Discussion Locked

How would you write a Letter of Recommendation - Tech Challenged Employee

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Recently I've let one of my helpdesk people go. He is very easy going, punctual and works well with people. He tries to do the right thing and is a team player. Unfortunately after two years working and training him, he is just technically challenged. We had an honest relationship and I've tried to steer him away from technology.

He asked me to write him a letter of recommendation for another tech job he is applying to. I'm not sure how to write one without misleading the reader or writing one about poor performance. How would you write one? Are there templates I can follow?

28 replies

by maevinn

A letter of recommendation is suppose to be honest. If you can't honestly tell someone this guy is the right candidate, why try? You'll end up lying, or saying nothing in 500 words. Give the guy a call, and say 'You know, I think you have a lot of potential, but based on your experience here, I can't recommend you for this position.'

by trtjj

That's true but ....When I let him go.. I told him that if he needed help with anything to give me a call. I know it's a mistake but it's the first time I had to let someone go.

by maevinn

Help the kid. Tell him bluntly that you want to help him succeed but that you can't honestly recommend him for an IT position. If he's looking for something in another career field, you will happily write up something talking about his positive points.

Or, talk with him and explain that you will write a letter the emphasizes his positives without mentioning the negatives, and explain that this means you won't be able to say anything positive about his (lack) of tech skill.

by lost_in_ny

I thinkt hat you can ethically provide a letter of recommendation as long as you limit it to only his strong points - if he's patient, respectful, attentive to end-users and gets along well with colleagues, hard-working, etc. then speak to those points as well as any others strengths he has. Clearly it is not appropriate to lie about his abilities. And, as a hiring manager yourself, you certainly wouldn't appreciate being told someone is strong in a particular area you can't tech him out for (like keeping commitments, respecting colleagues and customers, etc.) and then finding out one you've hired him that he's anything but.

One other caution - if you're contacted by phone, then you can try to emphasize the guy's good points, but if you're asked a point-blank question about his technical skill level, answer it truthfully - you can try to soften your answer, but keep it honest (you can say 'he's always eager to learn new skills and applies himself to learning' but you cannot say he's an excellent troubleshooter or expert in Active Directory or whatever, unless that is also true).

by bigbigboss

Don't write the letter, but give him your phone number so that he can give as reference. I don't read those recommendation letters and prefer to call and ask my own questions. This is less onerous on you, and the potential employer gets better information. And in the conversation, you can tell the potential employer what you feel are his strength and weakness, and won't get yourself in trouble.

by jaqui

Here all we can tell someone in a reference call is yes or no.
yes we would hire them again for the job, or no we would not.

not one bit more information is legally given over the phone.

in a letter you can positively comment on the good points.
the telling part of a letter would be no comments about tech skill for this situation.
the letter would be honest.
the areas with no comments would indictate clearly that there is nothing positive to say in those areas.

by trtjj

Well, I wrote the letter. The letter sounds like a positive character reference. I wrote a lot of good things but there isn't anything there about his technical skills.

by jaqui

gives him a positive reference, yet doesn't hide his lack from anyone reading it who looks for what's not said.
[ as most hiring managers will ]

It is a bit more work, in the short term, to write a letter of reference, but long term, it actually save you time, since you won't be feilding phone calls for references for the person(s) with letters.

by jmccardl29

I worked for a major govt research Lab and I sat on many interview panels. I was amazed at what some others on the panel thought was excellent and what was poor. One lot thought someone who could identify a 37 pin canon socket was great and another expected the applicant to know the type of ics used in say the keyboard controller or the maths chip (80287) (shows my age!). Also when you have a great team it can make it hard to pick someone else to climb on board. Granted you do need someone who listens and has good interpersonal skills and who is not frightened to admit the problem is curley and request help from another in the IT support team. Servicing and fault diagnostics often need heaps of experience and a logical method of approach.
Life is tough!

by r_chabie

Good. It seems you've got a job for him then!

Often a person has the potential and that's why s/he was hired in the first place.

However, he is left at his desk for probably a couple of months and learns nothing because the manager/senior staff are too busy killing fires.

After a while somebody remembers that they actually employed someone to make the workload easier, but the "not so new" resource is still not able to help. Who should be blamed?

Also, most technical people are not good at teaching others (I'm painting with the broad brush, I know). Some decide to fix the small problem themselves, mumble a couple of words and expect that next time the person should know how. Who's to blame?

Some of us (like myself) were fortunate to get a good mentor and are able to succeed in this difficult field. Some may be very smart and don't need it as much as others.

I think the technology world should focus more on identifying good mentors and mentoring programmes, and we won't have this common problem creeping up all the time.

by tor24

R_Chabie has brought up some excellent points that should be started as a totally new thread which would be beneficial to technicial staff who find themselves in the role of mentor or manager.

I personally would write the letter. However in this particular case, I would ask the individual to list some points that they would like to be considered for inclusion in the letter. It would give you insight to their self-evaluation and maybe their goals.

Monster.com has some great tips on how to write a LoR.

http://resume.monster.com/articles/recommendation/

by bajanpoet

Sounds familiar...

I'm currently in a situation where I've been "left at my desk" for months... I've been given stuff to do, but when I have questions my manager is nowhere to be found - he usu isn't even in the building... he's off "fighting fires" elsewhere in the organization...

Makes me wonder if I should look for another job....

by ram1951

In such cases I write "He believes that maintaining relations with users is even more important in undertsanding the nuances of technology and to that extent he has been successful"

Seasoned managers would understand what you want to say

by ckl_13

If you feel you would like to help this person get another job, then take the time to find out what he is looking for and what the job involves... Some IT departments are large enough to accomodate a liaison type individual who can effectively deal with the non-geek worker bees and translate their problems to the fully technical mr/mrs/ms Fix-its... Its a big world and there is room for everyone. People skills and work ethic is something that is more valuable than people realize and other skills can be taught....ckl

by juliechurchwell

(very easy going, punctual and works well with people. He tries to do the right thing and is a team player) Sounds like a good place to start.

The truth is the kindest thing even if it costs him the job he "thinks" he wants. No one is happy in a job that he has no aptitude for. Being rejected after trying ones hardest can be devastating. If you are not perfectly honest with him you may do harm to his future by allowing him to waste the most valuable thing he has, which is time. Give him an honest evaluation in parting, along with an appropriate letter. Encourage him to seek help from a career counselor who can help him build on his strengths. He is obviously trying to leverage the 2 years of experience he got with you into another job. He almost has to apply within the same field or he won't look good on a resume. Unless you make it very clear that he has failed he may not begin the work he must do to find a new career.

by woody goode

This is a basic test of your soft skills-- how to give a truthful answer without offending someone. The problem is no different than (a) hypersensitive bosses who asks for your opinion of their harebrained plan or (b) co-workers who ask if you think they're qualified for a promotion that they can't handle. (Or, for that matter, your wife or girlfriend who asks if she looks fat in this dress.)

The solution in each case is the same-- accentuate the positive and let the other person pick up on what you're not saying. (Or not pick up, if they're clueless.)

In this case, you write a recommendation that talks about his strengths-- punctual, hardworking, very well liked by co-workers and users, great team player, eager for new challenges.

That should be good for 3-4 enthusiastic paragraphs. And a smart person will know why you didn't praise his technical skills.

Do not say a word about where he falls short. First, unless you know what the position requires, you have no basis for assuming he isn't competent. If the job consists mostly of saying "Reboot" and "I'll reset your password", you're actually making a false statement.

Second, don't presume that the hiring manager has the same priorities you do. They might be full up on knowledgeable twirps, and desperate for someone who can be polite-- even if they have to spoon-feed him the answers while the user is on hold.

Third, even if he isn't right for this job, the employer might have other jobs he is right for. For example, they might also need trainers or account managers and shift him in mid-interview. (This does happen.)

Don't lie-- include your phone number so you can be called and answer blunt questions about his ability honestly. Although, even then, you should say something like "we require people who are really gifted in technology and that's not what he does well."

If you feel a person can't be a good employee in any circumstances, then don't volunteer to write a recommendation.

In order to move up the ladder, you'll need the ability to discuss a person or an idea in a positive way without lying or hurting feelings. Use this situation as a way to develop those skills

by ristau5741

Have him write it, all you have to do is agree and sign.

I've written several of my own reference letters, at management's request, gave to them for signing, I still use them today, in fact just yesterday.

by dr_zinj

First of all make sure that the employee understands exactly why you let him go. One of the best management consultants in New Hampshire recommends that (in short) the decision to leave should always be made by the employee by showing him or her that they can achieve their goals and will be happier working elsewhere. That often translates as informing them that they don't get the bonuses, merit raises, good assignments, best work hours because they haven't earned them. However, a lot of people really have NO goals and are just working there on momentum alone. Such an approach won't work with them.

Go ahead and write the letter. Emphasize the person's strong points. Even suggest positions that you know he or she should be good in (I assume you don't have any of those positions or you'd have transferred the person to one.) Provide contact information so the new employer can contact you. When and if asked about technical expertise, be honest about it. I personally like a Likert scale of evaluation: Outstanding, Excellent/Above Average, Satisfactory/Average, Unsatisfactory/Below Average, and Marginal/Cut-to-the-Chase-the-person-sucks-and-never-will-be-any-better.

by 01smmartin

You must be honest with what you write in the reference letter. They typically contain the former employee's strengths, I would shy away from placing any negative responses. If you do not think that you can write a positive letter that will help the former employee, you should not write on in the first place. If you cannot honestly write a positive letter you should explain the former employee that you could write a letter for them but that they would benefit from another writing it. I would not ask them to write it as it is your letter, referring them.

by rjones

If you pump him up the next employer can sue you if you misinformed them. If you state an adverse opinion he can sue you. Best to simply state the time he was employed and his duties.

by hschoenman

I've worked for three very large companies, the last two (30 years) as a manager. In both cases we (the managers) were "trained" by HR on a number of occasions to give out only name, dates of employment and ending salary (the corporate equivalent of the military's "name, rank and serial number") and for anything else to refer them to the HR dept. Under no circumstances write and sign a letter.

You can help the guy but not by writing a letter or verbally recommending him. Help him by telling him to find his true calling in a different field.

by hollandm

You wanted him gone, and he's gone. And you want to write a truthful letter of recommendation to help him get a new job. Great! Be truthful, but not revealing.

Simply say, "John Doe was a punctual, easy-going employee, who worked at XYZ company from date to date as a technical support representative. During his time here, he took only X sick days, and worked well with his co-workers." Short and simple. Say the good stuff, leave out the bad, and quit writing.

If they call you for a specific reference, and ask about his technical competence, you can answer truthfully if you want -- or just refer them to HR if you work at a big company.

Another way to help the guy if you want to help him (without lying to a colleague) is to say: "Sorry, but I can only confirm dates of employment." If they push, go ahead and say, "I already told you, I can't comment on his technical knowledge or ability, just confirm dates of employment."

This way, you don't have to say anything negative -- but you're giving a hint to anyone who's paying attention that you're not endorsing his ability, either. Anybody who hires him after a reference call like that should have been forewarned, but you needn't feel guilty about giving him a bad reference, and you've given him no real room for litigation or an unemployment claim.

by r_chabie

It is difficult to come up with a solution for this.

If one could begin with availability of mentors. Almost impossible request.
They usually have a heap of other responsibilities.

Capable mentors/managers. Many managers get into that position as a reward of good technical service to the company, but now has to manage people, something they may struggle with themselves. Took the promotion probably because of the financial incentives, and are found out of depth.

Unwillingness of senior staff.

Knowledge transfer/ lack thereoff. Many want to keep their jobs safe and would not part with what they know.

Please add more.

by bschaettle

It seems to me that you've already written a pretty honest letter: the first paragraph of your post. It's short, honest and generally complimentary of his better traits.

by tor24

Sometimes, but not always, managers are looking for people that can do the work they are given, but are also able to independently solve problems they encounter without too much intervention, supervision and "bothersome" questions.

There are two mind games that I use to overcome a boss who micro-manages one moment, then becomes unavailable for long periods of time.

First game: Imagine being the boss. After all, the boss always gets to stay in the office, while the workers run about. Imagine your manager as another resource for you (e.g. the person who will acquire the tools you need, grant you access to company resources, sign your timesheet). You can now skew that view to your advantage. If you know where everything is, you become the resource for answers, and your manager becomes the resource for action.

Now that you are, at least in your mind, the boss, you are the one that has to produce the answers. You are the one that will gain the reward for correct answers, and suffer the consequences of incorrect ones. Look towards taking control of your own destiny within the framework of your existing job.

Second game: Ask yourself whether you should ask a question or find the answer on your own.

Imagine if had to pay $100 for every question you ask your manager, like that of certain software companies' technical support. You may find yourself answering the original question without intervention, from an outside resource, or as a product of some logical line of thought, trial and error, or perhaps even a good guess.

Many technical folks are left to their own devices when they first start in the field, and again when they become accomplished. Try to solve problems, even if it means just straightening up your workspace, organizing your work, or documenting and optimizing your workflow.

If you find yourself with little to do, it will appear as though you are efficient, organized and capable. Technical people often find themselves inundated with technical work, while these important sanity preserving tasks are pushed aside. Use the time for self study and train yourself on some work-related aspect of the job, even if it as simple as creating your own technical web pages using the company's design elements. This will make you appear that you are attempting to contribute to the entire organization.

Most importantly, have a list of written questions prepared so that when your manager does finally return, you won't appear to have wasted time or impeded progress on projects.

by tljones00

In Texas you are only legally required to answer the questions of "did they work there?", "how much did they make?", and "would you rehire?". Anything beyond that opens you up to the legal issues of blackballing. Be VERY careful in what you say to any questions from a phone interview. You are not required to answer any of the questions other than the above, either positive or negative. If you want to say positive things to a question, then by all means go for it. If you say anything nagative other than that you wouldn't rehire watch out!!

by jpenrose

It appears that you've written the letter and have moved on (at least from this discussion anyway) but I'll chime in b/c I'm faced with the same challenge at the end of this month.

You said "We had an honest relationship and I've tried to steer him away from technology" which seems to imply that you've told him in so many words that he isn't cut out for a career in IT support. If this is truly the case and you don't want to mislead anyone then you really shouldn't have written the letter. You should explain to the man that you feel his strengths do not lie in the field of technology and that recommending him to continue down a career path that he is clearly not in tune with would be doing him a great disservice. If you want him to succeed then don't allow him to get in his own way. Do him a favor now.

JPenrose

This discussion is closed to new replies.