68 replies
by oz_media
Iraqbodycount.com logs a minimun ad maximun of reported deaths.
Reported [b]civilian deaths[/b] resulting from the US-led military intervention in Iraq, [i]this does nto include the terrrists and insurgents they went to fight in Iraq.[/i]
MINIMUM REPORTED : 12,943
MAXIMUM REPORTED : 14,997
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Here's a quote from a US site:
"U.S. IRAQ WAR CASUALTIES TOP 9,000, WHILE IRAQI DEAD/WOUNDED DON'T MATTER"
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
From a US source (I couldn't find ANY other reports on hwo many Iraqi's have died, from US or Middle East news).
US casulaties between March 2003 and June 2004, 834, UK casualities 59, Other countries 57 TOTAL: 950
Now those are soldiers as opposed to the Iraqi figures which ONLY show civilians.
Now I woud like to think that the Iraqi report is exaggerated quit a bit, maybe even 50% to bring the number down to the 6-7 THOUSAND number, yet no US sources were to be found, perhaps someone else with a BIT more time might wat to dig through US numbers.
As it sits now, Iraqi CITIZENS 12,000 and counting, COW less around 1,000.
by thelastword
by oz_media
When Iraqi news is tryig to make out the insurgents as the ones causing the most harm, I don't think they'd LUMP thier tally together.
Let's say three US bombs land in a populated area, two hotels, fifteen homes and a few shops are destroyed. During the rescue attempts to try and find the living, Iraqi's count seven hundred dead.
This means that the COW ALLIED force is responsible for killing seven hundred people.
This has NOTHING to do with insurgents and car bobmings, they are speaking about deaths DUE to COW allied fire. NOT the total number of dead Iraqi's.
Seeing as nobody else has even aired or printed a single stat to this efect, what else can we go on to actually say it was only 8 thousand or perhaps 20 thousand?
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
From OUR side:
1,186 coalition deaths, 1,053 Americans, 68 Britons, six Bulgarians, one Dane, two Dutch, one Estonian, one Hungarian, 19 Italians, one Latvian, 13 Poles, one Salvadoran, three Slovaks, 11 Spaniards, two Thai and eight Ukrainians, in the war in Iraq as of September 28, 2004
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
So we know how many of OUR soldiers died, I think we can respect th eIraqi numbers would be close, even if out by a few THOUSAND.
AGAIN, you ask for separation of insurgent and COW caused deaths, well these are the only numbers that show specifically how many have been killed by COW fire.
So can we let the insurgent casualties drop now?
We aren't talking about that, we are talking about COW actions that have killed Iraqi's.
by thelastword
Here's the actual link. Can anyone go through this and count up the numbers attributed to CAR BOMB and GUNFIRE? That will give us the number we are looking for??
http://www.iraqbodycount.net/database/bodycount2.php?ts=1096395028
by oz_media
How so? The USA is resposible for more friendly fire than any military force I have ever heard of.
Now you are suggesting they aren't using Guns, Mortars and are only responsible for air strikes?
Now go down your same page and count the number killed by air strike. ONE PAGE, now go to the LAST page and see how many have been killed by air strikes.
The page you are providing says VERY clearly, VERY VERY CLEARLY:
[i]This database includes up to 7,350 deaths which resulted from coalition military action during the "major-combat" phase prior to May 1st 2003. In the current occupation phase the database includes all deaths which the Occupying Authority has a binding responsibility to prevent under the Geneva Conventions and Hague Regulations. This includes civilian deaths resulting from the breakdown in law and order, and deaths due to inadequate health care or sanitation.[/i]
Now you have already raised this question and provided his same information in another thread. Why the double post ? Is it an attempt to get your point seen?
There IS no point, you said and I quote "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS"
And this is your proof, a website that shows how many deaths teh US is responsible for directly by air strikes, mortars rounds and gun fire.
They have INCLUDED RECENT insurgent attacks, as they attribute them to the USA not performing it's job as outlined in the Geneva Conventions and Hague Resolutions.
