Discussion Locked

Is IT degenerating into a field where idiots rule?

0 helpful
329 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I dont know about the rest of the world but IT in New Zealand is degenerating into a field where people think anyone can do IT. People dont recognise the skill and training that goes into a degree in IT and would rather trust MCSE which is not even NZQA accredited so in truth is not a qualification.

People seem to trust the advice of idiots these days. No research is done by technicians on the products they sell, they just sell the product they sell cos.
Ask a technician why he/she sells x antivirus and 99% of the time the response is because the x antivirus company is big or because it is good, no research done on the product just go by gut feeling, how utterly and totally pathetic is that. And that is just scraping the surface.
Case in example - true story
Large company in NZ (over 250 pc's per loc, several locs), uses large IT company in NZ to support its IT infrastructure, relys on this company for advice and providing the neccessary IT infrastructure. When we did our case study on the large company last year they had no network monitoring software for thier LAN, MAN or WAN, poor av, protocols bouncing from one side of thier lan to the other causing it to eat network bandwidth for lunch, Windows servers where Linux/Unix would have done the job better, I dont know about you lot but I have had a real gutsful of IT companies saying they can provide a service but all they do is cost thier clients money and dont do a good job about it.

329 replies

by apollocdr

Here the main problem is not the capability of the individuals in the I.T. department, but the total lack of comprehension of most of Management as to how much money and time it takes to keep everything pulled together.

We're operating with less than 1% of total Revenue as budget and are expected to not only keep everything running, but implement mass projects like Active Directory as well. If every day wasn't such a hair-on-fire panic, it would be funny.

by twaka

I see the problem as one that goes beyond IT which may go back to the head of IT not communicating effectively with upper management and other managers. When the general attitude is one of IT "plays" with technology and is high overhead, the implementation of the solutions that would be best gives way to "make do" with less, quickly.

Till something desasterous happens, or some kind of mandated compliance comes along, the best decisions seems illusive.

Added to that, with the constant changing of the IT landscape, decisions have to be made quickly with acknowledgement of certain risks otherwise projects will go on forever trying to adapt to perfection. Reinforcing the negative view of IT.

by amcol

Communication has never been one of the major weapons in IT's arsenal...which is really too bad, because it's the single most important skill anyone in any discipline must master in order to be successful.

The idea that "IT plays with technology" comes from two major sources. There's a lot of entrenched IT management that proposes solutions which have all kinds of technological bells and whistles and sound really, really cool but in fact have little in common with business strategy. Which is the other problem...IT managers not taking the time to understand business strategy, that there is one and what it is.

On the other hand, IT management isn't the only culprit. We've had enough years of technology ubiquity that anyone of approximately age 30 or less has pretty much grown up with technology. Those in the 30-50+ age group have been bombarded with enough messages that you need to understand technology, at least a little, in order to simply be able to do your job.

It's a two way street, with a shared responsibility. Both IT management and business leaders need to do a better job communicating, both talking and listening.

by too old for it

"... business strategy, that there is one and what it is."

How about business strategy, IF there is one, and what it is?

An unfortunate number of business "leaders" have stratigic vision no further than this coming Friday's earnings guidance.

They claim to do what the shareholders want, but ignore shareholders who want to know why the current CEO is making $10,000 an hour and living in a mansion in the Hamptons while the former head of new product development is now a greeter at WalMart.

(Maybe it's because of churn in the CxO ranks? Every couple of years, a new company to be CxO of.)

by geobeck

...then yes, definitely. It's the managers who hire underqualified IT people. Take me, for instance. A couple of years ago, I made the mistake of letting my boss find out that I'm "good with computers". I used to just tinker at home, upgrading my PC, tweaking my OS, and suddenly I'm responsible for a 35-user OU of a global AD network.

Thankfully we've got a great IT consulting company (the ones who set up our network hardware). I've learned as much as I can from books, and from dancing through this fire, but this shop would run a lot more smoothly with a real IT guy in charge.

Of course, they would have to pay a real IT guy a real IT-guy salary. And they will, eventually, when I manage to get myself out of here.

by neaolin

You are right about that. In my case, management manages to
hire competent technicians, they just fail to listen to them. What
is sad is that the technicians have resorted to doing things
behind management's back in order to make everyone's life
easier and better.

by geobeck

Anything that improves security, but doesn't cost money, I discuss with my external consultant, then implement myself. Management only finds out when they come to me one day and say "I think I broke something..." and I say "No, that's fine; I've already fixed it so you can't do that."

by tink!

If you look at it that way, my bosses are idiots too...for hiring me.
I probably know half of what many of you IT/Network Admin guys/gals handling large networks do. I'm not certified in anything. But I haven't ever had anything bad happen on my watch. I've managed to learn enough as I go to prevent security problems, and any loss of data. I've never fried any phone systems, lost any voicemail boxes, or crashed any networks or workstations. So I'm either smart enough for my jobs, or I'm just lucky.
Tink

by beads

Either your doing things right or you haven't found anything terribly bad enough to draw your attention to it. I'm sure we're talking the former not the latter, here. ;)

Comming from the "long in the tooth" camp. We've all had those opportunities to see something go awry, either because we missed something so simple it became difficult or because something we missed was truly enormous enough to fry something out. It happens even when your supposed to be an expert.

- beads

by cburgess

Actually you have a refreshing advantage.

I find that all too many who have pursued a formal degree and certification have had their intellectual skills stunted by the process they go through to get that degree or certification.

