Discussion Locked

I'm Not a Pirate, But I know A few ARGGH

0 helpful
33 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
This is something that has been festering for a couple of weeks now so I am gonna let it dump here. There was a discussion about Piracy and the fact that it is a bad thing, which it is I concede. The part that frosts me is this, everyone was talking about how it is morally and ethically wrong to Pirate, how it costs companies billions in rev. Blah blah blah. No one stops to think that the software we are suing right now be it windows or mac was, initially, Pirated from IBM. I dunno, if not bill and steve would this be a unix/linux world?

33 replies

by jkaras

Piracy to me is not morally or ethically wrong. CEO's etc... make a ridiculous amout of profit margin that is figured into to price of said product to compensate for any variance in profit whether it be software, movies, or music. These greedy individuals havent worked a hard day in their life and they dont care whether you are satisfied with said product or not, only profit. They use spin doctoring to their employees to take the company's side with "its coming out of your paycheck and future of the company if allowed" Lets face it, even if they received a higher margin of profit without any piracy, do you think for 1 second that they would invest in their employees rather than giving themselves a big fat raise as a reward for their genius? Better insurance, raises, I think not. We make them rich off our ideas and hard work, they just distribute the product and claim the success for themselves. These are the same people that steal ideas from others and put out their own version and ifyou had an idea they would steal it from you and attack you with a fleet of lawyers so you would never seee a dime. Where's their morality or ethics? I say we have a right to even the score because no one will play the game of life with morality, especially at the cost of $s. HARRR ME MATIES PLUNDER AT WILL!!!!

by mallardtooxx

I am so glad to see that there is someone here that sees the way things really are! It is so true there really is no ethical debate here just dollar signs! Like I said If it weren't for Bill and Steve we would prolly live in a Unix world right now...I think it is truly time for the Pirates to take a step up, after all it is OUR intelectual property they are pushin, not their's. Avast Matey, Sure the Mainstay and haul anchor Tis time gunnywhale these landlubbers and plunder their coffers!!!

by mrafrohead

Here's my two cents. If it is truly software that you use daily. Other than MS products, you should probably pay for it. Ie. WinRAR, Nero, your ftp program if it isn't freeware, etc...

But on the flipside. Here's something that bothers me. When you do pay for software, why is it that when you have problems with it, they never want to help you??? That's where my rage against the machine begins. They're fast as hell to take your hard earned money and then when they need to fulfil theirobligation to you and give you what you paid for, they're fast to flip you the bird.

Corporations should never ever ever pirate though. Yes, I know, I'm a hypocrit (or however it's spelled). But that's how I feel;)

One other thing though.DivX and Mp3's. I keep hearing about people that use DivX and Mp3's that we're all just pir8's. BS - please read here----> I have mp3's of ALL of my cd's. It's hella faster to just point and click and not have to get up to find a disk, than look for the disk and put it in the tray and wait for the drive to spin up. Not to mention same for movies.

So now that I'm off track and getting close to the limit, I'm done for now, but shall return later. Don't forget, don't use the hook to get the birds crap out yer eye matie.

Mrafrohead

by lou

everything you do or create is so well done that only you have access to it. You reasoning is pathetic. You state that companies make enough money etc etc. I ran a BBS back in the 80's. I understand most of the arguments for pirating BUT if you lefta door or window open in your house or should someone find a deposit slip with your account number on the bottom,does that give them the right to steal from you because they feel that you have extra?
Mainly you spew out garbage about companies should spend extra money on employees and benefits BUT YOU! are the cause of them not being able to. You are sucking illegally from bonuses to workers, better health benfits, better woorking conditions because you are a thief. The next time you see a poor person huddling in a corner outdoors on a cold night, look at him and at yourself and decide if you helped him not have aa warm meal or a place to stay because you are a thief!

by jkaras

Because of me? Really? I caused the crash of Enron that families future is lost while they(Big Wigs) live it up not going to jail, Xerox hiding 3.8 billion of false revenue, amid all the rest of the other corporate scandals let alone that both George W. and Dicky Cheney were both guilty while they were head of major corporations and got away with corporate spending that cheated the government in taxes, the investors, and employees? Our president and vice pres. who now passed a law that can onlytarget any CEO presently engaged in this behavior exanorating their past crimes! This our world where we are living and I dont like it.

by road-dog

It seems that there are a lot of folks posting here about "evil" CEOs living lavishly at the expense of the downtrodden masses slaving away in their cubicles.

