119 replies
by jimhm
My advise is live with it - Because it already sounds like Sour Grapes - I am not slamming or flaming you.
So you are stuck between a rock and a hard place, is she causing any problems within or outside of your department - No. Is it causing any delays in productivity - No. Is it only that she does nothing and is a tape recorder for all information others give her - Yes.
She will meet her waterloo soon, you need to just lay low - indirectly let people (management) know who has completed the work... let her take the credit and glory - and people will assume she has the knowledge... then - Poof - it will happen.
I my advise - stay low - keep quite - it would get ugly - look like a personality conflict and you would lose - or a pissing contest - and she will win.. best bet stay out of the shoot gallery..
by frr
I have experienced similar problems over the years and concur with the two earlier replies. I would also suggest that you cover your back by ensuring that every decision affecting you made by the manager is recorded in writing or email, even if you have to send her an email confirming a decision she has made to you verbally. She will eventually come a cropper and try and blame you for her incompetence - but, becuse you have a record of all decisions she has made, (in your email or on an internal memorandum) you can prove otherwise!
Other than that start scanning the job adverts.
Good luck.
by colinwee
I was in a situation like that with a boss who was totally inept, incompetent, lazy and stupid. I made sure to cover my a** well with documentation. But beyond that, to do my job well, I would create 'steering' documentation ... really short briefs that would get her to see things my way. Funny how many things started to occur like how I wanted it to. She takes the credit? Who cares. Everyone knows the truth. You've got a job. You need to do it to the best of your abilities (even if it seems like you're selling a piece of your soul).
Boss's like that unload their pent up tensions every now and then too. That's where covering your back comes in real handy.
Hang in there. Or quit. :-)
Colin
by mcpack
by elwoos
A lazy manager will eventually cause problems. When they fail to pump enough they will look incompetant to their supperiors. This image is reflected on all in the group. It is a dangerous maneuver but, I make the manager work. I follow chain of command and require appropriate guidance from my manager. It does two things. It gives opportunity for improvement. If it happens problem solved... It also gives opportunity for failure and for the upper management to recognize the problem. Either way, you have done what is required. You followed chain of command.
Besides that is what we pay them for. That is right, WE. They take a little out of our paychecks to fund the managers salery. They are accountable for that and should earn it as we do.
by dc_guy
The problem in your company runs much higher than your immediate superior. Somebody hired her. Somebody is keeping her on staff despite knowing that she is incompetent. Office politics is involved. Stay out of it! If you force people to show their hands, I promise you that they will NOT thank you for it. They might have so much political capital invested in this person that in order to protect it they will get rid of the whistle blower.
This stuff happens everywhere. You have to learn to put up with it and work around it. It's a survival trait in the business world.
I'll give you my standard advice: Get a dog, or spend more time with the one you have. A dog will help you get your priorities straight. Put more of yourself into the other aspects of your life and less into your job. Go home on time every night. Take your lunch break outside the building, preferably soaking up some solar-spectrum light that will both release endorphins in the daytime and help you sleep more soundly at night. And don't ever do anybody else's work for them.
It's a paycheck. It's a paycheck. It's a paycheck.
by sister_clamp
I have worked for almost two dozen employers, as a contractor and permanent, and one thing I've learned is that attitudes lower down the food chain ALWAYS reflect top management.
My last employment was with one of the largest IT organisations in the world. When the CEO changed, within 6 months, the entire ethos of the company changed...and not for the good.
Remember that people, after all, like to hire people who are images of themselves, or what they perceive themselves to be, and so it propagates down the line.
My husband is in exactly the same position as you. He's scanning job ads even as I type! That's the only way we see out of the situation. As for her eventually being found out...sorry, but it doesn't always happen.
It's only a job; it's only a job; it's only a job.
by tjona
All my life, I have been working with so many managers, why is it so hard for managers to be just as hardworking with their own employees ???
We worked hard and they get all the credits !
Your only concern is your own work and your own career (or it should only be). Whilst your boss may seem useless, it is not your concern. if your department is acheiving it's goals be grateful. You are waisting your time worrying about this. It doesn't make any differnce how good or bad anyone else is in your company. How hard you work is all that will come back to you. In the long run your work will get you the next job, so rather than stressing center your direction on doing the best you can for yourself as a technician. Your boss can worry about herself, her next job will be her future. (It is not worth kicking up a fuss, and it may be that there are factors outside your control or your consideration involved, so best to stop thinking in these lines altogether. If you cant do this leave the company as the problem has clearly become centered on you rather than her.
Sounds mean but that is life- and sometimes we have to face ourselves when we'd like to blame someone else.
by perseus
You Remember The Age Old Formula ?
Smart Manager + Dumb Employee = PRODUCTION
Dumb Manager + Dumb Employee = OVERTIME
Smart Manager + Smart Employee = PROFIT
Dumb Manager + Smart Employee = PROMOTION
Well Jokes apart, You will have to tread a very cautious Path. Since Other Depatrtments are also complaining yet nothing is happening, it only means she's got a sweet spot with Sr. Management.
You will have to adopt a give and take approch in this case. Dirty as it may seem, that's the only viable solution.
Here's how you do it. If she wants to take credit for your deptt's Hard work, well So be it. (It happens all the time. Everywhere. No Exceptions) Since She leads it, She will get it by default even if she didn't claim it. So Give it up.