THIS IN NO WAY SHAPE OR FORM says that all these deaths are due to insurgent car bonmbings, in fact if you look farther back in the timeline to when the US was still conducting Air Strikes, the numbers of deaths from them are much greater than the 100 shown on the first page.
Are the insurgents now conducting air strikes?
You may also want to read thir FAQ's page to get some sort of idea how the information is compiled ad by whom.
[i]"In this project we want to only record those deaths to which we can unambiguously hold our own leaders to account. In short, [b]we record all civilians deaths attributed to our military intervention in Iraq."[/b][/i]
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by tbragsda
.
To make us feel better? If a preponderance of civilian deaths are from insurgents, should that make me feel that what were doing has merit? That if we only caused 1 out of 5 civilians deaths, were less nasty than terrorists?
I would like to have these numbers... I guess. Its ghoulish to ask, as if I were asking for a spreadsheet. These were real people, with lives just like my own. If I did know, what would it change? I don't think it would make me dislike this war any more, and I doubt that it would change the minds of the supporters of war.
If I truly thought that what we were doing had some light at the end of the tunnel, that things would be great when X happens, I might feel like its worth it. Would it be worth it to those that lost loved ones?
If I sound a bit preachy, I'm sorry. I don't think were running around trying to kill civilians. Just, some seem so complacent about death. We went off our collective rockers after 9/11, but seem to give a big "ho-hum" at others suffering.
by thelastword
by oz_media
You raise some valid questions now.
Is Iraq out of control, judging by the US administration and the words of Iraqi citizens and leaders, YES IT IS OUT OF CONTROL.
Should the US dump it like this and leave?
No, it's too lat for you to realize the nature of your mistake and just slither away now.
Does it give the terrorists a free ticket?
No, they weren't terrorizig citizens as bad as they have SINCE the US occupation but that does't mean they weren't terrorizig Iraqi citizens at all. No I think they did need to be removed, I think a war in Iraq was needed, I think that Saddam should hae been removed. most of the allies also felt this way, yet it was NOT an urgency that required removing weapons inspectors who were doing thier jobs ad invading on teh premise of Saddam's stockpiles of WMD and an imminent attack on america. Especially when even then, they KNEW England was/is the next target.
the war is JUST but not justfied as an immediate action that was SO neccessary that you went against allied wishes and invaded by yourselves. Only to see GWB in front of the UN a couple of yars later :
"There was nothing about that speech that was an attempt to convince sophisticated European and African diplomats to go along with the American cause," Cain said. "He gave his standard 'I have a dream' speech,' which is, 'I dream we can spread liberty and secular democracy.' That speech works with an American public and not the United Nations."
"U.N. member nations desired frankness on the unstable situation in Iraq, possibly even an air of humility from the president. Instead, Mr. Bush said Afghanistan and Iraq are "no longer harboring terrorists," a statement not fully supported by news on the ground in both nations.
"If he was speaking to his [U.N.] audience he really doesn?t understand it," said Professor Shibley Telhami, a Middle East specialist at the University of Maryland.
Telhami, who was an adviser to the U.S. delegation to the U.N. during the first Gulf War, said, "At the time of Iraq?s invasion of Kuwait, people wanted to hear the moral authority of the world leader. Every word [President George H.W. Bush] said was weighed, was listened to. I was there. I could feel it.
"Today, when [President Bush] says human rights, what comes to their minds is Abu Ghraib. When he says there is more democracy in the Middle East what they see in Iraq is decidedly worse than before, in their own minds," Telhami said.
"Throughout the U.N. speech, President Bush emphasized common ground rather than the confrontational relationship between the U.S. and the bulk of its member nations. He did not attempt to justify his decision to invade Iraq without the approval of the U.N. Security Council."
by oz_media
In response to the number of Iraqi CITIZENS killed.
[i]"Thats great OZ, now hopefully they understand
That its not its not wise to fly planes into our buildings."[/i]
Well such attitudes ae exactly what has given the US a bad name for all these years, people who think that thier own best interests ae all that matteres in life. This is a self absorbed way of dismissing responsibility for your own actions.
I would be interested to find out just how many IRAQI citizens had flown planes into US buildigs, I'd hazard a guess at a whopping ZERO!
Now as for Iraqi INSURGENTS, there have been..............ZERO of them flying thier planes into US buildings.
So how is a hard working family man living in Iraq supposed to accet ANYTHING from th US at all, when reading quotes like;
[i]"Thats great OZ, now hopefully they understand
That its not its not wise to fly planes into our buildings. [/i]
Joke or not, that isn't even remotely funny.
by thelastword
by tbragsda
Well, OZ. In another of these threads, someone was trying to argue that at no point did anyone remotely connected to the goverment insinuate that Iraq was connected to 9/11.
"Find me one time! Just once!" I think is how it went. You may have fun talking to the delusional, I prefer the rational.
Any good with quotes?
"To disagree with three-fourths of the British public is one of the first requisites of sanity."
Don't think too much of my skill. I only remember the idea of quotes I want to use. Most cases I end up with some hacked version all my own. Guess that makes them mine.
by oz_media
Yes these figures do includ all deaths that are demed America's responsibility, based on the issue that it is the US's duty to stop al these insurgent caused deaths.
You should have said, a GREAT deal or a LARGE portion of the deaths of Iraqi citizens reported are due to insurgent bombings and atacks. Any sane person would agree with you wholly.
But for you to jump to an incorrect conclusion and state firmly "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS" is just an outright and blatant lie and you have not provided any information to support your statement.
All deaths are NOT caused by car bombs and insurgents at all. In fact if you read back in the document you provided it will show that air strikes hae caused many mroe deaths than car bombs. These are INNOCENT lives that should not be considered a part of war or discounted as a normal occurance.
SINCE the US invasion began, these insurgents hae killed mroe and more Iraqi citizens that ever before, is that not in turn atrributable to deaths due to the US military occupation? Of course they are, if you weren't in there thay wouldn't be killing as many Iraqi citizens unneccessarily.
This also includes oer 7 thousand deaths that were caused by US strikes as the war began, not even WHILE in Iraq.
Read the FAQ's and you will see exactly how and where the numbers are cumulated and confirmed, it will show you that MANY sources are US sources also.
Your claim was very bold, your proof was not.
I will accept that insurgents are responsible for many lives lost, but what about all the OTHER lives? What about the lives lost due to air strikes? Again you will have to read through to when air strikes were more effective and before ground troops were in Iraq.
Insurgents don't have fighter planes, they don't fly bombers.
Your statement also implies that the US does not use mortars or guns, well just ask the friendly soldiers you have shot or the familes of the allied soldiers you've killed, they will confirm that Americans do actually fire thier guns and not always at whom they are supposed to.
by thelastword
by thelastword
by oz_media
No there's no POINT I ned to get other than you made a bold and factual claim that simply isn't one.
When I made MY statement, I explained that there was no information available but my claims were directly from a middle eastern website. IN fact here's my post in full:
"[b]Reports from Iraq[/b]
Reports from Iraq, show that Iraqi citizens killed DIRECTLY from COW allied fire is betwen 12,000 and 14,000. "
I also QUOTED "Here's a quote from another private US website: U.S. IRAQ WAR CASUALTIES TOP 9,000, WHILE IRAQI DEAD/WOUNDED DON'T MATTER"
At what time have I made the statement ( as you imply) that the USA is responsible for betwen 12 and 14 thousand deaths? It certainly wasn't in those last two statements.
YOUR PERSONALLY ASSERTED, without any quotes from another source, YOUR OWN FACTUAL AND SOLID WORDS. "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS".
Well I think we can safely conclude based on the information you provided yourself, that this is 100% pure BS. It isn't a fact at all, your statement is completely unwarranted and untrue.
