15 replies
by apotheon
I'd offer a job as a team member, maybe, but not as a project manager.
The people I'd be most likely to hire for project management would be people who've had extensive experience with open source projects or have experience with small, dynamic development teams that have shown a talent for adaptability.
by raelayne
Not sure how someone got certified without experience -- that's one of the criteria. Are you sure the person is certified, or did he or she print up a certificate on the home computer?
And no, don't do it. The #1 contributer to project success is an experienced project manager. Why bother if you aren't going to do everything you can to ensure success?
by duckboxxer
by moemar
by raelayne
If you're asking whether it's essential for the project manager to have IT experience, I'd say maybe not.
I worked on a huge project once that was in trouble, and the PM (a favorite programmer of the execs and good-old-boy) was replaced by a consultant who was a top-notch PM, but had limited technology project experience.
He succeeded fabulously because he knew his limitations, was a great judge of people, and had the good sense to trust the people who knew technology to make technology decisions. So how did he succeed? He asked great questions, was very organized, always told the truth -- to the team and to upper management -- didn't over-promise, quickly dealt with issues brought to him, etc. Because he had limited technology experience himself, he did a great job of explaining things in terms they could understand to the business execs.
You know some business execs tend to distrust technologists because it all sounds like magic to them. Because they can't understand it, they can't control it, and that really sends some execs over the edge. So sometimes it's good to have a non-tech person leading a project because the execs trust what they say. As long as that person knows he's getting the real scoop from the people who know technology, all is well.
Admittedly only one experience in a long career of projects, but it is possible. Note that none of this has to do with PMI. You're looking for a certain style and certain personal characteristics.
by dc guy
PMI certification counts for zero with me. I have not been impressed with the people who have it.
Which leaves me with... nothing. Nothing that you've told me qualifies him for the job. He must have something else going for him or you wouldn't be considering him at all. What is it?
by ebeck
If the person in question has significant PM experience, yes. Contrary to other posts here, the fundemental process of PM is what you really need, teamed with experts within the project for IT areas. It's not as great as the perfect IT PM person, but could even be better, since they could challenge the ways of doing things that an IT resource might assume is the only way to do something.
Consider the type of IT projects as well - which are so diverese alone that no one IT PM is always the best bet. Actual software/game dev projects are a bit different, but still, a great PM from other fields could still work, as long as they have some technical knowledge.
by rkwan
by rob mekel
It all depends on what kind of project it will be.
If it is a project where the PM needs hands on skills, I would strongly discourage you to hire this PM. If otherwise I see no objection to hire this PM, as the PMI certification should guarantee that. But [b]make damn sure[/b] that he has the qualification and [b]has track record[/b] of it.
Rob
by -=kurt=-
PMP Certification is (of course) only one of the criteria you could use when evaluating the PM candidates.
Often what looks like an IT project is not. For example: A CRM project is about good customer relations not IT, a portal project is about knowledge integration not IT. IT may be an important mechanism for delivery, but it is not the goal in it self. A good PM must have a strong experience in the area that defines the business goal of the project.
In addition a good PM must be aware that project management basically is a systems approach to management where integration of many different teams and skills is essential. In a typical "IT" project you will have persons from business areas, marketing, customers, design, development, testing, operations etc. In contrast, most operational management is analytical by decomposing a subject area into specialities of technical proficiency. (This requires a different management strategy.) The typical ?IT manager? has an analytical management style focusing on technical proficiency.
So what does a PMP certification give you?
It verifies that the candidate has:
1) A bachelor's degree and 4500 hours of PM experience (or 7500 hours of PM experience if the candidate only have high school)
2) The person has formal training in project management and has passed an exam. In addition the person has work experience in all project management areas covered by the exam.
3) The candidate must continually update her knowledge in project management
4) The person is bound by an ethical code of conduct.
In my opinion I would primarily be focusing on experience in the area that defines the goal of the project and secondary on PM experience and PMP certification. However, the PM must have some of both backgrounds.
-=Kurt=-
by kj_smiley
I assume this individual qualified to take the PMI exam through non-IT project experience such as construction, or civil planning, etc.
Hiring PMs is tough, and I personally do not place high value on PMI certification. I am certified, and yes I did learn a few things from my studies, but I find this certification very low on my checklist for hiring PMs. I would interview this person for the qualities of a good PM, perhaps have some trusted project team members in on the interview as well.
Also, think about all the people who tackle home improvements on the weekend. Some are really good at estimating time, cost, risk, keeping an eye for quality, and keeping the end goal in mind. Others are really bad at it. I?ll bet a vast majority of these folks don?t even know what PMI stands for.
This person could be a natural and you may miss an opportunity to have them work for you.
by cln
I personally, wouldn't do it, however I've seen it work.
I have a colleague who was hired as an IT Project Manager with NO IT experience whatsoever, and no project management experience. She does have an MBA. None of us thought this would work. She didn't know that. She went on to be very successful and is PMP certified. She now manages projects for a large bank, although I don't think they're IT projects.
by dan furlong
IT Projects are different than many other projects, but if the candidate has vast experience working on other types of projects, he / she may be able to adapt to IT. It is dependant upon their aptitude and level of experience on other projects.
The biggest differences on IT projects are not in the project management skills, but rather in the processes / methodologies used within the project itself -- such as SDLC for software development projects. The basic PM skills are no different for "most" IT projects.
One more thought: I would not assume b/c they are a PMP that they have EVER worked on ANY project before. Or, if they have, it may have been a one person project. We have all heard about a PMP or two who were creative in their application process to PMI. I just go with "Trust, then Verify" motto!
My last thought, and the one that I always go with, is "What is your gut feeling?". If you like them, and they have the aptitude to learn what you need, then you can usually end up with a strong employee that meets your requirements.
For instance, I know a guy who built a bridge here that ANYONE in our state would pay dearly to get to run ANY project. I believe he could run anything. He is just that kind of person.
by dave lathrop
Definitely needs experience. More important, you need to feel confident that the person has learned from that experience, and the experience of others. This is includes being able to explain where they made mistakes (nobody's perfect) and what (20-20 hindsight) they would differently now. And where nothing could be done.
Watch out if they were always blameless in all of their failed projects.
by pmpsicle
I keep seeing ads that repeat the same error made by many people who've commented on this. Knowing the details of any task within a project does not guarantee the sucess of the project. In other words determine your requirements for THAT job and hire for THAT job ... not another one.
I've worked on many types of projects ... many in IS and IT and many in other fields. The truth is that detailed knowledge of any of those fields has never helped me successfully manage the project. It makes me feel better, it makes the hiring manager feel better but it just doesn't help me run the project.
Being a skilled, knowledgeable project manager who knows when to shut up and when to ask questions, on the other hand, does help. In fact it is the key.
If you need to confirm this in your own mind ask yourself this simple question ... when was the last time you saw ANY medium complexity multi-person project where EVERYONE knew EVERYTHING that was needed in the project. (That's why we have users on the project after all :> ).
(Please notice that I'm sidestepping the issue of PMPs without project experience since they are supposed to be reported to the ethics commitee).
Glen Ford, PMP
Can Da Software
IS Project Management
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending