Discussion Locked

How would a Democrat President. . . . .

0 helpful
49 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.....handle the ?war against terrorism? ? including the war in Iraq, the tensions with Iran, Homeland Security, Middle-East policy, border security, etc.

As a disclaimer, I?m of the firm belief that the ?attacks? directed at President Bush are 99.9% political, and only .1% substance. I?m also a firm believer that ?those in the know? realize the dangerous world in which we live, the real threat Radical Islam (and Iran) poses, the ?state of war? Iran is actually waging against the USA, etc., and ANY Democrat president would do little or nothing different.

Fast forward to January 2009, assume that President Bush?s policies and actions aren?t much different than they are today, assume that the Democrats won the White House and retained control of Congress. What will a Democrat President with a Democrat Congress do in February 2009?

Also as a disclaimer: Anyone who has the gall to suggest that they (Democrats) will maintain the ?wrong? status quo ONLY because it?s a course President Bush has put us on deserves ?the idiot link?. So don?t even go there unless it?s to suggest that the Democrats are the biggest hypocrites and dishonest, disingenuous demagogues to ever live.

So, if President Bush is ?doing it all wrong?, what would the Democrats do that is ?doing it all right?? So far, after listening to all of them for so long, I really don?t have a clue. (Joe Biden, however, does have a specific course he would try to implement; but of course, I have a better chance to being elected President than him.)

49 replies

by absolutely

We'd all be fully underground by now.

"Mission Accomplished" would not be the phrase used, but something similar would have been declared, and it would have been equally untrue.

by jackofalltech

I'm sure not all Democrats are the same but all I see from most of them is a rabid, unreasoning, unsubstantiated hatred for President Bush. I firmly believe that most of them, if given the chance, would reverse ALL of his policies regardless of the consequences to America simply because they are HIS policies.

If I didn't believe that God is in control I would be very afraid of what this country will be like in five years.

Ralph

by Member 25348569

I'm only going to comment on the "War on Terror" for now and, OK, we are starting from the fact that I don't agree with you about the "War on Terror". I believe that even to describe it as a "War" legitimises and glamorises it in a way that it doesn't warrant. As it's been promoted by GWB, it's the best recruitment possible for the terrorists.

What about the Democrats? I would have reckoned that a Democratic administration or even a slightly less gung-ho and more circumspect Republican administration would not have gone into Iraq.

That then questions how much of the tension with Iran is due to your invasion of their next-door-neighbour? Were I an Iranian, I'd be frightened of the US administration's actions and words over the previous five years. I might want to explore the option of nuclear weapons given that the possession of same seems to have benefited North Korea.

As for Iraq now; if you have a Democratic President next time around, I reckon that he (or she) will probably formulate a knee-jerk exit strategy for Iraq based on US political motives rather than Iraqi needs and that will end badly, too.

I don't think you can win this one with either flavour in power and even a draw is pretty unlikely but you might get a better exit strategy for Iraq with a Republican in power if only because guilt keeps the troops there.

If Al Gore - who has now been over here - is an example of your democrats then we're all doomed. What a smug GIT!

I'll have to Google Joe Biden next time it rains.

by liljasper142

The body of democrats have already made clearly known that their intention is to surrender and leave Iraq and elsewhere and bring the troops home before a stable Iraq can be completed thereby emboldening any and all anti-America factions to do whatever and wherever they want. Bad idea for those who still love a sovereign and constitutional America.

by jdclyde

They will "retreat", not "surrender".

They will then TRY to blame Bush for the following blood bath as genocide sweeps Iraq as they stand there and do nothing like the worms they are.

Their Bushphobia is going to really hurt US badly.

by support gal

I think you meant to say January 2009, not 2008. The election isn't until November 2008.

I get a little annoyed today when I hear that so many people are now not backing the president or the war. We had a chance as a nation to say we felt the war was wrong in 2004. Bush took his victory as evidence the nation was OK with what he was doing. While I didn't vote for him, that's how I took it as well. We know nothing now we didn't know in 2004. He said it would take a long time and we would have to sacrifice. Well he was right.