I never said that insurgents were NOT responsible for the deaths, I cited that an IRAQI report said there were between 12 and 14 thousand deaths attributable to the US occupation, is that a lie? No, it isn't not in anw way shape or form. In fact YOU prioovided the link to reinforce my point, IRAQ claims that 12-14 thousand citizens lives have been lost due to Us military intervention.
Nobody had trid to detract form your point at all, I am focused entirely on YOUR point, and it is ENTIRELY incorrect.
Read YOUR statemetn, read mY quote and the cited source. See the difference yet?
You didn't offer anything based on my wording and you didn't throw m off. You just stated a false claim.
by oz_media
Now you are talking about how Americans incorrectly lump insurgents in with ordinary citizens.
You have just spent several posts claiming that the insurgents are lumped in with Americans?
I didn't say the Iraqi's were ungrateful, many Iraqi's said they were ungrateful, while on camera and while the conversation was focused on the efforts of GWB to help rid them of terrorists.
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by oz_media
That my source was clearly identified as an Iraqi source sue to the LACK of other reports or sourcs?
Or was it you ststement "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS".
I never said ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY THE USA. We ae talkig about what Iraqi's think and if there is an improvement. Well if my quote is an example of what Iraqi's believe, then oe can easly surmise that NO they don't think things in Iraq are better since the US invasion. My point has fact and confirmation.
Your QUOTE is simply an inaccuracy. What is it you can't see?
I never made a claim, you did. Your claim was wrong, my says EXACTLY what I said it says.
by oz_media
So what was the reason for the invasion?
Simple question, you made the statement, can you support and prove it, because nobody else in th world can.
With respect to the website I quoted, at no time did I validate it's integrity, you assumed that, it wasn't said.
I actually did say that there was nothig available from US sources so I was quoting from Iraqi sources.
THIS IS WHAT THEY SAY, not me.
by thelastword
by tbragsda
I have lots of problems with the Bush administration. Much past the war. It has been my theses through many of these posts, and discussions, that we should blame all of us. I spent time before the war going to a march or two. My voice did not get through. Honestly, I didn't try hard enough. The wars backers that have come to feel its wrong, they didn't think enough about the whys and hows. Its there fault too. Bush could not have walk us off to war with out our approval. We have a Senate and Congress plus Judicial branch of our government. So, while I have lots to dislike about Bush and his appointees, the Republican party and some Democrats, I have a share of the blame too.
Edited for clarity.
by thelastword
by tbragsda
.
We have tried so many different reasons, that seems as good as any. I doubt that it is truly that simple. It has a lot to do with other factors. Getting a base in the middle east, oil etc..
I guess when it gets down to it, I don't care right now WHY we did it. History can look back with a clam dispassionate eye. Its more important to me to stop it. Slowly pull out troops, send them packing today, bring the UN in, leave them to fend for themselves. I can hardley see how any plan is better than the next. I am sure of one thing, we are part of the problem right now.
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by oz_media
The words of Vera Lynn (sp?).
So it would be nice to see all the troops removed. Do you really, for ONE second, don't think they will be quickly whisked away to fight soemwhere else because Bush has a bone to pick?
What would America do all day if it wasn't at war?
by oz_media
That what people realize NOW.
But why did America GO to war?
the answer is simple as pie, FEAR.
by thelastword
by thelastword
by thelastword
by oz_media
If you want to be heard, understood and respcted, you may wat to begin by at least QUOTING what you are referring to, or even mentioning HOW your flames are aimed at.
Then you should provide some PROOF to support your flames.
If you ae implying that I lied in saying you wee sold FEAR, you should say so and prove it other than "THAT'S A LIE!"
I was here watching the hoards of Americans defending the American reason for Iraq and it was SAVING THIER FAMILIES AD PROTECTING THIER COUNTRY. Anyoewho wasn't fully behind it was told they were unfaithful citizens for not supporting thier familes and that they'd just let thier families die.
