Discussion Locked

FTC launches war on zombie nets

0 helpful
45 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Thursday, June 9, 2005

ZOMBIE WAR GOES WORLDWIDE

By Bob Francis

Posted June 03, 2005 5:00 AM Pacific Time

Give the Federal Trade Commission some credit: It has some marketing skills. "Operation Spam Zombies" got plenty of play recently both because it is a good idea and because the name attracted a lot more attention than it would have if it were, say, "Operation Computer Spring Cleaning." Yawn.

Seriously, the FTC had a program a year or so ago called Operation Secure Your Server. I'm sure you recall that.

Aside from its attention-grabbing name, Operation Spam Zombies appears to at least have some strategy behind it. The program is a worldwide
effort to educate ISPs about the dangers of botnets and their role in the spread of spam.

The FTC has the lead in the U.S., but 20 other countries have also signed on to send information to more than 3,000 ISPs around the world in an effort to disable destructive botnets. The committed countries are already members of the London Action Plan, an international coalition
working to prevent spam. Among those signed up are Canada, Denmark, Germany, Ireland, Japan, the Netherlands, Taiwan, the United Kingdom, and the United States. The missing piece so far is China, the new King of the Zombie PCs, according to several recent surveys. But working together, that's a start.

Botnets, or zombie networks, are groups of computers infected by malware; the malware controls the infected PC and uses it to send spam
or launch DDoS attacks. You know that mail from "eBay" popping in every day asking you to "update your account" and, oh by the way, send credit card information along with it? That was probably sent courtesy of a botnet to make it more difficult to track the e-mail back to its
annoying originator.

A recent survey by anti-spam company CipherTrust estimates that 350,000 PCs a month are being recruited into this zombie army. Other surveys
suggest there are millions of PCs worldwide that can generate spam or create DDoS attacks. Researchers from the Honeynet Project tracked more
than 100 active botnets, including one containing 50,000 compromised zombie machines. That's quite an army of undead.

According to the FTC, the anti-zombie education program consists primarily of a letter sent to ISPs. The letter recommends that the ISP
proactively identify the computers on its network sending above-average numbers of e-mail messages and then find out whether the computers are being used as zombies. The letter suggests that infected machines be quarantined until the zombie software can be purged.

OK, a letter is probably somewhat less threatening than George Romero's zombie eradication recommendation in "Night of the Living Dead." But then, if you recall, that didn't work out so well either.

If you want to keep tabs on the zombie war, check out CipherTrust's Web site and download the Zombie Meter, which tracks worldwide zombie
activity in real time.

If you'd rather not wait on the FTC's letter striking fear into the hearts of the heartless zombie masters, you can look for companies such
as CipherTrust, IronPort, and Symantec, which offer network appliances aimed at keeping your computers zombie-free. Other companies, such as
Postini, offer mail-filtering services. And Avinti recently introduced iSolation Server 2.0, which uses virtual-machine technology to test for
behavior in an e-mail and identify viruses for which there is no known pattern or signature.

Sophos offers software and services to avoid the zombie curse. It also publishes a monthly virus report, so let's check the charts: The top
three computer viruses in May were the W32/Sober-N worm (43.8 percent of reports), followed by the W32/Zafi-D (14.5 percent) and the W32/Netsky-P
(13.1 percent).

"In May we saw a lot of activity surrounding Sober-N as it cunningly climbed the chart by using social engineering tricks, such as offering
free World Cup tickets, to lure recipients into opening the infected attachment," said Gregg Mastoras, senior security analyst at Sophos.

The bilingual Sober-N worm, which typically poses as an offer for tickets to the 2006 World Cup in Germany, was detected at the beginning
of the month and rapidly spread across 40 countries. Here's the part I find stunning: It accounted for 4.5 percent of all e-mail.
Four-point-five percent! That's a lot of soccer fans and a lot of potential zombies.

Bob Francis is a senior writer at InfoWorld

45 replies

by dr dij

Strike 'em hard with those LETTERS!!!

(Since a UN resolution telling zombifiers to stop would be ineffective of course!)

Keep the internet safe for grandparents and kids

In all seriousness, I think we need to make securing computers easier for the clueless. Also ISPs might require certain software and/or config to connect if customer is zombified.

