Discussion Locked

Identity Theft National Law (choicepoint)

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
The ChoicePoint incident of theft of 145,000 person's personal data caused Diane Feinstein (D-CA) to propose national law similar to california law. This would notify victims. Since this might not have been noticed immediately as not a network break in but bogus companies, I'd like to suggest one better: ALL requests from ANYONE buying personal info be logged to a central database. This way, people who saw their info being purchased for no reason could alert authorities. You'd be able to access this like requesting your credit report. Unlike your credit report, this would contain only an indication that your personal info had been purchased, not the personal info itself, except for identifying info. The govt could run this but I don't trust the govt, would rather have private industry consortium run this, all companies that submitted data would pay to run this in proportion to the amount of data they submitted. They might have to leave off requests from law enforcement agents if verified from the report for on-going investigations so as not to tip off the criminals. What do you think?

8 replies

by salamander

...would be something similar to California's state law on the credit freeze. In that state, an individual can request that their credit be frozen. For a person requesting a credit freeze under California's state law, credit cannot be extended until the credit profile is temporarily "unfrozen" by the legitimate holder of that identity, to be accessed only by a specified company, where the individual is identified by a password, phone number, and other information. It's frankly too easy for credit to be extended...technology and ease of use have outstripped privacy concerns. An individual should have the option to lock down their credit profile and not permit ANY inquiries without requiring some hoops to be jumped through. I think a lot of people would go through the minor inconvenience of not having instantaneous access to credit (God forbid that we should actually have to wait a business day or two for something), rather than have to go through the major hassle of identity theft.

by montgomery gator

You can call the 3 major credit bureaus and have a fraud alert put on your credit reports. That way, they have to contact you if someone is accessing credit information. I had trouble with identity theft (my ex-wife was applying for accounts in my name) and that fixed the problem. I recently applied for refinancing of my house, and the mortgage company called back to verify information because of the fraud alert, and after that, everything went through with no problem.

by salamander

My understanding is that the fraud alert is available only if there is reasonable suspicion that a fraud may be committed, or evidence that a crime has already been committed, and that it expires after seven years. I'd like to see something available without having to meet that "reasonable suspicion" standard...just because I want it as a matter of general principle. I think that there should be a mechanism to be used strictly as a preventative measure, to seal credit reports against all inquiry, absent explicit consent from the rightful identity owner. While it's true that no system is foolproof, I have to think that identity theives, like most other criminals, would generally prefer to harvest those credit profiles that have fewer safeguards.

by dr dij

So maybe they only need minor changes: require them to allow anyone to receive notice if any personal info or credit info was accessed. But this company was a spin-off from big 3 credit bureaus so maybe they didn't offer this if not required to.

I think it should be codified in law rather than you having to search out credit bureaus that they log the fact that they've given a way info to a (supposed) merchant in georgia when you live in Philadelphia. You'd know instantly there is a problem and the credit bureau if notified would probably find this merchant person is a fraud, not really a merchant.

Even if they were a valid merchant, they had no reason to access your personal info, and most likely had side business stealing personal info.

Having all transactions available for scrutiny by the person most interested in preserving their identity (themselves) would go a long way to keeping ever more clever identity thieves out.

According to the computerworld article, these people actually bought the data rather than hack in, pretending to be legitimate business people.

by johnmcgrew

...the reality is that the credit reporting industry will never let it happen. Your info is sold hundreds, if not thousands of times a day, and the last thing they want is most people knowing it.

by ccalvin

I agree that the list of requests should be available to the credit subject. But the reporting company should be strictly liable for any damage caused by fraudulent use of reported information.
Double damages to the damaged party. Single damages to the government. This would make it worthwhile for the credit reporters to know who was buying. And verify with the credit subject.

by craig herberg

One thing that seems to be missing from these conversations is the notion of permission. Notifying people after their identity is sold is akin to closing the barn door after the cow escapes. If we are interested in preventing/reducing identity theft, we need to make it harder for those involved in identity theft, including those who facilitate it (just read the newspaper or watch the news). Since your social security number is not public information, it should not be for sale. Each and every release of your private information should be preceeded by your permission. Data clearinghouses will become better stewards of your privacy when they are required to.

Craig Herberg

by roger.radda

Why can't we change the law so that each person's personal information belongs to the individual, and may not be used by any other company or individual without prior written consent, or proper compensation. Penalty for each violation of law - maybe $100.00 to $500.00 per occurance.

This discussion is closed to new replies.