some of the good will go with the bad. It is not a perfect system, solution or world.
If you don't agree, please email me a picture of your birth certificate where it shows you guaranteed "One-Free Internet". (goodnub@hotmail.com)
Get over it.
by krm
Get the government out of the internet, they'll only screw it up like they have EVERYTHING ELSE!
What's wrong with "banal pleasures"?
Sorry, but I'll take freedom and responsibility for myself over the illusion of security and government control any day of the week...
by scoid
by medievaldude
>>What's wrong with "banal pleasures"?
you want to do things that are immoral without any consequences.
I think the only people who are concerned about the government regulating the internet are those who want to get away with something.
>>Sorry, but I'll take freedom and responsibility for myself over the illusion of security and government control any day of the week...
Immoral behavior, even on the internet, is not freedom. It is the real slavery, and so many are shackled (perhaps even addicted) in bondage.
by greybeard770
. . . people rob people.
This record keeping would be a nightmare for ISPs to archive that kind of information. For how long would they need those records?
The company I work for uses a firewall system which logs the external sites contacted from inside. That log is about 4 million entries per week. We are not a big operation. Tree huggers cry when somebody requests a printout of that log.
Cars should record everywhere they go, who is driving, passengers, and the speed, and the driver's blood alcohol level, and emotional status, and reason for the trip. Maybe cars should just be outlawed.
Give me a break.
by tomsal
You know stress is bad for you right? So why worry about something like ISP policies to police what you are doing? I don't know about you folks but I don't like stress and therefore I avoid it where possible...work is stressful, heck life is stressful, don't need to add more.
Someone cares about what sites I visits - fine, send me a few bucks I'll burn my history file to CD and mail it to you.
I could care less. So what if a porn site comes up because of an annoying ad that can't be avoided before its recording in some web log. Oh no, someone will think I visited that porn site on purpose (wow and to think I thought I was a grown adult too). I know what I do, I know I don't frequent inappropriate sites -- xxx, piracy sites, warez...if anyone with half a brain looks at a history file and they see one porn site (or piracy, warez, etc.) show for every 100 websites visited and can't guesstimate that "gee may that was unintentional viewing" - they are morons.
So you guys worry about what people are watching you view on the 'net, I'll just make sure I keep people from hacking my passwords to my bank and mortgage accounts and make sure I keep virus attacks at bay.
by richs
by deepsand
To quote Ben Franklin, "He who would trade a small essential freedom for a little temporary security is a scoundrol, and deserves neither freedom nor security."
The idea of treating net traffic as being open to public scrutiny, while other forms of communication are treated as being private, is logically inconsistent, and serves merely to further surrender the general freedom that serves as the keystone of this nations founding tenants.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Security posts
Sort by Trending