1. If you don't have a policy on maintenance of laptops - WRITE ONE UP AND POST IT QUICKLY. Before the first laptop was given out, there was a policy in place and a form for the employee to sign. No signature - no laptop.
2. Again, if you can show the damage was due to negligence, the employee should be responsible - something which should be made clear in the policy. If it is due to old age, out of date software/hardware, etc., the laptop should be replaced. (Suggestion, purchase a long-term warranty for the laptops. If you're keeping them for a while, it may well be worth the extra cost.)
3. You answered your own question with this one - you need an effective policy in place. If everyone in the company is to have a laptop, it is imperative you have a policy to fall back on.
4. I agree it can be difficult to know if it is user negligence, but again, an in-place policy will help with this. As for the costs - that long term warranty will help. (We use strictly Dell workstation/laptops and get the 3-year warranty for every machine.)
5. We are also an SME and need to watch costs. Because of our in place policy on laptops, and all machines, we have minimal issues with 'broken' equipment.
If you have problems coming up with a policy, do what we did when coming up with ours - Google it! We came up with several options which we merged to a policy which fit our company. If you're still having problems, talk to your legal department. They may have resources available to get you what you are looking for.