However You can make sure that within the deptt you get credit where its due from her. May Be a Time Off or Raise or a Paid vacation. This is a long drawn process but please keep your consious aside for some time. Slowly you start a push to accompany her to the Deptt Meeting with Sr. Management. Since as you say she's got no Idea of what's happening in the Deptt, She will appreciate the Face saving you can give at those meetings. You in turn can integrate more with Sr. Management. Over time you can build a case with other Deptt against her and use your newly found Integration to show her the door. Remeber Patience is a virtue.Good Luck!
by questor1
I agree with the earlier postings, but would like to add that you should watch out for office politics...
You need to carefully look at how this Manager got their position in the first place. Was it years with the company, (former) tech expertise, related to the company President, assumed a job no one else wanted or was qualified for, etc.?
The bottom line is that consultants are often thrown into problem situations because of their expertise (tech and people-handling skills), yet are considered expendable when something goes wrong. It is easy for the Manager to blame an expendable employee or consultant for the Manager's lack of coordination or tech skills, so be sure to document all conversations!
Regards, Questor
by jrjs
My first piece of advice is to check your motives for this complaint.
It should be recognised that an IT Manager's job and responsibilities differ from those of an IT technical professional. Can you be sure that she is not performing her job responsibilities properly?
My second piece of advice is to make sure that you perform your job responibilities in an exemplary manner and to be seen to do so.
In any decent organisation, people will be recognised for the way that they perform their work. If your organisation does not qualify, time to check the Job Ads!
Finally, as recorded in another response, don't let work dominate your life - make time to enjoy life outside of work. We 'work to live' not 'live to work'.
With luck, concentrating on your own job performance will get the recognition it deserves and enable you to avoid seeing the things that concern you about your manager.
All the best ;-) (DLTBWYD).
by perseus
by goanna
by commandgce
In any social situation there are three major variables - task, affiliation and power. There is no way you can solve this problem with a task or affiliation approach. So, it's politics.
Find out how the boss got her present position. Who pulled the strings? Was this a Peter Principle promotion? What does she have on her promoter? Who else in positions of power is linked to your boss? What do they think of her? How much clout do they have? If they think she's wonderful, you're in the wrong job; look elsewhere. If they're willing to trade dirt, think what will happen to you, afterwards. Again, look elsewhere. You may think you have the balls, but they own the ball!
by d_bones
Many thanks for all your suggestions, I'm polishing the C.V. as we speak. I thought the only real course of action was to sell my talents elsewhere. I just feel the injustice of the situation that affects others, not necessarily me, may be salvagable. And as a couple of you suggest. Perhaps I should "Get A Life" or a dog.
Many thanks, it's nice to know your not alone
Chances are she relaizes her shortcomings. If I were you, I would help her learn the right way to do things...teach her...make good suggestions and praise her when she gets something right. Chances are she will eventually move from that position and she will recommend you to take over in her place. Be smart and do the right thing by her, after sll, she is your boss. Things will work out to your benefit in the long run if you exhibit the right karma.
Brother Richard
by perseus
Hey It happens to all of us. You certainly are not alone. Yes its a good Idea to Polish the CV even if you may not need it.
What you may try is to not work so hard. Especially not like Alice The Dilbert's Cow Worker. Cheer Up. It may not be as bad as it seems.
by jplace
by boneyfish
by rcdata
I have been a Manager for many years now and I have learned one thing. A good manager will surround himself/herself with good people. A manager is only as good as the people under them.
A great manager will not be above anyone else in there department. Yes, at times the "buck" has to stop somewhere.
My "employee's" would consider me a great manager, I am involved in every aspect of the projects at hand. I am also considered a "friend" because I do not put myself above them. I don't know everything and sometimes you needs a fresh way to look at a particular problem in order to come to a resolution. Sounds like your boss is a good manager and not a great one. Maybe you should ask her when she is done with the paper if you could read it..
by d_bones
Many thanks for all your suggestions, I'm polishing the C.V. as we speak. I thought the only real course of action was to sell my talents elsewhere. I just feel the injustice of the situation that affects others, not necessarily me, may be salvagable. And as a couple of you suggest. Perhaps I should "Get A Life" or a dog.
Many thanks, it's nice to know your not alone
As stated in earlier responses. Make sure your work or work product is impeccable. Get tuned into what the boss is asking of you. Similar situation for me a couple years ago (with back-to-back bosses). Take the high road and understand the office politics.
The moral of the story is that both bosses met/chose their fate by their actions. Me, I'm still with the company.
by mgordon
by sw1ne2001
Interesting thread this, I have enjoyed the many views expressed and would just like to add my 2p.
D_Bones.. As a manager myself (after many years working my way from the very bottom of my organisation and working in a lot of the roles within my business sector), someone made the decision to allow me to run my own bit of hell in the technical arm of my company.
The same organisation did not prepare me in any real way to handle the responsibility and unfortunately this seems to be a norm within industry as a whole. They, (HR / Personnel etc) promote people to do a managerial role on a number of criteria, knowledge, length of service etc without really considering the 'soft' (sic) skills needed to run a unit, it cost me (and others) pain whilst I developed. Still if you can't stand the heat....
One of the key gripes I have came across is "my manager is lazy", how do you know? Do you do her job? In my experience a manager is paid to ensure that the business is managed properly, to ensure that projects, products and deadlines are delivered as required to the organisation, and, if they are paid to be line managers, that the employees they manage are motivated, developed and kept busy.