It sounds like you already believe that the current surge will not make a difference and in 2009 we will be in same boat we are in now. I'm in hopes that we will finally get Saudia Arabia, Egypt, Jordan and some other allies in the region to help use broker deals and help Iraq govern. But the opposite could happen and we could be in a full out world war by then. Predicting the future is tough stuff.

Back to the question, I don't think all Democrats would do the same thing just as I don't think all Republicans would do the same thing. For example, I don't think John McCain, had he been elected in 2000, would have gone to Iraq. Now that we are there I think he will have different reactions, if he is elected, than say Giuliani or Romney might.

I don't know who I'm going to vote for at this point. There are some that I trust and some that I don't and I've changed my mind about a few. While I want to vote democrat depending on who each party offers, I may vote republican. November 2008 is a long way away. Hopefully we will be in much better shape by then.

by danlm

He will pull us from Iraq in 3 months no matter what the consequences. He also won't do squat if there is another attack on the homeland. Edwards will do the same thing. Neither of them have a clue. As far as that goes, those two twits will pull us from Afghanistan. They have no balls, none whats so ever.

Clinton will most likely pull us from Iraq, but in a phased fashion. She will not change any of the War On Terror strategy. Including the NSA policies.

Dan

by Former member

It used to be that Democrats pushed social programs to address problems in this country and Republicans pushed war to hide those issues. That changed with President Clinton who had his Bosnian war and who fired one Tomahawk missile for each day he was in office and disarmed the county by not replacing those missiles and other weapons used.

Regarding President Clinton, Bill held the title but Bill and Hillary were the team. If Hillary were reelected (very possible due to the female vote) we would see something similar to the Clinton legacy.

With the Republicans, I see no change in the status quo. Lip service only.

The Clinton legacy started the country down the road where the disaffected and disenfranchised began losing the few rights they had. The Bush legacy found a plausible (at the time) reason to further this course of action. In support of this, I only point out the Patriot Act; there are other actions if you look.

The question I pose to you is: Does the vote matter, especially in light of electronic voting with no standard of accountability? Do parties mean anything? And, should we not look at Thomas Jefferson and his radical views regarding how often a country needs to overthrow its government?

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"Does the vote matter, especially in light of electronic voting with no standard of accountability?"[/i]

Yes, the vote does matter. If ~300 people in Florida had voted a different way in 2000, Al Gore would have been elected president, and we wouldn't have had to put up with the recent media orgasm over his movie, [i]An Inconvenient Truth[/i], and we wouldn't have to be putting up with the current stupid and insane Concerts for the Climate (or whatever stupid "cause" they're doing nothing about). Moreover, without those ~300 votes, the Democrats would have had nothing over which to start their hate-affair with GWB.

You asked, [i]"Do parties mean anything?"[/i]

Parties mean EVERYTHING. People who vote "person over party" overlook a very significant reality -- the party with control of Congress has the upper-hand; it chairs all the committees; it sets the agenda; it presents bills for consideration; it confirms presidential nominations; it can initiate investigations (regardless of the merit or lack thereof); and on it goes.

You asked, [i]"And, should we not look at Thomas Jefferson and his radical views regarding how often a country needs to overthrow its government?"[/i]

I certainly wouldn't call those views radical, especially when put in the context of Jefferson's time. Moreover, his sentiment is right-on. When a government, for example, can act as a power broker to take money (by force and coercion) from one citizen -- literally take the fruits of a person's labor (which is slavery, at worst, indentured servitude, at best) -- for the sole purpose of giving that money to another citizen who did not earn it, especially when the transfer is tantamount to the payment of a bribe -- money in exchange for a vote -- then it's time to take Mr. Jefferson's sentiment to heart. To paraphrase Yogi Berra, Mr. Jefferson would be rolling in his grave if he were alive today to see the massive infringements on individual liberty ? especially when it?s done in the name of freedom and democracy!

The time to take back individual liberty is long overdue. However, I believe it can be done peacefully and without shots being fired, and within the framework of our system ? something Mr. Jefferson would probably be astonished to see, since it means his ?experiment? is still breeding success after more than two hundred years. On one hand, Mr. Jefferson would be appalled to see what's come of his (and others') creation; on the other hand, however, he would be quite pleased to see it still alive and well.

by Former member

You:
"If ~300 people in Florida had voted a different way in 2000..."
Me:
Which way did they really vote? This event happened in the state that Bushes were in control. Jeb Bush, Governor, to be exact. In light of the events surrounding the Diebold voting machines, what might happen in the future? Would the election also go to the person most politically favored or monied? There is no accountability, not in voting machines, nor politics.

You:
"Parties mean EVERYTHING. People who vote "person over party" overlook a very significant reality -- the party with control of Congress has the upper-hand; it chairs all the committees; it sets the agenda; it presents bills for consideration; it confirms presidential nominations; it can initiate investigations (regardless of the merit or lack thereof); and on it goes."

Me:
Veto power. It takes a long time to gather the support to override a veto in most cases.

You:
"I certainly wouldn't call those views radical, especially when put in the context of Jefferson's time."

Me:
Jefferson was a product of the French revolution. His idea's were radical then, and they are far more radical today in a country of 'sheeple'.

You are correct that the time is past to take back our liberties. Without shots - maybe; information is a powerful concept properly applied or withheld...

Norman

by support gal

I may be wrong but I think TJ's comments about over throwing the government on a regular basis was referring to our ability to change power in congress every two years. Like Maxwell said, the majority party controls everything. We just overthrew the government in November 2006. Wish we had had done it two years earlier.

by Former member

Jefferson mentioned "Every twenty years." This is far outside the two years you mentioned for congress and the six years you failed to mention for the Senate.

by support gal

While a Senator's term is six years, They don't all run at the same time, like the House of Representatives. Every two years 1/3 of the Senate seats in the country are in play, so the entire congress is really up for grabs every two years. Even if TJ said we should overthrow the government every 20 years, instead of 2, I think he meant our ability to overthrow the government through the electoral process and we have that ability every two years. I often call friends on election day and remind them our our constitution gives us the right to overthrow our government and if they want to take advantage of that, today is the day.

Oh, and as much as I admire TJ's document, as far as how he would feel about our loss of liberty, remember, he was a slave owner. So if you are a very rich, educated white guy he might be concerned and roll in his grave a little. Otherwise, I don't think he would care.

by Former member

"Oh, and as much as I admire TJ's document, as far as how he would feel about our loss of liberty, remember, he was a slave owner."

Yes, so was George Washington and most of the members of our early government. In light of the time, this is irrelevant.

by danlm

Everyone wants to forget the history when it doesn't suit their argument. I'm sorry, but no it's not. It shows a contradiction by our founding fathers that doesn't place them in the golden light that you so cherish.

People need to get a grip. Our founding fathers weren't perfect. If they believed so much in freedom, they wouldn't have had slaves. The only thing they cared about was themselves and the freedoms they wanted. You don't think they knew that what they were doing was against everything they were trying to achieve. Now you do them injustice. Your also stupid to think that.

I'm sick of people glossing over what they don't want to deal with when it comes to the founding fathers and their history.

Our founding fathers were as back stabbing as any polition you have today. John Adams did the mid night raid with supreme court justices when congress was in recess. And Jefferson did everything in his power to get rid of them.

What a crock of sh*t, I'm sick of you people only pulling from history what suits your argument. Go for it, I can find historical documents you so choose to ignore anytime I want to prove that our founding fathers went against more then one principle that you so cherish and wave in my fkn face.

Dan

by maxwell edison

You?ve been misquoting and/or misapplying Thomas Jefferson?s sentiments over the course of several messages, so the time has come for me to ask all of you to put such quotes and sentiments in their full and total context.

It started when [i]normhaga@...[/i] asked, [i] should we not look at Thomas Jefferson and his radical views regarding how often a country needs to overthrow its government?[/i] And he went on to suggest that [i]Jefferson was a product of the French revolution.[/i] I?d like both those comments qualified. If anything, the French Revolution was a product of ?Jefferson?s radical ideas?, not the other way around. After all, Jefferson was well into his political life at the start of the French Revolution, and was actually acting as the United States? first Secretary of State (in the Washington Administration) upon its start.

[/i]patvickers@...[/i] went on to say that Jefferson suggested [i] over-throwing the government on a regular basis [/i] (by way of regular elections). When and where did Jefferson say that? And in what context?

[i]normhaga@...[/i] went on to suggest that Jefferson advocated [i]a revolution (or an over-throw) of government every twenty years[/i]. He did? When and where did he say that, and how were his comments intended?

How about FULL AND TOTAL context for the things you guys claim Jefferson said? I anxiously await your history lesson. .

(And I won?t even mention the misleading [i]Jefferson was a slave owner[/i] comment. We could write books debating the nuances of that issue.)

by support gal

Just found this on Wikipedia.
Thomas Jefferson:
Views on political violence

Concerning the Shays Rebellion after he had heard of the bloodshed, Jefferson wrote to William Smith, John Adams's son-in-law, "What signify a few lives lost in a generation or two? The tree of liberty must from time to time be refreshed with the blood of patriots and tyrants. It is its natural manure." Several anti-government groups have pointed to these words of his to justify their movement. Timothy McVeigh, the Oklahoma City bomber, was wearing a T-shirt when arrested bearing the words, "The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants."

Give me a few minutes and I'll change it to show that I was right.

by Former member

Every generation needs a new revolution.
Thomas Jefferson
http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/authors/t/thomas_jefferson.html

Many others are here as well.

Maxwell, I never said Jefferson was French. If you choose to read your history, as any politically responsible person should, you will find that Jefferson was a United States Government minister (ambassador) during the French Revolution, that he was deeply supportive of the French Revolution, and that besides his personal views in support that he was in France as repayment of Lafayette's support of the American Revolution. Therefore, 'MY conclusion' that he was a product of the French Revolution.

You can Google if you wish.

"Jefferson became an ardent supporter of the French Revolution, even allowing his residence to be used as a meeting place for the rebels led by Lafayette."
http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/jefferson/jeffworld.html

by maxwell edison

I never suggested that you said Jefferson was French. Go back and try to comprehend the exchange, and perhaps you'll understand.

However, in my opinion, your "conclusion" that he was a "product of the French Revolution" makes absolutely no sense for the reasons I stated.

And your snide comment: [i]"If you choose to read your history, as any politically responsible person should...[/i]", is equally nonsensical. You obviously have no idea how much I may or may not "read my history", so any such suggestive comment reflects on YOUR ignorance, not mine.

As far as your "brainy quote" source, it's not good enough for me. Find a reliable source for your claimed quote -- one that puts it in full and total context.

by Former member

You issued a challenge. I met it. In between times, I checked your previous discussions. You a an idiot. Therefore, I am done with you!

by maxwell edison

Brainy Quotes" is not a reliable source, and it's not one that puts a quote in full and total context. I asked for full and total context -- that was my challenge. You failed to meet it. If you're that much of a push-over, I'll leave it to the readers to decide who may or may not be the real idiot. Now go run off with your tail tucked between your legs.

by ontheropes

...yet you can't understand a post as clear as normhaga's above. Too funny. :^0 :^0

I know, I know... I'm an idiot. Give me the link. Whoopee. :^0

I wonder who gave the link to you first. :^0

Don't you hate when the chickens come home to roost? :^0

Sleep well.

by maxwell edison

We don't have "Congress" and "the Senate".

"Congress" is the total legislative body -- both the House AND the Senate.

House elections are every two years. A Senate seats is decided for six.

by maxwell edison

Do an Internet search with the keywords [i]56 signers declaration of independence[/i] and then tell us what you really think.

by absolutely

And?

That doesn't change what is good -- not "who", "what".

Imperfect heroes are better than none.

by danlm

Tell the rest of these jack offs that only quote one founding father the same thing.

Dan

by danlm

I do not deny all of the good that our founding fathers did. I do not deny their genesis in what they gave us.

