Discussion Locked

Is Holographic Storage the real deal?

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Just recently I've head news of growing interest in holographic storage.(http://news.zdnet.com/2100-9584_22-5973868.html) Maxell just announced it will have some available to consumers by Sept. 2006. Word has it these discs can hold up to 300GB. Will this actually stand a chance against BluRay or HD-DVD? Even if its a superior product, what's it going to take to get it on the map? Everyone loves to root for an underdog.

7 replies

by neil higgins

ever came up with a holographic disc.There you are "copying" all your favourite discs from the local rental store,and up-pops a holographic image of a Sony security guard,who wags his finger at you,bawls in Japanese that your a *******!! for cheating the movie industry,and their "illegal" code tells you that the disc will self destruct in five seconds :)

by mattit

Then it calls the rental store, has your account revoked, melts your dvd player, blows out your tv, creates a throne for your ps2, and somehow takes a piss on your xbox.

by mgordon

I made my first hologram way back in about 1972; bought a helium-neon laser tube and built the power supply from various junk parts. When we finally succeeded in getting a hologram of a pile of integrated circuits and other electronic parts, it was intensely exciting. That the technology could store vast quantities of information was immediately obvious, the hard part is deciding on a transformation as well as techniques. You see, the whole point of holographic storage is space diversity, not too different than we already use in CD-ROM recording with redundant bits and error-correcting code, but in holography the redundancy is at least 2 dimensional whereas on a CD-ROM the redundancy is 1 dimensional (linear along the track). Also you can think of holographic storage as a type of parallel input/output, whereas DVD and CD is serial.

If it were up to me, data would be stored in rods that screw slowly into or out of the reader in operation, avoiding the problem of disks where linear velocity changes with distance from the spindle. The rod would display a pattern of dots onto a sensor array,producing perhaps a 64 bit snapshot in parallel, but we can easily imagine much larger arrays of dots. The rod is then rotated and advanced 1 degree, and another snapshot obtained. For disk-based holographic reading, you might project a virtual image of an array of dots onto a sensor obtaining a very high degree of parallelism. The symbol rate would not be all that high, but because of parallel reading, the bit rate would be very high.

by neil higgins

Back in 1967,in the UK,was a cult tv show called "The Prisoner",where actor Patrick Mcgoohan was a disafected British agent,resigned,and was kidnapped to the "village",where a host of odd-balls tried to find out why he quit.One episode was called "Speed Learn",where history information,dates,places,etc,was transferred to the human memory in minutes,via ultra sonic sound.Far fetched hokum it was,but apparently,in the near future,it may be possible,via electrical imput stimili,to learn,listen,or see data,such as music,movies,propaganda,or anything you like.Far fetched? How come you can "hear" your favourite piece of music "in your head",and hum the tune.Or "imagine" that all important movie scene,as soon as someone mentiones it.Science fiction maybe,but I'm sure someone out there is trying.Also,remember that 1980 Douglas Trumbull movie,"Brainstorm",with the late Natalie Wood,and Christopher Walken.I think it may be available on dvd somewhere.Now that IS scary.How the hell could the movie,and music industry control that?

by mattit

I think the best way for our society to advance is to accept the unbelieavable or "far fetched" as a possibility, once we do that then It becomes a reality. Do you think even 100 years ago they would think its remotely possible I'd be sending Neil Higgins a message from Central Wisconsin? They'd laugh. Just like how we laugh about the "far fetched" things we imagine now. Those things will become a reality, and the things we cant even fathom now will become the near future.

I completly agree with you ;)

by mgordon

Slightly off topic, but yes, I remember watching "The Prisoner" and was profoundly influenced by it, and partly frustrated by the bizarre ending when he finally gets out.

by neil higgins

With appologies to all holographic storage devices everywhere,but your right,The Prisoner did end in a bizarre manner.The trouble was,there should have been 22 episodes,but all the budget money was gone by episode 14.Episodes 15,and 16,were shot with little effort.Noone got paid apparently.Episode 17,the bunker,missile fireing,rock concert,escape one,used up a third of the budget,as it was shot after episode six.Get it?
Dont get into the semantics of it all,as you could probably write a thesis,and get a uni grant for it.Oh yes,the purpose of the ending.I can't remember.That would be telling...

This discussion is closed to new replies.