If your manager crows because you did work well and to time / within budget etc then they have performed exactly as they are required by the company (why have a dog and bark?).
You are passionate enough about your work to raise the issue, are you passionate enough to change the situation? Your manager deserves your respect and honesty, as do your subordinates, colleagues and customers. If you break that trust then people tend to respond badly (bad news in the longer term).
Ask the lady in question what her goals are for you and the department and then help her to crow louder, it will be good for you and good for her. Who knows she may be promoted and then it could be your responsibility (and then your fault!).
Both sh*t and cream float, it's hard to get sacked in larger organisations (unless you are stupid) but you rarely rise further than you are able to handle and as long as you please your boss then you are in with a chance.
Concentrate on you, if she is as bad as you think then she won't last.
You are worth your own investment.
Regards,
Ian
by rjoseph
The only thing I would add is this. You will never get anywhere in life bringing others down. Let them fall themselves. Many people said cover your back, well I will get more specific.
You write the code? comment it with your name or e-mail (if it is internal only, so you don't get spammed) and explain the workings very well. If ever someone audits your work, you will be the first one they ask. Sounds simple but it works.
Documentation is another great way of focusing on yourself a bit more. Write the white papers for the projects, and include your name on it.
Concentrate on getting some spotlight on you rather than trying to place the AXE over her.
Your in a tough area, and by focusing on her you are the only one that will get hurt.
by gabby22
Agree completely. I've been in this situation a couple of times and advised many others in the same boat. It's not just about being nice and happy. Any of the more obvious solutions (apart from jumping ship) can easily damage your position and your career. If you white-ant your boss, how's your next boss gunna feel about you?
IMNSHO the *only* approach is to support your boss to the maximum as far as work and advice goes (if questioned about her performance, make neutral comments, and don't get drawn into trashing sessions). Sometimes this is hard, particularly when she wants you to do things that you think are a waste of time. However, I've generally found that stupid, greedy, ignorant or arrogant folks are the easiest to manipulate, so you can get some good practice here.
But back to the subject. Do everything you can to make her look good and stay on top of things. Others, including others at higher levels, will notice eventually, and it will reflect well on you.
Finally, although you should CYA, don't make it too obvious or she may work out what you're doing and you could become the fallguy. People like this are often great survivors - that's how they get to where they are. If she think's you're a threat, it's time to pack.
by leyther
We had a similar situation recently. Our Ops Manager came in and seemed to be competent, and knew what she was doing, but then the cracks started to appear. First it was that she would claim we were the ones at fault although it was blatantly obvious she was, she lied continuously, claimed credit for other peoples work, and criticised others for doing something, then go ahead and do it herself. As we were in the office with her we noticed the flaws sooner than those who would only be there rarely, but eventually she was seen as what she was by all. But she was still working here so we had to make do of a bad lot.
Then she left; and its now become apparent that she was even more incompetent than we realised, now we have had a chance to sort through the mess she left (we still wonder what she was doing the whole time she was here).
To me it seems that a bad manager is only allowed to get away with what they do because nobody above them seems to take the time to check what they're doing, or know what they're doing. As an office employee i have someone above me who is checking my work, but who is checking the checker?
by cindy in fl
This will sound like an echo but it bears repeating - you never get anywhere by bringing others down, not in the long run anyhow. And the person you damage the most in attempting to do so is yourself. Don't even think about it politically, think about what it does to who you are. It's not worth it, and not what you want to be remembered for.
Next to ensuring that your work is of the highest quality possible, I have always felt that the the key to all of this is documentation. Commenting code, creating a "paper" trail of your conversations and assignments, etc. It's all been said by others here, and it's the best advice. That way if/when "what goes around, comes around" you'll not be caught up in the fall out.
I add 1 documentation technique that I learned the hard way. Keep track of what you do on a daily basis (I use a steno pad). Not minute by minute, but in chunks of an hour or more (no, it does not take that much time, I've done it for years). Then, and this is the key, write a monthly status report. Your boss will think it's a terrific idea (it really is a great tool for her at appraisal time, etc.) and you have a comprehensive paper trail of your accomplishments that can be used for a multitude of reasons: Use it when compiling reasons why you deserve a better raise or rating at appraisal time, use it to cite specific accomplishments when writing a resume for that new job, etc. I write one whether my boss requests it or not. Biggest lesson I've learned in my years working in IT.
Good Luck.
by gamboge
by andy_c
by susan_h
If the only "bad" part of your job is your aggrevation with your
manager, changing jobs is not the answer. There are similar
managers everywhere (think Dilbert and the pointy-haired boss).
A new job may just mean another "incompetant" (or worse) boss
with assignments that are nowhere near as interesting or
rewarding. Try getting your satisfaction from a job well done.
by ted100
by adkins1218
I feel your pain,I went thru 5 assistant plant managers and 5 plant managers in 11 years at the same company and out of all of them only 1 was both technically comptent and had the people skills to get the best out of his employees.Look it's easy,go back to school,open your own company then YOU are the boss.You probably don't work rotating shiftwork so you have nights,weekends,holidays off(read:work 8,sleep 8,party 8)also you most likely have a sit down job,a\c in the office ect: Quit whining.Do you really think a new outlook twords the boss now really would be believed? More importaintly, could you look yourself in the mirror?
I think the best thing would be to a)Look for another job. and b)Prepare to open your own business.This might mean distance or local college degree's,get published in the field you are in,but quit whining and get off your butt and make a change to improve your situation.In the meantime,suffer in silence,keep a smile on your face,do the best job you can and create change to put yourself on a path to a better future,only you can make it happen.