But for individuals to:
1). Forget about the rest of the founding fathers and only quote one.
2). Ignore history that shows that they are not perfect, even when it contradicts what they are quoting.

Piss's me off.

What our founding father gave us is great. What they did was great. No denying it.
All I hear from these dick weeds is Thomas Jefferson. No man makes a nation, and Thomas Jefferson wasn't the only founding father. Ff the dick weeds that think he should have been. His presidency was mediocre, he lost the first presidential election and it took three votes of the senate for him to win the second election because the American public didn't have as high as an opinion as dick weed above did. The man was great, but he had failings.

I prefer Alexander Hamilton as an example of a founding father. Him and Jefferson could not stand each other. Hamilton also showed a much better understanding and ability to run a government then Jefferson ever did.

God, I hate Wikipedia. But this shows that even his opponents realized his wisdom and turned back Jefferson's policies.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Hamilton

[i]Hamilton's nationalist and industrializing vision was rejected in the Jeffersonian "Revolution of 1800" as too elitist and hostile to states' rights. However, after the War of 1812 showed the need for strong national institutions, his former opponents -- including Madison and Albert Gallatin -- came to emulate his programs as they too set up a national bank, tariffs, a national infrastructure, and a standing army and navy. [/i]

Dan

by Former member

Dan, to present a better context than I think you may have examined. All peoples today have been exposed to slavery, meaning been in or their ancestors have been slaves. The names of the indentured servitude change with the times, but slavery is slavery no matter the name.

At the risk of starting another heated debate, I will suggest that today you are a slave without knowing it. To better qualify this bold statement; you spend the first four months of your working year to pay a tithing to the government. Should you fail to pay your taxes the government can exercise, at its discretion, the option of corporeal force to take what it views as its goods. This is my belief of what slavery is. I could let this go further into economic slavery. I just choose to leave the thought her for now.

I agree with you totally that we each take from history that which most closely fits our belief paradigm and I am more than happy to discuss this with you or anyone else in a reasonable fashion. I try never to be closed to new ideas or thoughts.

Regarding this paragraph:
"What a crock of sh*t, I'm sick of you people only pulling from history what suits your argument. Go for it, I can find historical documents you so choose to ignore anytime I want to prove that our founding fathers went against more then one principle that you so cherish and wave in my fkn face."

I hear this from radical Jews all the time in regard to Hitler; they have forgotten about the Pol.'s and the Russians. They have only interpreted the facts in the light that gives them the greatest propaganda leverage. Before you start, I do not support Hitlers attempt at genocide but I at least have looked at the whys. This is only one example. My conclusions will not always be supported by the official version of history, however they are based upon my interpretation of history as what I have read.

If I am wrong, or if you can sway me, then I will openly admit that I am wrong. And yes, early politics were dirty even by todays standards.

But at this point I stand by the statement that slavery is irrelevant.

by absolutely

So, do you feel strongly about this?

:^0

I think Jefferson & Hamilton both had their points. Some of the wisdom of Jefferson's ideas tend to require more time to be fully evident, but I think careful economic analysis of well-known topics in current events reveal that some of Hamilton's innovations that you copied from Wikipedia are flawed. I'd be most interested in discussing the merits of those ideas that make the country better for its people. If necessary, I'll stipulate that they're all dick weeds across the board, in return for dispensing with ongoing [i]argumentum ad hominem[/i], which is always a waste of time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Hamilton

[i]Hamilton's nationalist and industrializing vision was rejected in the Jeffersonian "Revolution of 1800" as too elitist and hostile to states' rights. However, after the War of 1812 showed the need for strong national institutions, his former opponents -- including Madison and Albert Gallatin -- came to emulate his programs as they too set up a national bank, [b]tariffs[/b], a national infrastructure, and a standing army and navy.[/i]

Tariffs, for example, have become a favorite tool of candidates for office. If these were not on a sliding scale, there would be greater stability in what is required of American workers in our efforts to compete with foreign laborers.

by maxwell edison

I agree about the forced ?economic? slavery, a sentiment I?ve expressed quite a few times in these discussions. One citizen is literally being FORCED to work to SERVE the needs of another. Start with that definition, and what is the word? Slavery or indentured servitude ? anything but freedom and liberty.

