Discussion Locked

Is Black History Month Still Necessary?

0 helpful
68 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ran across this article in emagazine About.com. Here's what it said: Does the country still need to dedicate a month to learning about the contributions of African Americans? Has African American history now converged with American history, and, therefore, the celebration should be eliminated. Morgan Freeman, a long-time critic of the holiday, strongly believes that Black History Month is not just unnecessary but ?ridiculous.? According to Freeman in a December 2005 60 Minutes interview, black history should not be relegated to a month. In fact, argues Freeman, Black History, after all, is American history. So what do you think? Is Black History American History and why do we or don't we need a month set aside for it...What about Japanese History Month? or even better Indian History Month I mean the settlers wiped them out and took their land.

68 replies

by jdclyde

but because of the political climate, why is only ONE held up and has a big deal made about it?

by jdclyde

Desired by many? Yes.

I completely agree with Freemans points on this, but on the other side of the coin, it doesn't hurt me one bit as a white dude, for there to be honored, a "Black History Month".

I am not their target audience.

by jellimonsta

I agree with you on this. I don't see a need for it per se, but it has no bearing on my situation by existing.

by tink!

to those whites who get rubbed the wrong way every time focus is specifically placed on blacks.

In a sense, placing this type of emphasis by promoting such a month, is also promoting continued racial divisions. If ever we are to become one society that welcomes all races and cultures as equals, than we should stop creating special moments where all the attention is focused on one race or culture.

The more we continue to segegrate special times for one specific race, the more we create the feel of segregation within the hearts of the other races.

Black history is indeed a part of American history and is taught thusly in schools. Has been for a while now. Therefore, it really doesn't need it's own month any longer.

by jdclyde

Just imagine what would happen if there was a "White History Month"?

There are plenty of racist organizations in place for the furtherment of this single race, but just try to have instead of United Negro College Fund, we had the United White College Fund?

Hypocrites and racists, abound in the world.

Oh, that is right, you can't be racist if you aren't white. I forget that.

It is a joke to hear how MLK made more of a difference to the country than Washington or Lincoln.

by oz_media

Well you are the target audience but it doesn't make any difference. I think you are well aware that Africans were brought ot America on slave ships where they were put to work and hung for noncompliance as needed.

They then were freed, and now are far from being a visible minority in the USA. Martin Luther King, Ida Wells-Barnet etc. All made great contributions to black people living in America.

That said, we don't have caucasian day to educate black Americans on white history. I don't think it would really make any difference either, much like black history month doesn't.

A black history month used to actually have meaning, it was an opporutnity for people to focus on learning the heritage and roots of many early Americans that helped to forge the America you livein today.

With most such history being as common knowledge as white history, is there really a need to dedicate a day to learning it?

Mind you I also agree with you, if it doesn' teffect you in any way, who the hell cares? But I do see it as unnecessary these days.

I just got back from Seattle early this morning, back again this upcoming weekend, being amongst white minority in Seatlle, I'd be more interested in caucasian American history, it seems to have been pushed aside as being too prejudiced.

But there's just one thing I can get out of my head this week,

"Oh YEAH, so high and then I fell. Oh YEAH, can't stop the ringing of my funeral bell."

Hows the hunt coming along?

by jdclyde

So far, not much results.

Spending this week at the unenjoyment office taking some of their employability skills classes that local employers are looking for, just to add it to the resume, and taking the cisco classes at night.

Next week, I go visit Dow and see what they have to say for themselves. B-) Getting practice on smaller places first, but I know Dow is hiring and in my field, so that is my target.

by av .

It might be interesting to give all the nationalities a month of their own if they plan on continuing the practice.

AV

by jiminpa

At the risk of sounding prejudice No No a thousand times no! Just like I don't think we need the united Negro college fund. Maybe I am naive but I would really like to think that in this day and age we would need that type of thing. If someone would come up with the idea of white history month or the united Caucasian college fund the ACLU would be in an uproar.

by jck

And something else we don't need either:

Minority preference for college entrance or tuition aid.

You should get in based on your grades...and get financial help based upon financial need.

Not the color of your skin...
Not the gender you were born with...

But only upon accomplishment and true need.

by jdclyde

Not only do we export our old people to Florida, but we passed a law BANNING the racist practice of "Affirmative action" in the state. I was surprised it passed by as much as it did, but pleasantly so.

If the advocates of such policy weren't such racist gits, I could see giving a leg up to PEOPLE from under-served regions, but to say only blacks from that region are left behind sends the message that they MUST be inferior as a species if the other ethnic branches in the same poor regions don't need the same "hand up".

Telling an entire ethnic group they are inferior is probably NOT the best motivator in the world.

by mattie289404

Isn't racism when you base something on the color of skin or origin. So if my skin were black and I would get special treatment for college isn't that racism.

by av .

It is a very sensitive subject. A Caucasian college fund would never be seen as anything but an insult.

AV

by jck

I've always asked why we had that...never could get a straight answer.

American history is American history, and even as old as I am I was taught about Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr., Rosa Parks, Crispus Attucks, Malcolm X, Jesse Owens, George Washington Carver, et. al.

Fact is, if we want to end segregation we have to end the call for it...completely.

I agree with Morgan Freeman. It is wrong to those of [b]any[/b] heritage in our history books to have their history limited to one period of time of the year. It should all be part of our history that is focused on and studied the year round.

I think the real reason it exists...is so that guys who were huge proponents of it (like Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton) are guaranteed paid speaking gigs that month.

by jdclyde

is because any White politician that DARED to talk out against it would be toast.

Equality is not equally dispersed.

It IS an insult to MLK's memory to take his birthday off. The mans dream was to be able to WORK as equals, so WORK your ass off. It is little wonder these have become quiet jokes to anyone on the outside (not black). They have been hijacked.

The shame is, when Jessie first started up, he had a lot of good things to say. To bad he got into the money/corrupt politics of it and lost his way. He had the makings of being a GREAT man. Now he is the joke of a nation. (still better than Sharpton or Rangel.)

http://wcbstv.com/breakingnewsalerts/charles.rangel.investigation.2.824777.html

http://thehill.com/leading-the-news/ethics-committee-launches-formal-rangel-probe-2008-09-24.html

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/16/AR2008091601938.html

by jck

[i]It IS an insult to MLK's memory to take his birthday off. The mans dream was to be able to WORK as equals, so WORK your ass off. It is little wonder these have become quiet jokes to anyone on the outside (not black). They have been hijacked.[/i]

Everyone gets MLK off that works for an employer that gets federally recognized holidays.

I mean if that's the measure of why not to take off, then no one should take off Christmas...cause that's an insult to Jesus. He died for your sins so you could live and work without fear of going to Hell...right?

We all get it off...take it off.

Or what about Labor Day? Isn't that insult to ALL workers??

Jesse Jackson....GREAT?????? Nah. He was being an adulterer before Clinton was. Go figure.

You're keepin my brotha Clinton down!!! :^0

by notsochiguy

...who was probably the only person to benefit from the assassination of MLK (or, as I'm sure he'd prefer me to say, the first one to duck was the first one to make a buck)????

I'm not saying...

I'm just saying.

by av .

Obama is President of the US and has forever proved that the playing field is level for all Americans, black, white or other.

Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton need a new gig. Their arguments no longer stand up.

Morgan Freeman focused on the fact that maybe something like Black History Month shouldn't exist anymore. I think he might be right.

AV

by ksoniat

I saw an ad for the "Black Pages" just last night. A listing of businesses owned by blacks to be supported by other blacks. I had never seen that before.

I'm in the "no skin off my nose" category too, but know there would be an uproar is the "White pages" actually just meant no "yellow pages".

by jdclyde

because you are a racist if you object....

What a crock of sheet.

Sorry, can't use transferred guilt to control me or manipulate me. I have zero "white guilt".

by oz_media

I have no guilt at all for what my ancestors have done and the horrific past actions of white history.

I don't expect anyone else to bear such guilt for their race either.

Germany, I have every reason in the world to resent Germany and Germans. My home town, my parents, my grandparents, my great grand parents all suffered the atrocities that Nazi Germany put upon Southern England. I still remember finding bits of Spitfire or Luftwaffe planes in the fields and near bunkers back home when 'playing war' as a kid.

But my family and ancestors went to war to fight for their country, their Prime Minister who sent them there too.

Germans, even those that have moved to England and America were called back to fight for their homeland.

Just like Amerircans today, Germans in 1939 had no idea what was really going on and simply fought for their homeland (Heimatland).

I have no issue with the men and women who fight for what they are lead to believe is the right and just cause, but I don't celebrate German day just to appease them either. I don't expect Germans to be sorry for what they did just as I wouldn't apologize for what my ancestors did to Germany. History is just that, something that has passed and to be learned from, which I think we all have with regards to slavery anyway, of course there will always be those who do not change, but they are few and far between. Black history month will not cure the KKK's hatred for example.

The Germans Heimatland (Homeland), coined the term "Homeland Security" (the Nazi SS), which the US later adopted themselves to describe their modern day fascist equivalent in to con the masses and rally support for a single, right way of life and to 'correct' those who live according to different religious and cultural faith. cough cough ahem...

Anyway, just because you don't celebrate doesn't mean you have forgotten but it is also not a reason to begrudge history.

by jamesrl

For Gay and Lesbians who prefer to use "gay positive" businesses.

No skin off my nose.

James

by jdclyde

a "gay negative" book would be poorly received in the press, even if there were a market for it.

Demonize what you disagree with, no matter which side of an argument you are on, is standard operating procedure.

by mattie289404

I started this thread and the input is unanimous, no need for black history month..but the disturbing underliying attitude of "no skin off my nose" will someday come back to haunt us. It is skin off our noses; I've personally witnessed on several occassions while in the AF; pilot training being denied to white person because put away for black Affirmative Action slot..it is skin of your nose when your children and childrens children lose jobs, scholarships and promotions to Affirmative Action.

by mattie289404

A business page with black owners asking for black customers and black support...just goes to show that "white guilt" is alive and well. The article should never even been allowed to run.

by jellimonsta

I didn't personally see it that way. I don't think there is a need for a < insert race here > month. But I have no issue with specific interest groups or nationalities having their own business pages (there is a Christian Business Directory here).
However EOE/AA is complete crap and I don't even want to go there (I am a government worker)!! :p ;\

by oz_media

Being in Western Canada, Richmond specifically, if the Yellow pages were for oriental immigrants. Mind you, they already have their own phone books, both white and business pages.

They tried the pink pages here too, flopped.

by jdclyde

Decades ago. [i]"I have sinned" - James Baker.[/i]

And no, Jesus died for your sins, not for the labor force or freedom of the flesh.

I have NEVER had MLK day off. It is just another day.

by jck

Colleges there have found ways to now "promote ethnic diversity"...so, it may not be a "points system" anymore at U of MI (Fraudriguez U...hahahaha).

[i]"At Wayne State University Law School in Detroit, a new admissions policy, without mentioning race, allows officials to consider factors like living on an Indian reservation or in mostly black Detroit, or overcoming discrimination or prejudice.

Others are using many different approaches, like working with mostly minority high schools, using minority students as recruiters, and offering summer prep programs for promising students from struggling high schools. Ohio State University, for example, has started a magnet high school with a focus on math and science, to help prepare potential applicants, and sends educators into poor and low-performing middle and elementary schools to encourage children, and their parents, to start planning for college."[/i]

-Tamar Lewin, NY Times, January 26, 2007

Guess that part of affirmative action in MI is still alive and well?

And, California if I remember right removed the requirements from colleges and universities long before MI did.

I've always thought that in a college entrance dossier, age, sex, and race should never be put onto it. Only your qualifications.

Kinda like getting a job.

by jdclyde

Yeah, the law got past, so now the academia have to find a way to get inferior people into positions over superior people by virtue of back door politics.

Just like there are PLENTY of "token" blacks in business positions, there are plenty in academics. A shame, because it really tarnishes the people that EARNED the right to be where they are, regardless of the color of their skin.

These same people that would be fans of Darwin, are breaking the cycle of evolution by not having only the best of the best evolve into the next phase. Instead, the worst of the worst have the mass litters, causing humans to DEvolve.

by jck

just because someone has "academia" trying to get people of color in makes them "inferior" is a bit racist.

just because someone has someone trying to do extra doesn't mean they are.

although, most professors probably are trying to get "favorites" into colleges...which means...people involved in fulfilling favors...or making their schools more money

and besides that...i'm sure that some people who aren't white think there are "PLENTY" of token whites hired by their buddies for nothing more than a golf partner at the company and someone to go on business trips with who won't tell secrets.

and devolving has been happening in the white community too, with the "good ole boy" system. we'd be ignorant to think that favoritism only happens in non-white communities.

like my dad always told me as a kid:

"sweep your own back porch before you complain about how dirty someone else's is."

by jamesrl

Didn't see the gay business directory that way. Don't see my wife's church's business directory that way.

James

by jdclyde

IF someone made an ANTI-gay directory.

Right now, people that disagree with homosexuality seem more willing to be tolerant of others. The same is not true towards people that DO stand up and believe that homosexuality is wrong. THEIR view is not tolerated, is it?

Both sides of a coin.

by jamesrl

Malcolm X became an enemy of violence(and his former associates killed him):

"Brother, remember the time that white college girl came into the restaurant?the one who wanted to help the [Black] Muslims and the whites get together?and I told her there wasn't a ghost of a chance and she went away crying? Well, I've lived to regret that incident. In many parts of the African continent I saw white students helping black people. Something like this kills a lot of argument. I did many things as a [Black] Muslim that I'm sorry for now. I was a zombie then?like all [Black] Muslims?I was hypnotized, pointed in a certain direction and told to march. Well, I guess a man's entitled to make a fool of himself if he's ready to pay the cost. It cost me 12 years.

That was a bad scene, brother. The sickness and madness of those days?I'm glad to be free of them."

Alabama governor George Wallace became "born again" in the late 70s and apologized for having been segregationist. He appointed a record number of blacks to positions of power.

James

by tink!

Every MLKJ Day my hubby never fails to mention that black employees are given the leeway to take that day off on fear of discrimination cases coming down on the company, but if a white person tried to take off Lincoln, Washington or even President's day - would it be excused? NOT!

Our society to chock full of hypocrisy..ESPECIALLY when it comes to discriminiation.

by jdclyde

Minnesota, not Michigan.

Jessy "The Body" Ventura, to be specific.

No, ours went in the general election.

by jck

besides, i already wanna off myself cause i have to come into work everyday. :^0

by jck

that's why i've said for years:

no law, rule, or regulation should be written to prefer any standard of person, excepting giving preference to one group: Americans.

no laws giving "gay" rights...or "black" rights...or "womens" rights.

write a law...if someone has their rights abridged under that law...no matter what the gender, race, creed, sexual orientation, of the offender...or the victim...that breach of law should be dealt with immediately.

the day we get over individualism and learn that it's not your just right to be an American and have your liberties...but everyone who is born her legally...then, we will learn to move our government to give everyone an equal chance and get past the barriers that cause separation and individualism to be acceptable rather than excluded.

by afbell8

That's spelled "whitey".

And for all of you that think that Black people are just waltzing into "the good life" due to affirmative action, I'd challenge you to spend a year in my shoes.

by oz_media

Has nothing to do with black history month other than they CAN pertain to the same culture (I don't use 'race' because we are all part of the human race regardless of culour or cultural diversity).

What I do see though is a minority becomeing so large and vocal, they are no longer a minority. I don't think Black History Month is really needed anymore, we are all aware of hos our ancestors acted and I don't feel a need to apologize or feel guilt for the past of mankind.

by jdclyde

Maybe having some GOOD black role models for a change would be a good thing? In a time when being a pimp or a ho is no longer thought of as a bad thing, we could USE some good role models.

by oz_media

I know I know, you don' tlike Obama but....there is no possible way you can deny that he is an excellent, positive role model to all BLack people living in America today.

So much for "the man" keeping you down. He was driven and not raised with a father in teh White House. He busted his own butt, he worked hard and he managed to draw enough peopl einto believing him that he is today the President/Commander in Chief of one of the world's greatest nations.

Damn, that makes ME want to be black!

by jck

he hasn't learned how to belittle his own race properly yet :^0

by jdclyde

only blacks were devolving.

Not paying attention again.

We have been paying the lowest denominators to over-breed for generations, while the more productive have smaller families. What kind of effect do you think THAT has?

And yes, any time someone has to lower the standards for a single group, you ARE saying they are inferior, because they are not able to step up as equals.

And hiring a friend or son of a friend is favoritism, not racism. Not based upon race/gender, so nothing to do with this conversation.

You get more and more A.D.D every day. Take your meds, and then you might be able to follow a single train of thought?

by jdclyde

No, I am not in the practice of typing out all the no-no names for each group, so there are probably plenty more I would misspell if I were to try. B-)

As for Bell, life is what you make it. It sounds like you are in favor of the racist actions of affirmative action. I choose to accept people for who they are and what they are able to do, not the color of their skin. I have risen above that.

by jdclyde

when people try to make history "nice", they commit a grave crime.

Much of history is not nice.

candy coat it, and we never learn from the mistakes.

by mattie289404

I see no one has broached the subject that blacks who were sold as slaves were in fact slaves already in Africa and sold by blacks..that part seems to be lost in the history books except for one history professor I had in college who made it a point to ensure it was stated. Lets just say the blacks didn't take kindly to that bit of info. Some blacks think a boar full of white people just invaded the whole continent and took them away..not

by jdclyde

black history has nothing to do with the racism known as affirmative action.

I don't care of blacks run around honoring great black people and their accomplishments.

The more that is done, the more it will be realized that the racism of affirmative action was NOT responsible for these same great people or their accomplishments.

Maybe people like Bill Cosby will be listened to by people of ALL races?

by mattie289404

Obama is mixed..the white part of him drove him to be president..haha..just joking..actually he seems sincere in a kinda naive sort of way. I'm sure he'll be nice and jaded in a year or two..

by mattie289404

I was a government worker for 24 years..you want to see racism at its best against whites work for the DOD a while.

by afbell8

Sorry for the new thread, but I wanted to respond to your last post, and had "reached my maximum message level". Your post is at bottom.

I didn't offer an opinion on how I felt about AA. I was responding to what you posted, which was:

"Do you have to walk around wanting to shoot "whity" on MX day?"

Now, say what you want, but to me, that was a depiction of a Black person talking.

I posted to a)correct your spelling and b) to remind this community that even though we can (and do) have differences of opinion, it's not necessary to be insulting. And, since we're on the subject, as far as the AA thing goes, in my 47 years I have yet to meet an AA beneficiary, and I know PLENTY of Black folks! :-)
----------------------------------------
That is part of it, jck
No, I am not in the practice of typing out all the no-no names for each group, so there are probably plenty more I would misspell if I were to try. cool

As for Bell, life is what you make it. It sounds like you are in favor of the racist actions of affirmative action. I choose to accept people for who they are and what they are able to do, not the color of their skin. I have risen above that.
Posted: 03/09/2009 @ 12:21 PM (PDT)

by jck

i've known a lot of people who benefitted from Affirmative Action, even though they were not as qualified for a job.

And, they were not all black. Most, in fact, were native Americans. I grew up in Oklahoma, and my hometown is (maybe was...might have moved it) where the HQ of the western tribe of the Chickasaw Nation is located.

I also have known "minorities" (put in quotes because no ethnicity is a majority in the USA anymore...the only majority here now is women, in reality at just over 51%) who have gotten educational funding and college entrance based on their "minority status".

Fact is, no one no matter their race or gender or religion or sexual preference or creed or anything else...should get a preference. Law should be written to apply equally to all Americans. Scholastic assistance should be given based on academic merit as well as true financial need (not that you moved out of your parents 12 months before and had mom and dad paying 3/4 of your bills so you qualified). Educational entrance acceptance should be based on academic merit as well.

American needs to eliminate all preference, and give rewards to those who rightly deserve it.

Otherwise, we will continue to teach our future generations that separatism is acceptable.

by bizzo

A wise man once said:
"Do not judge a man by the color of his skin, but by the content of his character"

So no, I don't think that Black History Month is necessary.
Because after all, doesn't calling at Black History Month go completely against the quote?

by oz_media

You're a Brit.

As Graham Chapman once said "Oh, I don't like darkies!"

>She doesn't like darkies. Ha ha ha. Who does? Ha ha ha! Well now, Mrs Scum, your second question for the blow on the head is: What is the main food eaten by penguins?
What is the principal food that penguins eat?

Chapman: Pork luncheon meat.

by mattie289404

It is interesting to hear from people from other countries. So what is the climate among blacks in Europe? I mean Brits had slaves too? And since all white american ancestors are from mostly Europe..I have no idea what I am trying to say...

by mattie289404

Yep that's the point. No one wants to be passed over for jobs, promotions, housing cause the color of their skin. But they do want to benefit based on the color of their skin..can't have it both ways..but most blacks have been trained from birth that if they don't get something then just play the race card.

by oz_media

I think he simplifies his replies carefully so as to not say what he shouldn't let out of the bag. I watched Biography on him, it was really well done actually, not focusing on his political career more than his life and personal history. He is actually quite educated and has been very clever in his moves to the top.

It obviously went into what he had done politically and how he rocketed to the nomination, but it proved him to be very educated and able minded.

I think what I found funniest about your reply is suggesting Obama naiive, afgter 8 years of Bush. Electing Bush showed half of America was naiive, to do it twice was just unimaginable. :D

I think KcCain was a great option too, after watching that last freakshow for 8 years, it was like a breath of fresh air to see TWO candidates that actually had some credibility and goals other than merely trash talking each other with no substance offered.

You couldn't have done worse with either of them, perhaps now you can begin on the road to rebuilding your once great nation again.

I'm actually quite happy for you all now, there is finally some shred of hope on the horizon for America again.

by oz_media

We really did have pink pages. A fun sized Yellow pages with pink pages. It bombed in no time, who'd think of getting into the already inundated, printed business directory market with the number of cells phones used today?

My mama always said, stupid is as stupid does.

In Vancouver we have an enormous Asian Indian population, being a commonwealth and having a VERY tight relationship with England.

They had their phone book too, but nobody could see the type due to contrast issues.

Actually, as a salesman, it is common knowledge that the BEST place to market any product or service to the East Indian maketplace is in their local mosque business directories, they will shop that directory before ever looking elsewhere.

We had a Jewish directory once but the pages were too big and not trimmed to the cover size, so they hung over the edges to get all ratty and wrinkled.

Our French directory decided the Yellow Pages didn't give them enough credit so it separated itself from other directories.

Our Chinese directory only covers three letters of the alphabet, C, L & W.

Our US Pages tried to take over the BC Yellow Pages so we had to burn it.

The Native Indian, red pages only covers businesses, more specifically casino's, liquor stores and legal aid.

Sorry, I'll find a new way to kill time now.

by jck

that i devolved because of...? what?

i never gave anyone anything because of their skin color. i never condoned it.

slavery ended over 100 years ago. no one is alive who was a slave.

hell, my ancestors died moving across the trail of tears, building this nations railroads, etc.

where's my free land? where's my reparations? where's my apology from the government?

my cherokee bretheren still get crapped on out in Western NC, where some of the homes still have dirt floors.

find me a HUD project in the inner city without a wood or concrete floor.

wah...get over it. everyone in this country has had the same civil rights for 50 years.

get rid of the chip, and when treated unfairly follow the process of law.

but don't tell me i am responsible for the actions of my forefathers...and don't expect me to give you a handout because of it.

and i don't care if you're black, native american, chinese, german, etc.

so if it's not only blacks...then it must be all people...and i assure you...i didn't devolve.

only those who fill themselves with disdain and hatred devolve; no matter what the color of your skin.

by jck

if the KKK can still go beat up and even (although rare nowadays) hang a minority any day of the year...don't we should give minorities at least one "pop a cap in the white man" day?

and before you go sayin they already do:

most crimes committed by blacks...is against blacks.

same goes for hispanics as well for crimes against their own ethnicity.

anyways...me being white and native american...i need to find me a girl who is a mix of bloodlines i'm not so our kids will be totally melting pot-ish.

diversity is only feared by those...who can't be diverse.

This discussion is closed to new replies.