Going to war based on a SUPPOSED attack is going to war based on FEAR o an attack, or going to war based on FEAR.
If that's NOT what you were referrng to, perhaps you could be more clear before ranting.
I'm not trying to have a go at you, but you offer a comment than ofer a rant , but without saying who or what you are complaining about, you are just bitching for the sake of bitching.
by thelastword
That response was to do with your old bickering about whether you actually stated 14,000 or whether it was a quote so dont get ll fussy on that. As far as backing up my statements, I think I've done pretty well here???!!
If you read more closely you will see that I agreed with that statement. Further, if you were paying attention you would notice that I am a fellow Canadian!
by tbragsda
.
If we stay, and things deteriorate. We could say, its because we stayed, or we could say it would have happened anyway. Same is true if we leave. We don't have a test lab to run these ideas through (or at least real world one).
by onbliss
by thelastword
by oz_media
I neer said ANYTHING of the sort regadig how Iraq news is more reliable than US or that the US news was incorrect.
EVERYONE on Earth knows that new in ANY country is SKEWED and colored to suit the network and the advertisers. The reason I showed no US souc is because none cam up with a simple search, yet several middle eastern sources did. Which makes sense, how the hel is the US going to track how may civilians die?
The info provided is cumulated from US and Iraqi sources anyway so such a statement would be untrue.
I nver made ANY bold assertions or statements YOU DID, YOU BOLDY SAID IN CAPITAL LETTERS "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS"
This is of course, pure bulls*it! If you can't admit that it is purely inaacurate rambling, then I can see where further discussion attempts will lead with you, nowhere.
You made an incorect statement, not I. I quoted a source as beign FROM Iraq and then exactly what they said the cout is, no US sources provided an alternative that I could easily fid so therefore ONE opinion is just that, ONE opinion.
Your response was a comment that could not be more untrue and was simply just words in a line, not anything substantial. How you can NOT see this is truly mind boggling!
Lets suppose you say, I headr that All Canadians are liars, from a US website, then posted the info found, that's fine.
If I replied "ALL AMERICANS ARE LIARS BECAUSE BUSH LIED" Do I have ANYTHING to prove or lend fact to it? No. It's just a lie.
So if you will not recognize you had stated an untruth, made a slip up, or simply lied, then that's fine, just don't expect any credibility in furture as you try and backpeddle to explain that's not what you meant. That IS what you meant, you capitalized every letter.
by thelastword
by oz_media
You didn't have a proper plan, nor wre you prepared for the consequences, this MAY be oe reason the rest of the world didn't jump on the whole INVADE iraq idea.
Well you did, it's done, it's too late to look back.
You have no choice other than to finish what you started. If this costs the Us 800 Billion in the end, and destroys your country ad it's economy in the rocess, well then teh USA just like everyother super powr who SCREWED up in the past will soon realize it's mistake ad perhas the people may be humbled a lttle.
Or should the rest of the allies jump in now, end the war in a year or so and then claim credit for saving you all? While saying I TOLD YOU SO! Will America no longer b a super power? Heaven forbid, it is inevitable that you WILL lose that status as it has never been retained by any Super Power in he past, it is economically impossible. I just didn't expect to see it this quickly.
by oz_media
You we sold fear as a mean of retaliation.
I was shocked to see you by it in the first place. I was STUNNED beyond beliefe to see it accepted, especially from such a politically motivated and focused nation.
by tbragsda
Your looking for numbers of dead now. I guess this will be our search again in a couple years.
If we leave, or stay, lets hope we learn something.
by thelastword
by thelastword
by tbragsda
.
What makes you think that we would go stomping around the world, pushing our nose in other sovereign nations business, calming superiority... Wait... Your talking that history stuff. Never mind. You didn't see South America. As a matter of fact, there is no South America.
Back to work bringing freedom and prosperity to the world.
by oz_media
by oz_media
by oz_media
I had no idea whatsoever what you are talking about as I am a clueless Western Canadian.
