I'm just adding to vicrh's correct answer. The verify function works with the create command. It is not an independent function. The following section from the man page for the tar command states that one of the listed functions must be used with any invocation of the tar command. Verify is not on this list. So verify must work with one of these listed functions. It turns out, as I already mentioned, that verify works with the create function.
The man page for the tar command says the following:
FUNCTION LETTERS
One of the following options must be used:
-A, --catenate, --concatenate
append tar files to an archive
-c, --create
create a new archive
-d, --diff, --compare
find differences between archive and file
system
--delete
delete from the archive
(not for use on mag tapes!)
-r, --append
append files to the end of an archive
-t, --list
list the contents of an archive
-u, --update
only append files that are newer than
copy in archive
-x, --extract, --get
extract files from an archive