Discussion Locked

Fragmented drive array..how do i?

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have a server that is badly fragmented, about 5777 fragmented files and 59000 excess fragments. I have tried diskeeper and it cannot defrag the drive sucessfully. The data is not corrupt, it's just very slow. I have plenty of room for diskeeperto work, about 1.5g on a 8g array. The MFT is also very fragmented, page file is not. I once heard that I can do a full backup on the data, format the drive (OS is on a different drive) and restore the data back, this would give me a clean slate.When I ask around, other techs tell me i will be wasting my time, others tell me to replace the drives. Logically if the data goes on the tape in a contiguous format, will it not go back on the formatted drive in contiguous format. I am getting mixed reviews, is this a viable method to defrag a hard drive?? Thanks for any help you can offer.

9 replies

by ruturaj

Considering the amount of data on your drive I'm assuming you have either exchange or SQL if so try defragging with diskkeeper after stopping all services relating to SQL, Exchange etc it would also be a good idea to stop the netlogon services & breaking all network connections this keeps open files to a minimum.
Hope this helps.

by sdefor

I have already tried with disconnecting everyone and every share. Also I stopped every non critical service that was running. My drives just hold data and 2 main apps.

by Member 35772270

I spent 3 weeks evaluating defrag programs last year for the problem that you have. It was a waste of my time. I found that both diskeeper and speedisk defragmented my data drive (with all files closed) but reported a percentage of my OS disk was still fragmented. So I backed up my data files by copying them to another system to be safe. I then reloaded the system formating all of the drives. Reestablished my share and printers and copied my files back to there orginal location. I did nothave any additional applications installed (just NT server), so take that into consideration before you do anything. Remember to record all of your setting. My solution may not be viable for you, but it worked wonderfully for me. Good Luck....

by greg hayes/raxco software

I assume you are using the commercial version of Diskeeper? If you are using the Win2k built-in - which is a "lite" version of Diskeeper - then it is unable to defragment the MFT.

What does Diskeeper say are the most fragmented files? If you run a Diskeeper defrag pass - immediately , what does Diskeeper say are the most fragmented files? Did they change any at all?

Freespace on NTFS partitions is actually located in 2 different areas - INSIDE of the MFT Reserved Zone and OUTSIDE of the MFT Reserved Zone. Under NT 4, this zone is a fixed size. Under Win2k, it is dynamically allocated on partition mount - up to a max of 12.5% of the partition. This is important as the Microsoft defrag api's don't allow defraggers to move files INTO the reserved zone - thus restricting the actual amount of freespace that is available for defragmenting. Does Diskeeper show any kind of messages related to freespace.

When you say the MFT is fragmented, how many pieces is it in? Diskeeper counts the $MFTMirr as a fragment of the $MFT, even though it is a separate file. Thus, if DK shows the $MFT in 2 pieces, then it is actually in 1 piece (contiguous).

- Greg/Raxco Software

Disclaimer: I work for Raxco Software, the maker of PerfectDisk 2000 which is a competitor of Diskeeper, as a systems engineer in the support department.

by calvin.ctr.best

I have been using Diskeeper on our array and have run into much the same situation. I have found that by either moving the page file completely off the drive or setting it to a minimal size that Diskeeper can then do the job right.

Calvin

This discussion is closed to new replies.