In contrast, you can achieve a level of breath-taking demonstrable expertise in your field as long as you pursue self directed studies ...learning never ends for the truly gifted.

by jamesrl

Boy, grateful you are not...

I made my start 20 years ago because someone knew I was good with computers depite little formal training(one half course in programming in University, using mainframes to generate stats, some work experience on mini computers). That was before certs existed. It was expected that I would learn on the job and I did. Some of what I learned didn't end up being useful elsewhere (Wang sys admin, Banyan net admin).

In my books, a 35 user net is small. And add to that hopefully someone somewhere central put a lot of though into designing the AD network and group policies etc so that it required very little work on your part. In my org, we have one person in an office of 80, and in another regional office of 50, no one - the person from here goes there on occasion.

You've been given an opportunity. Use it. And maybe be just a tad grateful instead of insulting the people who hired you. If you have never managed a budget for employees, you might not be aware of the juggling act your boss had to go through. If he had to pay for someone with more qualifications to babysit an admittedly small net, he would have to cut somewhere else.

James

by amcol

James...outstanding post.

In this era of college degree required, cert programs up the ying yang, and formal training programs as far as the eye can see, we forget that in the previous generation professional business people in most areas were largely self taught via OJT. Perhaps the generation that hired THEM were more adept managers than we are because they were obviously much better at recognizing talent in the absence of a classical education.

You're dead on right also about the gratitude issue. I'm worn out listening to the chronic complainers who represent that situations less than totally perfect are totally horrible, and since nothing is ever perfect everything must be horrible. How easy it is to complain and blame, and how ultimately valueless an exercise. Talk about biting the hand that feeds you........

Isn't it also just amazing that the same people who carp incessantly about their bosses, the moment they themselves become managers all the problems are obviously the fault of the next level of management up? And their staffers, hoo boy...it's astonishing these people can find their way to work by themselves every morning.

by tink!

I'm not trying to ACTUALLY insult my employers, I was just responding to geobeck's comment that management is idiotic for hiring incompetent IT people. In comparison to many of you, I'm sure I could be called incompetent. But does that really make my managers idiots? I personally don't think so. Like I said before, I've prevented damage and disasters and am more than capable of installing and maintaining systems.
If I were to be put up against a certified IT guy/gal tho, I'd probably be whomped. So don't get me wrong, I'm very grateful for my position (mind you I was hired as Admin Asst/Ofce Manager, but just happen to be running their IT since they don't have anyone else)
Tink

by too old for it

... for someone with more qualifications to babysit an admittedly small net, he would have to cut somewhere else."

Like the CEO's country club dues?

by jdmercha

1st job lasted 8 years. Worked for my hiring manager for 2 years. Had about 7 different managers after that. Upper management decided to put all their eggs in one basket. The company (with 10,000 employess when I hired on) went out of business after I left.

2nd job lasted five years. I had three different bosses. Went through two reorginizations. My boss had 4 different bosses in that time. Company dropped from 12,000 employess to 4,000 before being bought out, again after I left.

3rd job lasted 1 year. It was a small startup that failed shortly after I left.

4th job lasted two years before I left for more money. Hiring manager left 6 months after I was hired. Company was bought out and closed down after I left.

5th and current job has lasted over 7 years now. My hiring manager left after one year. I've reported to six differnt bosses in that time.

Summary - 25 years of experience, 5 jobs and 20 bosses. And only 5 years working for the person that hired me.

by why me worry?

At my last job, I was responsible for a mixed Novell eDirectory/Windows 2003 AD tree with over 5000 users spread across 4 international timezones consisting of 23 worldwide offices. Yes, we had regional admins who we delegated control to for their part of the world, such as Asia and Europe, but I still did the bulk of the work in terms of daily administration and system engineering and upgrades. Granted, it was absurd for a company of such a size to have only one Netware CNE on staff, such as myself, but I somehow managed to deal with it for the time being. I am no longer employed with that company and am seeking a company where I won't be the one man expert for a particular technology.

by scouterdude

Lots of good comments on this thread.
Agreed, 35 users is tiny. If you feel you want to work in IT, you've got a great chance here to get a career started. Give it your best, and doors should open. (No, that's not guaranteed.)

If you don't particularly like the work tho, work on whatever other skills you have and enjoy and plan on moving on. IT certainly isn't for everyone.

If I did hiring, I'd pick OJT and experience over certs any day. I started in a different field and 'started playing' with the computer stuff. My last cert was NW4 CNA, but now I help manage ~200 servers, and numerous critical systems for the org.

by beads

When I started IT - oh so many years ago - you were basically in an environment shut off from the rest of the world. IT folks basically respected one anothers abilities and in-fighting was a rare occurance.

We seem to be going downhill as we become both more siloed and decentralized at the same time. Knowledge sharing is all but frowned upon while corporate feudalism regins supreme. We have no firm measure of who actually knows what anymore and hiring has become more of a guessing game than one of presentable skills. Basically, we don't have much in the way of respect for ourselves - why should management?

- beads

by jdmercha

"people think anyone can do IT"

I've only been in IT for 10 years, but 25 years ago I graduated from college with people who got jobs as programmers, with degrees in business and phsychology. They happened to have taken one programming course, and that was enough.

I got my first network admin position having never seen a network before. Nor had I had any training relating to networks.

How do you go downhill from there?

by gralfus

The bottom lines for management are money and looking good. Managers don't typically see or care about hidden costs, as long as the expense doesn't show up on their own bottom lines. In this way, they can justify their jobs to their higher-ups. Expenses are bad, cost savings are good.

Cost cutting always seems to target IT first. One problem is that those IT techs who remain keep things running too well, and management pats itself on the back for cutting unnecessary costs. If things begin to break, management has to respond. Now, they may respond by outsourcing everything. They did at the first company I was with. This brought lots more headaches, but in the short term management looked good for making being decisive. Then they started cutting how many contracted IT people they had, because "everyone knows" that in order to cut costs, start with IT. When complaints about IT began rising, it was ignored as part of the process of change, or alternatively blamed on the contracted company. In this way, management never has to be answerable for its bad decisions regarding IT.

Thus, some companies are left with overworked, underpaid, undertrained geek wannabees instead of highly skilled teams that handle problems quickly and efficiently. It is up to those who control the final bottom line to control the hidden costs of poor IT departments (and poor IT hiring, compensation, strategy, etc). This isn't rocket science, it just takes wise managment willing to look at things differently than the "everyone knows you cut IT first" crowd.

by jkameleon

It's whoever owes the business that's in charge. Profits belong to him, as well as losses. It is therefore only fair, that we unite our forces as a team, and do our best to screw things up his way.

by m_a_r_k

There are idiots and smart people in every industry. It probably just seems to you like there's more in IT b/c that's the industry you work in. IT stuff is a helluva lot more complex than it used to be. And it is a helluva lot more critical to a company's infrastructure than it used to be. Nowadays we have all these networked systems and distributed applications with large databases. In the not too distant past, we just used sneakernet and floppy disks to haul our data around. DOS was a very simple OS. Windows and Unix and all these network OSes are much more complex. Especially when you consider that they are all talking to each other. Today we have a ton of different apps from different vendors all tied together to run an entire company. One bug in some distant application can send crappy data to your database front-end and could foul it all up. Sometimes the software that a company sells isn't even developed by that company. It consists of many glued-together libraries and applications from different sources. Ever heard of "DLL hell"? And then the aforementioned data interchange interfaces add another level of complexity.

by bfilmfan

Well that is what I used to call it anyway, way on back.

I agree that IT is far more complex an area than in days of yore.

I wonder how many of these younger people can even imagine having to build a JK Flop gate from transistors?

by blieffring9

J K was simpler, but most of the work was done with D latches.

"I had to build a database out of zeros because ones were too expensive."

by tony hopkinson

you've been damn lucky. This trend started years ago in the UK.
I put it down to two things. Originally IT was almost guaranteed to save you money, because it allowed you to cut very labour intensive manual systems. The other thing was the boom, when IT became fashionable and the career to get into. There was a massive influx of poorly trained badly educated inexperienced non-vocational wannabes, coupled with methodologies such as RAD and the massive personel turn-arounds, the skill level within the trade was diluted enormously. Hence some very expensive failures, rash promises, and poorly thought out attempts at solutions. When it went nipples up, management could point the finger at themselves for not managing as well as they could or they could do anything else.
No surprise really is it.
Now whether you blame the propeller heads for promising more than they could deliver, or the business heads for reading potential as actual will depend on which side of the desk you are sitting.
Bit of both as usual I suspect.

by beads

Tony thats so true of what we saw here in the US as well, it just made me sick to my stomach.

One thing you hinted at was the complete knee-jerk reaction management had regarding IT in general. Used to be that your IT manager came from some other generalist skill only to become the IT manager. Generally, they didn't have a clue as to what DP/IS/IT even stood for other than personal career advancement. Some of those things are changing with more CIO/CTO types atleast being able to type on a keyboard without outside assistance let alone do anything... well - "technical".

- beads

by jmgarvin

Man, our IT problems make NZs look trivial. We have credit card companies losing data, "high security" areas getting hacked, and total server outages that need to have high availablity!!

Total mess...but at least MSCEs aren't thought of as the second coming anymore...it seems education is starting to trump certification (esp with the 100% pass cert or the cert sellers)

by nzbn

The largest Network IT companies in NZ found thier IT in MCSE and its coming round to bite companies in the ass very soon I think, One of the other posts up above was quite right in that the flood of wannabes into IT has seriously damaged the industry, people just dont want to believe (here) yet that technicians actually need proper training, they would rather beleive the person telling them what they want to here rather than the plain out and out truth.

In reply to IT budget above ^^^^ yup I can see how IT gets finances cut to shreds and operating on 1% must suck something bad, What mgt fail to realise is that IT was put there in the first place to make them more money by doing things faster, cut the budget, stress out your techs and your network runs like crap, all of a sudden things take longer and projects that could make a company money have to be delayed,
I bet they didnt figure that into thier cost cutting.
Perhaps the first place to start cost cutting is the darn marketing dept, they waste most of thier money on "branding" that actually does not sell anything, or make the company any more money, in fact it just costs them millions, hmm millions more spent on IT, bet you a decent IT team could make a company a whole lot more money than "brand" advertising!!

by beads

Certifications should never have been a replacement for a four year degree. Not now, not then, not ever. Learning to do more than high-tech line assembly is not an answer, either.

We saw the same thing with the "paper CNEs" of yesteryear as well.

- beads

by jwood99

By your comments I assume that you are implying that someone who has achieved a CCIE certification isn't as effective as a someone who has gone to school for four years, correct?

by why me worry?

Not so much paper CNEs', but paper MCSEs'. Novell had a much more rigorous and tougher certification process that required really knowing the stuff and having hands on experience to pass the tests. Simply cramming for the test and memorizing Q&A would not do you much good. I recall being in a job early on in my career where I had already had my CNE and I was working with a so called "MCSE". We had a crashed server that needed to be rebuilt within 4 hours according to the SLA. The cause of the crash was that the partition table got corrupted on an NT4 server and the thing simply would not boot because the drive array was shot. So anyhow, this guy gets out his trusty NT4 CD and attempts to reinstall the OS from scratch. He wastes an entire hour trying to install the OS, but he fails because the drive array is shot and there is no logical disk configured on the RAID controller. Anyhow, I take over this machine, blow away the old corrupted array and recreate a new array and logical drive from scratch. I then take the CD and reinstall NT4 all over again, followed by a restore from tape. Mind you, I was not an MCSE at the time and had very little knowledge of domains and all that NT crap. The other guy was MCSE certified and had no god damned clue what a RAID array was or how to even troubleshoot it. Like I said, certs don't mean squat. If you don't know your stuff, you may as well find another line of work.

by surflover

I disagree... I.T. as a whole is MUCH less complicated than it was 25 years ago... I worked at DARPA then on the Arpanet project... we had networked several thousand mainframes and RNPs (remote network processors for you young pups) across the us and 87 other countries at military installations around the world...

This was accomplished using assembler to write communications drivers to manage the physical comm ports (and every machine was different)... it didn't save any money, it cost a LOT of money...

...AND... Management didn't know ANYTHING about what we were doing... for the most part, once you got above the 2nd tier manager, they had ABSOLUTELY NO EXPERIENCE with technology... Our biggest challenge was trying to find analogies they could understand to get our point across so they could make decisions that weren't stupid...

(My first division chief was a retired B52 pilot, but he was a real nice guy) :^O

by m_a_r_k

How can you say IT is MUCH less complicated today? Do you think that we don't have DARPA-like networks today? Heck, almost every large company today has their very own network that squashes DARPANET in horsepower. And have you ever heard of Al Gore's Internet? Didn't the Internet grow from DARPANET?

Where companies used to have one or two mainframes connected to a bunch of dumb terminals, we now have dozens of Intel-based PCs on steroids connected to hundreds or thousands of plain old desktop PCs, remote laptops, PDAs, etc. Every large company that I know of has been transformed this way. It doesn't matter what computer language these things are written in. I used to do some assembly coding and there is no comparions between that and the stuff I develop now using C++ and .NET. Not even close.

Compare the IT budget as a percentage of overall expenses between 1980 and 2005. Compare the overall size of IT departments. Companies now are totally (yes, TOTALLY) reliant on IT. In 1980, if IT suddenly went away in a day, it would only have been a nuisance. Now it would be catastrophic. In 1980, most employees' only interaction with IT-anything was the TV or telephone.

by surflover

I dont think the tasks are more complicated...

debugging an abend dump in octal and/or hex is not for the faint of heart... I think the school for the step trace tool on the H6000 was 3 or 4 weeks long, and more than half the students failed it (it was a BEOTCH of a class)...

what I was really referring to was that management in those days usually came out of finance (or some other LOB) and had no experience or understanding of what those on their staff did for a living (nor did most of them care to know)... and that IT has not deteriorated to that state, it has always been in that state as far as I have seen...

But to your point, regular businesses did not even have IT in those days, so for the rank and file business, I guess that could be said

by jamesrl

It was geobeck....

I learned on the job. I didn't take a course to learn how to make cables, or setup Banyan/Lantastic/Novell servers. One of the reasons I left a small consulting partnership was ot go to a big company and learn big networks.

I wouldn't be so sure about the people who have certs. Certs with no experience - versus someone with on the job - not sure I would agree that you would not look good in comparison. Certs and experience - thats better.

James

by pemory

I agree with James on this. I've been in IT for 10 years now, but I have only one cert. I got the cert basically to get my foot in the door for interviews. Most hiring managers would take a look at my resume, and due to their only knowing the current buzzwords, would say "You have quite a bit of experience in I.T., but do you have any formal certifications?". (Keep in mind that I have both a BS in Computer Science and an MBA...)

On the flip side of the coin, I've worked with people that have multiple certifications who couldn't do the most basic of tasks. When I taught college IT courses, I prided myself on the fact that my students didn't just repeat what they learned, but they actually understood the theory and usage behind it. That way, they not only prepared for certification, but also to get an entry-level position which would help them gain more experience and confidence.

In short, take any and all opportunities to learn and improve yourself, whether they be by formal training, self-study, or just asking questions.

by m_a_r_k

Surfer, you raised some interesting points. I suppose the real answer is "It depends".

We might have the same tasks these days in general, but now we just have many, many more of them. And we expect more from them. We're a victim of our success. Sure the tools are more powerful now. But that is with everything. VCRs, programmable thermostats, electronic ignition, electronic banking... all do the same tasks as 20+ years ago but are much improved at what they do. And all are intended to make life easier. You remove the human element to make things easier and easier to control but it does complicate matters precisely b/c humans have less direct control. Twenty years ago I could change my own spark plugs. Now I can't even find the damn things. I don't know about this H6000 trace tool but in comparing my experience now to then, I'd have to say that development tools take longer to learn to fully utilize now. Compare Visual Studio.NET to Borland Turbo C. Turbo C took absolutely no training time. I didn't even know C yet when I started using it and I was productive in a few weeks. Look at the number of classes your local community colleges offer on all the different aspects of .NET (or Java or Oracle or ... (take your pick)). Actually those ancient archaic debuggers were right for the job at the time. Now we have multi-threaded this, multi-process that, multi-platfrom something else all going on in the same application. That old H6000 trace tool wouldn't get us very far.

As you said, we didn't have much in the way of an "IT department" but there were a few specialists running around trying to keep all those mainframes humming along. I've always been in R&D and my management always rose through the engineering rank and file. Many of our corporate executives came from engineering. We rank and file engineers used to b!tch about the idiot engineer executives running our company into the ground. In the old days (like the early days of Texas Instruments), a company could get by without having a clue how to manage a company's strategy and finances. Not anymore. Ahh... memories of my youth...

by surflover

eloquently as I would have liked, but I think you got what I was trying to get at... and absoultely (should that be in another post? :-))... the conceptual complexity of .net and some of the other "panaceas" of IT (there have been many over the decades) can be daunting at the very least... I had the good fortune (or misfortune) to be sent to months and months of schools in the early days to learn the intimate details of mainframe and RNP operating systems, which, when you dug dowm to the hardware level, were UNGODLY complex for the day...

...like you, I picked up turboC, turbo pascal, Ada, and other OOD stuff in days... it took YEARS to become proficient in the OS level assembler...

and you are absolutely correct (there's that word again :-))... today there is just so much MORE stuff you have to know... the long and the short of it is, it's probably not much more or less difficult... it's just different...

(sheer profundity, eh? :^O)

by surflover

I did some work for DEC several years back... They were run by engineers... They developed the most reliable operating system ever designed (most of the big UNIX vendors are still trying to develop the capabilities that VAX clusters had in the 80's)...

and look where that got them... you're quite right about having too many engineers in upper management :^O

by m_a_r_k

Their OS was called VMS, right? Brings back memories. Those things hung around until at least the early 90s. I didn't have to use it veyr often. Thank goodness. Yeah, I prefer Windows' GUI.

Here's a trivia question: What does "VAX" stand for?

by fakir0059

I assume that the man writing the article is from New Zealand. I'm sure that he would think of the IT in another County the same way if He were from another World. It is not the IT people who are Idiots. It is the Business world, as cited in the article, that is totally stupid. They get carried away by the sales Pitch of the Salesmen. Any business has to employ a salesman that can sell. If he can't sell he'll be fired. First of all why would a Large Company need the support of another large Company to support its infrastructure. Why can't they have the inhouse support. I can understand if the company was small. It would certainly need to retain outsiders to support it. But I believe the support means security. And the security is hardly improved no matter what large company is hired to support it. It is a misguided thinking.

The news feeds are full of news items regarding the newely discovered security flaws. These companies make a living covering security failures. These companies will go out of business if the security failures are rooted out.

The only way to defeat the security flaws is to develop a new method of surfing the web as discussed at
http://www.newerawisp.blogspot.com/

But this article is very discuraging. If the people at large companies are idiots there's no hope for the development of the alternate method of surfing the web.

by nzbn

Outsourcing vs In-house CBA found that outsourcing was cheaper than hiring thier own internal network anlalysts.
Through proper security and requirements analysis the network could have been designed and supported properly, But the crunch of it comes when alot of managers believe that they are getting the best service from supposed big IT companies so trust thier advice. - security problems dont just come from the web, employees can be the worst even when they dont mean to!
A big problem is the corperate smoozing that goes on, x IT company takes x manager out to lunch, x manager thinks great he bought me lunch must be a good IT company. hmm

by amcol

Formal education has a negative impact on cognition but self study has a positive impact.

Is that your thesis?

Other than observation, which I suggest in your case must have been very limited by definition since what you say makes absolutely no sense whatsoever and is directly opposite my own observations made across decades of interaction with thousands of professionals, do you have any real evidence to offer in support of this ludicrous claim?

by dc guy

Anyone over forty can remember when we all joked about the fact that the clerks and secretaries kept the place running smoothly. It was no joke. The workstation revolution squeezed those people out of the corporate pyramid.

Now you can watch a manager using his "time-saving" computer spend half an hour trying to center the heading on a report.

The people who actually knew what was going on and what to do about it are gone. Some of them mastered their computers and are still around but doing different jobs. They're easy to find, they're the ones everybody goes to when they can't solve their own problems. They just don't have the power they used to so they can't save us from our own ineptitude.

by surflover

I've hired several "ex" admins as line managers and project managers, and it has been remarkably successful... several have moved on up and made outstanding executives...

by dba-mi

If someone was truly gifted, would they not have the ability to earn a degree in their chosen field? Would earning a degree indicate some intelligence and some work ethic?

by amcol

One need not be "gifted" to earn a degree. Slogging through a course of study over a long period of time in pursuit of an academic credential doesn't require a Mensa level IQ.

Earning a degree does imply a certain level of work ethic in that the chief ingredient in the successful completion of a degree program is, in fact, hard work. It doesn't necessarily have anything to do with intelligence, however...there's little correlation between how smart someone is and their ability to navigate through an academic curriculum.

There may be a correlation between intelligence and being class valedictorian, but for the 99.99% of the rest of us one thing has nothing to do with the other.

by kevron

This is why we have degrees, to prove that we can work hard to meet our goals. Simply saying you are talented in a certain subject and beijng able to prove it, does not prove that you have any work ethic to back it up.

by tink!

Getting a degree does represent intelligence and work ethic, however, not all intelligent people with good work ethics have the means to earn a degree.
I married right out of high school and I have 3 kids. Luckily I had the work experience to land office jobs. Otherwise I'd never be where I am today. Unfortunately, despite my desire to have a degree, it's hard enough paying for my kids school expenses!
Tink

by jmgarvin

However, in many cases you can only rise so high without a degree.

Does your employeer have a tutition repayment program?

by tony hopkinson

I can asure you VMS is still around and still going. It's not state of the art anymore, very clunky compared to modern stuff and a dying niche. DEC kit coupled with the OS, has an extremely high reliability factor though and a gratifying minimum of maintenance. I used it 92 - 99 and then 2002 - 2004. The only time it got rebooted, aside from installation of new software, was to check if it still would.

by jezza_t49

AT TAFE NSW- Australia, some eople who do IT courses don't what they are doing and have done it over the last 6 years, eg Diploma in Sys Admin

by nzbn

It's kind of along the range of would you go to an accountant that had his degree/masters or someone who went to an MYOB course and then offered thier services as an accountant, or having a trained and degree qualified surgeon operate on you or someone who has done a first aid course.

Unless that person who has CCIE achieved it after or before thier degree as part of professional development. What is taught in a degree offers far more than any other course to the client/employer

by jphoeke

With all due respect, I don't think that NZBN knows how much work goes into obtaining a CCIE. I believe that there are only about 15,000 world wide.

I worked with someone who worked up to taking the 2 part CCIE exam. He missed passing the first part by only 3-4 questions. His experience? 15 years working as a network enigeer on networks that most people would envy. This also requires them to work with teams of individuals spanning geographically diverse locations.

Most people live/work in an IP world. The CCIE is still tested on IPX, AppleTalk, and most of the other protocols that aren't used any more.

by nzbn

I can see your point that the CCIE is quite demanding on a person, A degree can be also very demanding (There are 3 out of a class of 30 left from mine)
Yup the IP world is pretty much it for 99% of people, and well appletalk I'm just not going to go there (They can keep coming our way :) )

I dont know whether I see the point in training in protocols that are no longer in use, IPX is good to have a working knowledge in because there are still older Novell systems around but older protocols that are no longer in use are this way for a reason.
Although it is good to know about older protocols that are no longer in use so we can counsel people away from them :)

What is also missed from alot of these types of certs is the business side of it, information systems, project management, system analysis and design methadologies, IT people often hate this part but it is essential to round your knowledge and make you more effective in a business environment which is where your skills will be utilised

by beads

Passing the written portion of the CCIE is considered the easy part of the exam not the hard part. The hard part is passing the two day hands on test in your area of specialization. Most tell me that the first time was the worst - pass or fail and usually has some sort of "bucket story" to tell afterwards. People so made so upset that they needed a bucket or flight bag. Generally, after the second session.

According to Cisco there are little less than 10,000 ACTIVE CCIEs in the field. Since it requires you to recertify every three years its still an arduous process to keep your skills up.

I have to take a couple Cisco exams nearly every year just to maintain my CCNP (in Routing) certification. It seems like there is always a new one comming out or replaced, etc.

Hats completely off to the super-geeks that have the patience to keep up with everything. I have also personally spoken to a couple of folks who are working on MULTIPLE CCIEs. The record, last checked was five concurrent CCIEs! No one that I have heard has all seven. So its not that insurmountable of a goal to achieve. Difficult. Very, very difficult.

I have the utmost respect for those folks who choose to be the very best at Cisco networking they can be - really!

And tell your friend to take the CCIE review with GlobalKnowledge, et. al. Definitely makes a huge difference than trying to do everything on your own. No matter how bright you are.

- beads

by nzbn

Yup it doesnt always end up cheaper, Im not privvy to thier accounts details but the cba was done by a guy who knew how to do the figures. Only the network was outsourced not the Oracle, or Jade developers

by mjd420nova

The scourge of IT is the managers, they are all
based in life on increasing income or production
and decresing cost and overhead. This results is he NUMBERS game and no one wins that waY.
The head manager puts the pressure on their
underlyings and the buck rolls to the bottom
and as a result you wind up with a department
that is filled with certified heads and very
few real experienced workers who do do all
the work. Window dressing.

by why me worry?

It takes one half-assed moron in the executive dept of a company to bring in one non-technical bonehead to lead the IT dept. This spells for a disaster as this new CTO or CIO is completely clueless and has no concept of how systems work or why one is better than another. Many times I see these idiots becoming IT managers or directors and making decisions based on hearsay and reports they read in IT publications like "Gartner" and "Technology Week", which are highly biased against anything non-Microsoft. I've been in this situation twice in my career where we had a mature and stable network running for decades, and in comes some new hotshot IT manager who has his own ideas of what is "good" and decided to rip out the current system in favor of his own crap that he thinks will be "better for the company". The company spends an absurd amount of money to go forward with this half-ass idea and then realizes that they did not foresee the problem involved with a system conversion project of this scale. The new IT manager gets his ass fired, but the IT guys like myself are stuck tyring to fix a half working system and clean up the aftermath of the mess that some clueless moron shoved down our throats. My policy is: "If it aint broke, don't fix it" and I don't give a flying f**k if Gartner or Bill Gates says you need to convert to something else.

by jkameleon

> The new IT manager gets his ass fired, but the IT guys like myself are stuck tyring to fix a half working system and clean up the aftermath of the mess that some clueless moron shoved down our throats.

That's why you still have a job. Had everything run smoothly, you'd be downsized a long time ago.

Idiots don't make our jobs harder. They keep our jobs.

by jdmercha

"The new IT manager gets his ass fired"

I've usually seen the manager keep his job, place the blame on the IT staff, and then outsorce the project.

by jamesrl

The work your ass off and maybe you could be a CXO...

I could also add this - you have a hard time attracting experienced ambitious admins to a small net. Great techies thrive on challenges and 35 users generally doesn't provide many.

I made that kind of decision many years ago. I was an independant, doing consulting and maintenance for a number of clients at an hourly rate. But I worked with small companies - 35 or 40 users at the max. I ended up moving to a lower paying job at a big corporation so I could learn about world wide networks - great career move.

James

by too old for it

... starting with the Marines right out of high school to an IT contracting firm today.

Jealous? nah ...

Bitter at watching frat boys with no skills other than how to schmooze get paid obscene sums to schmooze witht heir peers? yeah.

by jkameleon

> So to justify our jobs, all things must be broken and require round the clock maintenance?

Exactly. Every mature industry does that. Your car, for example, is designed to last exacty 5 or 10 years (depends on warranty). Many vital parts are prestressed, so that they virtually break after certain period of time. Many millions of R&D dollars were spent to achieve such precision. Making a perfect product is the dead sure way of making yourself obsolete.

All big software players, Microsoft & such, employ similar phylosophy. They change versions, and "rock the standards", and so on.

Things like maintainability, roboustness, reliability & such must also be taken into account when designing software, as well as your own time & effort you are about to put in it. If customer wants it quick & dirty, true professional makes it quick & dirty.

by why me worry?

I've heard of such scumbags in the workplace and it simply is unprofessional and disgusting. As IT professionals, we are paid to keep a system running and well maintained without having to constantly be rebooting servers around the clock. If breaking things and purposely making yourself busy to give the appearance that you are doing your job is what you call job security, then I suggest you find a new line of work, like a crooked auto-mechanic. IT would fare well with less people who are looking to justify their jobs by looking for excuses to break things.

by amcol

Could have been expressed a little less colorfully, but you're on target with your thoughts. You're obviously a bright guy who's capable of making a valuable contribution. Why sabotage yourself with vulgarities, epithets, scatalogy, and silly violent fantasies? You're better than that.

by jkameleon

Following your logic, you should consider your car sabotaged because it's designed to fall apart after 5-10 years. If this is the case, the whole car industry is crooked, not just some auto mechanics.

You could also consider your clothes sabotaged, because they will be out of fashion in a year or so. Namely, the purpose of fashion is to keep textile industry busy.

But, we could also look things the other way around- the purpose of textile industry is to satisfy fashion plate's need of ostentation. Similarily, the purpose of IT is to satisfy the moron's need of stupid software. It's the economy man, supply&demand, and all that. No sabotage is necessary here. You just do what you are paid to do, that's all. And then, you are paid to fix the stupid things you were paid to do before. As simple as that. You are supposed to do theese things for money, not to make the world a better, smarter place.

Besides, who needs sabotage anyway? The way it is, it's hard enough to keep things going as it is.

You might also consider this. Suppose, that you work in the ideal workplace, with all the time & resources at your disposal, no abhorrent bosses, no distractions, not deadlines, nothing. Even the operationg systems & tools you use casue no problems. And so, you build an ideal IT system for your employer. 100% reliable, stable, easy to administer and maintain. And, once it's finished- what are you going to do? Put your legs on the table and happily observe it flawlessly humming along? No way! Sooner or later, someone will come by, and ask himself "Now, why do we need this guy for? He's doing nothing, just happily observing our excellent IT system. Let's downsize him!"

by jdmercha

Planned obsolesance is a byproduct of competition. Sure the auto manufactures can build better cars. The problem is nobody would go out and buy a $500,000 honda civic that would last 40 years.

by beads

Not hardly. If you can get through the CCIE without the basis in math, philosphy or CS then your a much more logical thinker than, myself.

Most of the CCIEs I have meet have a degree in CS or IT.

Don't forget that the CCIE is the third tier of the Cisco cert program. CCNA, CCNP (various as I lost count past the first dozen or so) and finally the CCIE. Of which there are what seven separate tracks, now?

Is it a replacement? No. Its a certification that is good for 3 years, now. Used to be only two. Guess which one lasts longer?

- beads

by tony hopkinson

cert is why. From a degree it's usually when.
A generalisation true, but neither one is really a problem as long as the person who got it is interested enough in the subject to continue learning, and aware enough to know they will have to keep on learning.

by why me worry?

A lot of these CEOs' have very desparate wives and horny little sluts for daughters. Best way to get back at the bastard CEO is to shag both of the women in his life.

by too old for it

... when some CEO's snot-nosed teenaged daughter flounces out of the house in her prototypical Western mall-rat attire (I'm thinking ultra-ultra-low rider jeans, showing off her all-over tan and contrasting thong, cropped spaghetti-strap top with some http://www.tshirthell.com/ saying on it, sunglasses parked on top of her bleach-blonde head in lieu of a hat) in some Taliban-inspired villiage.

Not gonna happen, because Mr. CxO is never gonna leave Grosse Pointe (or wherever).

by amcol

You've been making some good posts recently in other threads. Why the backslide? I was hoping you'd learned your lesson.

by blieffring9

I've been operating computers since DOS, IBM/360 DOS 22. Many things remain the same. There are professionals that need computers to help them make decisions, and computer professionals that help computers make decisions. IT professionals learn IT in school, or fall back on management and accounting training when IT gets hard and complex. Why does it take 4 years to get a degree in something that lasts only 3 years? People with management aping skills get noticed and accepted by management apes. IT professionals are the boiler stokers for a company; nobody wants to see them or their dirty mess, they just want to water ski behind the ship. Computers still only access memory, set, clear, or invert bits, add, negate, shift, test results, and change instruction sequence. Everything else is a combination of that, or understanding the philosophy and thought process of the interface's organization. C is not machine instructions, it is a philosophy of library calls and interfaces and code organization.
This was all documented in the 50's - 70's with these basic laws and corollaries:
Murphy's Law. Failure will happen in a most profound and unexpected way to cause the most damage possible on several fronts. I.e. A branch cut from a tree will sweep the ladder out from under you so that you land first, then the branch, ladder, and chain saw add injury to insult.
Parkinson's Law. With growth comes expansion. Expansion creates complexity. Complexity creates decay. Companies and concepts become so big and complex that small minds can't see the whole big picture or add enough energy to prevent entropy.
The Peter Principle. People are promoted to their level of incompetence where they remain until promoted to the side. Ever wonder how such an important manager, with no staff, became available to take over your group?
Cole's law. Finely chopped cabbage, carrots, and mayo.

by blieffring9

A large company had to outsource because domains became terratorial over their data. No one group owned all of the data to be able to form complex data summaries and pricing lists to generate full contracts from any one location. They shut down the individual division's IT and farmed it all out to a neutral party that hired the KEY programmers for much more money under one overall neutral organization.

by alxnsc9

Let me add more - IT personnel is forced to study private companies' views, principles and products instead of being educated in Informatics, Computer Science, etc. Science and scientific knowledge are expelled from our sphere of activities. Salesmen dictate anything and they call this "being aggressive on the market", and what a paradox - aggressive persons are widely recognised as simpletons - by any reason and culture, aggressive merchants are highly respected!

by kevron

I need to take some lessons from amcol. I've been way too sympathetic to people who really do nothing to deserve it. It seems the more you feed into misguided people, the more they use their malfunction to take advantage of people. Do you want some cheese with that whine?

by kevron

I also would like to publicly apologize to amcol for my posts about him in another topic. I've been ill and in a bad mood lately, and nothing this person did warranted the way I responded.

by amcol

And I'd like to publicly acknowledge that while I appreciate the sentiment an apology is unnecessary. Everyone's entitled to their opinion, to express it, and to use whatever means they want to do so. I never take anything said in these spaces personally.

"Do you want cheese with that whine". Great turn of a phrase, I hope you don't mind if I steal it.

by m_a_r_k

Wow! Flip-flops! Does anyone still build stuff out of those things anymore? Oh I used to love the good D-flip flop and it's cousin the JK (and wasn't there a SR flip-flop also?).

by jamesrl

I've done a software project where there wasn't a list of items for the "next" project before the finishing touches are complete.

If you build the perfect system, no doubt the user's needs wants and desires will change the moment you put your feet up.

The challenge is approaching the users and asking the right questions.

If you think your users are morons you might not be the right person to ask those questions, and you might be a couple of steps closer to the unemployment line.

James

by jkameleon

What you told is true if you are self employed, or work for a small company. In this case, customer satisfaction matters.

If you work in IT department, paid by the hour, it's different story. "Customer", your employer that is, may never be so unsatisfied with you, that he'll bother to look for, and hire somebody else. But, he may not be entirely satisfied either, because he'll increase your workload.

If you are self employed, you bear the responsibity for your actions. In a huge IT department, some (usually moronic) CxO is in charge, and he/she bears the responsibility. It's therefore only fair to screw things up his/hers way. If that leads to some calamity, it's not your problem. It's not your business, nor your profits.

by jamesrl

I worked for one company that had 80,000 employees, 5,000 of who were in IT. I've also worked for myself and in small consulting firms for small business clients.

In the huge firm, customer satisfaction mattered to everyone in IT. All management got their bonuses based on customer satisfaction and employee satisfaction. The CIO couldn't be everywhere. He set the general direction and tone and let people get on with it. We were big enough to organize programming groups around specific needs. I spent time in the HR group and Finance group (very different cultures). We developed long term relations with these customer groups and worked with them to understand their needs and objectives. We implemented time tracking so they could see what we were spending our time doing and to improve our ability to plan and forecast.

James

by jkameleon

Looks fine. That's how it should be, I guess, but as far as I can tell, it usually isn't. Workplaces like the one you described are pretty hard to come by theese days. One has to get along with what he's got, and as long as salary is OK, crappy corporate culture doesn't bother me.

by jdmercha

The outsourcing agency hires unqualified people at very low pay. People you would never hire to do the job. Then they hire one well paid and well qualified person. They sell you the job based on that one persons talents. Then they pull him off the job, giving you the unqualified people. That way they can resell the qualified person to the next unsuspecting company.

by tony hopkinson

I haven't manged to get fitted for a mortar board either. Worked my ass off at work instead of college. Saying that I wish I did have that bit of paper, then people who were incapable of judging whether I know my stuff would feel that I did. The most disappointing thing to me is the constant devaluation of the qualification itself. Employers in the UK consider anything but a top mark as arse wipe, some of the highly qualified idiots I've met they are right as well.

by tony hopkinson

would have got it wrong.
Must have answered too quick, deprived myself of the opportunity to burn someone trying to be clever.