I've seen this scenario all to often, and thats often the cause of companies having poor IT infrastructures.
Many techies as we know are not the most personable of people, but when it comes to the job they are employed to do they are often untouchable, you know the type of people who simply rythme off answers to problems you've been working on without any joy, which is often because of endless hours reading through manuals and techie guides. I'm not saying all people but you know the people I'm talking about.
Put that person in the hands of an HR executive or interviewer and they'll never see the workplace they are intended for, they'll see them as awkward and will advise that they don't think they'd fit in, but that person together with another techie and they come to life because for many of said indivduals IT is there life. You may scoff and think how stereotypical but you know these guys, cause many of them are your colleagues, your friends and indeed many of the people who will answer your problems on sites like this.
At the end of the day many a diamond in the rough will pass by your organisation due to an inadequate HR department.
IT people KNOW IT people and as such should hire IT people, you wouldn't ask a butcher to hire a vet purely because they both deal with animals in one way or another, likewise just because an HR administrator sits down in Front of a PC doesn't mean they're qualified to guage IT People, and ALL TOO OFTEN it's the personable they guy who was confident who "Talked the Talk" It didn't matter that the HR Interviewer didn't have a clue what they where talking about cause Joe average used a few tricks of his own to guage how technical the interviewer was and blurted out the biggest load of technical bullshtein you'll ever hear but will make it sound convincing and ultimately get the job and these people we all know they're the guys and gals you're always asking how did they get the job and how are they manageing to hold on to it.
Bravo TPO for standing behind your convictions as there too lies the problem in many IT environments, Too many Yes men and Accountants playing at IT but thats another story......
Regards
Martin Mack