I know that's a long shot but may be essential in the long term. Biz would not think of hooking up to net without firewall, etc. (tho some do)

by deepsand

A defense that relies solely on fortifying the targets a) is resource intensive, b) does nothing to get non-productive traffic off the channels, and c) is a reactive approach that does nothing to avert attacks via new vectors.

Without the active co-operation of the communications industry in general, and the ISPs in particular, we are doomed to forever trying to hide, each within his own armor.

by jmgarvin

Let the user retaliate. Let vigilante groups form. I'm dead tired of all the zombies and unsecured computers on the broadband "LANs." I'm tired of being port scanned by johnny script kiddie and I want to bring him to his knees.

/old guy "get off my lawn" rant

by dr dij

I just didn't think letters will do anything, but are probably a necessary requisite to passing law or industry best policy self policing, cooperation.

by deepsand

Yup; the kiddies got no respect for we OM, that's for sure.

Were it not for the fact that Adelphia might retaliate against some of my clients for violating their Terms of Service (ToS), I'd launch counter-strikes against the zombies on their loops. Given that they're on 24/7, so that even if they have a dynamic IP address it remains their's forever, they're real easy to find.

If a simple software firewall can ID them, why can't & does'nt Adelphia shut themdown for violating the ToS?

by roger99a

I've been saying it for months. ISP's should limit access to port 25 and this problem would slow to a crawl.

by antuck

Actually, SBC in the Chicago area, not sure if they did it else where, blocked port 25. The problem came from people using there own domains suddenly couldn't get email and had to go through SBC servers. This would be so much of a problem had they let the users know before hand. But suddenly one day emails stopped flowing.

by dr dij

you can ask for exceptions.
since zombified pc users are unlikely to ask, as the real owners are not triggering the spam
and
the zombie lords will just move onto next pc

by roger99a

Cox internet did it to me, too, but I think it was more of a ploy to get another $30/month out of me for a commercial account. I know they didn't do it over their whole network because I still get viruses and spam from their DHCP clients.

by antuck

I love the use of WAR in everything now a days. We have the war on drugs, war on terrorism, war on zombie computers and the war on common sense. I keep picturing a special ops team crashing in and taking out the bad guys. So far I've seen the war on drugs fail. We'll never win that war. The war on terrorism I see as failing. There are to many groups out there hiding so I don't see that being a war to be won. The war on zombie computers will be lost as well due to the war on common sense people have. So far the only war being won is the one on common sense. And that should be the easist one to win. Why do we use the word "WAR" for everything?

by dr dij

someone got offended when I jokingly suggested we allocate $87 billion and descend on the florida trailer parks where many US spammers operate their zombie spam nets from.

Commandos will raid the trailers, arrest and imprison people who are even suspected of doing this indefinitely.

send them to Gitmo, pee on their copy of windows scripting and activex book. They'll talk (we hope)

by antuck

Well it couldn't have been the Bush's who were offened. They would love that kind of money.

News break: Roits started in Redmond WA. over the peeing on windows scripting and activex books. The govenrment has declared WAR on people who pee.

by synthetic

So that when real war is made by our fearless leaders (how long was Bush in Vietnam, How many deferments did Cheny get?), we are so immune to the horrible implications the average Joe does nothing (until his kid is drafted).

by dr dij

they changed deaths to 'casualties' but eventually this means the same thing to us.

I hear the mil now calls them 'trits' (short for attritions). As if changing the name will turn focus.

by dr dij

we have an effective polio vaccine but people are still getting this in remote areas of the world I believe

by synthetic

No amount of legislation, no "war", will win the "fight" against spam, and phishing. As long a one in a million buys one of those stupid cameras, or gives their account info from some of that sweet sweet Nigerian money, these things won't stop. The only way to rid ourselves of this garbage (not having a zombie machine, that is another argument involving monopolies, bad reactive updates, and all the marketers in Washington who will be the first against the wall when the revolution comes) is to not make it profitable, this means everyone using common sense, which means in the end were screwed and this stuff will go on indefinitely. After the nuclear war, only twinkers, cockroaches, and spammers will survive.

by deepsand

As long as there are marks, the shills & ropers won't be very far away.

The only thing that changes is the con itself.

by deepsand

Rank, w/ [b]%[/b] of [b]Total Worldwide[/b] Bots

1) 7% - Winsford
2) 5% - London
3) 2% - Seoul

Think Neil's got anything to do with this?

by deepsand

Study: AOL Leads in Zombie Infections

Internet giant's customers account for the highest percentage of infected PCs, researcher says.

John E. Dunn, Techworld.com
Thursday, June 16, 2005

AOL is the global network most infected with "zombie" PCs, according to a new study.

Prolexic has spent the last six months compiling information on the problem of zombies using real-world denial-of-service attack attempts generated by the hijacked machines. AOL accounted for 5.3 percent of all infections, with Deutsche Telekom in second place with 4.67 percent, and Wannadoo third with 3.27 percent.

The most infected countries as a percentage of the total detected were the U.S. (18 percent), China (11.2 percent), Germany (9.6 percent), the U.K. (5.1 percent), and France (5.1 percent). However, calculating zombie numbers on a per capita basis, the most infected countries turned out to be Hong Kong, Germany, Malaysia, Hungary, and the U.K., in that order.

High Profile ISPs
"It shouldn't be a surprise to find that some of the most high profile Internet Service Providers are most susceptible to providing a safe haven for large numbers of zombie PCs," says Prolexic CTO Barrett Lyon. "It is these networks which are continually being exploited to support large scale DDoS attacks."

"Just because a home user subscribes to a reputable brand doesn't mean they're safe from the online criminal fraternity," he says.

AOL has since defended itself by pointing out that it is by some way the largest ISP, and that the number of zombies on its network is actually low in relation to the total number of its subscribers.

Prolexic was at pains to emphasize that its zombie data was culled from attempted real-world attacks, and not traffic to research honeypots, used by some to calculate zombie incidence. The company's business is in selling "clean pipe" Internet connections so the assumption is that the data comes from attempts through its own network.

The company said it had seen a shift in the way zombies were being used for DDoS attacks in recent months. Attackers now favored "full connection based flood" whereby real IP addresses were apparent to the defenders. Such a brute force type of approach could still work because the sheer number of addresses could overload blacklisting systems.

by jmgarvin

AOL really doesn't care about security...gee...sounds like EVERY OTHER ISP...argg...

by deepsand

Bad sh*t gets propagated via broadband; dial-up simply offers too few opportunity for reproduction.

It's the operators of the local nets, with cable ISP being the worst, who provide the environment for efficient reproduction, who are in the best postition to control such but don't.

AOL users simply tend to be unsophisticated, making them better hosts.

by beads

Until ISPs can market that they are zombie free zones theres little you can do about it. Problem is monitoring requires activity by both a computerized system and by a technician. This of course makes people squimish as there may be things in email that you don't want others to see. With that said reading the first few lines of a message or subject a few thousand times for similiarities is should be enough for a monitoring program to kick out a sample for human analysis.

The downside is that someone is going to start spewing on about freedom to speech/spam. Its a really fine line here for the ISPs working with a fairly small margin of profitability but one I think is being overlooked.

Personally, I like "Blars", http://www.blars.org/errors/block.html, outlook on things. He doesn't just block individual spammers but ENTIRE ISPs for not blocking spam. If enough folks out there were to block more range blocks, besides those from the usual sources in China, the Koreas and Brazil, to name a few you've probably seen if your actively blacklisting, then and only then would you see any curbing of spam.

Punish the ISPs then the individual!

- beads

by deepsand

June 15, 2005

AOL: We're Not Zombie Haven

By Gregg Keizer Courtesy of TechWeb News

America Online hosts more denial-of-service (DoS) spewing zombie PCs than any other ISP in the world, a report released Tuesday claimed. AOL thinks that's just fine.
Prolexic, a Florida-based company that offers a DoS mitigation service, tracked attempted attacks over the last six months to rank ISPs. AOL topped the global and U.S. domestic lists, with machines that use it as their link to the Internet accounting for 5.3 percent of DoS attacks worldwide, and 11.7 percent of those conducted in the U.S.

Worldwide, the German family of Deutsche Telekom ISPs -- t-ipconnect.de and t-dialin.net, among others -- came in second. In the U.S., Comcast, Bell South, Verizon, and Ameritech fleshed out the top five.

