Discussion Locked

Importance of Cache size on larger HDD?

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

How important is the Cache on Larger HDD's
Does it really matter if you get one with a larger cache or is the access speed of more importance.
Perhaps it may be a combination of the two!
Do Larger drives have an access delay problem?
I think they do. At least so on my older PII.

7 replies

by maxwell edison

Hard drive cache is a temporary data storage area used to enhance drive performance. Larger buffer cache size can result in improved drive performance. A faster drive on top of that will improve performace even more. Rotational speed is a major factor in hard drive performance, as it determines how quickly data can be retrieved. Typical rotational speeds are 5400 RPM or 7200 RPM for desktops, and 4200 RPM for notebooks. Normally, the faster the disk spins, the quicker the drive (faster access/seek times and higher transfer rates). For performance reasons, 7200 RPM or higher is usually recommended. 7200 RPM drives for standard desktops are the current norm.

by maxwell edison

More on chche:

Data cannot travel directly between the disk and the interface because each operates at a different speed. The cache acts as a buffer, matching the speeds of the two. Second, disk cache acts as a holding tank for data retrieved from the disk, improving performance.

When a read command arrives at the hard drive, the disk drive decodes the command and checks for the requested data in the cache. If the cache does not contain the requested data, the drive retrieves the data from the disk. At the same time, it reads ahead on the disk for more data than what was requested. All that data is saved in the cache. Since many applications process data sequentially, it is likely that the next read request will be for data that follows the last request. Retrieving data from the cache takes much less time than from the disk-microseconds, as opposed to the milliseconds required for the arm to move and the disk to spin. Thus, if the data is supplied from the cache, performance can be greatly enhanced.

by maxwell edison

You asked, "How important is the Cache on Larger HDD's"?

Answered above. Larger buffer cache size can result in improved drive performance. So if improved drive performance is important to you, then cache size is important.

You asked, "Does it really matter if you get one with a larger cache or is the access speed of more importance"?

Answered above. But to elaborate, disk caching is a performance enhancement feature designed to increase overall speeds. Caching is more of an enhancement than drive speed, but both are important, and both are measured in milliseconds - less than a blink of an eye.

You asked, "Do Larger drives have an access delay problem"?

Answer: No, not generally speaking. But some larger drives may not compatible with older operating systems and/or older hardware. You mentioned that you have a Pentium II, but no mention of the operating system, processor speed, motherboard specifications, BIOS versions, and so on, all of which could have a factor on hard drive performance and/or compatibility. You also didn't mention what you consider a larger drive - and relative to what? A 15 GB drive might be considered small for a Windows 2000 Server running on a Pentium II 400 MHz, but large for Pentium II 266 MHz desktop running Windows 95 and/or certain motherboards with older BIOS versions that don't support drives over 8 GB.

If you're having a specific problem, I might suggest that you spell it out specifically, providing all the particular details, instead of asking such general questions.

by thechas

Too add to what Maxwell posted on the second half of your question:

Your PII system likely has a UDMA or UDMA33 IDE controller.
A newer drive that has ATA100 or 133 data transfer rates needs to run in a compatibility mode to function on older hardware.
Depending on your specific drive and controller, this could cause a slight slowdown.

A more likely cause of slow access would be the use of the drive manufactures BIOS overlay software to get around any drive size limits on the PC itself.
These software solutions for large hard drives can cause the system to take more time for data transfer off of the drive as you have an extra layer of drivers between the drive and the PC.

Another factor that can cause a large drive to appear slower than a smaller drive is how the files are stored on the drive, and the seek time of the drive.

If you have 2 hard drives with equal seek times, the smaller drive can seem to be faster as it has fewer clusters to check for the file.

Chas

by johann2_2

I would like to rectify the situation. I will now give all details. Thanks for the input!

My PC is A Dell GX1 PII 450 Mhz, 100 Mhz Bus speed. 256 Mb of PC 100 RAM, 32 Mb Vodoo 3/2000 Video Card
I have two HDD. The first is a 13Gb HDD running @ 5400 RPM My newest drive is a Quatum 120Gb HDD running @ 7200 and it has a built in 2Gb Cache. I am also using a Creative Labs Sound Blaster Live. Not a Value Card. It has an onboard 4 Mb Video card but it is disabled in the Bios. Oh Sorry! My Bios is Flashable and I have done so for over 5 years, so it is the latest from Dell. I would like to inform all possible respondents that I have always considered this to be one of dells lemons. I love the machine and because of the problems I have become very familiar with all of the components built into the board. My Monitor is an Optiquest 775 (#2 in the year it was bought) If there are any further questions I would be most happy to respond and of course as always I am very happy to hear any and all responses.

by wlbowers

The larger cache helps with the faster transfer of data.

Specs that will affect data transfer.

RPM speed of drive. They are up to 15,000rpm now.
Cache. 2mb is the norm. 8mb for high performance
Seek Times. These run from 9ms 9(slow) to 4.5ms(damn fast.

If you are having problems with your PII. I would check the bios to see if it is up to date. This is a problem with the larger drives of today and older machines.

Depending on the maker of your drive you can download a testing software that will test and certify your drive

What size drive are you using.
Who made the drive.
What OS.

Lee

This discussion is closed to new replies.