Discussion Locked

I don't like to work with my manager

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Hi, I am have been working in my company for 3.5 years now and i have started as a systems analyst at the development department and then i moved on april 2004 to the production department as a business analyst in which i used to handle system changes, Data integrity... in sept. 2004 my responsibilities has changed to not carry what i used to do but to be responsible for cost benefit analysis, project coordination, and basically solving business problems from systems perspective. Well, what i do now does not belong to the production department it is purly business consulting but i am still kep t in my current structure as a business analyst working for the production department. Now, my manager has no information or expertise on what i work on, moreover does not provide support to me. i look for support to my manager's manager as he is an Expat who has all the knowledge that i need, he guides me and even assign me tasks. he then informs my manger of what tasks i he assigned to me. my managers only role is to evaluate me at the end of each year, but i "actually" work for my manager's manager. i would like to change that but i don't know how. moreover, my manager is a kind of person who is very bossy i.e. likes to give order and a very show-off person. i find it hard to communicate with my manager as we have a different mentality (what i am looking for is something that my manager has no understanding of, another thing my managers think i know nothing!!). basically i don't believe that my manager should be my manager i beleieve i belong somewhere else. Your opinion is highly welcomed.

8 replies

by Former member

Good description of your situation.

It seems clear to me where the problem is. Your manager does not fully understand the nature of your job and in fact you receive direction for your boss's boss. You may actually interact with this "big boss" more than your manager. If the description of your boss is accurate this would be VERY threatening to your boss.

Your company sounds like is a highly buracratic organization with many divisions. In this type of organization if you interact with your boss's boss without your boss's participation he will feel cut's out of the loop. It is out the nomal chain of command.

Your boss cannot complain about this openly without potentially angering his boss so he takes it out on you. The solution could be to actively solicit the inclusion of your boss in the process.

This shows your support of the chain of command, shows you are not trying to circumvent your boss's position, and will likely end up getting your boss cut out of the process, which is what you want to have happen. This is because including him will be a demmand on his time and he doesn't know the job anyway. As you said he doesn't fit with your current responsibilities the big boss will see this and factor him out, unless he is better connected than you realize in which case you really need to make sure you stay in his good graces. Make it apparent you are showing your "support" for your boss and the chain of command.

Try it, it is the smart and political way to go.

by salamander

I've used this approach before, and it does work. Just remember to keep your communications professionally neutral, be pleasant, and keep your boss in the loop. Also make sure that you don't make any professional missteps that he can call you on...dot your i's and cross your t's. Give it time, and you may be pleasantly surprised by the outcome.

by david.williams

The first thing you MUST do is talk to your manager. Before you do so WRITE down what you want to say, how you are feeling and what you expect the outcome to be. Then go in and tell him and leave the paper with him for reference. Wait for 2 weeks. Then ask him if he has anything to say. If you get no luck, then do the same with the personnel manager - not a girlie but a manager.
If there is no personnel manager or it still doesnt work - then you must do the same exercise with your managers managers. If that doesn't work LEAVE.
It's all about following the correct procedure. Always keep your cool. Always stick to your story.
Make sure of your facts. Be prepared to leave but never get angry.
Be alert to the fact that you may think you are more important than you actually are.
You will set in motion a set of actions that will end up with you being a happy, valued member of staff OR you not working there any more.

by salamander

"If you get no luck, then do the same with the personnel manager - not a girlie but a manager."

In the interests of observing proper protocol when taking the issue up the chain of command...what do you do if the personnel manager is female? Does she still count as a "girlie," or not?

by jck

I would only go from your manager to the HR department if each department/group has their own HR people. Otherwise if you have one corporate HR department, I'd go from your manager...to his boss...then to corporate HR.

I think the only thing you could do worse than leaving your inept manager out of the loop...would be to leave your manager's boss that you like so much out of the loop.

Just depends on the company/corporate hierarchy where you work. Make sure you follow the chain properly.

by dc_guy

Is this situation so bad that you would consider leaving? Jobs aren't all that easy to find these days, and when you do find one you'll inevitably discover that it comes with a whole bunch of problems. They'll probably just be different problems than the ones you have. Be sure you're really THAT unhappy here before you initiate a process that can result in looking for another job.

As for talking with your boss about the problem, be careful. He sounds like a pretty neurotic person with a lot of problems. Don't expect him to respond rationally. I'm curious as to why you haven't discussed this issue more frankly with your boss's boss. You seem to have good rapport with him. Do you think he'd be straight with you? If you don't have his support, you're probably not going to get anywhere anyway. He's the one with the power to solve this problem.

But whatever you do, think long and hard before you do it. You're very lucky to have a job. Almost none of them are perfect and a whole lot of them are much worse than yours.

Remember Drew Carey's classic line: "Oh, you don't like your JOB? Why didn't you say so? There's a support group for that. It's called EVERYBODY! They meet after work at the bar.

by nkqx57a

Other than being disenchanted with your boss, it sounds like you maybe working in a Matrix environment. If so, you will have multiple managers and one of them will be your manager for all things administrative. The rest of the managers will manage you on the project or tasks associated with the project. I have worked in Matrix organization where I had four managers, one administrative, one project, and two task managers. Each had specific responsibilities for their respective areas. The only one that I really liked was the project manager, but as a professional I learned to work with and not against those, I worked with and for. One of the things I learned during my military days was you salute the uniform and not the person wearing it. The same goes for the civilian side, you must show respect for the management position, even if you do not like the person in that position.

If things were as bad as you say, then speaking with your Human Resources representative would be a proper way to go, especially if you find it difficult to speak with your management team. Most HR representatives, contrary to some? beliefs will usually make an effort to help you.

by deepsand

Your's is an all too common problem, in all walks of life.

If your manager's superior fully knows of and understands the situation, then he is either satisfied with it, or lacks the actionable authority to change it. In this case, your only viable option is to seek employment elsewhere.

If, on the other hand, said superior is not fully cognizant of the situation, you may wish to consider enlisting him first as your mentor, and later as your champion if you can determine that he is open to either replacing your manager or transfering you to a more amenable chain of command.

This discussion is closed to new replies.