If you want to force a login, then you probably want to run the entire site over HTTPS, and not HTTP, lest something get cached somewhere and bookmarked by some less than scrupulus network admin.
here are some options:
1. Install a Lotes Notes Server. Security will be much greater than anything Microsoft has ever put out. Can be configured to force login for access and limit what can be done by whom based on simple grouping. You can tie it into your databases and create quick and easy data delivery tools. You can use encryption, or a Notes Client over a secure connection to access the data, if you use the Notes Client, each user would then need to have his ID file on hand, adding to the security of the system.
Alternately usingIIS you can run the whole thing over HTTPS and force a login at the start. You would probably want to code it in XML with a bunch of scripting, or JAVA, either of which can be big bucks. If you use an NT box with IIS, you probably want to create it as a new domain to keep it seperate from the company network, setting up this kind of system is complex to get them to work in concert and you have to maintain 2 access systems.
You may also want to consider VPN software such as Checkpoint's VPN-1, or one of the many others.
good luck
-Mike