Normal syndrome and painful. Typical of slow death syndrome of an individual and this permeates into the team. 2 things:
1. company should have Management by Objectives environment, so manager is driven from top down.
2. if you consider yourself leader, then learn to "break through". i.e. when things need to get done, do them. Take initiative with the team, and breakthrough the slow death syndrome. Diplomatically let senior mangement realise the team operates without the lazy one, this is done through motivation, setting your own objectives and getting the results. Maybe set up a news letter, electronic, and let the company know what the team is doing. Challenge other department resources to better your results and create healthy competition. Do this inspite of the lazy manager! E-mail me for more if you want!!
by sealife
You have run slap-bang into an injustice. It is interesting to read the advice that you've been given so far:
* Pick up the sword.
* Run away.
* Life's like that.
* Who are you anyway?
by robertsrules
by mek804
Some of the replies here mention "just live with it". I don't think
that's the trick at all. I like robertsrules response: find something
for her to do, but be extra tactful about it.
Her flaw is that she likes to "step forward to take credit". This is
the chink in her armour. Find a way to get her to get off of her
duff and do things using phrases like "I really need someone
with your kind of clout to take the ball on this one" or "this
would make other departments know how wonderful we are".
Sounds weaselly, I know, but your world has already been
tainted by weasels, and you will have to play by their rules now.
Glory hounds fall for it every time, and now you've not only
gotten them busy, you may well have made yourself a "good
guy" in the process.
Incompetent managers are not always the ones who hire
incompetent managers--the blame for that, and for not finding
a way to help get rid of them, often falls on HR/Personnel, as
well. But I suppose that's a whole different thread...
mk
by sealife
You have run slap-bang into an injustice. It is interesting to read the advice that you've been given so far:
* Pick up the sword.
* Get a dog.
* Run away.
* Life's like that.
* Who are you anyway?
The question of what to do is interesting. If we allow injustices to prosper then what of the world in which we live? I suggest that it will just get worse.
To stop the injustices he propogated Hitler had to be stopped. Appeasement didn't work. Early indications are that it was a good move to take him out even though the cost was massive.
Some of us can fight and some can't. You have to decide whether it's an important enough issue for you to deal with directly; whether it's your way. There's plenty of advice on playing politics in these posts and I agree that it's a risky option. It is what humans seem to do when they get into organisations though.
I have to say that I never had a job for long that was just a job. I have been lucky enough to do things I've been passionate about. There was lots of conflict and I moved about. Some I won and some I lost but I am glad that I fought for what I believed.
I also think that dogs are great company.
Good luck with whatever you decide to do about herself - you'll meet lots more of the same in life.
by philip
I would recommend writing a letter to the next superior expressing your thoughts. This is a sample letter that came to me and though it is probably not true, it points out how to express the incompetence of your boss:
Dear Mr. Baker,
As a graduate of an institution of higher education, I have a few very basic expectations. Chief among these is that my direct superiors have an intellect that ranges above the common ground squirrel. After your consistent and annoying harassment of my coworkers and me during the commission of our duties, I can only surmise that you are one of the few true genetic wastes of our time.
Asking me, a network administrator, to explain every little nuance of everything I do each time you happen to stroll into my office is not only a waste of time, but also a waste of precious oxygen. I was hired because I know how to network computer systems, and you were apparently hired to provide amusement to myself and other employees, who watch you vainly attempt to understand the concept of "cut and paste" for the hundredth time.
You will never understand computers. Something as incredibly simple as binary still gives you too many options. You will also never understand why people hate you, but I am going to try and explain it to you, even though I am sure this will be just as effective as telling you what an IP is. Your shiny new iMac has more personality than you ever will.
You walk around the building all day, shiftlessly looking for fault in others. You have a sharp dressed useless look about you that may have worked for your interview, but now that you actually have responsibility, you pawn it off on overworked staff, hoping their talent will cover for your glaring ineptitude. In a world of managerial evolution, you are the blue-green algae that everyone else eats and laughs at. Managers like you are a sad proof of the Dilbert principle. Since this situation is unlikely to change without you getting a full frontal lobotomy reversal, I am forced to tender my resignation, however I have a few parting thoughts.
1. When someone calls you in reference to employment, it is illegal for you to give me a bad recommendation. The most you can say to hurt me is "I prefer not to comment." I will have friends randomly call you over the next couple of years to keep you honest, because I know you would be unable to do it on your own.
2. I have all the passwords to every account on the system, and I know every password you have used for the last five years. If you decide to get cute, I am going to publish your "favorites list", which I conveniently saved when you made me "back up" your useless files. I do believe that terms like "Lolita" are not usually viewed favorably by the administration.
3. When you borrowed the digital camera to "take pictures of your Mother's birthday," you neglected to mention that you were going to take pictures of yourself in the mirror nude. Then you forgot to erase them like the techno-moron you really are. Suffice it to say I have never seen such odd acts with a sauce bottle, but I assure you that those have been copied and kept in safe places pending the authoring of a glowing letter of recommendation. (Try to use a spell check please; I hate having to correct your mistakes.)
Thank you for your time, and I expect the letter of recommendation on my desk by 8:00 am tomorrow. One word of this to anybody, and all of your little twisted repugnant obsessions will be open to the public. Never f*** with your systems administrator. Why? Because they know what you do with all that free time!