I also agree that any issue of slavery in the United States is pretty irrelevant today. (Although there are those who continue to milk it for all it?s worth.) Unlike normhaga@..., however, I will debate the issue, should anyone want to. (Not to suggest he couldn?t, mind you, because I?m sure he could, but rather chooses not to.) Moreover, any discussion of slavery in the nation?s early days must also consider all consequences. Both Washington and Jefferson, for example, might seem hypocritical in that they both owned slaves, but yet opposed its practice. But there?s always a ?rest of the story? to consider.

What if, for example, Jefferson acted on his principle (at least as publicly stated) and freed all his slaves? What would have become of them? But since he didn?t, what did become of them? From what I understand, Jefferson?s slaves were not ill-treated, as so many were, and they actually had a pretty good life, comparatively speaking, at Jefferson?s estate where they pretty much attended to their own needs, grew their own food, and raised their families. They weren?t bought and sold and beaten into submission, but rather left in a relatively safe environment to live their lives, instead of being sent out to fend for themselves in late 18th century Virginia. Jefferson loathed slavery, as he wrote many times. And it was Jefferson who led the effort to ban the importation of new slaves. And Washington, as a condition of his will, freed his slaves upon the death of his wife, even giving some of them a pension.

Most important to consider, however, is this. While it may have proved difficult and/or impossible in their present, both men assisted in many ways to lay the foundation for a future America free of slavery. If such people would have taken a firm stance against slavery, at that particular time in history and under those particular circumstances, it?s quite possible the U.S. Constitution would have never been ratified by all original 13 states ? in fact, it?s a guarantee it wouldn?t have been. As such, setting the stage for the future was vastly more important than being politically rigid on an issue.

You, Dan, might be offended in how these founders are placed on a pedestal; but I, on the other hand, am absolutely disgusted in the way they?ve been unjustly trashed.

by danlm

Is not trashing them. If you want to consider our founding fathers being trashed in your words, then the fact that people do not look at all the facts about them and only what they want is your trashing.

I would rather understand as much as possible about a person to make a decision then only the good things. Only knowing the punch lines that everyone spouts is a trashing as far as I'm concerned. And it shows total disrespect for who the person really was. Knowing that these individuals made decisions for our country that sometimes went against their beliefs because they thought it was for the best gives me a whole hell of a lot more respect then someones punch line that they always spout. Also knowing that these individuals had failings and still achieved great things for this nation again makes me have more respect for them.

I am not a great fan of Thomas Jefferson, I will admit it. I think the man was all about idealism but found that it did not always work in the real world. His inspiration to others was his greatness, but his leadership as president and the policies that he put forth were not. And I think that the American public felt the same way during his time, which explains why he had such a hard time becoming president. And you will also find that other founding fathers did not agree with everything the man said. But, again your punch liners will never bring that subject up.

By ignoring that the founding fathers had different visions and different ideas of what the constitution meant again shows a lack of respect, and again is trashing who they really were.

Dan

by maxwell edison

Based on a very short and very limited message of mine, you certainly presume to conclude a lot. Too bad you chose to address what I didn't say instead of what I did.

I didn't say a lot of things. Why not challenge those as well?

by danlm

Max, your words of being tired of our founding fathers being trashed is what I responded to. Your right, I assumed you was talking about my belief that the complete understanding of these individuals is needed, both good and bad, was what you was talking about.

I won't apologise, because I'm not sorry. I feel my response, even if it was incorrectly directed at you was appropriate for the thread.

Dan

by danlm

[i]Tariffs, for example, have become a favorite tool of candidates for office. If these were not on a sliding scale, there would be greater stability in what is required of American workers in our efforts to compete with foreign laborers.[/i]

Where as others that I have seen here on TR take offense when their favorite founding father is questioned. I don't, and I won't. The specific policy you are commenting on was not perfect, but the federal government does require funds for day to day operations and Alexander Hamilton recognized that and so did other founding fathers. It's the real world, governments need money to operate or there is no government. Idealism is great on paper and in speech's. But to make it work, you need funds.

Dan

by maxwell edison

We erect monuments to people who give stirring speeches and appeal to the masses. And although Jefferson was not known as a great orator, he spoke with his pen.

There are no such monuments to Alexander Hamilton, however, except for the very system that powers our current free market society. When it came to the real nuts and bolts of making a great America work, no one deserves more credit than Alexander Hamilton. (Too bad he was so damn hung-up on "his honor" and let Aaron Burr shot him!)

Disclaimer: Alexander Hamilton was a great writer in his own right, and was one of the anonymous authors (along with James Madison and John Jay) who penned the Federalist Papers. Thomas Jefferson, himself, called the Federalist Papers the greatest commentary on the principles of government ever written.

A great documentary on Hamilton could be found on PBS Videos. It would be worth anyone's while to watch it.

by av .

If we have a Democratic President next time and they retained control of Congress, a bad situation will only get worse. There is nothing that they will do right.

What if John Edwards was our next President. He's the candidate that thinks the "war on terror" is just a bumper sticker slogan. If Hillary gets in, we will set a timetable and pull the troops out of Iraq leaving it in chaos and ensuring that Al-Qaida can have their base of operations.

No matter what Democrat gets in, we can count on giving amnesty to 12-20 million illegal aliens that will permanently overload all of our social programs, so they'll have to raise taxes. Spanish will become a second language in the US and we'll all have to learn it to accommodate them.

Obama will raise taxes so we can all have universal healthcare coverage. We can all look forward to higher taxes if he wins too.

We're going to start trusting Iran because Nancy Pelosi had tea with Ahmadinejad and he said his country is just pursuing nuclear energy for peaceful means. She believes it.

Joe Biden does have a plan for Iraq, but dividing the country doesn't sit well with most. He doesn't have much support even though I think Iraq could eventually end up that way.

I'm not endorsing GWB either as he is the one that sank this country into the Iraq quagmire by not planning for the aftermath of Saddam's fall. He isn't running anyway.

There is no way I would ever support a Democratic president to take over the mess we are in. If anyone thinks we can just pack up and come home from the war in Iraq, they are mistaken. Even if Iraq and the war on terror were not linked initially, they are now. Its no bumper sticker. If we leave Iraq in chaos, their fragile government will collapse and there will be a worse threat than Saddam that takes hold. Their first stop will be America.

I'm not satisfied with either party at this point, but I think a Republican President can do a much better job than a Democratic one.

AV

by av .

Is Fred Thompson the Ronald Reagan of our time? Maybe. Can he save America? We need saving at this point. I'm not sure if he's the real deal or just an actor. Do you think he is the GOP's rock star like Obama? Or, does he look that way because he's undeclared and no one really knows where he stands on the issues?

AV

by Former member

"Tariffs, for example, have become a favorite tool of candidates for office. If these were not on a sliding scale, there would be greater stability in what is required of American workers in our efforts to compete with foreign laborers."

Tarrifs may be the problem; I am of a mixed mind. More than tarrifs I see globilization as the problem. Industry attempts to maximize profit and minimize costs to themselves and to the consumer. One of the simplest methods to do this is to minimize the cost of goods produced. This means seeking to produce in the countries that have the lowest cost of wages. The outsourcing that results from this has the beneficial effect of reducing the cost of goods bought but has the undesirable effect of reducing employment.

When you place tarrifs on an equal level with other countries, the country that now has its cost of goods sold raised runs to the U.N. and to the world court thereby forcing those measures to go away. This was most recently evidenced with the American steel industry. (Yes, I am choosing only one small example when there are many causes.)

In this regard, I tend to be elitist and say to hell with the other countries; that we should tend to our own people first.

Another example is NAFTA. Is it good or bad. It really depends on who you ask. I worked for one company, Autoliv, who outsourced part of their operations to Mexico. TO this day there are problems in meeting production deadlines because of the difficulty properly producing the needed product in Mexico and getting to the company who does J.I.T supply. Autoliv thinks it is the best thing since fried icecream, the displaced workers think it is terrible. Of course there is also the point that it brings much needed income to a third world country (please leave the illegal immigration alone) and thereby raises its standard of living.