The spectacular crashes of several large corporations and the spotlighted abuses of some corporate executives makes the news whenever found. The vast majority of companies "doing it right" don't make the news.

If one were to generalize upon the postings in this thread, one could assume:
1) Employees feel justified in stealing from the company, they are unworthy of trust.
2) Employees feel that they are entitled to the same perks and pay scales as highly trained and experienced Senior Management; regardless of education and risk.
3) No matter how much is expended on pay, bonuses, and benefits, employees will still feel deprived if they earn less than Management.

Suffice it to say, why should Management treat you better? If they are all painted with the same wide brush as the worst among them, why shouldn't they treat you exactly as they treat the worst, most unproductive, and least valuable employee.

Don't treat every CEO like Kenneth Lay, unless you want to be regarded as Wally from Dilbert.

by madroxxx

One thing that kind of skews the figures is when companies assume that everyone using pirated copies would buy the product if pirating wasn't an option. Not true, software packages are so expensive that many would do without rather than buy.
WhileI agree software for business use should be purchased, I really don't feel guilty about installing a pirated copy of windows on the computer I gave to the poor kids down the street. It didn't cost Bill anything. If anything I might have just createdsome future customers for him down the road since these kids might now grow up computer literate.

by tomsal

Two wrongs don't make a right, as the old as dirt saying goes.

No one said being ethical, moral or just generally being above the "crap and BS" that is the vast majority of corporate society these days --- is easy. If it were easy than no one on earth would ever stress about doing the right thing.

That said -- I fully agree with the points raised about the a$$hole CEOs and how executives take full advantage of their employess who in turn bust their arse 50-60 hours a week (average) and get walked over and shafted on their end of the deal.

That enrages me like you wouldn't believe actually. But again, stealing - and lets call it what it is...its stealing. The terminology of "piracy" only helps aid in de-sensitizing the real crime. Finally that's the fundamental wrong with it -- as long as its AGAINST THE LAW, it shouldn't be done - especially in corporations. That's just blind stupidity if you ask me.

Personally, if you go to my house right now and look through all the software you'd find not a single piece of stolen software. Oh I mean "pirated". I have made audio CDs - but guess what they are all songs off CDs I own anyway.

95% of all the hard nose arguments FOR pirating are just excuses if you ask me. Yeah the world of licensing and copyright laws and the way we the IT workers get shafted sucks like a hoover in the middle of a hurricane - that's life. Deal with it.

Cry to someone else.

by jkaras

Also it's been our computer history that computer technology is held back to insure maximum profit telling the consumer that what they bought a year ago is already obsolite and need to upgrade to run anything. Everyone in this time lives with the struggle to make ends meet and strech a dollar to provide any kind of future for ourselves as well as our families while dealing with this greed inflation and lack of quality. Think about the 3rd world countries that work for these companies paying them sweat shop pay, outsourcing support to phone centers that wont help you. (had that job too!)Morality and business dont work together in our dog eat dog world, call me a pessimist, I prefer realist. So if this is stealing then we are all thieves guilty of stealing. I'm proud to be a thief then and I will brag about it like I'm one bad mutha from prison, lol!!!

by jkaras

I understand your point of view and share them in the professional world that everything has to be by the numbers, that's business. However, all electronics that I have owned in my life time has had a record button on it from boombox to vcr to tevo to computer. The technology has always allowed it, only now are movies, software, and music companies are singin the blues crying over an injustice of lost revenue. If it is stealing then, when we record a tv program, music, etc... is it still stealing, are we all criminals then? Are we guilty of owning stolen merchandise (vcr, tape recorders), if then explain how Curcuit City is still legally in business? No, it's stealing only if we profit from selling the pirated product, then yes it's stealing. These corporate machines over price their product to compensate for loss variables, and the retoric used that the price you pay increases due to theft is the biggest lie. Trust me I used to be a manager for the biggest home improvement company and I'll tell you how much they cheat the customer while smiling in your face catering to your ego and takin you for a ride. ( it was my job) Dont take this wrong but I sincerley doubt that if I went into your house and looked at all your computers inthe house I doubt that you bought every os or software on all systems let alone the copy you gave to friends, family, and for some maybe not you used your copy to repair side customers(this repair point is stealing, conciede) or boss's pc.

by pallan

1. There are legal uses for a VCR, and a tape recorder, a CD burner, etc. There are also illegal uses. Recording a copy of a CD which you purchased legally is fine, unless you start distributing copies. It is legal to record TV shows for the purpose of time shifting. Your argument seems to ignore the legal uses of the above mentioned equipment. Using your logic, car dealerships are in the business of selling murder weapons.