Wishing you a grand and glorious day,
Cecelia
by dumbuser
Ok, so my mom told me life isn't fair --- I can see that when losers like this get managerial jobs and the rest of us slug it out in the trenches.
I know, too bad the city bus can't "remove" her one morning. In lieu of that, you'll probably have to do one of a couple of things: 1)leave, 2)shot her, 3)undermine her, 4)ignore her. Personally, I'd either figure out how to ignore her (though I'll admit, watching her take credit for something she didn't do is irritating, to say the least) or move on. You need to find a manager/leader you can respect.
by rkallianpur
Hi,
Not knowing about your circumstances, all I would like to say is do not let her bridle your enthusiasm for your work or for you seeking better things for your customer. Do not fall into the trap of thinking that "oh, she gets the praise,so why should I bother"? You will do yourself injustice and to the ones who rely on you - your customers.
In so far as your boss, think of it not being your problem. Trust me, people know who does the real work, who is there just to take credit.
And by the way, if there is no encouragement from your boss, do not take it personally. Mediocrity rarely encourages excellence - they are threatened by it.
Ravi Kallianpur
ravi@i-55.com
by cabnva
by isgirl
In my experience, Managing a workgroup requires an entirely different set of skills than being a NetAdmin or IT Tech.
Managing any department requires endless reports to Sr. Management, boring Management Meetings, budgeting, shuffling the schedules of staff, and very little hands on project oriented work.
Managers are also held responsible for the screw ups of their staff, so they may find that they take the blame when something goes wrong and feel entitled to take the credit when things go right.
It is my opinion that the grass always looks greener, and you may think your boss doesn't actually have to work because you see them wasting a little time at work. Odds are, she is working on things you don't have any interest in or any desire to be involved in - like the departmental budget or metrics reporting for the weekly meeting.
In my opinion, a Department that finds little need for direction from their manager is well managed. It takes a certain personality type to delegate responsbility and knowledge to those beneath them. Some managers let their staff do very little because they don't want to lose the control they have over their staff in the form of their superior knowledge.
My advice is to look more closely for the things that she is doing that qualify as work and compare the time she spends on personal calls and recreational reading to the time you spend on personal things at work....I bet it will be close.
Last, you might demonstrate to her that she leads by example and do a little light reading of your own on company time and feel free to make personal calls when you wish (or do you already?). This may remind her that she is setting the example and she may cut back on her time-wasters in the office too....or she will let you get away with it.
Bad managers are everywhere and you may find the same or worse in the next job. Learn to adapt.
by johnnysacks
Having been through quite a few companies, this is VERY typical and you're best off to garner all the exposure you can for person #1 - you.
Believe me, it doesn't take much - if you're good, everyone knows enough to look past the facade of this non-entity manager.
Hopefully you're in a Fortune 100 company and there's room above for him/her to be promoted.
by rbchapin
by orion215
by capabel
I was in a situation a few times like that and the easiest way out was when I felt I was being pumped for obvious information that my boss wanted to use for his own. I would initially give him bad advice and horrible direction so if it was ever used or passed on as his he would take the blame not the credit. Then I would draft possible options after the sh** hit the fan coming in as a savior. The boss quickly realized I wasn't his pawn, but his opponent and decided to take a position elsewhere about a year later where I was then promoted to his position.
The key is your only a worker so you more than likely won't take the blame for bad decisions as much as your boss will so if he/she is inept let them be and don't bail them out. Eventually someone will realize they don't have a clue and look for others who do!!
by rcdata
A Good manager will surround themselves with good employees,
A great manager will manage the paperwork and work with there employees!!
If all the work is being done, sounds like she is doing a "good" job! You may no like the way things are done but you have to ask yourself,"How would I manage the department?" Try and ask to read the paper after she is done with it !! The way things go is if your assigned work, even if you think it is your bosses work, bottom line.. it's your work!!
I am the owner of my own comapny, I work hand-in-hand with my employee's!! I don't know everything and sometimes you need a new way to look at things. You shouldn't be concered with what she is doing.. just do your job!!!
by rob c
In my 40 years of working (20 years in IT), I would categorize managers into -
10% competent, and managing well
30% competent(once), but evolved to using politics
60% incompetent, and using politics.
And a very high percentage of the 90% adept at avoiding/shifting blame, and stealing credit.
You could go down my path and blow the whistle, then fight for two years to protect your job, until the stress kills you.
Or, try to get upper management to introduce a philosophy of 'accountability'.
In an ideal world, there would be either an official or anonymous means for staff to rate their managers.
If the top manager is competent, and secure in his abilities, you could get a few staff to send anonymous suggestions for introduction of such
a rating system.
Unfortunately quite often the top manager, is just as political as the rest.
I left (or was pushed out of) auditing in early 80's because audits were not being done properly. It is only recently that their slackness is being exposed.
Hope you have better luck than me.
Rob C
PS I have found that most staff these days would rather suck up, and protect their own backs, than try to fix things.
by david
People will treat you like a doormat if you let them. It's not easy to confront your boss but, in my experience, if you put your comments across in a firm, but professional, manner without being nasty or rude you will mostly gain that person's respect.
Once you've gained respect then you can sort out the issues. Bolster yourself and go to it buddy. Good luck.
by realgem
Look, you're not going to change your boss. Don't bother trying. Also, don't compromise your professionalism by feeding mis-information to her, spreading rumours, or bad-mouthing her.