This is one of the best examples of the Hamilton / Jefferson dichotomies I can think of.

If you wish to go on, where should we start: the Carriage Tax case (Edward Paine), the Slaughter House cases (industry), I think the Madison case (the right of the federal government to print money and prohibit the states from the same). If this were to go on, it would also be best in its own thread.

by danlm

I've read various web sites on the founding fathers, but I have not as yet read book biography's on them. I would like to read some complete biographies about Jefferson, Hamilton, Adams, Madison, Franklin, and Washington. I know there were other founding fathers, but those are the biographies I want to read most.

They were such a mixture of idea's and temperament that came together to give us what we have today. Id rather buy these books then go to the library, there are certain things that are just worth keeping.

The PBS series I will look for Max, thanks.

Dan

by maxwell edison

He's got a long track record (at least long enough) for people to know where he stands "on the issues". During his 8 years in the Senate he was certainly a player. And he cut his political teeth on the same table as Hillary, on the Watergate Committee as a minority council. The difference is, Hillary went on to become wrapped-up in her own "corruption" (real or perceived), while Thompson has seemed to maintain a high-ground.

I think Thompson will announce this month, maybe in August. I think he'll run a great campaign, people will get to know him, and he'll win the Republican nomination. And being Hillary's toughest opponent, he'll go on to beat her in November 08.

But no, I don't consider him the "GOP's Rock Star", opposite the Democrat's Obama. Thompson's got substance.

by jackofalltech

Even if all those 'lost' votes had been counted and Democratic, they STILL would have lost. Didn't anyone besides me see the actual numbers or are you intentionally forgetting them?

Ralph

by maxwell edison

There will be no pullout of Iraq, regardless of who wins the White House in 2008, Democrat or Republican. U.S. troops will remain a formidable force in Iraq until the Iraqis are fully capable of defending themselves against their hostile neighbors and terrorist factions within their own borders ? regardless of how long it might take. Even then, the U.S. will maintain a very strong presence. We will not turn our backs on the Iraqis.

All of the anti-Bush and anti-Iraq war rants are all political. And the Democrat?s ranting the loudest all know it. The Democrats, however, should one of them win the White House, will absolutely destroy their own (his/her own) credibility as a result. This goes likewise for the Democrats in Congress who will, with a small fringe exception, go along with the war. And the war against radical Islam will continue. In fact, I believe it will actually escalate, but perhaps in ways unnoticed by the general public.

I wonder what all the Democrats out there will think if one of their candidates wins, but continues the very policy he/she continually campaigned against. Just like President Bush said quite a few years ago, the war that was started on his watch will continue through future administrations. And they all know it to be true. The Democrats have done a grave disservice to all involved for not publicly stating what they know privately, and especially for publicly saying just the opposite, all for political expediency.

I almost hope a Democrat DOES win the White House in 2008 just so I can be proven right. (Mark this message for future reference.)

by absolutely

"All of the anti-Bush and anti-Iraq war rants are all political. And the Democrat?s ranting the loudest all know it. The Democrats, however, should one of them win the White House, will absolutely destroy their own (his/her own) credibility as a result."

It's still more important to elect somebody who knows his/her ass from elbow than to destroy the credibility of somebody who doesn't.

by absolutely

But, obviously, you'll use it when you find an article that conforms to your own bias.

[i]God, I hate Wikipedia. But this shows that even his opponents realized his wisdom and turned back Jefferson's policies.[/i]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Hamilton

[i]Hamilton's nationalist and industrializing vision was rejected in the Jeffersonian "Revolution of 1800" as too elitist and hostile to states' rights. However, [b]after the War of 1812 showed the need for[/b] strong national institutions, his former opponents -- including Madison and Albert Gallatin -- came to emulate his programs as they too set up a national bank, tariffs, a national infrastructure, and a standing army and navy.[/i]

War should be an exception, and not the basis for the structure of our government. We should be prepared for it, but not preoccupied with it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.