Discussion Locked

[i]I am a socialist who believes in paying taxes for the greater good[/i]

0 helpful
126 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I received an email from a peer (it was a nice email) who said that he/she was [i]a socialist who believes in paying taxes for the greater good[/i].

We've all heard this before, of course -- the [i]greater good[/i]. But you people (you [i]greater good[/i] people), you and I both know that your [i]greater good[/i] coincides exactly with your individual best interest -- but you wish to force others to serve your best interest. You are either one who believes in equality of outcome, thereby taking from others that which you do not have; or you are a wealthy elitist (yes, there are wealthy elitists in socialist systems) who wishes to keep people from achieving their true potential, or keep them mired in mediocrity servng your wants and needs.

Very few people are naive' and ignorant enough to actually believe that mankind can actually live as one big happy family -- [i]from all according to his ability, to all according to his needs[/i] (although there are some, I suppose). You don't fool me with your [i]greater good[/i] nonsense. You simply want something that others already have or will have. You simply want others to serve your best interest.

And people don't realize how much "socialism" we actually have in America! (Or they simply won't admit it.)

P.S. Another way of proving that your [i]greater good[/i] equals your own individual interest is that you fail to consider and/or you simply ignore the fact that another's definition and view of [i]greater good[/i] might be (and will be) different than yours. However, you insist on imposing your view of the [i]greater good[/i] on others, regardless of how contrary it might be to them.

126 replies

by tony hopkinson

You agree that taxes are necessary in a community. So do I.
In fact to disagree would indicate you were an anarchist.
What those taxes should pay for, well that's a whole new ball game.

As far as I'm concerned, the greater good is a side effect. Any safety net to catch those struck by intentional misfortune, can catch me as well. If I don't persuade others of that, then my ass in in the abyss, because one of your capitalists chums decided to maximise shareholder value and outsource my role.

As for Marx, well he was a sadly deluded extremist, so you have more in common with him than you think.

I don't what socialism you have in America either, haven't seen any evidence of any ever, lots of liberals though :( . What you have is the welfare vote, a very different animal altogether.

by absolutely

[i]Any safety net to catch those struck by intentional misfortune, can catch me as well. If I don't persuade others of that, then my ass in in the abyss, because one of your capitalists chums decided to maximise shareholder value and outsource my role.[/i]

Marx is even more recent than the factory system, before which people helped out their neighbors in times of bad luck. That system allows easy differentiation of freeloaders from unlucky folk, and does not waste resources with centralized collection, followed by nationwide redistribution, of wealth. National safety nets just waste resources which [b]would[/b] otherwise do more good (1) to those in need (2) preventing them from being chronically in need (3) helping many others never be in such need as to depend on handouts.

by tony hopkinson

Poor houses as well.

helped out their neighbours in times of bad luck, what have you been reading?

Remember I'm a brit, we created the labour movement, for one simple reason, so no one could threaten our livelihood to make us indenture our children. It was real, it did happen.

That's my heritage.

Ask a black american if the laws against slavery should be abolished because they are no longer necessary.

If you stop fighting your corner, someone will steal your stool, sit on it and then have you lick their boots clean. Simply because they can.

What Marx was thinking about I haven't a clue, I suppose it could have been considered as logical a progression of the labour movement as slavery was for capitalism. I'm hard pressed to pick which one I think more stupid, but I tend to side with Karl at that extreme.

As for your last point, I agree wholeheartedly, I'm just not so wide eyed an innocent to believe that's where the money would be spent.

There's a big difference between the lifelong welfare recipient and the guy who through the vagaries of the market, birth, education, local demands is unable to constantly provide for himself.

I've been in continuous employment since June 1981, I still believe in that safety net, it's simply insurance. It certainly won't be a handout in my case. I've paid for it good and proper.

So no more citing scrounging parasitic f**kwits as the norm, not someone like me and you. Try say, a seasonal worker. Should they be paid double because they are out of work six months a year? I'm for it, what say you?

by john.a.wills

The U.S. government runs the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which insures bank deposits (100% up to $100,000, a much better dealt than the UK system). It also runs the helium mines, an insurance scheme for company pensions, a compulsory unemployment insurance scheme (actually administered by the states, but under federal law) and a compulsory pension scheme called Social Security (not the same meaning as that phrase has in UK). Besides that it subsidizes public housing, which is administered by the states in various ways (in CA to house the poor for life, in SC to house those down on their luck and help them back into the main-line economy), provides grants (yes!) and subsidized loans to college students, and probably does many socialist things I cannot off-hand remember.
The California Earthquake Authority provides insurance against earthquake damage.
Credit unions are popular throughout the country; other kinds of consumer co-operative are also to be found.

by tony hopkinson

Certainly they are by my definition.
Not commune type things, but a group of labour who hire capital.

I'd love to see more of that everywhere, it's real hard to do in the traditional corporate environment. They don't like it all, seem to think it's backwards.

I see nationalisation didn't catch on. :D
You'd all be a lot more annoyed if it had.

This will sort the wheat from the chaff, how did you feel about GWB introducing steel tariffs to protect your ailing domestic industry?
That was a very 'socialist' policy.

by tonythetiger

[i]If I don't persuade others of that, then my ass in in the abyss, because one of your capitalists chums decided to maximise shareholder value and outsource my role.[/i]

it is simply because your role is not worth as much as you think it is.

by absolutely

And tell us more about why you hate socialists. There are many, many excellent reasons to hate them. Which of those reasons is most important to you?

by wkl

Must be one of those Open Source GNU-license devotees, eh?