Since she's not adding any value, then you (and your peers) are essentially running the department. You probably have a lot of leeway; enjoy it. Would you rather have a micro-manager who can actually do your job and is constantly second-guessing you? Trust me, you don't.
Wish I could offer some assistance, but....
Some years ago I was employed by a small company. My boss (the Technical Director, who was also the General Manager)quit; the office was bought by another division and my new (Technical Director)boss was a newly-hired female PhD I was actually looking forward to working with. One of her first orders of business was to replace me (a business move I can understand if she knew what she was doing-- which she did not). Long story short-- she did not last a year, but I was since long gone (having gone on to bigger and better things).
It may be a sign to start packing your bags while you still have the time to do so on your own schedule. This one sounds like bad news you can not do a thing about.
by winfan
First off, this manager was picked by her boss for what the boss thought were valid reasons. If you complain to the big boss he or she is most likely going to be offended and not take it kindly that you challenge their beliefs/decisions. That makes you come out the loser again.
Upper management will take the view that you were hired to do your job and not to evaluate your manager. Her being lazy should not effect your job performance. If it effects her own job performance and it ultimately will, she will pay the price.
You only have one choice and that is to do your job and do it well. Let nature take its course with the lazy manager. If she's incompetent then it will catch up with her at some point.
by delbertpgh
Like Candide said, stick to your own business. If you're as good as you wish your boss was, your competence will speak loudest for you. That being said, every technical problem has a human and economic environment, so if you want your good works with the tech stuff to actually be effective, you have to understand the personal and organizational side of the trade. Which means getting to know your way around the company, and becoming known in turn. A real techie's job is getting effective solutions to human problems that are actually out there, and not taking for granted that what he knows how to do is what needs to be done. Do that, and you will be known and loved, and can move past your boss with grace and serenity. In other words, she's not your problem.
Your boss may be the female equivalent of the Dilbert's pointy-haired incompetent, but she's there because she's got something figured out that you probably don't. Time to get your head out of your cube and learn what's going on.
Humility and a decent wardrobe will help, too.
by aln
by sao
by stillwaters
by joecolly
by kroof
by bcdrguy
by thesage
by joew
by john_hurt
Lazy managers are hard to work for; however, in dealing with this I always ask the same question: "Have you talked to her about your feelings?". What if she doesn't get it? What if she thinks she is doing her job, but everyone around her doesn't.
One of the key elements to becoming a valuable employee is to learn to "develop up". If you were in her shoes you would not want a group of people generating an uprising towards you. You would want to understand how your people felt, weed out the "soft criticism" and work on building a platform of trust, and teamwork.
My suggestion: Go talk to her. Be up front, but not confrontational. Suggest a team meeting in which everyone clarifies areas of opportunity in the team, NOT THE INDIVIDUALS, and suggest ways to improve.
If your problem persists, then I believe JIM (other respondent) was right - let her ride to her death; however, remember - once she is gone someone else will take over and there WILL be traits you and your co-workers don't like about that person.
Better to resolve the issue now, and avoid either getting on her bad side, or getting so fed up that you leave your company. Find a way to make it a better place to work.
JH
I think many of the respondents are suggesting laying low and let your manager's lack of work ethic solve itself.
Why is this tolerated at your company? Why are the upper management allowing this to go on? Before you take any action, make sure you have answers to the broader questions.
In my firm I would be just as dissapointed in a staff that did nothing about this manager as I would be with the manager!
Geoff
by mikefromco
If I were above a department doing that, you'd best run for cover too.
As much as I wouldn't support a manager described by the original poster, I'm not going to tolerate a mutiny either.
You're upsetting an applecart for what reason (in the case of the original poster)? There's no evidence that she is not rewarding her staff or even if that is within her ability.
So, just for taking credit? Bah. If the money's good and work isn't bad, deal with it.
Besides, the next manager may be a micro-managing nut!
by mikefromco
It is hard to determine whether your department is functioning or not. On the one hand, it sounds like it is getting the job done.
But you do say 'other departments moan and groan' as well. Other managers or other workers?
I've worked with hands-off and hands-on managers; truthfully prefer hands-off unless needed.
In my own style, I try to only offer guidance where needed. If I have to follow people around, I may as well do it myself. I'm looking at the bigger picture making sure the parts come together.
Keep in mind that some management designs also give the manager little to do, except admin stuff; especially when things are going along well.
If you like what you're doing, just document the work you are doing to cya. If she basically leaves everyone to their own, chances are you won't have a problem unless you create one. I wouldn't do that unless I had a job lined up...
by joemales
I agree with the previous response on being friendly and working with this person in a positive way.
This person is probobly keeping her guard up knowing that she is in a position way over her head. If you show a little understanding and work with her, maybe she will work harder. If not, use the latest technologies out there. You have spycams that can monitor her every move. Then you can go to her bosses computer and accidently turn camera's on. Isn't TCPIP great!
by douglasault
by d_demoura
Your hierarchical business structure defines your course of action. By all means, you MUST always cover your back. This insures you have documented all procedures / decisions and are capable of supporting your claims if ever they need be. Most likely, your "boss" relies entirely on building relationships with his/her management superiors and uses that bond to his/her advantage. This is also a valid method of management that I find mostly used by older managers who have lost some of their technical edge. It's OK, they are still managing. This will not do if this person is acting as a project manager. A project manager requires technical skill to guide project resources. If your manager's decisions are affecting projects, then it is your duty to keep an account of all actions and decisions. If your manager is just there to provide structural business support, and provide direction to someone else's vision (a puppet), then there little you can do ... they are probably doing their job correctly as long as you are doing yours correctly. However, I find the upper management is usually less savvy to begin with, that's why we have jobs.