2. Yes, much of what is sold to us is overpriced. How this justifies stealing is beyond me. We're not talking about stealing a loaf of bread to feed our families here, we're talking about stealing Windows XP, the latest PC game, or productivity software. If you think a product is overpriced - DON'T BUY IT.There are competing products that can often be legally acquired FOR FREE. Price inflation does not justify theft.

3. I bought none of the software I use at home. Everything I use at home is open source, and acquired legally. The only non-OSS software I use is the occaisional game, which I buy and play under WineX.

by tomsal

You are right I did trade software with friends and family...shareware, free and demo CDs that come bundled with certain magazines I subscribe too. :)

But seriously, I'm not trying to be self-righteous or come off like I'm a saint...that would bea huge lie if I said that. Trust me. ;)

I used to copy games left and right back in the days of the commodore 64, I cracked the games and copied then. I never sold them mind you, but at 8 to 10 years old, I used the excuse then that I didn't knowany better. Believe me, I know plenty hackers, crackers and guys who run warez sites - if I wanted to I could get a Win 2000 Advanced Server, the latest MS Office, I could get pratically any new game -- all for free. I just need to ask and it would be done. But I don't.

Trust me the temptation is there, but I just don't.

Now for your point about why record buttons are on VCRs and tape players..etc... I wondered that too at one time. Then a lawyer (met at a social gathering) explained thatthe difference is - if the broadcast is publically available (ie. Radio, network TV) or you pay for it (ie. premium TV - HBO, etc.) than the LAW says YOU ARE ALLOWED to copy it for your own private use/viewing/etc. But you can't (even though most people do) distribute it to anyone for profit or otherwise.

With software you can NOT compare the two - it is NOT the same as recording a show with your VCR. A cable show (or network TV show,etc.) doesn't have a license agreement before the show. Software does.

Your assumption is wrong - search my house you'll find no pirated software. If I do have a copy I didn't pay for, I got a copy from work - with a valid license. Call it a small perk of being IT at my company.

by miamipctech

I agree with you, I would however spared the obscenities. We live in a politically correct societies where everyone is preocupied with not hurting someone elses feelings and watering down the truth. The Truth is the software companies make lots and lots of moneys making a selected few extremely wealthy and their work force continue not being adequately being compenesated for the fruit of their labor. It is also true that the prices for Microsoft Products (just to jump on the Microsoft Bashing wagon are outrageous). The greateast truth is this. You and me are not responsible for someone elses actions/injustices/mal-practices/sins/illegal acts. We (you and me) are responsible for our own actions. Piracy is stealing is plain and simple. Black and white. I know this concept seems out there in a grayscale world, but absolutes are still out there for those who are willing to live a moral/ethical life.

by tomsal

You are right - it all comes down to how we as individuals decide the life we want to live.

As for my earlier post - there's valid reasons for the "edge" I put on it. First I've gone through this topic at least 50 times arguing with people who'llearnestly try and convince the world there's some kind of twisted justice in stealing software. So many people pirate its not funny (and I'd love someone to explain how when people steal it doesn't affect the price of goods for the honest consumer -that's a crock).

As for the CEOs - I was being nice by just using the word I did. How many honest people lost 401ks, life savings because of greedy, bull-headed CEOs? How many CEO's draw fat paychecks and HUGE benefits even when they are laying off hundreds even thousands of workers. I retract NOTHING about CEO's, yes some are good and decent so I probably should make a carpet statement. But I'm not big on people profiting on the detriment of their workers (who in effect help pay for those fancy cars, mansions and fat expense accounts). I love it when I see on the news that the government is busting a CEO for such things.

I just say it as I see it - I don't sugar coat.

Your post was a good post and I agree with it.

Merry Christmas

by road-dog

If you are on somebody's payroll as an employee, they are paying you for your time, effort, and knowledge. What you develop on their dime is theirs, not yours.

Look at it this way, If you hire somebody to paint your house before selling it, how much do you owe them? The answer is whatever you agreed to pay for the job. Their sweat does not translate to ownership of your house in any way.

As for credit, yes employees are due credit for good, bottom line friendly activities. If your supervisor doesn't acknowledge your performance, then so be it. Decide for yourself if you are happy working there.

by madroxxx

It wasn't. Dos(QDOS) was bought increddibly cheap but thats just shrewed business. But his point was still valid. Microsoft stole Double space and packaged it into DOS. Windows was also pretty much ripped of from apples lisa O/S.

by leehellcat

I agree, in the corporate world their is no need for Pirate software. Most companies make enough money that they can afford the extorsionate prices that Mr Gates charges for his sub standard software.......
....But, how can you realistically expecta home user to fork out $300 for the next version of Windows, and another $600 on the latest and greatest version of Office.

Now the arguments that Piracy would not exist if CD Writers did not exist is rubbish, there is always a way to copy software. In truth if the price of software was somewhere near realistic the the majority of people using pirate software would not bother.
I have to say, I am yet to join the Linux clan, but it gets more and more tempting. Maybe in the new year.
Lets just hope that with Linux gaining more ground on MS that Bill gets the idea into his head that we don't have $1000 to spend on a computer, and then another $1000 to spend on lining his pockets to make it work !!

by pallan

Yes, and of course Apple came up with the idea of a windowed OS all by itself. Oh wait, it started development on that project after the Steves were blown away by X. Double space is disk compression, and if you can convince me that it is possible to "steal" an idea as basic as disk compression Amazon.com owes you a job defending the one-click patent.

It's often been said that there are no new ideas. Everything is just a variation of something that's already been done. That's probably not true. However in this case it underlines the fundamental problem of arguing about who stole what and from whom when we don't have a full understanding of the history behind the product.

by mallardtooxx

Windows Which is a direct decendant of MS dos is a blatant rip off of unix. Look at your command structures in linux and then compare them to ms dos. Windows 1.0 was actually a scab of the unix visual operating systems of the mid seventies. Bill gates is the Master Pirate. People seem to think that he is a software genius....no he is a really good pirate and a hellafine businessman. It is not that I condone Piracy, but, I think it is funny how people tend to forget what the world was like before Microsoft

by pallan

DOS and Windows share some things in common with Unix variants. Directory structures, similar command names, etc. Windows, in its early stages, was a rip off of Apple's work, which was in turn a rip off of the X Consortium's work. At worst Microsoft infringed several patents in DOS and Windows, but since the holders of those patents didn't file suit, that point is moot. Nothing there is pirated.

by pallan

If I'm Microsoft, I can realistically expect people to "fork out" $300 for Windows and $600 for Office. Why? Because *they do*. Time and time again, they do. Despite the fact that they don't need it, they buy it. Release a new version of Windows, people flock to buy it without considering whether or not it's needed. Same thing goes for Office. The fact is, there alternatives to these products who's prices start at *free*. People spend that $900 *by choice*. If they *choose* not to spend that $900, they have no right to use the products.

Your arguments would only hold any truth if there were literally no alternatives. However, most home and SOHO users (remember, they're the ones you're arguing have a right to steal) can get allthe functionality they want from A Linux/OpenOffice combination. Price? $0. Arguments that Linux isn't ready for the average user are at least a year out of date, an installation of any of the 7.x RedHats is no more difficult than Windows. Most people rave that Mandrake is easier yet. That doesn't even take into account pay-for-use (but still relatively cheap) distros like Xandros and Lindows which have been designed to capture the newbie market.

by madroxxx

They actually packaged the competing product, were sued and then had to pay retributions for the theft.
I do agree that the windowed os was not apples idea but I didn't feel like typing out a 10 page history of windows in order to defend the point.

by jkaras

I appreciate and respect your opinion and mean no disrespect to your character or to anyone who differs from my opinion, if it came off that way then I apologize, I want no bad blood mearly stating opinion. But we both agree that having it is personally subjective right or wrong vs. making a profit is wrong was my point. My piracy is only for my personal use, not for gain much like any recording. I dont see the difference because a licensing agreement, I'll conciede that I maybe cheating, but not a thief or crimminal. I think everyone is guilty somewhere in their life of these petty indescretions, maybe not you, but most whether recording your favorite song off the radio rather than buying the over priced cd that has 3 songs worth listening. Worldwide consumers are rebelling against this all flash no substance that milk people of as much money as possible, unfinished products requiring patches/upgrades, 4 differnt dvd versions of your favorite movie etc.. The one good that has come about is the fear that these corporations are forced to realize that people wont stand for it much longer and hopefully a change can come through where everyone can play nice, it's a nice hope and one I hope to witness in the future.

by jkaras

My point of having some mp3s or not buying a second copy of windows for my other pc didnt cause a homeless person to live like that. I dont see the harm in it any other than recording a song off the radio for personal use, its the same for me. I'm not sampling because they have more money and deserve to be cheated. I just dont have much sympathy for these individuals that ruin lives for their profit, who make toasts that "poverty sucks" at the private club they attend that costs more than most families make in a year, give excuses why they can only have the cheapest hmo for employees, claim there isnt enough to give a raise that keeps up with inflation, while they get a 30,000 raise for their brilliant decision making. I'm not out to offend anyone merely make a point that its not something that I'm going to go to jail or prision over. My sampling isnt the cause of the domino effect that the U.S.A. is currently in. These companies post profits well beyond their employee staffing and choose not to take care of the people that make it possible for them to live the lavish lifestyle. this discussion is merely a way to open eyes, not make excuses, we the people have the power and we give it over to these people without a fight ensuringthem power over us. Rather than arguing with one another on plays into their hands where our predictament never changes. I know this sounds rough but I'm not accusing you of wrong doing I just differ in opinion and not splitting hairs over the definition of stealing. I sencerley hope everyone has a great holiday season full of happiness the those who matter to them most, and if what I say offends, again it's and opinion not something personal.

by maxpower1111

I would like to have a happy holiday, but if what lou says is true, I'm gonna end up homeless because you made some archival back-ups of your software. We all know that making an archival back-up is a good measure to protect your investment........isn't it?

by madroxxx

"If I do have a copy I didn't pay for, I got a copy from work - with a valid license. Call it a small perk of being IT at my company."

So you would rather steal from your boss than pirate software?

by mrafrohead

He prolly means the same thing as when your work buys you books and crap. When you quit and move on you get to keep the books. Probably the same thing.

Since I'm posting again though, I want to clarify something. I noticed a few references to people profiting off of pirating sw. I personally don't see anything wrong with sharing. But if you are making a profit off of someone else's work, then you should be stoned to death or maybe even caned like that winey kid that was tagging cars. That's one of the most disrespectful things that you can do to another. But that's just my opinion.

Mrafrohead

by maxpower1111

Let me guess. Ether you are the CEO, or your CEO reads TecRepublic. LOL
On a serious note. I agree that not all CEO's fit that profile, i.e. the one that runs my company (I could use a raise too). High-level corporate administrators in general do tend to put more emphasis on the company's well being than the employees. Whether it is a conscious behavior or just loosing sight of the fact that the employees are the company is debatable. Surely you must see how some people can feel the way so many do about the American corporate Emperors.

by mallardtooxx

Road-dog You are right. I think you hit your mark on this last post. But I am going to also say this. I have sat on both sides of the fence, I have been a cubicle peon that druges his day out in hopes that the clock will somehow speed up. But through hard work, a little luck and a lot of risk I jumped the wall and defected to upper management. I must say, there is a very skewed image of the untold masses. I got to the point where I found myself defending the "minions" more often than the "slavedrivers" In my way earlier post I missed my mark, I think it is unfortunate that so many bright and gifted young tech people are forced away because they are overworked and under paid. I also concede that it is not fair to paint everyone with the same color here. For every Kenneth Lay there are 20 good guys/gals in the drivers seat. YOur point was well made, well taken and greatly appreciated. Sometimes the threads seem to get a little tangled.

by djent

Was it Apple that stole Xerox's GUI or MS that stole Apple's GUI or Lotus's spreadsheet, and so on and so forth. In a recent MS quarterly statement, they disclosed for the first time, desktop OS profit margin of 85%. And they whine about slow adoption rates, Linux defections, piracy and the rifraf in Tahiti. I feel alot more benolence toward the hungry stealing carrots from my garden then Ken Lay stealing my 401K. We all determine our own morality, St. Peter isn't a Vegas matre'd and Bill G. isn't a saint.

by lou

No you are not the cause... you are a symtom with whats wrong with America, I, ME, MINE.

This discussion is closed to new replies.