Discussion Locked

Hackers, crackers, etc. - treated like heros?

0 helpful
184 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
IT professionals are fascinated by hackers, crackers, etc. On the one hand, this is interesting coding. On the other hand it makes so many people's work more difficult, takes away from the time people can devote on other aspects of their work. Are we fueling the fire or just getting to understand the enemy? Is this IT's version of the Sopranos?

184 replies

by kevaburg

Ever seen the film? We have a lot to learn from these people. Wrong-doers should be punished severely but those that want to genuinely reform should be welcomed into our community with open arms. What better way to protect against unethical hackers than to have an ethical hacker on your side?

by Member 22744991

This particular topic is ammusing at best. Hackers, crackers, avwriters, phreaks, etc are no more heros that they are villians. Nore are they any worse / more acceptable that govenrment agents, either our side or theirs (which ever our/their side might be for any of us). Think of them as some would a layers. . . an evil, nescessity.

The term "hacker" has lost its original meaning over the years (at least in the technology world). Now days, there are some many people that are dropped into the catagory of hackers, despite the fact that they have only a remedial understanding of technology let alone can only dream of coding in assembly.

If not for hackers, hundreds of thousands of bugs and whole would exist in every piece of software. We could debate the concept that "if there were no hackers to uncover the exploits, we would never need to patch them". This is true, but at some point someone would discover it. Now, here is something for the security community to think about:

Which weould you rather have"
1-A number of unknowledgable scriddies attempting to attack your environment, using methods that were discoverd as the result of some hacker posting the vulnerbility to Bugtraq
2-Insecure code in your environment, which is never discovered because its never been tested/investigated/hacked/counter engireered?

Being in the security arena (you guess which hat), it is not what you see that you need to be most concerend with, but that which you do not see.

I say allow the hackers to continue. Allow them to test the waters. Are they making things more difficult for us? Sure, but like I tell my kid: The only way you get better it to be challanged. The same applied with the Infosec arena

by chucklereed

to call purveyors of malware a necessity to point out sucurity weaknesses is like saying murderers are necessary to show how people may be slayed

by dcollins1

Any first year grad can design a virus but do they also know how much damage they cause by there program

by amsoft1993

As a software developer now network security specialist, I think the facination (worship) of hackers / crackers from IT pros is limited to those in the field who know very little about software development an computer programming. I have seen cracker code, and believe me, most of it is poorly designed and is full of bugs, but if the ultimate purpose is to destabilize a computer or network, it's more than sufficient. It should be required for Administrators to at least have a fundamental understanding of programming, OS APIs and how to programatically access the TCPIP protocol stack.

by andeanderson

You are correct in saying Administrators should have a fundamental understanding of programming to counter the hackers/crackers.

I, for one, do not have the luxury to spend too much time, or resources, re-learning basic programming to battle hackers/crackers and elected to take a "Certified" course called "Certified Ethical Hacker" which was advertised to prepare corporations to defend against hackers/crackers.

I left the class entertained by some of the stories and by a classroom network that got hit by a virus just after the Instructor finished bragging about how he had never used an Anti-Virus program and had never been infected.

After getting the server reloaded, half of the programs we were supposed to learn about would not work, it was a mix of Windows and Linux, so we were told to find them on the Internet and study them at home on our own.

I found I had learned more about protecting my network on my own than what this so-called "Certified" class taught me. Maybe they should have hired a real Hacker to teach the course instead of just a Book-Educated "Expert."

by aaron a baker

I have absolutely no respect or regard for hackers.
why go into someone's else's source code if not to figure it out and possibly make changes? Why the bother? I believe that there are two types of Hackers out there. Hacker A, being the letch that goes into a program and alters it to function for his/her own nefarious purpose. Hacker B, "Not acknowledged" is the person who goes into a source to learn and. These would never dream of inflicting discomfort on the Computing world and so for the most part remain unrecognized. These I can respect and even admire. WE all want to learn and in this business, it doesn't take very long for one to get left behind so you always have to be on the lookout for what you might have missed. But these are the "Good" hackers. As for the Other vermin out there, I still believe that a very stiff Jail sentence,instead of a pat on the back would go a long way towards reducing their numbers. AS it is now, some of us are actually stupid enough to hire them, under the false impression that" While they are on our side they won't affect us", How absurd. Hackers A, are vermin who couldn't come up with the required credentials for an honest position so they resort to attention getting by disruption thereby costing us Millions in untold damages.
Not to mention what we have to go through. It's pretty hard to have anything but disdain and disgust for these B types.
Problem is, How do we tell them apart?
And so it goes.
Regards
Aaron A Baker

by kevaburg

On one hand you say you have no respect for hackers. On the second hand you say you respect and even admire other hackers that "want to learn". If they want to learn, read a book!

To say that you have no respect for, I presume, unethical hackers, is a very dangerous position to take. These people probably have a better working knowledge of our networks than we do. They have to in order to do the job they do.

As hacking of any description is illegal (unless governed by specific contracts for penetration testing) the view I get of your opinion is that this illegal activity is OK for the chosen few on your list.

by semmyd

Love them or hate them they have directly affected our work as network and systems admins. We have to catch up fast and we have to learn what they know otherwise we are going to be found with egg on our faces all the time. Whether you like it or not security has become a critical area for a lot of organisations. Companies now want to hire SysAdmins who have a working knowledge and are consious of security. Its a shape up or ship out scenario. What better way to learn about protecting your network than to hack it yourself!

Changing times!! I have found the SANS curriculum to be quite educative in this respect all though very pricy.

by jez

To kevaburg .... hacking itself is not illegal. Unauthorised access to a system or data is the illegal part.

If it wasnt for hacking ( the good kind ) there would be no linux.

You need these people bad and good to keep us on our toes in making secure systems and keep us up to date with their depth of knowledge.

This is not a black and white argument.

by amyousso

As systems & network admins, we need to learn the techniques the hackers use, to protect our systems and sometimes save us time.

For example this weekend we had no way to work around a lost admin password in one of our main WinNT servers.

We had to work all the weekend on that. But thanks to some website that gives hacking tips, we could easily access the SAM (Database that hold users and pwds) delete it, booted with a blank admin password and restored our system. (so, are we illegal !!)

I would like to describe hackers as opposition parties in a democratic country.

When there is opposition parties, the ruling party can better watch out before making decisions.

So, let us better protect our systems and let hacker enjoy their hobby.

by amyousso

As systems & network admins, we need to learn the techniques the hackers use, to protect our systems and sometimes save us time.

For example this weekend we had no way to work around a lost admin password in one of our main WinNT servers.

We had to work all the weekend on that. But thanks to some website that gives hacking tips, we could easily access the SAM (Database that hold users and pwds) delete it, booted with a blank admin password and restored our system. (so, are we illegal !!)

I would like to describe hackers as opposition parties in a democratic country.

When there is opposition parties, the ruling party can better watch out before making decisions.

So, let us better protect our systems and let hacker enjoy their hobby.

by theundertaker

Interesting perspective... But I have a question: How are books written? By people who have done "something" and want to share their findings (or want to capitalize on a current trend by merely re-stating what hundreds of others have previously stated, but that is another rant). Even in college, when we "read a book" isn't that followed by lecture and then some sort of examination to test the subject matter of the reader?
Now before you fire off with some foolishness, allow me to expound. I do NOT advocate any illegal activity, but there are ways to learn that are legal and ethical (VMWare, networking with others, sharing environments, etc). As with open source software, having many eyes looking at a problem will result in new problems, followed by new and creative solutions.
Breaking into systems is trivial, and defacing web sites is foolish. The really "fun" aspect is in defending your site against the ones that choose the "wrong" side. Playing the game 7x24 and keeping things secure while pitting your intelligence against the collective brainpower of the rest of the planet, now THAT is a rush (and the true test of one's skills). This is a task that gains (and deserves) others respect.
Please remember that the essence of hacking is looking for and gaining knowledge, not breaking into systems or releasing malicious worms/viruses.

by simplyshaman

ok first off.. kev.. he's got a point... those who take a look but don't cause harm.. only help the it community... most of the time what the "true" hackers ,or that which was originally known as white hat, are about is to help other programmers tighten security by leaving little notes in a system they've penetrated... the human capacity to learn is absolutely profound... and there is only so much that can be found in a book... but as far as hiring so called hackers when put in regard to these malware coders out there... they're not hackers.. not in the original sense of the term.. but they do serve a purpose... they help to debug our systems by showing us where our programming and security flaws are... yea i'd hire them... but they would be watched...

by aaron a baker

misunderstated my intent. What I can and do admire about "Some People" is that they are willing to into a program to "Learn". I can't think of another name for it as it could easily be thought of as hacking. Once your in, you've hacked, that's the bottom line. So what's the difference, the difference is the reason for the act. I respect anybody to tries to better him/herself. This is not the same as hacking for the purpose of altering and /or causing malfeasance.
I have on many occasion gone into a program, "To Learn" and I've learned a lot. That doesn't make me a hacker, " I don't change a single thing. It make's me a person who is learning. Not all of us had the luxury, not matter how earned of going to a school to be taught and had to learn on our own. So it was with me and I've been learning since 1985. Allow me then to restate, there is a vast difference between the person who want's to learn and the scum who do everything they can to cause discord/damage and disorder. To me, this widens my"Chosen few" list to much more than might be imagined. As a matter of fact, I never met a Tech who hadn't gone into someone else' program, does that make them bad, see my point? We are not all bad, we just want to learn. The trick is, how do you tell us apart?
Hackers in the true sense of the word are vile and should be treated as such. However I for one refuse to stop learning on the basis that I might be thought of as one of those. There is an awful lot of knowledge out there and we'd be foolish not to take advantage of the learning possibilities.
And so it goes
Thanks for the comeback.
Aaron

by ni70

[i][b]HACKER[/b]: A slang term for a computer enthusiast, i.e., a person who enjoys learning programming languages and computer systems and can often be considered an expert on the subject(s). Among professional programmers, depending on how it used, the term can be either complimentary or derogatory, although it is developing an increasingly derogatory connotation. The pejorative sense of hacker is becoming more prominent largely because the popular press has coopted the term to refer to individuals who gain unauthorized access to computer systems for the purpose of stealing and corrupting data. [b]Hackers, themselves, maintain that the proper term for such individuals is cracker.[/b]

[b]CRACKER[/b]: (1) To break into a computer system. The term was coined in the mid-80s by hackers who wanted to differentiate themselves from individuals whose sole purpose is to sneak through security systems. Whereas crackers sole aim is to break into secure systems, hackers are more interested in gaining knowledge about computer systems and possibly using this knowledge for playful pranks. [b]Although hackers still argue that there's a big difference between what they do and what crackers do, the mass media has failed to understand the distinction, so the two terms -- hack and crack -- are often used interchangeably.[/b]

(2) To copy commercial software illegally by breaking (cracking) the various copy-protection and registration techniques being used.[/i]

It amazes me that even IT Professionals do not know the difference between hackers & crackers. I'm a computer enthusiast, which by definition makes me a hacker, but in no means makes what I do illegal. I enjoy working with computers and open source software, by [i]hacking[/i] the source code to get it to work the way I want it to work. I just wish people would use the term hacker properly!

Post edited because some still don't understand the difference between [i][b]hack[/b] and [b]crack[/b][/i].

by el_gazzítò

That is great. I agree fully. To Hack a program is to go through it step by step and learn how it achieves what it was written to do. Everyone who is tech savvy must have done this at least once.

Doesn't matter if the program was written in BASIC, COBOL, C, Assembly or any other language. If you have done this, then you have hacked.

Also, there really is no better way to learn how to program assembly, than to go through someone elses code. You can learn "All there is to know" from books, and that is great, but there is no better way to learn (for me anyways) than to actually see it in action.

??? Hasta Lasag?e !!!

Gazz.

by dgenerous1

i lost several moths of schooling because of people not understanding the differnce in what i do(my highschool took my laptop away several times and could never get into it to prove what i was doing, but caused my other classes to slip cause they had all my work) and what the little shits at the end of the room where trying to do. if people who are in a point of power came to understand the differnce in the two types of people who hack and crack then our life would be simpler and people would have less right to hate us and have more cause to go after those whom need to be caught( i still think the goverment is pushing this confustion of terms)

by cmurray8

In my humble opinion the IT industry has had a fascination with 'dark side' programmers since their 'creation' in the 1960s. In some perverse way they have advanced the IT industry which I'm sure many would not admit to.

by joeaaa3

1. Hammer
2. Nail
Add an adequate amount of force with 1. to stike 2. and you have it.
You hit the nail right on the head. Too much armchair discussion on a subject that has been around for a long time, enough said.

by rlutes

Let's define the name...First most of today's press goes to the errant kid who knows how to "google" and download someone's piece of work. If you are in charge of defending a network and budgeting for it you may feel different about respecting anyone that comes peeking into your "windows".

For the shear pucker factor take a job that will fire you when one of your so called heros does penetrate your network.

It is illegal and unethical to trespass.

by techrepublic

A few years ago I did a career day talk for a Junior High school. The majority of the questions afterwards were some form of "how do you hack?"

by kevaburg

I worked as a techy in a school for kids between the ages of 11-17 and how many questions got directed towards me regarding how to hack? Too many to be healthy!

Hollywood in this case I feel is to blame. Hacking has been glorified for years and you only have to watch "War Games", "Hackers", "Password:Swordfish" and the "Matrix" trilogy to witness that for yourself.

Hollywood made them heroes.

by ilmotore

I'd like to know where the data that implies IT professionals are fascinated with hackers comes from.

In the case of virus writers, or those that copy and modify other's viruses, I don't know anyone who has had to deal the results of their "work" who doesn't wish a whole lot of jail time for these miscreants.

The ones that "hack" keys codes to pirate software and such are just criminals that should be prosecuted.

If they are writing rsp like coolwebsearch, they definately need some jail time.

Sorry, but I don't admire criminals and pests.

by kevaburg

But try explaining that to some of the earlier posts inthis discussion! Respect hackers by all means. That implies understanding they can cause damage and means need to be implemented. Admire and become fascinated by them? Sounds to me like someone wanting to be one without the braincell to do it!

by dgenerous1

those a$$holes who write the coolwebsearch crap and the spyware idiots need jail time but what their doing is leagel, 1) you downloaded there software so you acecpt the ussage agreement 2) you donloaded someone elses work for you enjoyment and didnt pay them in currency so they have asked you by way of the usage agreement to share your computer for there research( wich in most cases is you)
and i have a couple good queston for you: how much of you software is the original disc? and if you lost you cd-keys wouldnt you go online and get a keygen or go to a list of keys so you could use your disc?
for a company to see that its sales are going down due to piracy is a complement not an injustice, hiking the price to some astronmical leve of 400$cnd for windows xp sp2 and a key that may nolonger be valid is not worth it especialy when the whole disc is downloadable from th ms website. and its also true the its that dont really have a clue( the ones that are sent to the odd windws has frozen case or are made to systematicly replace comps on a network) are the ones whom are fasinated with the "hackes and crackers" that the media spews out, and some are jelous that its usually a kid in his/her early teens to late teen(very odd that a hacker of 25 is put on tv) can out think and manouver them n the it world

by kevaburg

Surely if a hacker has gained access to a system that the person does not belong in, that is illegal? To that end, I agree entirely with ethical hacking to determine a networks strengths and weaknesses but these projects have to have very clearly defined goals and restrictions to prevent this turning from a gain to a loss.

Hackers certainly do keep us on our toes, but there is a difference between that and willfully destroying or exposing sensitive data.

You are right: There is no black and white but at which point do we draw the line?

by rlutes

Why didnt you do what every other windows admin does. Start loading windows and restore the currently installed version.

Apparently you havent had to budget for or tell your stockholders WHY? some clown broke into your network.

by kevaburg

I think there is a difference between accessing legitimate resources on your own network and accessing resources that you shouldn't on another. If it wasn't for that point and the problem you described, all password recovery software, port-scanning tools and the such-like would be illegal to purchase.

I think the keywords are "authorised" and "unauthorised" access and how the terms are defined by a companies IT Security Policy.

by dgenerous1

if it was a point of athorization then all one would have to do is submit a notice of intent to a company and if they dont directly tell you not to then you could assume athority and access their systems. beyond that it becomes grey because you need proof that you were there and its always easier to copy a file then to plant one(one that they can delete to say you were never in the system) and then again they could also have you arrested for tampering in vital information( that consequently does not have to be prooven in court) and since 9/11 im sure were all on the lists of people who know too much just because were in it/is and not there back pockets

by avid

you have watched too many hacker movies. obviously ou know nothing about the law. "if it was a point of athorization then all one would have to do is submit a notice of intent to a company and if they dont directly tell you not to then you could assume athority and access their systems." what the hell. are you going to write a letter to some one and, if they don't answer, assume that you have their permission to access the systems ? how old are you anyway? you sound like you are about 14. am i close ? do you really think that the government gives a rats a$$ about some little kid. do you seriuosly think that your name is anywhere on a government list of people who "know too much"? this is the real world and as bad as it may bruise your little ego, no one in the government even cares who you are. you just are not that important.

by leoxml

I am afraid to say nothing new, but in essence IT as it seems to develop (not just computing hard tasks) is the exploration of new possibilities. You may call that possibilities: cybernetics, information power, etc. All these terms are same fascinating as people involved. Simply, if it works and could be programmed - it is IT. Hackers are IT heroes in the way they do their own decision (have time, will and take risk), not just follow market needs.
As you noticed I exracted IT from the mix of legality and ethics. Do you realy think IT is strictly humanitarian and The Matrix is a waste?

by rlutes

Technology was leveraged to AUTOMATE mundane routine tasks. As such we also stored data. Some of you may not remember or even have a clue how to do what your computer does for you. IT is just a means to an end a utility.

by kevaburg

IT has helped to streamline businesses to help increase productivity with lowered associated expenses. I don't believe you can call it just "a means to an end". The problem is that this productivity suffers because admins are taken away from the business afairs of a company to deal with the hackers that are engaging in what I see as "playground bullying"!

IT plays a huge, misson-critical role in most businesses, but now, instead of supporting the company, it has to support itself first so that it becomes an asset and not a hindrance.

by 1ronman

I read some of your replies and I think "man what a bunch of foolish little children"! for example, dahabam says "I would like to describe hackers as opposition parties in a democratic country" and "let hacker enjoy their hobby" What a dope! or leoxml who thinks "hacking is no different from exploring" and says "Hackers are IT heroes in the way they do their own decision (have time, will and take risk), not just follow market needs". Obviously you should have been beaten as a child and your mommy never taught you right from wrong. How about I go exploring in your bank account and take your money for my own because "I'm willing to take a risk?, and its your fault I took your money because you should have protected it better! Or how about I "go exploring" in your house. If I find something I think is cool, I get to keep it because you were foolish enough not to protect it better (ha ha on you!) What a dope. Or how about break into your your moms or grandma's house and take their stuff because I'm willing to "take a risk". Here?s the point that you parents failed to teach you. It?s wrong to take other peoples stuff. Its wrong to go into other people houses (they call people like that burglars) maybe you think they are cool too though so my point will be lost on you and the other dummies in any case) Breaking into someone?s house, breaking into someone?s personal information, breaking into someone?s computer.....maybe I could draw you a bmp.

by shorne

Hey Mr. GB4
I happen to agree with what you are saying in this post, but after your parents taught you all that good stuff about right and wrong didn't they have any time left for social skills? Calling people morons and dopes may not be entirely effective in attempting to get your point across.

by jwasserman

I think the major source of confusion on this topic is that the how you define "hacking".

I don't think that any one will argue that unauthorized access to systems and the execution of malicious code is wrong.

I believe that hacking has a much broader definition. Tweaking apps or an OS to meet you needs on your own pc has long been considered a 'hack'. Doesnt anyone remember using resource editors to change icons before they added the funtionality to the standard OS's? What about 'easter eggs in applications and OSs? How about forcing an OS to to show different folder backgrounds (perhaps to tell what server the files are on at a glance)? Most of the nice little features of a the GUI interfaces we all use started out that way.

Network intrusions/attacks use 'hacks' to do thier dirty work.

Similarly, locksmithing is not a crime, but using those skills/techniques for unauthorized entry is illegal.

The term 'hacking' has been coopted by the media to explain something they have trouble explaining to the public and as a catch phrase that is easy to sell airtime and paper.

We need a better word to describe intrusions and attacks. The industry needs to differentiate the techinques from the illegal acts that can be committed using the techniques

by roadbiker

The problem is youth having an extreem lack knowledge and acceptance of ethics and the glorification of what is esentially electronic vandalism.

by avid

i think gb4 is absolutely right. HACKING IS WRONG. stealing is wrong. you can't just rename a thief and make him a hero. this is not a robin hood situation. hackers are cowardly thieves.

by rlutes

First off though. I see too many people develop and expend energy and capital for the sake of IT. For that reason some things are a means to an end. IT by it self does not make money unless you are selling services or information.

by kevaburg

People that don't understand the technology think throwing money at security and expending energy almost randomly is the answer. I recently took part in a roll-out in Germany and the project management team wanted to put a RIP1 compliant personal router into an OSPF network without permission because someone mentioned segmenting the installation network!!!!

Maybe the people you are talking about need to spend more money on training and awareness rather than hardware?

by rlutes

As a consultant I make systems work as inexpensively as I can for the things that make sense. That is my job. If they want to throw money they can throw it my way. IT for the sake of IT wouldnt be profitable for me in the long run. Understand the customer's business and their security situation is paramount. Every business has diffent levels of security anxiety. It would not be affordable and may not be desireable for me to employ the same systems that I use in a doctor's office for a billboard web site.

by jrgnvogel

Some of our post graduate computer science studends rewrote windows xp as an exercise completely in pure machine code, I was completely surprised as everything worked as normal. This includes officexp etc. The only difference was that it loaded and worked extremely fast. The total os only used 22 mbytes of hard drive space. Unfortunately I had to tell them to erase the program as it was an absolutely windows look alike system. This would probably have caused the uni a lot of legal problems as they wanted to put it on the net for easy downloads. Anyway what was that team effort, hacking or cracking? Needless to say they all got extremely good marks for their study.
Regards

by kevaburg

When so much noise was made about Microsoft losing portions of code and Cisco having it stolen I think this may be regarded as illegal. But it wasn't marketed so noone gained financially so where is the problem? Maybe the fact the code was altered would be the argument against you in a court of law. Maybe not.

Hacking or cracking? I'm not really sure but it sounds like Microsoft could learn a thing or too from this lesson!

by rlutes

Did they use microsoft source code? If so they ripped of Micro$oft. Incidently, I dont know of many universities or colleges that dont require CS students to develop their own OS. Mine was based on BSD.

by joe mctroll

Real meaning of "Hacking" (not the one used by self-proclaimed "IT experts") means doing clever changes to a machine or program in order to make it do things not originally programmed/designed to, or to do better/faster/easier the thing it does... what most people understand for "hacker", though, is what should be referred to as "cracker"

As for legality of your students' efforts: whence did the knowledge of windows internals come? if they un-assembled or reversed engineered winXP (most probable, since you said everything worked as usual) then it WAS illegal, though IMHO not legally suitable for it was for a research purpose and no financil gain was obtained.

If, on the other hand, they re-wrote everything from scratch, using the MSDN guidelines about binary interfaces and usage of windows internal functions, then it is perfectly legal and safe: that's the legal basis of projects such as WINE and ReactOS.

If it's the second chance, well - what are you waiting to send those genious students to either project? They are waiting for them, open arms!!!

On the other hand, if they reverse engineered... well, me thinkest they could act as advisors to either project: not writing directly any code, but offering hints and general suggestions... that way (if my understanding of the law is correct) we would be on the legal grey side... read: more or less safe ;-)

by kevaburg

Has anyone got any comments on the "Hackers Race to Expose Cisco Flaw" article? One has to wonder why these hackers want so badly to expose flaw in the IOS of a company that supplies so much hardware to the Internet, wouldn't you agree?

by kevaburg

The consultant does exactly what you describe. We are in a competitive market and if we were to produce less than the results you describe or we were to use the same solutions for every environment then we would not suceed and we would go under.

The problems come later when we hand over the projects and the less knowledgable sysadmins start making changes, adding inappropriate hardware and so on. And this happens alot.

We install systems appropriately. These people undo our work through their lack of training and awareness and that is the fault of the company in question and the IT management that looks after them.

by jrgnvogel

No they did not use MS source. It took the team of 10 guys just about one year to write it. The problems was it was complete look and work alike to xp. The only difference I could see was that it did not use IE or MS messenger. Everything else worked normally.

by jbrill

It's the same reason why a very large percent of arsonists are firemen. Either they start fires to make sure there is enought work or they do it so that in their response to it they can bee seen as the hero.

With everyone idolizing the hackers, they can feed this need to be recognized by bringing to near death that which they love the most and claim to be saving it by exposing the flaws. It's a sickness.

by raxterusa

This question poses many responses on many many different levels. First, what is a hacker, cracker, phreaker, etc? Second, do they serve a purpose, legal or no? Why are many of these people being held in reverence and/or awe by those who are in the fields of IT security and other middle to end-user areas of the discipline?

The term "hacker" is misused by virtually everyone and this is due to the acceptance of poorly educated media types not taking the time to know the subject which they write/talk about. To be a hacker, in its true form, is to be one who simply "hacks" at the keyboard or other input device to enter code. Hacking is not, in its purest form, as it sounds, like hacking a piece of wood in two. Crackers, on the other hand, refer directly to what it is that they do, they "crack" or break into other programs either maliciously or no. Phreakers are just a variant of the cracker, at least from what I have seen.

Next we should explore what service or dis-service they provide:

Those who would break into and write code that would expose flaws in other programs do serve a function, albeit many times illegally, the exposing of detrimental flaws that make certain programs vulnerable. This is a function that should have been handled by the developer. By exposing the flaws they have inadvertently created new IT posistions within a developer's firm, if it is a responsible developer, to ensure that the "finished" product is secure BEFORE they sell it as the hottest thing since processed ground wheat. Not to mention all of the outside jobs that were created like SysAdmin, Security Firms, and other various 'support' jobs. As we can see many of these positions would never have come to pass should these vulnerabilities not been.

Those who would write viruses, they too serve a function. Similar to the previous, these simply tend to be more malicious.

Lastly, why are they being held in such high regard? Simply put, it is not uncommon for the many to be awed by the few who can do something that the many cannot, at least yet. This can be proven many times over. EXAMPLE: One could use Einstein in this manner, he saw things in nature that few if any of his time could, therefore he was held in high regard even if his findings did eventually cause a great many deaths. With the true "hacker" and the "crackers/phreakers" the same holds true; they have the knowledge, poorly gained or not, and in return garner at least humility from those with less knowledge. Many times unrightfully so, yes, of course. But even to that end they are part of what we call IT.

by jeasterlingtech9

hackers: without hackers there would have been no advances in computers or operating systems a hacker pushes, pulls, prods, changes backgrounds, wants it to run faster, smarter, and in his order.
cracker: most of the "bad guys" that most think of as "hackers" these are the ones who break into systems, break serial numbers, and send phishing emails

A hacker might find an exploit and tell the company
A cracker might find an exploit and tell his friends, sell it to a group of crackers, and write a virus to use the exploit
The hacker mystique from the movies comes from the fact that even the crackers in the movies are fighting against worse evil

by gskur

Most of the code out there is poorly written. No, not in dissonance with the industry practices and standards, but wrongly, rather poorly thought through, often slapped together in a hurry by cutting and pasting (with lots of extra "jucy" fat remaining), kind of ?chisel-and-hammer in a not-so-promising-apprentice?s hand? quality. The structure is often ill-conceived, jumbled, lacking in so many ways, and, too often, is plainly stupid. Even without anybody from the outside putting an ?evil finger? to it, you have PROBLEMS, all the time, don?t you? And, of course, 9 out of 10 UI designers should be fired on the spot. In short, most of the software written and sold to the public for profit is really bad.

And if you, the reader of this post, disagree and feel slighted, offended on behalf of all of your (our) glorious ?high-tech? profession(s)?you are in a wrong profession, my friend, for in this one you understand little.

And when a talented person sees this crap written by the EMPLOYED mediocrities, tested (ha!) by the EMPLOYED dim-witted testers, signed of by the EMPLOYED ?fat-ass? managers, and sold for profit by the EMPLOYED oh-so-clever sales and marketing dudes to the generally ignorant (but not so stupid!) public?then he (and an occasional ?she? I am sure) gets mad. And he wants blood.

If any of you ever told your company that the software you sell is crap, that it is a shame to be doing so, that it is unethical to dupe the customers, that it needs to be redone and it will cost so much money (or more) and will take so much time (or more)--if you told all that and are still employed there?let me know where you work, and I?ll be happy to clean bathrooms in you glorious company for free for the rest of my life. Honest to god!

This is what I know.

Now, what I think about hackers is this.

The only way the dissatisfied really can tell ?them? so that that ?they? will listen, the only way that is immediately effective and satisfying is to PROVE that ?they? knowingly develop and sell not-so-good software. Ant the best way to prove is to demonstrate... Of course, this reasoning is not what is commonly known as ?rational thinking?, but some of these individuals must be very pissed indeed.

And, of course, there are mischievous youngsters (now, as in all the time) that are to prove they are smarter than everyone else (or stronger, or braver...) as always the young (and especially males) have done. Besides, many of these fall in the above category as well, I am sure.

There are very few out there who are actually trying to profit from it, to steal something. These are just like regular thieves, just modern tools.

Oh yes, it is unethical, immoral, illegal, etc. whatever the motivation. The hackers need to be punished severely because they, ultimately, do not succeed in teaching the ?bad guys? a good lesson (these will never learn!) but punish the general public.

Just to strengthen my argument:

There are many examples of very popular excellently written free software. I?d be shocked if you did not have at least half-a-dozen of those on the machine you are reading this post at ;~). Do you guys know why this software (which is so widely used) is not targeted by hackers? And don?t even start thinking that the authors of those software are the hackers themselves (or their friends are)! So, what might be the answer?

by activated

Thats why they admire the hacker. Hackers are the lowest life-form in the tech world. They are below contempt. To destroy is the hallmark of cowards, and criminals. To build is the effort of the truly heroic. Those techies that dont see or understand the difference are themselves lacking in basic virtue.

by redline

I am not fascinated by them. They need to go to jail, first offense, and then treated more harshley if they do not learn their lesson...

by tlea

The ?Hacker? can be lumped into the same category as the Jewel Thief, Old West Outlaw, or even Robin Hood. These are romantic stereotypes that appeal to a certain rebellious side of us. Look at all of the films where the thieves are the protagonists, and law enforcement officials are the bad guys. There must be some universal appeal, or these movies would not exist.

In my opinion the ?Hacker? is just a modern day version of the rebel or outlaw stereotypes, that?s why certain people find it appealing. Like most romantic notions the reality of the situation is very different. Many ?hacker? activities are destructive and cost companies and consumers millions if not billions of dollars.

?Crackers? on the other hand can help protect us from companies that are trying to seize permanent control of intellectual property. A great example is older software. I recently downloaded and Amiga emulator because I used to be an Amiga enthusiast. I was looking for some old titles that I used to own. Most commercial titles can no longer be purchased. Lucky for me there are Abandonware sites that have ?cracked? versions of these old titles. If it wasn?t for these cracked versions there would be no way for me to acquire these titles.

Of course ?crackers? also cost software companies millions, if not billions of dollars in ?lost revenue?. Oh well, I guess you have to take the good with the bad.

by jmgarvin

I am a hacker. I look at things, see how they work, and find possible flaws in them. I socially engineer people to find information, I break network security, and I get information for server.

But wait, I also teach people how to do this (and get paid for it) legally.

To be a network/system security guru, you must also know how to break your network/system security. Those that don't understand security are doomed to fail. If you can't break your security, if you can't red team, you are finished.

Hacker in most context means one who is seeking technical knowledge.

What everyone here is talking about is a cracker. These are the bad guys that are unethical and will steal your credit card information. A hacker may gain access to your credit card information, but never use it for ill.

On that note: If hackers are treated like heroes, I have yet to see it. I've written a couple papers on security and the lack there of, and yet I don't have the hero status...

I think a mythology has been built up in the IT world that these crackers are so uber there is no hope. Learn how to hack your own system and you will see how your good/bad your security really is!

by t-cally

Criminal nature will exist to the end of time. It is unfortunate that for some the only attention they get is when they do wrong and if you have chidren you should have come to find that they will do wrong for the sake of attention. Which could be the very fuel for them to continue. Basically they just need to be hug, and then beat the ___ out them!(not your kids, the criminals)

by msmith

Hackers do get too much press! They seem to be a class of programmers that have ventured into unknown regions and got lost. Are they trying to show up the Bill Gates' of the world? Are they saying " we belong in there somewhere .. make room for us!" ?? Could it be they are working to take down gov't, or perhaps just any organized approach to communication? Then,perhaps, any one of them could say "I brought it all down!" or, like terrorists, "I am responsible for that awful worm!" Data gunslingers, that is what they seem like, and we give them "too much press!" They do, indeed, make my job and thus my occupation, a little harder to engage w/o second-guessing these guys .. and maybe that is also something they like about hacking - disruption!

by blueknight

Heroes are good guys, not law breakers... hackers, crackers and the like, are not heroes, they are miscreants. They do seem to get much better "press" than they deserve which then gives script kiddies and others the desire to do likewise.

These people (hackers etc.) probably keep doing what they do for the media coverage they receive, much like terrorists (which, in a manner of speaking, they are).

The real heroes are the network and system administrators who are able to prevent, or minimize, the damage that can be caused by the work of hackers et al.

by dhodgen

We all have at one time or another dug into our bag of tricks in order to get the job done. Hacked a registry file, cracked a program to make a silent install. Phreaks by definition alter connection lines in order to get more out them. Most programs have been hacked and improved because of the hacks. Dos and Linux themselves started out as hacked programs. The terms do not denote good or bad, just the approach used to get the job done.

The question is the ethics behind what is being done. Do you hack the registry to improve upon and keep a computer running or to bring it to its knees. Its the dark side, the unethical side that needs to be addressed. I prefer to call them the breakers. Spyware, viruses, and security flaw finders. For every bad apple out there I am willing to bet there are a hundred or thousand others hacking, cracking, and phreaking for the right reasons. We are the heroes not them.

by dirtylaundry

dhodgen - your post was sane and I thank you for it. Hacking was never the term for bad, but thanks to the media's ignorance of all things tech, they lumped it together to equate it to "bad" people. What many fail to realize is that it is a form of "modding* programming code. People "hack" their cars, their motorcycles, and as we know, computer cases, but we use the term "modding" for that. I don't believe it's the *evil* aspect that is admired so much as the respect for the area of knowledge or expertise that is required to understand programming code enough to alter it. Most likely IT shakes their head and say to themselves, "With all that knowledge, think of what GOOD they could do instead of having been misguided to think that destructon is better."

by avid

the time we spend fighting hackers could be put into developement a new technology instead of being wasted on better security. your argument points to you being a hacker, so i can see why you defend their point of view. and if you are a white hat, then the black hats are providing you with employment. so i know where you are coming from. but i must disagree that hackers are important or neccesary. they are breaking the law in most cases and most are unethical. i would rather spend my time building new technology rather than spend it finding new ways to keep these useless piles of sh@!, that we call hackers, from breaking old technology. maybe we in the PROFESSIONAL world should come up with new terms for them that is more fitting, like thieves and cowards. this may stop our youth from wanting to follow in the foot steps of these criminals.

by 0troy

New technology is constantly being created. And certain vendors are doing just what you suggest, Making new technology instead of fixing old technology. For example, no longer does microsoft support versions of windows before NT (2000 is soon to join those ranks). If "new technology" is so much better, why are there the same problems with it?

Developers need to learn from their mistakes before making new ones.

by nishanthnair

"the time we spend fighting hackers could be put into developement a new technology instead of being wasted on better security. "

This suggestion is like saying disposing US army and missiles and use those money to feed the poor ... :) As we all know this cannot happen bcoz we must be prepared for a security breach....Same is the case with computers..
For a bank , it is worht the amount spending in fighting hackers than to find accounts hacked one fine day morning ..

by avid

I do get your point, but you can't really make compare the two. i know that we will never be a eutopian society where everyone is more concerned with doing what is right instead of doing what they want, but we need to develope better and harsher laws to govern the consequences of hacking and similar crimes. I contract out to several banks. we recently went through a FDIC security audit and had to make some more changes. these changes were very expensive and time consuming. most of the changes were really not necessary but had to be in place because of employees that might be potetial hackers. i know most of these employees personally. not a single employee their has the slightest understanding of hacking. this, and many others, are examples of the paranoia and expense created by hackers. i know they will always be with us, but i think there would be fewer of them and also that they would choose their targets better, if we lumped them all into the same category, both legally and ethically, and gave them very stiff punishments.

by catfish182

You do bring up some good points. They are breaking the law. Regardless how you look at it it is a criminal act. BUT is it really anyone here who makes hackers out to be more then what they are. I think its 2 things, the media and the internet. I say its the media due to the reports you hear glamerizes the lone person doing all those bad things to such a big company. Most people love to hear of a big rich company getting the stick. thats what hackers do. I say the internet because they go there to meet others because they cant go anywhere else. Most of these 'hackers' are kids looking for a way into the IT world. (i say kids even though im only 33)Though hacking they have a direct portal to tech and they can use it. No one is telling them "no you dont know how to use it" they have free reign. Imagine you can go to 2 stores both which hold your favorite things. One store says "you can look but dont touch" while the other store says "play with it, work with it, do what you want". Which one would you go into? What we as IT (IS, whatever it is) need to do is be aware of people that are interested and try to help them in some way. Also if your reading this and saying "O he is a hacker, i know it" well 2 things.... 1 no im not. 2 thats the atitude that is making people act like that.

by dgenerous1

point blank im a hacker, that doesnt mean i go out of my way to hurt other people, but it does mean i know tat others dont like me because i have skills they could never have. Some of the best programers in the world right now are hackers. they take some peice of software that there using and break-it so they can get to know it better and maybe fix anything that amy be wrong....need i remind you about the win98se login security??? i think not, but it was hackers that cased it to be changed, not the corprate world. Calling us theives and criminals, well there are some whom get that god complex and need to be dealt with, but the rest of us who do the world good by posting our finds on bugtraq and give aid to companies like maccaffe and symantec should not be kept in the same pile as the bad eggs. yes i defend my brethren, but we also punish ourselves too. Keep in mind that the common viruses thats let loose is because someone isnt listening to us and then after the talking doesnt work proof needs to be seen, but of course any scriptkiddie could make a terrible virus from just cobbling someone elses droping worm and a system format command. oh yeah, the professional world means anyone who is paid for their sevices and i get paid to check others security...form the outside.

by avid

you need to check your ego. if you are not breaking the law then it is okay. if you are you are a criminal, a petty one at that. i have more respect for criminals who actually put themselves in harms way. hackers are cowards who think they are smarter than the rest of the world. this kind of delusional thinking is infecting the other kids who could have a meaningful career in the Professional IT Arena. your post exhibits the very flaws you speak against in your post. "point blank im a hacker, that doesnt mean i go out of my way to hurt other people, but it does mean i know tat others dont like me because i have skills they could never have." what makes you think that just because we have chosen to ply our trade legally that you are smarter than the rest of us. everybody gets caught sooner or later. in most cases they get caught by too much bragging. so, check your ego.

by avid

so if i break into your house, rummage through you closets, maybe open your safe, take a peek at you wife she is showering, it is O.K. as long as i put everything back where i found it ?

by 0troy

I find it amusing that so many of these replies are so full of fear and confusion. Put away your pitchforks and torches, and do some research. Let me begin by saying that VMware writers (even by my standards) are no better than crackers. Crackers simply want to expand their domain over your computers, and will use any means to accomplish this feat. They deserve blame, and deserve to be caught. But as for the researchers finding exploits and releasing them, these folks are helping you much more than you think.

I am reminded of a lockpicking discussion on full-disclosure at Defcon. Many times had the speakers found serious vulnerabilites in the construction of locks, and many times had the vendors ignored them. If you found out that anyone would be able to open your gun lock simply by hitting it against a solid object, you'd return the lock and get a new one. But you can't do that if the company deems not to release the flaw or recall the product. Now lives are at stake. The point of all this is, you, as a consumer should have the right to know. You have the right to know if the version of Apache you're using can be exploited by anyone with a 1K text file of exploit code and an internet connection. And anyone who would keep you from that knowledge is doing you a disservice.

As for non-disclosure, it's simple... When guns are outlawed, only the outlaws will have guns.

Would you rather be armed with tools to test your network in ways only hackers can? Or would you rather trust a vendor trying to keep their share prices up? (but that's another rant)

True hackers do not concern themselves with exploiting your server. That task is (sadly) trivial. We'd rather interest ourselves with coding chalenges, and writing white papers to get the word out about serious problems that people just aren't aware of.

We're contributing, and we're helping you guys out more than you think.

Imagine finding that you've been hacked, spending hours cleaning up the penetration, listening to the vendor insist that there are no problems with their software, reconnecting the server, and getting hacked again. Which is more frustrating? Not being the owner of your servers, or having to apply patches every second tuesday of the month?

PS: for the record, a Phreakers "hack" phones and phone systems as a hobby, they have nothing to do with computers besides their interactions with phones.

by jmgarvin

That is a good point. Many vendors (for what ever reason) will not admit to being vulnerable to ANY attack. Not only is this bad for the admins, but it means crackers have a free pass...

When the vendors get serious about security, you'll see the media attention to hacking dwindle (it will be far too technical at that point)

by jmgarvin

Typically not only do I teach how to be a script kiddie (using the available tools and such), but I also push for programmatic understanding (buffer overflows are a great start).

It is a hard road and a short course probably can't teach you what you need to know.

My suggestion: If you want to learn how to hack, get the tools, get the programming knowledge, and get the deconstruction attitude.

Keep in mind, some people just aren't hackers. They don't think that way or function at all like that. Some people tread a fine line between being a good guy and a bad guy...and some people can't help but cause trouble.

by 0troy

I've always been of the mind that one is innately a hacker. They have an innate interest in technology and computers, and a serious case of curiosity.

You may start as an tech, but if you nurture your curiosity, you will evolve into a hacker.

It can be taught, but it may just leave you more confused.

by dgenerous1

true the best hackers are the innate ones but it is not to say that some of the ones out there are just "book" learned kids that want to see how far they can go before they get caught. Curiosity helps but the drive to learn more and a mind that can see how things work dynamicly are the only true prerequisites. and for a definition hacker: (Originally, someone who makes furniture with an axe)
1. A person who enjoys exploring the details of programmable systems and how to stretch their capabilities, as opposed to most users, who prefer to learn only the minimum
necessary.

2. One who programs enthusiastically (even obsessively) or who enjoys programming rather than just theorizing about programming.

3. A person capable of appreciating hack value.

4. A person who is good at programming quickly.

5. An expert at a particular program, or one who frequently does work using it or on it; as in "a Unix hacker".

6. An expert or enthusiast of any kind. One might be an astronomy hacker, for example.

7. One who enjoys the intellectual challenge of creatively overcoming or circumventing limitations.
"taken from dictionary.com"
with this in mind please refrain from calling the worst of us hackers rather call them as they are: crackers: those whom use there talents to gain illeagal access to others systems, scriptkiddies: those whom use others programs to gain the same efforts as a cracker but dont understand how it worked( imo is the worse out there), and remember next time u download your next anti-virus update it was created by a hacker.

by leutiusm

I had the fortune of growing up with a "hacker". If some of you remember the DOD scandal of 1996, Ravanent (TAG) was responsible for over 250k worth of damage. He was imprisioned in Juvinilj for 3 years and (when he reached 18) was then employed within the very same department he was convicted by.

Hackers/crackers fall into two classes. Amatures, that do little more then bash their heads against firewalls, and nuke on IRC, and the extremely rare professionals, that are generally gifted people with a point to make.

They alone are responble for the rising fault ownership shown by software manufacturers

The threat comes from professional coders, under the employ of information gathering corporate identities.

Either way, they know the risks, chose the action, perform their objective, and if they serve time, they accept it, and move on. Positive or negitively regarded is irrelivant. I see them as just another example of naturally occuring checks and balances of the IT environment

by stratti79

I was once an low level IT professional but now am in Human Services and study Sociology and am almost finised my Social Worker accreditation. I believe you are all missing the point of Hacker/Cracker phenomenon. The point isnt should they be or shouldnt they be but WHY are they and what does it SIGNIFY For the future. Despite the advances in IT I would still argue that IT has still got more growth potential and over the next decade I envisage IT networks in every home controlling everything from grocery shopping, to climate control not to mention what may be in the public sector. Point being a bad hack/crack that is malicious is no where near as damaging as it might be in the future. Back to my point are these hackers disaffected, bored, are there problems able to be corrected could their current states turn into something much more devious which to an extent now and certainly in the near future may translate into real human cost not the mere cash cost it does now.

by jmgarvin

Hackers aren't bored or disaffected. I'm hacking Windows and Linux security for a research project. I hacking some encryption schemas. I'm hacking streaming codecs. What does that mean? I'm taking them apart to see how they work and then working with them to make them work how I want them to work.

I want to make things work properly and I want to see WHY there are holes where there shouldn't be.

Crackers are a different ball game and usually fall into the "Hackers without morals" catagory.

Everyone is underestimating crackers (teenage disaffected youth) and putting the bad guys into a neat little box. This is a VERY bad idea.

All warfare is based on deception. Hence, when able to attack, we must seem unable; when using our forces, we must seem inactive; when we are near, we must make the enemy believe we are far away; when far away, we must make him believe we are near. Hold out baits to entice the enemy. Feign disorder, and crush him.
- Sun Tzu, the Art of War

by el_nene_4_u

Actuallly, I have the same kind of debate with my students every single day of the course, or at least every week. I completelly agree with you, let them do what they do best, test our code and our systems and tell us, the programmers and IT staff, what to do and what not to do with our applications. I prefer to have a well debugged app rather than a feeble one. On the other hand, I prefer the old meaning of the word hacker for the good guys, and to leave the bad stuff for the crackers, cyber-terrorists, or whatever yuou like to call the bad guys.

by rlutes

I read and still see people defending criminal behavior or at very least unethical. To the youngsters...be careful who you tell about your cracking, phreaking or hacking some of us won't bother hiring you.

by jmgarvin

I have and will hire hackers. If they get out of line, they are punished, but for the most part they are EXCELLENT additions to any IT team.

I want someone to break my security. I want to someone to tell me, hey you are an idiot, why are you doing that. I want someone to write unique code to take advantage of something I may think is secure.

I honestly don't think one can understand security without understanding how to break the security.

by avid

there is plenty of open source out there to learn on. it is not necessary to break the law to learn.

by dgenerous1

without hackers bill gates would have never found the beginings to windows, apple would never have got going, mit unix, berkley unix aix and dread to say spac os could not exist.hackers do so much good and then take all the brunt for anything that goes bad. To tell the truth, if you have ever been to a proper collage or university computer networking course then you probly listend to a hacker for say 120hrs or so and never knew any diferent. i agree that the ones who purposley cause mischief should be dealt with severly but that cant happen as long as the ones who get caught doing illeagel stuff are the ones getting hired by the big companies.

by jmgarvin

Those who WANT to be hackers will be hackers, but some just can't get the attitude. I'm not sure what that mythical attitude is, but it seems some people REALLY WANT to be a hacker, but just can't get the mindset.

Let me explain:
Let's say there are two students. One who is already of the hacking mindset and one willing to learn. The hacking mindset student will pick up everything pretty quickly, but need some pushes and deep explanation as things get more complicated. The other student gets stuck with your point 1 (they just can't grasp how to push the system), point 4 (they are too "real" to whip out fast and dirty code), or 7 (they can't quite "find" the limitations).

I found out I loved hacking when I accidentally wrote a "macro" (what were those damn things called???) that brought a friends bbs to its knees. After that, the love affair started.

Some people just aren't built to be hackers. They either are too anal about their coding or just can't see how to push the system to the limits.

by kontrolsphreak

If you're not creating, building, or making something better you are not a "Hacker".

If your sole purpose is to damage or destroy, you are merely an anti-social individual most likely angry that you are unable to create.

Call those people whatever you like, but NEVER call them "Hackers".

by dgenerous1

hackers are not vile nor are they all to be deamed such. if anyone could open there eyes and minds for more than a micro then they would see that hackers are not that bad, for such; a mechanic who takes an engine apart and fixes it is a hacker in the true sense of the word. a doctor who opens you up to help your heart keep beating is a hacker by definition, so to clump the bad with the good is not just a missight but a gross atrosity. I open others code to learn, gain ideas or to make a change that will make my life easier, not to cause mischief and malfeasance. does that make me a criminal? or just someone who bears watching? or am i and others like me competion so by not using a title that others can relate you use titles like cerified systems engineer and systems anylist....if you dare to learn more than how to use it then you are by definition a hacker( maybe not one of the elite, hell even im not there myself)

by avid

if you decompile code that has been copywrited and is protected from decompiling by the law or end user agreement and you do not have explicit permission from the owner of the the code, then you are a common criminal. no different than a petty thief. if you have permission, it is an entirely different case. there is no debating it. it is completely black and white.

by 0troy

That is true. It is illegal. But would you rather have Crackers decompiling code, and finding holes, and writing worms... Or Hackers finding the holes, reporting them (and in some cases fixing them).

Worms are a pain even with the patch to stop them. What about a worm that doesn't have a patch fix for it?

Who else is going to find the holes? The vendor??? While they do release updates, they'd prefer their software to be as unblemished as possible. Some don't have your best interest in mind.

I say you should have *your* best intrest in mind. And if you can't check the code yourself for errors that will wind up costing your company money, then you'd better hope someone with good intentions is, because the bad people definately are.

by avid

what caused them to take your laptop ? were you breaking the acceptable use policy of your high school?

by 0troy

Leave him be, some people just need someone to blame for all the woes of the world.

by avid

look, either you are breaking the law or you aren't. if you are breaking the law you are scum deserving the maximum allowable punishment. if you are not breaking the law, then enjoy yourself. i think where people are getting confused is when they think thhat they get to decide which laws are good and which ones are bad. that is not for us to decide. end of story.

by 0troy

Ever gone over the speed limit? Gonna turn yourself in?

Ever been in the carpool lane when it was just you in the car? Even on accident?

Ever littered?

Ever steal a candy bar as a kid? Sure the statute of limitations may have passed, but does that cure your guilty consience?

Think before you call lawbreakers "scum", or just say it into the mirror.

by ni70

[i][b]cracker[/b][/i]
A cracker is someone who breaks into someone else's computer system, often on a network; bypasses passwords or licenses in computer programs; or in other ways intentionally breaches computer security. A cracker can be doing this for profit, maliciously, for some altruistic purpose or cause, or because the challenge is there. Some breaking-and-entering has been done ostensibly to point out weaknesses in a site's security system.

The term "cracker" is not to be confused with "hacker". Hackers generally deplore cracking. However, as Eric Raymond, compiler of [i]The New Hacker's Dictionary[/i] notes, some journalists ascribe break-ins to "hackers."

A classic story of the tracking down of a cracker on the Internet who was breaking into U.S. military and other computers is told in Clifford Stoll's [i]The Cuckoo's Egg[/i]. http://searchsecurity.techtarget.com/sDefinition/0,290660,sid14_gci211852,00.html

[b]cracker[/b]
[i]techweb[/i]
(1) A person who breaks into a computer system without authorization, whose purpose is to do damage (destroy files, steal credit card numbers, plant viruses, etc.). Because a cracker uses low-level hacker skills to do cracking, the terms "cracker" and "hacker" have become synonymous with the latter becoming the most widely used term. See hacker, ECPA, CFA and virus.

(2) A person who reverse engineers software and modifies it for fun. Often applies to game software. See disassembler.
http://www.techweb.com/encyclopedia/defineterm.jhtml;jsessionid=Z0GAAJXL3T2CYQSNDBCCKH0CJUMEKJVN?term=cracker&x=0&y=0

[b]hacker[/b]
Hacker is a term used by some to mean "a clever programmer" and by others, especially journalists or their editors, to mean "someone who tries to break into computer systems."

1) Eric Raymond, compiler of [i]The New Hacker's Dictionary[/i], defines a hacker as a clever programmer. A "good hack" is a clever solution to a programming problem and "hacking" is the act of doing it. Raymond lists five possible characteristics that qualify one as a hacker, which we paraphrase here:

* A person who enjoys learning details of a programming language or system
* A person who enjoys actually doing the programming rather than just theorizing about it
* A person capable of appreciating someone else's hacking
* A person who picks up programming quickly
* A person who is an expert at a particular programming language or system, as in "Unix hacker"

Raymond deprecates the use of this term for someone who attempts to crack someone else's system or otherwise uses programming or expert knowledge to act maliciously. He prefers the term cracker for this meaning.

2) Journalists or their editors almost universally use hacker to mean someone who attempts to break into computer systems. Typically, this kind of hacker would be a proficient programmer or engineer with sufficient technical knowledge to understand the weak points in a security system. For more on this usage, see cracker. http://searchsecurity.techtarget.com/sDefinition/0,,sid14_gci212220,00.html

Edit to remove brackets from links.

by 0troy

Hey, lets all be afraid of things we don't understand! And then, when someone tries to help us understand them, we'll ignore them, and call them names!

Don't even bother trying to explain to them. Some people will never understand.

by stooobeee

Have you ever watched Evil Knevil do dare devil stunts? If onlookers knew beforehand that his feats would turn out successfully 100% of the time, no one would go to see him. It is this percentage of danger involved that drives people to watch. We are at heart rabble-rousers, jeerers in the crowd of spectators, and those who would yell "crucify him". Even those who pretend to be gentle and kind are inherently impure, and tainted with the desire for evil. What suppresses most of us are things like the law, the churches, and the conformity to civil actions that reflect morality and decency. If, suddenly, they were removed, our bent nature would surface and not be hidden anylonger.

Those who undermine those restraints take chances that put themselves and others at risks. These kinds of dare devils want people to watch them defeat the odds. Our advertizing of this clearly demonstrates our need to see them survive, and to be able to say aloud how good we are in comparison. But our hearts are far from that reality. "Personification" is a big word, but inwardly we feel satisfied that all the wrongs in our lives that are unfair are atoned for.

There are uncountable examples of people in the wrong that defied the odds and "made" it, and headlines appear when they do, symbolizing them as bigger than life. Many hackers get hired by the government after doing their evil deeds, and by virtue of their notoriety, can now turn themselves around because the "test" is over, and they can publically become servants of the society they took advantage of.

We are all capable of committing atrocities we dare not even think about, but fortunately are restrained by the reasons I previously mentioned. No one is exempt from this tainted self. Outwardly, we are law-abiding citizens; inwardly our hearts are corrupt, and under the right set of circumstances, are given to actions that reflect that.

Fortunately, our laws which govern our behavior are ideally for the good of all of us, and the majority seek to obey many of them. But our laws cannot govern what we think, and therefore cannot predict our actions. So we must speculate and wait, and when someone actively opposes them, he must accept the consequences, and be responsible for his actions. Hackers are not outside our social limitations, and should not be treated any differently than someone else who shows contempt for them.