Good luck with your boss, I suggest you leave it alone unless there's a major SNAFU.
by raelayne
You have in incompetent manager. It's disappointing. But it's also an opportunity.
What do you want? Your manager's job? Your manager to do her job? Your manager to let you do whatever you want in your job? Decide. It's business, not personal life -- you're allowed to be competitive and self-interested. And remember that it's probably apparent to everyone, including her manager, that your manager isn't doing her job. It's organizational inertia that's supporting the status quo. Tip it!
1. If you want your manager's job, it shouldn't be too hard. Build relationships with key people in other departments. Become the can-do person. Your reputation will build, and pretty soon your manager's manager will be getting pressure to move you into the leadership position from his or her peers. Look for a way to make your manager's manager look good. Skip a level. That will do it.
2. You want a real manager? Figure out who that should be. Then start dropping subtle hints. Build that person up. Subtly. Look for an opportunity to drop the hint to your manager's manager. By then, if you've done your prep work, he or she will have heard it from others.
3. You want someone to let you do whatever you want? To back you up and support you and stay out of your way. It's easy! I learned this from a co-worker who had 8 managers in as many years, and managed them all. Practice this: "As you've said many times, ..." Quote her all the time, every time you get a chance in a meeting. "Mary wants us to ..." "As Mary says ..." Pretty soon she'll think she did say all of that.
Most important, don't be a coward. Take charge of the situation and make it work for you. Or drop out of the business world.
by sartre1
I started my career as a Financial Analyst with a BS in Finance and Accounting. Five years later earned a graduate degree in MIS and migrated to IT. I have dealt with the "lazy boss" my entire IT career and have found two very effective solutions: (1) network and make alliances with the end users and business Managers or (2) make the risky leap into the contracting marketplace to ensure you skills remain intact and you don't become one of them as her breed is on the way out.
First, the end users and their Manager(s) are generally just as frustrated with this IT Manager and often have long-standing, legitimate grievances. Slowly and strategically make yourself available to them directly, as opposed convertly through your IT Manager taking credit for your work, and you will find they will not only bypass your boss but you will gain the credibility and respect you have earned. Further, in some extreme cases, such as my tenure with America West, a Vice President of Revenue Management (business side) actually recruited me to run their first Oracle data warehousing project, which was a huge success (they offered me Director before I transitioned) because of long-standing grievances with the incompetence of several key IT Managers.
Second, you have the option of contracting but this is both a riskier career path, although very rewarding, and one that does nothing to cure the old-school disease. Nevertheless, you cannot afford to just get used to it because you will eventually find your technical skills waning as well as your positive attitude. And, considering the new thrust in holding IT departments accountable to the core business in tying business processes to IT projects and applications you cannot afford to lose your technical edge.
In short, your boss is a fraud and I have worked for dozens of them at companies like Wells Fargo, APS, HDS McKesson, NCS Pearson, Cyclone Commerce, DHL, etc. As a contractor, however, I was able to expose them while I was showing MYSELF the door. However, this is a tough road to travel and one in which the rewards are long term. Yet, I have maintained my expert technical skills and still enjoy what I do...despite some occasional, lingering angst.
Take heart in that you are right, your boss sucks and is an old-school idiot, and do a search on Dice, Monster, or jobfusion to validate this: even Project Managers and IT Directors are being required to have hands-on technical skills, now. On a final note, don't look to your peers for support. Many IT professionals are too concerned with a paycheck, now, to embrace the future and ensure they have that paycheck in ten years.
My email address is sartre1@comcast.net. Please let me know how it goes and figure out who signs the checks on the business/end-user side and make alliances as it is way too politically treacherous to do so on the IT side: there are many of your peers that depend on that boss to keep their inept butts employed, too.
Ellis R. Miller
I'm 46 years old and have worked in the industry
for over twenty years. Most of that time I've worked
as a consultant/temp so I've seen the inside of
about 40 companies, big and small. I can tell you
with absolute confidence that, to one degree or
another, they're all the same. I'm also very
discouraged about do-nothing managers. I'm
considering seeking employment as a computer
operations department manager to see if I could
do a better job than the people that I've worked
for.
by forresto
by rob
by marar
My suggestion is to do a bit of all.
She is acting like this probably since she is new to management and thinks this is the expectations :-). May be you should talk to her in a good way about ways to solve the problems. If she is a brilliant person otherwise, she will understand that what she is doing is a mistake and is hurting others. And hopefully, she will change her ways.
In the meantime, do your homework and document all the approvals and rejections and other project related updates. In case, she doesn't change, you always have the backup.
by thebooch
I was in a situation like this, working for an incompetent manager and when it came time for layoffs most of my department went including me becuase of his longstanding ineptness.
Its really a shame when there are so many competent managers out there who are out of work and whose job went oversees. Its insult to injury...do your best to get her fired and move yourself up the ladder or open a postion for someone who overachieve and make your who department proud.
by lalalulu
by philreynolds
Hey Dave:
I hear your pain; I was in the same situation six months ago with a manager who was all that and a bag of crap!! So my advise is to just bide your time and give them enough rope to hang themselves with. It won't take long before people see its all smoke and mirrors and send them packing.
by stemplarv
by mgordon
I recommend reading "The Peter Principle" by Dr. Lawrence Peter. It is a thin book; and sums into these words "all men rise to the level of their incompetence." It speaks to an era that is not always relevant but the forces are still applicable. What happens is that a person that is competent will be promoted. Eventually the person will be promoted to a place where he or she is no longer competent. But will she be put back to her most recent competency? Usually not. Dr. Peter believes it takes about ten years before every echelon except the new employees and the CEO (who cannot be promoted) become incompetent. The result in many cases is the company itself is replaced, not just the manager. His example is UPS (United Parcel Service) versus the fossilized postal service. Corrolaries to the principle include such gems as your supervisor is your enemy but HIS (or her) supervisor is your friend. That is, your next promotion is to take your supervisor's job. If you are better than your supervisor, it will please the NEXT echelon to put you there but it will not please your supervisor.
Now then, in our technical world things are a wee bit different. I do many things -- graphic arts, photography, computer programming, and help desk. So guess what I do mostly? Yes, help desk, because it is amazingly tedious, requires extremely nimble thinking and excellent communication skills. Could I be a manager? Sure, but who is going to talk to customers? The fact is, sometimes a company, especially smaller ones, hire friends 'n family (nepotism) and if they cannot program a computer, cannot sit at the help desk, don't even come to work reliably -- what is the one position suited to such a person? You got it, management! Provided, of course, that the staff is self-directed and doesn't really need management in the first place. Jack be nimble, Jack be quick -- helpdesk positions are leaving this nation but internal corporate helpdesks are a pretty good source of face time.
What can you do about it? Probably nothing. The NEXT echelon up should be made aware of it in a nonthreatening way; ensure that you get "face time" especially in a technical world where hardly anyone knows what you do anyway. Being seen by the boss, nicely dressed and helping a customer for ten seconds is worth more than a month in a cubicle working on the Next Big Thing.
The Big Boss surely knows that little bosses are not actually doing the work; but the Big Boss is not a mind reader and should not skip the chain of command anyway. So get some face time. If you cannot get face time, YOUR days are numbered and the number is inversely proportional to your skill (ie, threat to your boss). A lazy manager gets that way by using survival skills; you should learn some of those skills (name dropping, face time, appreciating jokes but beware getting sucked into inappropriate games by a skilled provocateur).
by oz_media
Don't worry, given time she will be held accountable and it will come around, it ALWAYS does. I've seen people get away with it for years and are completely stunned when let go.
Welcome to management, get used to it, you cannot change it nor is it your place to do so.
IF you feel that you are not able to do YOUR job because of her, then YOUR failure will be reflected on her, not you.
OM
by adkins1218
I feel your pain,I went thru 5 assistant plant managers and 5 plant managers in 11 years at the same company and out of all of them only 1 was both technically comptent and had the people skills to get the best out of his employees.Look it's easy,go back to school,open your own company then YOU are the boss.You probably don't work rotating shiftwork so you have nights,weekends,holidays off(read:work 8,sleep 8,party 8)also you most likely have a sit down job,a\c in the office ect: Quit whining.Do you really think a new outlook twords the boss now really would be believed? More importaintly, could you look yourself in the mirror?
I think the best thing would be to a)Look for another job. and b)Prepare to open your own business.This might mean distance or local college degree's,get published in the field you are in,but quit whining and get off your butt and make a change to improve your situation.In the meantime,suffer in silence,keep a smile on your face,do the best job you can and create change to put yourself on a path to a better future,only you can make it happen.
by mark11727
...actually not entirely. I've had several bosses here over the last ten years, and each has his/her own way about them. Most openly give credit where credit is due, and one tends to include himself in the telling (as in "WE worked really hard to get this out" when in reality I did all the getting out myownself). All of them acknowlege me as the "go-to" guy, and as such, I usually get the "weird" projects, that either nobody else wants or knows how to handle. This has also earned me some flexabilty, allowing me to design and tweak as I see the need (although I've also been dinged during review time for sometimes thinking *too* outside the box.
Getting back to your own problem, I worked for a short while in a small software shop (long since closed), and one co-worker, who could never quite get it together, always came around asking technical questions... after a while, this person was going to be promoted (and become my supervisor) and I knew what a disaster this would be in the long run, so I left (there were other issues with this place).
Years later, a colleague told be that the Peter Principle eventually bit this person, but hard, and I knew it was for the best.
by chrisjohl
by jamesrl
This could be a good way to get fired.
For this to be successful it has to be framed in such a way that you look like you can help the manager acheive a win-win - she gets something and you get something. If you challenge in a non-constructive way, you will be seen as insubordinate and thats very dangerous.
Subordinates don't get to "pick" their manager.
James
by brianf
Well I concur with the majority of replies, I have exactly the same problem now, the issue is the manager may very well be lazy but that does not always equate to "DUMB". Your manager could very well be the same as mine they know how to play the office politics game. Ok the answer is get better at the game than they are and as others have stated CYA - cover your ****. Keep a log of everything you do take copies of all your notes off site make a note with date time etc of any comments your manager may make. I assume your fellow worker bees know the score so keep them onside and ensure they know what you are doing. Ultimately the truth will come out be it by internal/external audit or other means and then sit back and watch the fireworks. Patience is a virtue that you must observe in situations like this any confrontation will backfire with you being the loser.
good luck
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending