Discussion Locked

Is the mis-use of IT destroying our civil liberties?

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is a question that we all must think hard about because many Governments and private companies around the world are building up vast databases of personal data, biometrics and more.

The UK Government has already begun the roll out of biometric technology in passports, fingerprinting of school children and is well underway with the the UK National ID card and National Identity Register which will allow private companies and public sector to verify UK citizens using a single card and record all this activity. The UK ID card will also make use of iris scans, DNA and fingerprints. The UK Govt. also embarked on the NHS NPfIT (National Health Service National Programme for IT) in which all patient records will be centralised and can be accessed from anywhere.

Former PM Tony Blair and his successor have already shown their support for a national DNA database holding DNA for every UK citizen and the Home Office IPS (Identity & Passport Service) are also looking at RFID implants.

The UK Govt. like others has a terrible record when it comes to delivering IT projects and recent cases where NHS staff where viewing the records of a celebrity being treated at a different hospital, CSA (Child Support Agency) failing to deliver anything, NHS staff swapping swipe cards and leaving passwords at computer terminals and a report from the US about a company forcing RFID implants upon it's staff are all signs of what is to come.

Should we be embarking on these projects to use this IT technology to monitor, track, document and watch citizens 24/7?

HM Government and UK citizens have no formal relationship documented in the form of a consitution and this therefore allows this UK Government and future ones the right to use these systems as they like.

What implications for the future?
Do you want the police and Government to know your entire private life?
Is it the job of Govt. to award citizens identity or is it just the job of Govt. to serve the people?

11 replies

by rknrlkid

...I am against it, but not for the reasons most people think.

My problem is with the data handlers, actually.

Government workers, for the most part, are not the best and the brightest. (I have worked for state and federal goverment levels in the US, and can pretty well state this to be true.) Most of these workers can barely USE a computer, so you might as well forget about anything as advanced as this type of database. My experience with Human Sevices/Child Welfare etc workers are that they are barely a step above their clients. (Translation: they are poorly educated and computer illiterate also.)

My point behind all this? While the collection of data is theoretically a good (or neutral) thing, it is the user of that data that is the weakest link. Look at the mess that the Department of Veteran's Affairs had with missing laptops and hard drives. These are user problems, not computer problems. Elected officials must take the intended user into consideration when coming up with these policies. Unfortunately, our elected officials are EQUALLY computer illiterate, so the possibility of abuse and negligence is everywhere.

To paraphrase from Jurassic Park, just because we CAN do a thing does not mean we SHOULD do a thing.

by tony hopkinson

Only joking..

Who can say.

Find a donor to save a child's life.

Find the git who killed a child.

Get pulled in because some numpty made a mistake....

The scariest thing I find about the idea is the cost and me as a poor tax payer who will bear it.

As you say UK government's track record in IT is just f'ing horrible.

?100,000,000 for a "Hello Wrold" application is about their limit. :D

by jdclyde

about private citizens getting access to that information.

As if spam isn't bad enough, or telemarketers?

Stalkers delight to have all that information.

And with all the liberal groups demanding "right to know", it would be made public in no time, like most information in the US already is.

by tony hopkinson

Can you imagine the price for that sort of info.
In the UK civil service, someone at my level int IT earns about half as much and is overpaid.

The only good thing about the situation is they'll probably screw up the sale.

It's more likely to get out by accident than design. :(

by ben.rattigan

It's not about the limited legimiate use of these technologies (with the exception of RFID implants in the general pop.) it's about the fact there is not protection from this of future governments from using them for applications other than identity verification. Why does the Govt. need to know when I paid my council tax, got a book from the library or visited the doctor? They don't.

Your argument doesn't stand up because we could and probably will go further. Why not put CCTV camera's in every room of every house? Why not impose a curfew on the entire population? and so on... they would all stop crime, kidnapping etc... but who would want them?

Why should we have to suffer these big brother technologies for the sake of the few criminals?

The point is that governments all over the world (especially in the UK) are taking this technology too far! The Belgian's already have and ID and NIR database the same as will be implemented in the UK and it hasn't changed crime rates at all.

by tony hopkinson

The subject line was tongue in cheek, expect someone to mean it.

You are talking about power here.
Doesn't matter where you are left, right or dead centre.

Our political system lets those who desire it most, reach it, they aren't going to give it up.

This is merely more information about us.
There are already DNA databases, many cities already have wall to wall CCTV. Passports have to go biometric.

What they can do with a cell phone, or your PC activity is extra-ordinary.

Look at the data-protection act, it protects us from everybody but the government.

Stop p*ssing in the wind, you are just getting your trousers wet.

Every law you want made will have a get out clause in another. It will be ambiguous in places, it will be overriden for the 'public good'.

If you don't like it.
First kill the lawyers.

I'll be happy to help.

by drowningnotwaving

but by politicians, beaurocrats and the antipathy of the masses.

IT and related technologies are just another tool.

All the things you raised in your reply to Tony have all happened at some point (in terms of their social objective if not in their actual implementation), long before the application of computers.

My advice? Live your life expecting that someone somewhere is watching - it will remove significant amounts of paranoia.

They really are out there.

:)

by dadspad

Is seems more and more people are willing to give up some freedoms for safety. Unless there is large public resistance to the end of many freedoms as we have known it, many of these things will come to pass, but probably not all of them.

It is funny how generations have different values on their freedoms. It is very sad we fought 2 World Wars to protect freedoms we enjoy, now, by theats of violence, we seem to be taking them from ourselves.

Sorry, did not want to start a rant, please forgive. I do not do this often, do not intend to start a bunch of non-ending rants with others. :)

Edited to enclude more ee's

by av .

This is the age of Terrorism and unfortunately our civil liberties are going to be curtailed because of it.

The scary thing about this is the mis-use of the information. If your government or any government for that matter, could be trusted with the private details of someone's life, to handle it as it was intended, it could almost be considered a necessary evil. But, knowing how systems can easily be abused and how inept and corrupt most government systems are, I'd say its time to worry.

I don't like the DNA database idea or RFID implants. That is way over the top and I'm probably gonna get my guns out if someone ever tries to implant one in me.

There needs to be ALOT of public discussion before any systems are implemented. Criminals will not be impacted by it, just us regular folk and personally, I have my limits as to what I would tolerate.

This sounds like one of those science fiction movies that I would rather watch than be in.

AV

by ben.rattigan

for the ID card and NIR database which are the supposed great benefits for ease of access to public services. The system was first put forward by Tony Bliar's govt. as an entitlement card. Now after 2001 it suddenly changed to an ID card to combat terrorism and fraud, now they tell us it will help people with health conditions as it can be connected to the new Health Service database.

If the intention of such systems is to combat the terrorism in our modern world then surely that means if we do finally win the battle against this threat there will no longer be a need for these systems.

After WWII Winston Churchill got rid of ID cards in the UK under his "bonfire of controls", I don't think we will ever see a bonfire of these new controls though!

by drowningnotwaving

Under many guises in many countries such controls have been proposed.

It's easy to think of many reasons behind such proposals - not least of which is the need for significantly higher numbers of beaurocrats to manage and coordinate.

"Terrorism", as such, is just another validation (in their way of thinking) for such proposals.

This discussion is closed to new replies.