First of all, to be a socialist, you must reject the concept of private property. In the ideal socialist community there are no "taxes". You are a slave to the state, 100%, and nothing belongs to you, not even your own life. What you do and how you do it is dictated to you by the politico elite, which acts to ensure their social standing and wealth while "fairly" distributing the misery and the poverty among all of the good little socialists.

The American Founding Fathers were at least more honest in their day about enslavement. They literally owned other human beings 100% and had their way with them, buying, selling, trading and using them like they were farm animals.

Today, slavery is not so fashionable any more so the wealthy politico elite must make do with part time slaves, through taxation (as much as half of our income goes to paying one form of tax or another, making us not just "part time" but HALF time slaves.)

We semi-slaves, then, are compelled, by threat of legal jeopardy, to pay up, but have little meaningful control over how the money is used. In our case, the "greater good" is just what the politico elite claims it is, and I'll give you one good guess as to what that is!

by tony hopkinson

you don't know what socialism is, most seem to confuse it with communism and liberalism or even more horrifying some unholy amalgam of both.
In the ideal socialist state, you would never notice it was there, except when you needed it.

Well my ideal socialist state anyway. :D

Actually human slavery is the ultimate form of capitalism not socialism, so may be you have your halves mixed up.

by wkl

That would be MY ideal socialist state as well!

Actually, I don't think it matters much what you label it - if you aren't truly free, you may as well call it "Bend-over-and-grease-up-ism" if you're one of the little people.

Here's a great article that explains it all:

http://sonic.net/~goblin/9moe.html

by maxwell edison

We lost private property rights in the United States long ago. As long as property taxes are collected in perpetuity and subject to the vote of others, there are NO private property rights. At best, all property owners pay a HUGE deposit to a private individual for the right to pay rent (disguised as "property taxes") forever to the state. If one does not pay the rent, he/she loses the property AND the deposit.

By the way, personally, I support the abolition of ALL property taxes.

by wkl

Not only are your property rights diminished by the taxes but also by the state's ability to seize your property through eminent domain, and in some cases, the mere ACCUSATION of having committed certain crimes. America, the best justice system money can buy. If you don't have the money, you have the right to remain silent, while the elite caste has the right to do as they please with you.

What's this system of government called again?

by tonythetiger

for the same reason you pay anything else: To purchase goods or services. The only difference is that in the case of taxes, the storekeeper is holding a gun to your head making you buy stuff you don't want!

[added: And poor quality stuff at that!]

by sleepin'dawg

March 7, 2007

http://tinyurl.com/yskq5k

Prius Outdoes Hummer in Environmental Damage
By Chris Demorro
Staff Writer

The Toyota Prius has become the flagship car for those in our society so environmentally conscious that they are willing to spend a premium to show the world how much they care. Unfortunately for them, their ultimate ?green car? is the source of some of the worst pollution in North America; it takes more combined energy per Prius to produce than a Hummer.
Before we delve into the seedy underworld of hybrids, you must first understand how a hybrid works. For this, we will use the most popular hybrid on the market, the Toyota Prius.

The Prius is powered by not one, but two engines: a standard 76 horsepower, 1.5-liter gas engine found in most cars today and a battery- powered engine that deals out 67 horsepower and a whooping 295ft/lbs of torque, below 2000 revolutions per minute. Essentially, the Toyota Synergy Drive system, as it is so called, propels the car from a dead stop to up to 30mph. This is where the largest percent of gas is consumed. As any physics major can tell you, it takes more energy to get an object moving than to keep it moving. The battery is recharged through the braking system, as well as when the gasoline engine takes over anywhere north of 30mph. It seems like a great energy efficient and environmentally sound car, right?

You would be right if you went by the old government EPA estimates, which netted the Prius an incredible 60 miles per gallon in the city and 51 miles per gallon on the highway. Unfortunately for Toyota, the government realized how unrealistic their EPA tests were, which consisted of highway speeds limited to 55mph and acceleration of only 3.3 mph per second. The new tests which affect all 2008 models give a much more realistic rating with highway speeds of 80mph and acceleration of 8mph per second. This has dropped the Prius?s EPA down by 25 percent to an average of 45mpg. This now puts the Toyota within spitting distance of cars like the Chevy Aveo, which costs less then half what the Prius costs.

However, if that was the only issue with the Prius, I wouldn?t be writing this article. It gets much worse.

Building a Toyota Prius causes more environmental damage than a Hummer that is on the road for three times longer than a Prius. As already noted, the Prius is partly driven by a battery which contains nickel. The nickel is mined and smelted at a plant in Sudbury, Ontario. This plant has caused so much environmental damage to the surrounding environment that NASA has used the ?dead zone? around the plant to test moon rovers. The area around the plant is devoid of any life for miles.

The plant is the source of all the nickel found in a Prius? battery and Toyota purchases 1,000 tons annually. Dubbed the Superstack, the plague-factory has spread sulfur dioxide across northern Ontario, becoming every environmentalist?s nightmare.

?The acid rain around Sudbury was so bad it destroyed all the plants and the soil slid down off the hillside,? said Canadian Greenpeace energy-coordinator David Martin during an interview with Mail, a British-based newspaper.

All of this would be bad enough in and of itself; however, the journey to make a hybrid doesn?t end there. The nickel produced by this disastrous plant is shipped via massive container ship to the largest nickel refinery in Europe. From there, the nickel hops over to China to produce ?nickel foam.? From there, it goes to Japan. Finally, the completed batteries are shipped to the United States, finalizing the around-the-world trip required to produce a single Prius battery. Are these not sounding less and less like environmentally sound cars and more like a farce?

Wait, I haven?t even got to the best part yet.

When you pool together all the combined energy it takes to drive and build a Toyota Prius, the flagship car of energy fanatics, it takes almost 50 percent more energy than a Hummer - the Prius?s arch nemesis.

Through a study by CNW Marketing called ?Dust to Dust,? the total combined energy is taken from all the electrical, fuel, transportation, materials (metal, plastic, etc) and hundreds of other factors over the expected lifetime of a vehicle. The Prius costs an average of $3.25 per mile driven over a lifetime of 100,000 miles - the expected lifespan of the Hybrid.

The Hummer, on the other hand, costs a more fiscal $1.95 per mile to put on the road over an expected lifetime of 300,000 miles. That means the Hummer will last three times longer than a Prius and use less combined energy doing it.

So, if you are really an environmentalist - ditch the Prius. Instead, buy one of the most economical cars available - a Toyota Scion xB. The Scion only costs a paltry $0.48 per mile to put on the road. If you are still obsessed over gas mileage - buy a Chevy Aveo and fix that lead foot.

One last fun fact for you: it takes five years to offset the premium price of a Prius. Meaning, you have to wait 60 months to save any money over a non-hybrid car because of lower gas expenses.

[i] edited to add the link[/i]

by tig2

I had the pleasure of spending a couple of weeks in Sudbury on business in the late 90's. It was a wonderful place, inhabited by wonderful people.

EVERYONE- from the cab driver that got me where I needed to go, to the people I was working with was fabulous. Truly the nicest people I had worked with, and to my mind, still rank there in spite of other people I have met.

One of the people in the group took some time to tell me about some of Sudbury's history. He remarked on a time 10-20 years earlier when the pollution from the factories and mines had so disabled the town that they had to do some radical things to reclaim their earth. While I don't have complete recall of the details, I DO recall seeing the striations of black in the rock of the hillsides. And I could see places shored up by human engineering.

But what was proudly pointed out to me was that before they started trying to reclaim their town, the hills had been positively BLACK and erosion was a constant problem. When I was there, the black remained but many other natural colours had returned.

The other thing that was pointed out to me was the flowerbeds everywhere. People planted flowers anywhere they were- because the flowers would grow. And that was a new thing to this community.

If it is happening again, it's criminal. Sudbury is a beautiful place as I visited it. It should be allowed to stay that way.

Edited- typo

by jamesrl

Someone clearly is playing with the facts.

Sudbury was in the 60s and 70s one of the worst spots in North America for pollution. But in the late 70s Ontario introduced the toughest industrial emission standards (other than California) in North America, and emissions were essentially cut in half.

Sudbury is getting better. All of Ontario is getting better over time - some of our coal generators are shut down for good. But half of our pollution comes from the US, most from the Ohio Valley where coal is heavily used.

James

by absolutely

Who is more motivated to prefer economic stagnation than people who already have plenty of money?

by deepsand

If we accept your premise at face value, then you must hold that it is [b]not[/b] for the greater good that we have armed forces to defend against aggressive nations, police to defend against aggressive individuals, fireman to defend against violent acts of nature, etc., etc., etc.; i.e., that each person must stand alone in defense of his own life, liberty, and property.

Is this really what you believe?

by tony hopkinson

a defense is critical. :D

You can't help out everybody when they are short of a buck to buy some food either.

Too busy putting out fires and stuff for starters.

Personally I'd love to see the back of welfare, it's now institutionalised.

I await a workable alternative, or more correctly an alternative that won't take money out of the other pocket.

100% employment ?
Do able, not easy though and definitely not in the interests of those at the top of the food chain. They pay accountants not taxes.

Incidentally 100% employment is a stated goal of the British Labour Party, without nationalisation I hasten to add.

by maxwell edison

You know damn well the intent of this discussion. If you want to play your usual and silly games, bait someone else. I refuse to engage in meaningless dialogue with you.

by absolutely

I'm not ready to get as personal with deepsand, but he must know that in the context of 'socialism', the 'greater good' is code for the good of the unworthy at the expense of those who earn.

by deepsand

You [b]did[/b] make the statement to the effect that [b]anyone[/b] who claims to be motivated for the greater good has ulterior motives, such being the goal to attain a personal benefit at the expense of others.

Do you now deny having said so?

=============================================

"I received an email from a peer (it was a nice email) who said that he/she was a socialist who believes in paying taxes for the greater good.

We've all heard this before, of course -- the greater good. But you people (you greater good people), you and I both know that your greater good coincides exactly with your individual best interest -- but you wish to force others to serve your best interest. You are either one who believes in equality of outcome, thereby taking from others that which you do not have; or you are a wealthy elitist (yes, there are wealthy elitists in socialist systems) who wishes to keep people from achieving their true potential, or keep them mired in mediocrity servng your wants and needs.

Very few people are naive' and ignorant enough to actually believe that mankind can actually live as one big happy family -- from all according to his ability, to all according to his needs (although there are some, I suppose). You don't fool me with your greater good nonsense. You simply want something that others already have or will have. You simply want others to serve your best interest.

And people don't realize how much "socialism" we actually have in America! (Or they simply won't admit it.)

P.S. Another way of proving that your greater good equals your own individual interest is that you fail to consider and/or you simply ignore the fact that another's definition and view of greater good might be (and will be) different than yours. However, you insist on imposing your view of the greater good on others, regardless of how contrary it might be to them."

by absolutely

[i][u]If[/u] we accept your premise at face value, [u]then you must hold[/u] that it is [b]not[/b] for the greater good that we have armed forces to defend against aggressive nations, police to defend against aggressive individuals, fireman to defend against violent acts of nature, etc., etc., etc.; i.e., that each person must stand alone in defense of his own life, liberty, and property.[/i]

Please detail the logic you employed to reach that conclusion, beginning with an explicit statement of the aforementioned "premise".

by maxwell edison

.....and you know it. Why do you insist on attempting to play these games? Are you really that pitiful that you have to resort to disingenuousness to initiate conversation?

You should know by now that I don't take your silly bait. You should know by now that I don't take you seriously. So what's your motive? Do you wish to appear smart, or clever, or something to others? You surely realize you don't appear such to me. And as indicated by others who've posted to your silly line of answers, pointing out your disingenuousness, you don't appear such to them either. You fool no one. How sad you must be.

by deepsand

it to have been intended. It was your own words which stepped beyond the context of "socialism," by attacking the concept of "greater good," which allowed of my question.

That you failed to more carefully choose your words is not my burden to bear.

by tony hopkinson

Causes non americans to go so far as to quirk an eyebrow and say

'He think's he's free'?

You are not free , you will never be free, you can't be free, more to the point you don't want to be free, nor do you want anyone else to be.

No participating member in a group is free from the constraint of the rest. That's what family, friends, communities and nations are. A subsumption of individual needs.

Get something for nothing, thanks for illustrating my point , I pay my taxes for something.

The fact that you don't value it, or more correctly you put you individual needs before the community's, bothers me not at all.
People with your attitude get into power, kick the ass of anyone who is not already big people and then use the money for physical therapy after wrenching their arm out of joint patting themselves on the back.

Politics is the swing of the pendulum, extreme to extreme, I'm a moderate, I try to dampen it, not alternate between loud huzzahs and pitiful whining.

What goes around comes around, of course the same goes for these weird types you label socialists in ignorance.

by wkl

"People with my attitude"?? Whatever are you talking about? You merely restated my point - that we're not actually free at all.

Oh, but of course, Americans like to claim we're the "land of the free" and all that. But it is said that "freedom" is just another word for "nothing left to lose". I suppose I could just quit my job, slack off and sell everything, enjoying a nice vacation until the money runs out and then go on welfare, and let all the other taxpayers support me for a change! I'm not lucky enough to be disabled and draw a disability check, and go fishing all day every day like some other lucky bastards I know. Now THAT's freedom!

I really don't follow the rest of your diatribe, or what your point is regarding putting my needs ahead of the community. A community exists for the benefit of its constituent individuals, not the other way around! We aren't a bunch of ants. We aren't mindless expendable drones working in a collective. You pseudo-socialists seem to be working from an inside-out perspective.

by tony hopkinson

must have had my anti Maxwell head on. :D

Society does indeed exist to benefit the individuals in it. It can't do that though if those with a greater ability to contribute to it, do not.

You can't have a society if you set up the system so some can't contribute enough to 'pay for themselves' and then penalise them for not being able to do so.
That's just feudalism writ large, serfs and nobility, poverty line and high income earners. Merely a change in terms.

Psuedo-socialist my arse.

I am the real deal, unlike the self serving twats who buy votes with gifts to the poor.

by tony hopkinson

That's me as well is it?
Continuously employed and paying considerable taxes (UK remember) since July 81.

Anymore asinine generalities to spout?

I've told you before you can opt out of welfare anytime you like.

As long as I can opt out of stupid wars, naff legal systems, mediocre education, support of monopolies, graft, corruption, lobbying, big government, and dumb ass nanny state crap like the war on drugs.

by maxwell edison

.....those who are working and able, but want to continually widen the safety net for others (see note). And over here (I don't know about the UK), "tax the rich" to pay for it is the common mantra. (Of course, "the rich" is a matter of debate.) It's often said that (the U.S. version of) a liberal is willing to give the shirt off somebody else's back.

Note: Of course these "working stiffs" who favor tax increases (on the rich?) to pay for myriad programs (to cover both the able and unable), then must resort to using them (and favoring them) themselves because, as you said, you pay considerable taxes to fund the whole show. So in a way, you favor such a "safety net" for yourself as well, don't you?

Opt out? I don't think so, Tony. You could no more "opt out" of your system that I could ours. And regardless of how "good intentioned" such systems might (initially) be, they cause more harm than good. Of course, you and I will probably never agree on such a thing.

by tony hopkinson

we agree that the 'minority' is the target for taxes. We agree that claims for the greater good are utter garbage.
We agree that welfare fails the very people it's meant to protect.

My argument against the altruism twaddle was that the safety net would catch me as well.

Taxes on the rich is a misnomer. In terms of collecting income. 1% on the base rate will gain more revenue than 50% on the top rate. Equally that 1% is more valuable to the working stiff than it is to the 'rich' person.
There will always be and always should be a differential. Any sane society should attempt to narrow it, the only way nto do that is to raise the base, lowering the peak achieves next to nothing. They'll just pay their accountants to work harder dodging the burden.

It's a damn soundbyte, just like holding up those on welfare as scroungers, or socialists as thieves.
The efficiency of thge provision is certainly worth looking at. Whether some lateral thinking could get roound it altogether is worth looking at.

But somewhere somewhen if the state doesn't provide from taxes what needs providing, then it will be provided from some other part of your income.

by absolutely

as are "support of monopolies, graft, corruption, lobbying, big government" in general.

As for "the war on drugs", you're exactly right to call it "dumb ass nanny state crap", but socialism preceded that particular form of "dumb ass nanny state crap", and fiscal liberals & socialists don't consistently nor effectively push to repeal such crap, so you lot have to share the blame for that one equally with "conservatives". I don't recognize the acronym 'naff' so I suspect it's lewd & therefore irrelevant.

All wars are stupid, but it's less stupid to defend oneself against stupid aggressors than to not defend oneself. Wrong on all counts, except one, on which I grant you a draw: pretty good, considering you set out to defend welfare statism, but still Bad in Absolute Terms.

by tony hopkinson

those who talk about removing it wish to do it for their own personal gain and their societies cost.
Do you think stopping it will cure societies ills, will everyone just buck up and go out mowing lawns and flipping burgers?

Give me an alternative. It's the only way either of us will get some of what we want.

In terms of education, certainly the people who ruined education from the 80s in the UK, claimed to be socialists. I'm not sure how, since they did absolutely no service whatsoever to their community.
That mob make me livid, I rather agree with you and Maxwell, than that bunch of crap heads.
The prime component of the drivel they came out with is competition is bad for you, and failing teaches nothing.
Neither is a socialist principle.

They were also in favour of banning corporal punishment, uni-lateral disarmament, and a 20% pay rise whether they were any good or it could be afforded.

Maybe I need to go back to school, because for the life of me I can't see how anyone of them benefits society.

If they don't it's not socialism, it's a self serving lie.

by maxwell edison

I forgot which economist wrote the article in which I remember reading this (I might look for it), but it's a generally accepted notion that 100 percent employment is not possible -- 96 or 97 percent is the best any economy can do. The only way a nation to have 100 percent employment is to literally enslave people and FORCE them to work.

There are too many government "safety nets" and obstacles to maintain the REAL motivation to work, that being incentive. People work because of the incentive to do so. Whether that incentive is to merely survive, or to earn enough for a mansion on a hill, will vary depending on the individual.

But the [i]100% employment ..... stated goal of (your) British Labour Party[/i] is unattainable. For one thing, it assumes everyone wants to work, or needs to work, or will always work, or..... If you ask me, it's nothing but pandering to people because it sounds good.

by jamesrl

In Alberta, a province people are flocking to in order to get jobs, where entry level service jobs sit begging for applicants, the current unemployment rate is 3.6%. That is the number of people collecting employment insurance, who are supposed to be actively looking for work.

Some of those people are just taking some time to transition between one job and another. Others are just milking it as long as they can.

James

by maxwell edison

That's probably a pretty good number, 3.6 percent, to indicate an environment of full employment. I'd also be willing to wager that in such an area there are more job openings (ones that just about anybody breathing could fill) than there are people "unemployed".

by generalist

The four percent number for full employment also applies to the housing and business property market. Anything less than four percent means that demand is higher than supply, so prices go up.

Unfortunately, employment figures in the US tend to ignore several segments of the population.

One segment is those people who are underemployed relative to their skills. Senior engineers and master machinists who are working at McDonalds because nobody wants to hire them at the rates they could command are underemployed. (Many companies don't want to hire them because they are afraid they will jump ship if and when a better offer comes.)

Another segment are those who have given up on finding work befitting their skills and are semi-retired, living on their spouses earnings and doing odd jobs in the shadow economy to bring in extra cash. They tend not to be counted in the unemployment figures.

by absolutely

no time spent between jobs, and is just not realistic. You may as well vote for Santa Claus.

by tony hopkinson

Why shouldn't you be compelled to contribute to society (as you can), if you take the benefits from having one as an inalienable right?
That is something for nothing.

If you don't need to work, you don't have to, you still have to pay up though.

If you can't work, well that what welfare is really about, in a civilised society.

If you don't want to work, well I don't give a crap, don't put anything in , you don't get anything out. I'm quite happy with that. So you have two choices and the incentive is you get bugger all if you don't.

You've got to split welfare as social care from welfare as unemployment insurance, otherwise you can't have a sensible debate.

That just leaves open accusations of enslavement or throwing the mentally handicapped on the street.

Right wing goal is minimal employment to keep the costs down and maximise profits. Better still it gives you a cheap labour pool to recruit from and maximises your profits again.

That guarantees someone has to pay to keep that labour pool occupied in some way or other.

And it's you and I that pay, not them.

That's why the politicians feel welfare is an acceptable solution, they are paid to, and it pays them to.
Even right wingers have been known to buy the welfare vote when they have to.
Even if you persuaded me (and my 'comrades' that welfare was a bad idea and should be scrapped, no political party would ever campaign on that platform. No one would give them the money for the adverts and stuff, and the politicians would have to loose a potential hold on a sizeable percentage of our populations.

No welfare is a great goal if you state it properly, no need for welfare.

by tonythetiger

provide food to some of those who need food. I'm sure there are many others who, for example, would provide clothing for those who need clothing, shelter to those who need shelter, etc. (and I actually offered all three after hurricane Katrina!) But we didn't get any takers. Seems they say they want money for something to eat, or shelter, or clothes... but when they get it, they head for the nearest bar or dope corner.

by sleepin'dawg

supposedly unemployed really do not want to work and are content to live off the public purse. All those wanting to work and who are capable of working, are working.

by absolutely

[i]Ask a black american if the laws against slavery should be abolished because they are no longer necessary.[/i]

If I ask Clarence Thomas instead of Reverend Al Sharpton, would you consider that unfair? If so, why?

by absolutely

Thomas Sowell?

Repealing certain other laws would make us all more free. When all the welfare programs that keep us all working to pay our taxes from January 1 until April 1 or so are eliminated, then I might be willing to look at removing the laws against outright slavery. But not before then.

by tony hopkinson

I'll be happy to remove the laws against slavery the moment, it's no longer an economically viable business.

by tony hopkinson

Based on the question, presumably they would differ in opinion.
So to be fair, you have to ask both, otherwise you'll be accused of getting the answer 'you' wanted.

Remember I'm the moderate here.

by absolutely

"So to be fair, you have to ask both, otherwise you'll be accused of getting the answer 'you' wanted."

And that was exactly what you attempted to do, by specifying the race of the person I should consult, in the first place.

Tony Hopkinson is the biggest hypocrite.

by john.a.wills

is more corporatist than socialist: the employers and the employees in an industry join forces against everyone else.

by tony hopkinson

Self serving.
The beauty of co-operatives is there is no employers and employees. No possibility of the ruinous divisive split that gives us fat cat bosses and mad cap unionists.

That's two problems out of the way straight off.

by john.a.wills

consumer co-operatives certainly have employees. So sometimes do professional partnerships, which have quite similar structures to worker co-operatives, e.g. attorneys form the co-op and hire clerks etc.

by deepsand

Speaking in a public forum accords any and all the opportunity for such. If you've a problem with that you need only hold your tongue.

by absolutely

"greater good" keywords.

[i]"I received an email from a peer (it was a nice email) who said that he/she was [b]a socialist[/b] who believes in paying taxes [b]for the greater good.[/b]

We've all heard this before, of course -- the greater good. But you people ([b]you "greater good" people[/b]), you and I both know that your "greater good" coincides exactly with your individual best interest -- but you wish to force others to serve your best interest.[/i]

He opens very effectively with the statement that the peer identified itself as a socialist, putting all the text that follows squarely into that context. Nice posts, maxwell.

by deepsand

"greater good," rather than limiting himself to addressing "socialism."

That his statement may not accurately reflect his intent is a problem of his own making.

by absolutely

My understanding was that "his intent" was to discuss the use of the concept of the "greater good" as it is used to advance the cause of socialism. Was that your intent, maxwell? If so, there is no "problem of his own making" evident here, but only a failure on your part to understand the context he set. I had no trouble with that. Maybe you are being disingenuous.

by absolutely

up to their direct employer. I'll still buy fresh fruits & veggies because they're healthy.

[i]As for your last point, I agree wholeheartedly, I'm just not so wide eyed an innocent to believe that's where the money would be spent.[/i]

That "last point":
'National safety nets just waste resources which would otherwise do more good (1) to those in need (2) preventing them from being chronically in need (3) helping many others never be in such need as to depend on handouts.'

The point is that the mere collection of taxes is an expense, meaning that there is waste. In any nationalized safety net system, your money has to go to the national capital first, where some is just as good as set on fire, lost to administrative fees, blind stupidity, intentional corruption, whatever's lying around. Then, whatever comes back to your community for 'safety net' programs is less than what that same community, absent such taxes, would spend freely on local safety net programs. Really, Tony, people who are altruistic enough to vote for charity but not to give voluntarily? Who ever heard of such a thing?

by tonythetiger

they don't want the recipients to feel beholden to anyone, for that might lead to feeling guilty.

by tony hopkinson

So if welfare was not paid for through taxes and instead through charitable donations, you would make the same level of contribution?

All those who are compelled to contribute now would?

If you want to talk about realistic targeting
of the funds, more efficient use of them, such as getting people off it in the first place, great. Don't give me no rubbish about charity though.

A charity could be run just as badly as government welfare.

How much would the officers of such a charity pay themselves?

Whose political campaign chests should they contribute to?

What lobbying on other issues should they use their power for?

It would give the people in charge of it enormous political power, run well or not.

Worse still the more people in need of it, the more power you have.

Any of this sound vaguely familiar?

The only difference I see between welfare compelled through taxes and volunteered through charity, is a bunch of self interested types leaving those of us with a conscience to foot the bill.

Stuff that!

by tonythetiger

[i]So if welfare was not paid for through taxes and instead through charitable donations, you would make the same level of contribution?[/i]

By cutting out the two middlemen (the collector and the disburser) the cost would be drastically lower. And we, being closer to the need, are better able to determine how much and what kind of help is needed, as well as who [b]really[/b] needs the help, and who is just searching for a free ride.

by absolutely

[i]So if welfare was not paid for through taxes and instead through charitable donations, you would make the same level of contribution?[/i]

If welfare was not paid through taxes and instead through charitable donations, the level of contribution would I make is not for you to know.

by maxwell edison

Okay, I'll see your "Black American", and raise you two more! (pun intended - race card, poker lingo, .....)

http://www.townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/archive.shtml

http://www.townhall.com/columnists/WalterEWilliams/2007/04/18/a_minority_view_exploiting_ignorance

http://www.amazon.com/Civil-Rights-Rhetoric-Thomas-Sowell/dp/0688062695

http://www.amazon.com/Knowledge-Decisions-Thomas-Sowell/dp/0465037380

http://www.blueagle.com/books/sowellculturebooks.html

People like you who refuse to "get over" the race issue will ALWAYS continue the race issue. It's the leftist race-baiters who are the real racists in America today.

by tony hopkinson

It was an allegory, obviously you couldn't find
anything else in my post to refute.

I'll make a spleling mistake next time, give you some ammunition.

by maxwell edison

you suggested that I ask a "black American" about slavery (I forgot the exact question), and I linked to a "black American" who has some views about slavery that are quite different than the "black mainstream" (or your "white guilt" mainstream -- yes, I'm assuming).

Here's another:

http://www.creators.com/opinion/walter-williams/regrets-for-slavery.html

and another:

http://capmag.com/article.asp?ID=968

and another:

http://capmag.com/article.asp?ID=89

and he believes this:

[i]"History is not going to be kind to liberals. With their mindless programs, they've managed to do to Black Americans what slavery, Reconstruction, and rank racism found impossible: destroy their family and work ethic."[/i]
- Walter Williams (American who happens to be black)

That particular "black American" doesn't use the crutch of something that happened ~150 years ago, he doesn't live in the past, and "slavery" is a non-issue to him.

You asked, and I answered.

by absolutely

Tony isn't very good at it -- keeps playing the same cards, even when it's obvious he doesn't even have the right ones.

by absolutely

Some employers, and creditors, offer plans, for a small fee, that in effect insure against unemployment. These are available on an opt-in basis and are affordable to those providing them, in contrast to the government, which is deeply in debt, and projects its "protected" social security account to be on its way, irrevocably, to bankruptcy also. An inconvenient truth is that welfare statism can't work for long.

by tony hopkinson

Disagree completely

How can you say policing doesn't meet an individual need, or a transport network, or national defence.

If the things we do as a community didn't meet a general individual need we wouldn't do them.

The whole point of community is to provide as a group what it would be impossible to provide for yourself as an individual.

The system we both enjoy success in, guarantees that not everybody can provide for themselves.

by tony hopkinson

Agreed.
Institutionalised welfare is a long term disaster.

I could afford to pay in to private health care, I could afford unemployment insurance.

I can't afford them and public though, not without giving up much else.

It's a horrible fact but our economies are not strong enough to pay everyone a living wage.
If you take out the contribution that those of us who can afford it, there won't be enough left to provide for others.
Those on the poverty line, are unemployed more often and ill more often.

Employees are costs, less of them equals more profit. We'll never do anything about welfare in a system where that is true.

by maxwell edison

.....the kind of "needs" we're talking about. If you want to discuss it with me, stay focused on that. But if you want to divert to police protection, etc. (like deepsand), then go play your game with somebody else. Disingenuousness is all you're showing (also like deepsand). There's a distinction that you people (and you know who "you people" are) continue to cross and/or fail to see when confronted with an argument you cannot counter or an admission about yourselves that you can't bring yourself to make.

by tony hopkinson

You want to cut one factor out of a whole and say see this is what's wrong!.

At least credit me with some intelligence only a complete idiot would think the only impact on society of stopping welfare would be an increase in our personal spending power.

Neither of us are in a position to say whether welfare is a requirement or not, WE would only need it under the most extreme of circumstances. It's that excess that we contribute that pays for those who do.

Not one alternative Maxwell. You want to argue from self interest fine, don't deride me for arguing from what I see as mine.

I am not prepared to pay the price of no alternative to welfare, if you think there isn't one you are at best naive.

I don't want to see no welfare because then I could afford more holidays.
I want to see welfare end because it's demeaning, vicious, self serving and will eventually cost more than any of us could pay.

The latter of course is happening now, it's what makes you so strident. Welfare does not get people off welfare. It stops being a safety net and starts being a crutch. Take the crutch away and you end up with some angry non plussed bugger limping after your ass. Then you get to pay in a different way.

Unlike you I don't have the option of shooting the poor b'stard.

Me me me, I've heard that before, seen it in action, it didn't work.
When the wheels fell off everybody suffered, and wheels always fall off eventually.

It's not a lasting solution either, if you can't provide a living wage then you must provide subsistence otherwise society or community is a bad joke.

Suggest putting them all in the army and invading a couple more axes of evil type countries, at least they'd get fed, clothed and have medical attention.
Course that would cost more than welfare and you'd have to fund it, from your taxes.

But at least there would be something to discuss.

by tonythetiger

There was once a time when I thought I needed some of them, but when I called them and they didn't come (because their fire truck was too heavy for the bridge??), I learned that I really didn't. The only other times I need them is to clean up their own messes.

The highway thing is convenient at times, and it's nice that they pick up the garbage occasionally (would be nicer if they didn't lock out private competition.), but "need" is not what I'd call it.

by maxwell edison

.....on government spending, the parties involved must concede that there are really two kinds: one is to maintain the basic cost of government, which includes salaries for the elected officials, maintaining the buildings in which they work, roads, highways and such, the cost of maintaining the military and police protection, and so on; the second being strictly a social function, such as any and all programs that force one citizen, in some way, to literally support the needs (or wants) of another.

You said, [i]"To Maxwell ..... Disagree completely ..... How can you say policing doesn't meet an individual need, or a transport network, or national defence.[/i] The question I asked was, [i]"The state, generally speaking, should not provide for individual needs. Do you agree or disagree?[/i]

YOU are the one who brought up police, transportation network, and national defense, not me. You know damn well that the intent of my question was to address the second of the aforementioned kinds of government spending. YOU are the one who deserved your [i]Oh please![/i] comment. Moreover, YES, I DO want to cut one factor out when discussing the other. They are unrelated and serve different functions. If you don't concede that obvious point, you ARE the type of idiot you mentioned. Moreover, you also insist on pigeon-holing absolutely every transfer of money (from one citizen to another) program as "welfare". In the USA, we have millionaires collecting government money (or services) that was taken from mere thousandaires (Yes, I made up that word; at least I think I did!) -- anything but the image conjured up when one mentions "welfare".

YES, Tony, the two different kinds of government spending SHOULD be discussed separately.

So I ask again, [i]"The state, generally speaking, should not provide for individual needs. Do you agree or disagree?[/i] Of course, you DO disagree. You DO believe in myriad social services. That, my British friend, makes you a Socialist. (At least some form of Socialist.) From my perspective the socialist cure is much worse than any libertarian ailment it attempts to mend. And my guess is, you espouse such a "cure" to relieve the guilt of your own success or comfort. Well give away the fruits of your own success, Tony, and give others the right to decide what to do with their own. Like I said, "you people" are willing to give the shirt of someone else's back.

by tig2

Greater good as a concept sounds great. We all pitch in together because we are all interested in a greater good.

Yeah, right.

"Greater Good" is the rationale they make when they want to take money I earn and give it to someone else. When they give it to services that I use and benefit from, I am happy. When they give it to most social programmes, I am not so happy.

I am a Christian. Someone show me where I have been guilty of deciding that my greater good (expression of my faith) has ever been to the detriment of YOUR greater good (perhaps being of another belief). My greater good means little to me beyond my ability to continue to inhabit my corner of the world and live to the end of my days.

But the "Greater Good" theory means that I am not necessarily paying for things I believe in. In fact, it points out the ways I am paying for things I do NOT believe have a place.

I have gone through some amazingly BAD times. When that safety net should have been there, it wasn't. The net result was that I spent a lot of time on a friend's sofa, trying to survive and taking day labour because that was all I could do under the circumstances at the time. If you don't think that bites, guess again.

What killed me was being told that all I had to do was live my life in a completely irresponsible manner and I would be eligible for anything the State could offer. Have children out of wedlock? Free meal ticket.

When I finally went to the State agency for help, I was sick and hurting. I stayed sick for a long time. The experience still hurts.

The waiting rooms were filled with people wearing enough jewelry to have kept me going for a month. But they were there to make sure those cheques from the State kept coming.

I, on the other hand, could be given little. Wrong colour, wrong ethnicity, wrong family size.

The "greater good" presumes that everyone using the system will use it only for the intended purpose. To work their way out of a jam. That is NOT how it works.

I did day labour as a homeless person between chemo treatments. That money- $6.00/hour was taxed for the "greater good"- the same people who were wearing enough jewelry to have kept me from that point.

The good news? I survived. Am I bitter? Gosh, I hope not. I try not to be. Am I better informed today than I was then? Yep. Saw it all with my own two eyes. haven't forgotten that. Do I appreciate being taxed to the eyeballs for those slugs? NO. I DO NOT.

Please keep in mind- MY opinion. Not yours.

by absolutely

How much revenue is being lost to that type of legislation? Why is that the one you advocate removing?

by deepsand

make me withdraw, dissuade me from speaking when such is appropriate, or cause me to stoop to your level of incivility.

by deepsand

as per you view, such is the fault not of the reader but of the writer. In this regards it must be noted that maxwell long ago here proclaimed that he was the very best writer to have graced this forum. Were that the case, why then was not greater care given to avoiding such ambiguity?

by tonythetiger

[i]But somewhere somewhen if the state doesn't provide from taxes what needs providing, then it will be provided from some other part of your income.[/i]

What exactly "needs providing"? And why should those who [b]choose[/b] to work harder be burdened with paying more for it?

by tonythetiger

[i] Hah, I defend it only because those who talk about removing it wish to do it for their own personal gain and their societies cost.[/i]

making these people get off their duffs and working will help society. My personal benefit is secondary.

[i]Do you think stopping it will cure societies ills, will everyone just buck up and go out mowing lawns and flipping burgers?[/i]

You would be surprised what motivated humans are capable of :)

by tonythetiger

[i]As for your last point, I agree wholeheartedly, I'm just not so wide eyed an innocent to believe that's where the money would be spent.[/i]

And where would it be spent? On stuff? Then someone who makes stuff will have to hire more people to make more stuff. and then what, those people who are newly hired will have money to buy stuff, which will require even more people to make.

by absolutely

[i]"As for your last point, I agree wholeheartedly, I'm just not so wide eyed an innocent to believe that's where the money would be spent."

And where would it be spent? On stuff? Then someone who makes stuff will have to hire more people to make more stuff. and then what, those people who are newly hired will have money to buy stuff, which will require even more people to make.[/i]

You forgot one possibility, jdclyde, which is an INDESCRIBABLE BLACK HOLE OF TERROR to leftists: the money might be ... (cue spooky music, stupid teenagers walking [b]up the stairs, for chrissakes[/b], to see what is making the strange sawing noise) ... [b]INVESTED!!![/b] In that case, nobody will be hired as a bank teller, investment manager, market analyst ... Wait, none of those things are true, either.

If it's "invested", that means it's being [b]spent[/b], on something profitable, which means that [b]people are choosing to buy it[/b].

Bad socialists, no cookie!