"We're the largest ISP on the planet," Andrew Weinstein, a spokesman for AOL, said Wednesday. "You'd expect us to have the most zombies."

Weinstein went on to say that Prolexic's numbers were actually good news for AOL. "It's a demonstration that the tools we provide are keeping members safe. Our very aggressive actions -- we provide anti-virus, anti-spyware, and firewall services to our users -- make them measurably safer than those on other ISPs."

Weinstein based that take on a comparison of Prolexic's numbers with the U.S. installed base of each ISP. Assuming JupiterResearch's estimate of AOL membership rolls is on target at 21.7 million, America Online accounts for .54 percent of the total U.S. DoS attacks for each million subscribers. Comcast, on the other hand, has just 7.4 million users, but accounted for 10.7 percent of the DoS attacks, for a rate of 1.44 percent per million. Verizon, meanwhile, posted a per million rate of 1.9 percent.

"That's three or four times as many attacks per million subscribers," Weinstein argued. "The numbers show that AOL members are significantly less likely to have been compromised by a zombie. This is actually good news for our users."

Some major U.S. ISPs were notable by their absence. EarthLink, for instance, the fourth largest provider according to JupiterResearch, was not on the list of the top 20, although Mindspring, which EarthLink acquired in 1999, came in at number 17, accounting for 1.3 percent of the DoS attacks tracked by Prolexic in the U.S.

by jmgarvin

ZING! Sorry folks across the pond, I'm a dumb American and I don't know any better :-)

by dr dij

As I drive down the local streets, I regularly see 'No P' signs (a big sign with a capital P with a red circle and slash covering the P).

What else could this mean but 'No Peeing' ?
I tell my gal friend that I was going to stop and take a wiz by the side of the road except for that sign, (and she wacks me, wonder why?)

We must have alot of bums here in So. Cal.

by jmgarvin

When you ban a whole ISP (eg AOL) you could be potentially banning content that you (or your users) may need.

I do agree it would be a good thing to do...and I think I'll start doing it at home...

by deepsand

The problem with zombies lies in machines connected to broadband nets, which have nothing to do with AOL.

And, the sender's address on most spam is spoofed. Spammers spoof domains such as AOL & Hotmail simply because the large customer base makes it easier to find valid e-mail addresses to use as "senders."

AOL's approach to this problem is downright draconian.

If an AOL account holder's AOL e-mail address is so spoofed, with the result that AOL receives either a bounce-back or an abuse report, they shut down the account until such time as the account holder can convince them that they were not responsible for the e-mail(s) in question. They will [b]not[/b] first examine the headers of said e-mails; [b]neither[/b] will they provide such to the account holder.

With AOL, you're guilty until proven innocent; and, they seal all the evidence! This has caused many an innocent party to lose their AOL acount, with [b]no[/b] reimbursement for the remaining balance of their subscription period.

So, blocking AOL domains will do nothing to combat zombies & little to reduce spam.

by jmgarvin

Take a look at the mess of comcast...look how many zombies are your neighbors! Pretty scary stuff.

Oh, and I love getting the email from "pay-pal" and "e-bay" that I need to "reset" my account. Just peachy.

by dr dij

blars blocked my domain because spammers were faking email from it. He apparently didn't examine the header. He called my ISP (cihost) but they ignored him as email didn't come from their servers. Yet he still mistakenly blocks my domain because it is 'convenient' and DOES catch some spam. I don't really care because I don't email from it but BLARS MAINTAINS AN INACCURATE AND FAULTY LIST!

by deepsand

As a "Polio Volunteer," I was specifically designated as a combatant in the "War on Polio."

by deepsand

Rendering an ISP's net free of zombies requires no monitoring of content, but only of the specific types of traffic generated the client machines on its net.

And, as the activity of zombies wastes bandwidth, there is in fact a real benefit to be had for the ISP if such were to be curbed.

As for domain blocking, see my above post, at
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=4&threadID=176090&messageID=1793922[/v]

by jmgarvin

They seem to at worst be cousins and at best be one in the same.

If we could stop most of the zombies we could probably slow down a good portion of spam...

by dr dij

Blars is the fellow who has blocked MY domain for sending spam. In fact I have NEVER sent a SINGLE EMAIL from my domain, and it is well locked down (on a commercial host with no relaying, etc).

Spammers like to fake return address using my domain as 1) it is short, 2) I have a 'catchall' email for it so bounces that come to me instead of telling them it is invalid email address they're being sent from.

He didn't have an answer to this. He blocked my domain even tho he knows the emails are faked. Not that I really care alot as I use a different return address for any email I send out.

But this is a real indication that email is broken. He blocks my domain as it is expendient, and he's getting only spam from it, (even tho the spam is not actually from my domain).

Anyway I just wanted to expound on the inaccuracies of blocking lists and their problems.
I think it is fine for private individual to have block lists.

However if 1) I wanted to use the domain e.g. my biz domain, and 2) it was a gov't list and 'official' I might have problems getting them to remove me from it due to spammers, etc. In this case I'd have a real problem that the gov't was maintaining an inaccurate list. Deepsand, this is part of my argument against centralized blocking lists run by govts.

It probably does help to block whole ranges of addresses for many biz that would never get a valid customer from them.

by deepsand

What I did propose was a centralized, industry controlled system for identifying those to be blocked, with the blocking function being de-centralized.

This would afford for uniformity & consistency, along with a single point of appeal.

As things stand now, we've a bunch of self-appointed "guardians" who are accountable to no one but themselves.

by deepsand

Cable nets are inherently more at risk than are others; although it's much smaller, Adelphia is just as well compromised as is ComCast.

See following for AOL's response to their being named the zombie-meister.

[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=4&threadID=176090&messageID=1796923[/v]

by deepsand

This subject came up in other discussions.

The problem you've experienced is the reason that I argued for a centralized system for identifying those to be blacklisted, with the blocking being done on a distributed system.

Until then, we're all at the mercy of a bunch of demi-gods.

by deepsand

June 15, 2005

Major Spam Purveyor Agrees To Pay Settlement

By Thomas Claburn Courtesy of InformationWeek

Creaghan A. Harry is getting off easy. The accused spammer and perpetrator of fraud, based in Boca Raton, Fla., has agreed to settle charges brought against him by the Federal Trade Commission for $485,000, less than a tenth of the estimated $5.9 million consumer injury the FTC attributes to his sham anti-aging and weight-loss products.
Harry gets to keep the bulk of his $2.4 million estate thanks to Florida's homestead and asset-protection laws. Though the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005, signed into law in April, includes homestead-protection limitations that might have enabled the FTC to seek more of Harry's assets, the agency decided in a 4-to-1 vote not to risk the almost half-million-dollar settlement for a potentially larger sum.

Steven Wernikoff, staff attorney for the FTC, notes in an E-mail message that the agency based its monetary judgment on the defendant's ability to pay. "The Florida homestead exemption protects a primary residence from most involuntary liens regardless of the circumstances," he writes. "Thus, Mr. Harry was left with some equity in his homestead. This exemption frustrates the ability of the commission to obtain maximum recovery for consumers."

The irony is that, according to court filings, the complex network of businesses Harry used to peddle his quack cures barely touched Florida. Allegedly, he paid a California company to manufacture "Supreme Formula HGH"--ostensibly a human growth hormone product that promotes weight loss during sleep and prevents biological aging--and paid a South Dakota company for customer order fulfillment and credit-card processing.

The FTC claims Harry had proceeds from the sale of his bogus health products wired to a bank account in Latvia, all the while concealing his identity using the name Greg Miller and various unregistered business located in Canada, Sweden, and Switzerland with names such as Scientific Life Nutrition and Rejuvenation Health Corp. Web sites that sold his products don't identify any business name and are registered to individuals in China, court documents note.

While the continued abundance of spam suggests that prosecuting spammers is a quixotic crusade, Wernikoff believes legal pressure helps. "We believe it does have a practical effect," he says, noting that technological countermeasures and education are also part of the solution.

Certainly the Can Spam Act of 2003 is helpful for prosecutors. The FTC charges the defendant with numerous violations of the law, including sending messages with false and misleading header information, failure to provide a valid opt-out mechanism, and routing messages through poorly secured third-party computers, or "open proxies."

But when thousands of people are paying $80 online for supposed hormones that prevent aging, increase memory, boost sexual potency, and erase cellulite, law and technology face a real challenge in compensating for lack of common sense.

This discussion is closed to new replies.