Insisted that every ISP report certain types of activity directly to them. It all involved "Kiddy Porn" which on the surface was quite all right.
What the position was that any person who logged onto specific sites had to be reported and then the Federal Police came out heavy handed and paid you a visit to see just what you where up to.
Well in typical Government fashion they neglected to place any safe guards in place for the ISP's they only made it mandatory to report certain activity. The Feds on the other hand where as subtle as an atomic bomb going off 3 inches from your left ear they stormed in stole all of your equipment to see exactly what you had been up to and then if warranted brought a prosecution against those involved in illegal activities.
Well a friend of mine was doing Post Graduate work on Government and was looking for information on different Governments around the world he tried "Whitehouse.com" which at the time was a hard core Kiddy porn site.
When he saw the material that appeared he logged off thought that he had made a mistake on entering the address and tried again with the same results. Two weeks latter he got a visit from the Feds who kicked his door in stole all of his equipment and took him away to help with their inquiries. He was eventually released after 2 weeks of integration but his equipment was not returned as it was required to confirm his story.
Naturally all of his backup material was also required just to make sure that he wasn't covering up anything and he was not allowed to take copies this effectively brought all of his studies to a screaming halt as well as branding him a "Pervert" so he was an outcast at the Uni and anyone who remotely came to his defense was automatically placed under investigation for the same thing.
Now you have to remember that every piece of telephony is monitored in different countries that ranges from simple phone calls to fax transmissions to all data transmissions and if certain strings appear in the data stream it gets flag recorded and eventually handed to a human to have a look at just like the data covering the 9-11 incident eventually got processed.
Everything is done by computers who sole job is to monitor all communications and then the Governments skimping on resources do not have enough people available to actually look at what is collected. It appears that the Bureaucrats & Governments seem to think that the hardware alone will be enough and then skimp on the human element. I believe that was brought forward in investigations subsequent to the 9-11 incident.
Over here this particular guy drooped out of Uni eventually had all of his equipment returned because he had done nothing wrong and was told to sue the ISP for Deformation. Just like a typical incompetent Government decision they want to be allowed access to the data but not have the responsibility when things do go wrong so the ISP in this case while having a Statutory Obligation to report any activity has no protection for doing this and is legally libel for any damage done. But at exactly the same time the Government has in place monitoring equipment that can do all that they require without the need to involve third parties.
When I see Legislation like the above I see it as nothing more than penny pinching by Governments who are unwilling to provide sufficient resources for the investigation side of their business and then legislate for third parties to do what is quite easily done by Government Departments.
The really sad thing on these occasions is the fact that the data is captured by never actually looked at unless it comes under a "High Priority" incident like 9-11 did and even then it was only discovered about 6 months after the event. If sufficient resources where devoted to the Intelligence Gathering Agencies we would not even be having this discussion as the whole thing would and should be a moot point.
Col