Is monitoring usb extracted files an invasion of employees privacy
Would like to know the opinion regarding the ethical implications of monitoring employess usb storage file extractions from business network PCs.
Message was edited by: Beth Blakely
Storage
Would like to know the opinion regarding the ethical implications of monitoring employess usb storage file extractions from business network PCs.
Message was edited by: Beth Blakely
by cmiller5400
by sapna.goel
In my opinion, monitoring of employees is not against their privacy rights. When employee knows he is going to be monitored... then should be no problem at all
for more information visit:
http://www.spy-software.in
by ic-it
There may be some companies that do need a tool like this however since you are the CEO of the company and it is your web site then;
It would appear that you joined and started this thread to SPAM us.
by ajaxnii
by cmiller5400
The question is valid and the answers could affect our product or others positively or negatively.
Regarding if its ethical for developers like us to better know the IT community feeling about the privacy aspects of one of our products (The question) I would say its very much ethical.
I am, however witholding my opinion.
It appears to me that you are trying to tap our knowledge for free so that you may make a profit.
Hang around for a while, contribute, and then see what kind of responses you get.
This site has been innundated with people trying to pull fast ones. I am not saying that you are one of those people. We are a bit wary of newcomers who appear to have ulterior motives. If you are serious, let us get to know you and you may find our input to be constructive.
So the question remains.
Well, yes. Its important for us being that we have included the function on our products. and could make changes based on suggestions.
To the not so welcoming comments. Please notice my name, and who I am is fully and correctly disclosed, so I don't think your comments apply under the circunmstaces.(I post my complete name on the email to be seen not a nickname.)
by jdclyde
I don't believe for a second it is a valid request.
Anyone that has been in IT for more than a week knows full well that there is NO expectation of privacy of ANY kind on a company computer.
There is nothing to discuss.
by oz_media
When it came to the Rogers contract issue, the FACTS were apparent and clearly defined in thier contract. Som econtested that it was ROgers position to ensure that the person agreeing to it, understood it (nto so of course)by singing it you are sayign you have read and understood it. Therefore the rest of that topic is a non-discussion. It took a couple of weeks of arguing, getting slagged and flamed before I finally gave up trying to express that fact to someone else. "Regardless of how you 'feel', it is a non-issue as it is legal to do so." END OF STORY! nothing left to discuss, opinions aren't worth shite.
There is mention of ethics, in both topics too but ethics are completely irrelevant. LAW states otherwise, so therefore, end of discussion, right? Or at least you'd like to think so. Even on an ethical erspective, if the employee had any ethics, they wouldn't be using work time or computers for anything BUT work that is completely above board. So for someone to complain about the company intruding upon them 'unethically' when they are using the company property for what it isn't supposed to be used for is completely unethical anyway. SHEEESH! Where do they find these people?!?
Ethics, morals etc. pshaw!
We are talking legality, therefore law applies and that's all there is to it.
Thank you, JD!
Well, Some organizations might view it that way (strictly legal). Others nevertheless will care about the extent of what is being monitored considering the moral of their team and soforth.
We appreciate your feedback.
by jdclyde
that run around telling people "their rights", when they have NO idea what they are talking about. We have both had our fill of the "Freedom of speech" losers. ([i]lonewolf anyone?[/i])
The ONLY obligation the employer has to the employee, legally AND morally is to inform the employees that all communications MAY be monitored.
Don't like it? Then frig off and start your own business!
Rock on Oz. The boys LOVED Maiden two years ago, so going to have to keep an eye out. Thanks for the heads up! ThingOne is ALWAYS playing "Dance of the dead" on the guitar. B-) Now, if only Priest would come back around again! Been almost three years, and THAT would be a cool show for them to go to.
by tonythetiger
not legal, but a kind of internal precedent. It was an employee's flash drive that was alleged to contain pornographic images being hooked to the computer. Our legal department determined that we could not use the contents of the files on an employee owned device for any other purpose except to determine whether or not WE owned any of the files. We are forbidden from even disclosing the names of the files we do not own.
Since then, we have changed our policy to allow only company owned devices to be used on company owned computers.
Something like...
Hi, my company has this function that we are including in our products. I'd like to get some input on whether this may cause issues for us....
Try that in a new post and you'll probably get a better response.
If you do, I promise I will give you my honest opinion, others likely will as well.
by oz_media
First of all, when yuo are using the company's computer, ANYTHING you do can be legall monitored by the employer. They can log and monitor your email, they can have al lof yuor outbound emails forwarded to someone else for review before actually being passed on (which i have done) and they can certainly monitor what files are transferred by a removable drive.
It is NOT your computer, yuo are NOT guaranteed any form of privacy when using a company's property, you can ALWAYS be monitored and watched if they choose to do so, with or without a specific policy in place, it is private property that you have the use of in order to conduct company business.
That if the function was only capable of disclosing the names of the USB extracted files and not the name of files already existing on the users usb device.
It would be fine for most organizations regulations and respect employees privacy.
by ic-it
and I think you are earnest in your request.
The point (which you have likely grasped by now) is that advertisement or enticement towards products is not an acceptable methodology on these forums. (Unless it is offered as an answer to a request for a tool that specifically meets the needs of the requestor and then affiliation should be disclosed).
Your name was fully disclosed, but there is nothing in your message that discloses your association to the topic until one goes to your site.
From an IT perspective I believe in the company's right to expect non-disclosure of critical information. Most users understand that they are subject to monitoring and your product would be a tool that could assist.
Personally I don't like your web site because of the way the information is presented i.e. the Shockwave/Java presentation of everything, but that is your perogative.
by ic-it
I don't mind a Flash intro (that I can cancel), but I want to look at menued options that can take me in and out of a site in a hurry.
Example:
menu item Products - Mouse over results in any products available and possibly sub-menus on a mouse over of a particular product.
When I am researching purchases, I want to see the choices, features, spec sheet and move on or bookmark for a return.
I don't want to be waiting for a page to load if I am on a slow connection.
Eye Candy is nice in it's place but not on most non-graphically oriented commercial sites, unless it is offered as an option such as; panoramic view of the new sporty blah blah.
But as I opened, it may just be me. ;-)
From the way you've put it, it seems like a legitimate and ethical use of the technology.
You are not snooping on the person's drive, only tracking what they are extracting.
ONe may complain that you don't have a right to track it if it's personal, but they would be wrong.
Anything on a corporate computer is fair game for the corporation and it is completely ethical for them to monitor traffic on that computer. The fact that the traffic is via a thumb drive rather than the 'net is irrelevant.
You pass my ethics test, for what it's worth.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
Thought you'd like that, I always like to be the bearer of good news.
Talking of good news:
Priest have just left the studio after recording a true concept album. All songs meld together and are focused on the life of Nostradamus. Supposedly a long, theatrical stage show with very few breaks between songs. Actors, props etc all following the same story.
Saw Priest a couple of times during the Angel of Retribution tour what a freakin' HOOT!!!!
Check out Maiden's site: http://www.ironmaiden.com for some teasers and a few peeks at thier 757, which Bruce flies himself between gigs.
Judas Priest: http://judaspriest.com/
and KK Downing has an AWESOME site now!
http://kkdowning.net/
have fun and Up the Irons!!!
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending