There are a lot of different options out there. As a programmer, I was in a very similar position. I wanted to move up, was working on a advanced degree but didn't have the focused knowledge to advance in the particular direction that I saw myself in - software development management. I did hover find a job managing system engineers and found that to be more rewarding than I hoped. It gave me experience in the two areas that I was lacking it in - hardware and management. It has only served to further my eventual goal of managing software engineers.
My point is whichever path you choose, make sure that in some way it can help your long term goals. It might even not be apparent to you at the time, but managing a career is like anything else. If your path isn't working out for you, reevaluate its effect on your long term goals and change it, if you feel it needs changed.