Discussion Locked

Hard drive on server replaced twice

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The hard drive on our application server, Dell Poweredge 2500 (2 years old) failed twice in the last month. The first time, we were also experiencing problems with the tape drive the night before so Dell replaced both the tape and hard drives. Two weeks later, the tape problems were not completely solved (tapes are all brand new and the system still said that the tape drive needed cleaning ... which we did). Files were backed up but tape would not eject automatically.
Then, we got a BSOD on the server "Start unit device failed", "no boot device available". Question: is it possible that the problems with the hard drives is somehow related to the problems with the tape drive or some other common unit. Because if so, replacing the hard drive will not solve the problem. Note: we also replaced the cable.

4 replies

by sgt_shultz

you know, you could be getting hacked...you *sure* those hard drives were really bad? because dell did more than replace hd's and tape, i bet? they reinstalled OS also...just mentioning...
do hd's and tape share the same controller? that is only way problems on tape drive can affect hd's imho. at least in way that only showed up later, not right after install. besides, sounds like tape drive is working ok if only problem is won't eject (and dell replaced drive). and i doubt flakey controller as i would expect worse problems than 'clean tape' if flakey controller. might look at termination if scsi. might be wrong/defective termination . maybe more than one device have termination enabled or something (only need it on last physical device in scsi chain). nowadays you turn it on and off via software configurator for device. maybe hd AND tape drive have termination on?
if both tape and hd to same controller the finger points at controller. you've already replaced the drives and cables, not much is left besides flakey controller or incorrect scsi termination. is scsi? is ide? i would like to have second opinion on bad hard drives. make sure they are really bad. do you still have failed hard drives. can you put them in another pc and verify failure with manufacturers diagnostics (for eg. western digital diag or MaxBlast). i would try for another failure quick. bake server with blankets and lights to see if i can force failure with heat. pretty dramatic (smile).

by lmayeda

Ran the manufacturers diagnostics on the first drive and it came up with a lot of errors. The 2nd drive would not cycle up. Both tape and hard drives are on the same controller. Drives are SCSI. Thanks for the info...I'll just knock on wood and hope for the best. Management was not confident about the reliability of the server so they OK'd purchase of a new one. Both are now online and the business application has been transferred to the new server with the old one only working as the terminal server. Thanks for the info.

by lmayeda

Hard drive is SCSI. First failure, drive was definitely bad because the diagnostics came up with a ton of errors. This time, I am not so sure. How can I check the SCSI termination? Would the system run for 2 weeks with incorrect termination?

This discussion is closed to new replies.