You are right on all points, I am wrong on all points.
I am also tired of circular discussions, enjoy your day.
by thelastword
by oz_media
by thelastword
There was no circular discussion that I can see. Alot got proven with regard to the stance of Iraq. I have a firm position now against GWB, regardless if a cause has been uncovered in Iraq through all of this and suddenly there is some validity to it, itdoesnt change what HE DID and what he caused and I feel he should not be voted back in. I also feel that voting him back in would result in the loss of every shred of american integrity and would leave them utterly alone with the situation. So I learned something from it and I hope people reading it will change theri vote.
Have a good day Oz
by oz_media
It may hav been in another related thread as it has been raisd in a few now.
Either way, it REALLY doesn't matter to me, I know what I found and where it was from. THE EXACT SAME SOURCE YOU QUOTED.
by thelastword
by oz_media
Firstly, nobody is tryig to prove anything to you, you were insisting that I said something I didn't, you use the same source I had to try and show what I was saying was proven wrong, which it didn't prove anything wrong other than your statement, end of story.
As for 'try it again', you asked me to be clearer on my post (above). I edited the post to be clearer and said try again.
You come back to that by saying TRY WHAT again and then shooting off your mouth about me being on your case. You already said it wasn't clear, I reread the post and cleaned it up as even to me it didn't make sense, I think I compresssed two sentences without checking the context.
Just relax man, settle down, it's no big deal.
I edited my post so you could understand, that's all, no need to get upset about it.
Now WHY are you constantly being misunderstood?
Well as you have shown here, you respond in th wrong part of the thread. If you wanted to ask WHAT I meant by try again, post UNDER THE THREAD, not somewhere else. If the thread has reached its maximum level, just QUOTE what you are referring to in your response.
Eg. In your last post you said: "it doesnt f**king matter
what do you mean 'try now'?? Al you have done is argue with me all day, because you are dead set on proving that I have nothing to say on anything."
Then add your comments under it like so:
I meant that I had edited the post so it may be clearer now, I didn't even think it made sense when I reread it.
As for proving you have nothing to say, I think that's a little extreme. I was set on proving that your statement, "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS", was incorrect. The information you provided and linked to even says otherwise. The website you listed doesn't say anything of the sort, in fact it says the US is responsible for all these deaths. If you look down the list, they DO hold the US responsible for SOME insurgent actions, but where they are talking about deaths from mortars, gunfire and especially air assaults, they include MANY Us actions and not just the insurgents. Thus saying your URl proves that ALL deaths ae due to insurgents is just plain wrong. And yes, if you save the text file and open it in Exel, it does lean heavily away from car bombings being the mian issue.
It's really quite easy when you get the hang of it.
To be fair, when I first came here I said what I felt and what conclusions I had reached based on what I had read and seen. I was quickly shown HOW unaccetable this is because the forum is mainly US dominated and they require hard facts in order to see a point of view. I then learned to carefully research all comments before making them.
Just think yourself lucky it was me and a trivial issue, some of thse guys would have just chewed you up and spit you out for reaching a conclusion. That's why MANY people from Canada, England, Australia etc. rarely participate anymore, there's no thought process here anymore, no opinion, just a collection of web searches to appease the technically minded.
by tbragsda
by thelastword
by oz_media
You're right, I'm wrong and far too tired of this to continue.
We are not talking apples and apples and that will never end.
Have a great day and don't worry about it, it's not worth the time, there's no point to be made and no conclusion to be reached.
From what I can see by looking at the spreadsheet or site itself, is that SOME of the deaths were due to isurgents (car bombings) even if half of all deaths are from insurgents, it dismisses the claim of all deaths are caused by insurgents. That's the only issue I think you ae trying to defend. Whatever, you are 100% correct and I shall refrain from questioning your statements again.
P.S. Americans can't really play hockey anyway, they just buy Canadian teams.
by thelastword
by thelastword
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending