Discussion Locked

Is there an antivirus software conspiracy?

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What do you think about a potential antivirus software conspiracy? Do you agree with Jonathan Yarden that at least 90 percent of computer users are ignorant about how computers work? Share your comments about a potential antivirus software conspiracy, as discussed in the Oct. 18 Internet Security Focus newsletter.

If you haven't subscribed to our free Internet Security Focus newsletter, sign up today! Click this link to subscribe automatically:
http://nl.com.com/MiniFormHandler?brand=techrepublic&list_id=e044

17 replies

by gruvdog

There would be no money trail if virus authors were on anti-virus payrolls (ney sayers think before you flame me on this one).

Secondly the author makes the assumptions that such a money trail is: a) sought by law enforcement at all, and b)not well hidden if it exists. Both are naive assumptions.

by millennium7900

Because 90 percent of computer users have no idea about computers, isn't this WHY antivirus software is necessary and why virus's are successful? DA??

by rodney.owen

Like Jonathan I have worked in the IT industry for over 20 years and now teach others about how to work within the IT industry. It is funny that many virus out breaks coincide with the end of the University Software Engineering course and that many of the viruses released are rehashes of the old ones.

The success of the malicious code is directly linkable to the number of home PCs that don't have anit-virus software installed, no spyware removers installed yet are connected to the Internet with persistent connections.

Also the malicious code only appears after the details have been published somewhere.

It's time that users, those who know about PCs and those that don't, to take responsibility for the success of the malicious code. If the holes are plugged then the code cannot run.

by halc

Maybe you guys have been in IT too long.

How many precautions and programs does a user need to run to keep "safe" nowadays. Look a some of the other posts and your own clean-up arsonal. Things are out of hand for the average computer user and it is NOT their fault. I personally believe that Joe User should not have to worry about all the details of patch levels and intricacies of firewall settings just to use their computer. Most of the blame lies squarely on the operating system and software vendors who don't seem to have a clue about secure software engineering methodology. There aren't even patches for all the identified holes!

Oh and another thing, your second paragraph is total bunk. Being on a university network, we see new viruses/variants almost weekly that are not recognized by the latest definitions and we wait with baited breath for yet another release that includes the latest threats. The virus spreads in spite of the fact that we are running anti-virus software.

Things should be getting easier for the general user and in some ways they are. However, security is definitely not one of those ways.

by saphil9

I agree that there are a certain number of script kiddies who are all about bragging rights and who take previous worms and change them in minor ways to be able to brag about it.

There are also a few more serious programmers who write code to steal information and credit card numbers. These people rarely seem to get caught, though they are shut down pretty quickly.

There may also be terrorisic motivations as well, though I think most of the terroristic people want to kill, not just inconvenience, their target populations, so this does not seem like a large group to worry about.

There may well be government agents whose JOB is to disrupt business for the purpose of spreading fear, uncerntainty and doubt. Not necessarily US government agents, but the concept is not a real reach when you consider the other things governments do to further their own interests.
Do not forget Eschelon (the biggest packet sniffer in the world) run by the good old US of A for its own inscrutable purposes.

The conspiracy probably doesn't include the antivirus companies. They are living off of the fears of probably 70 percent of the users in the world, who are buying antivirus software to protect themselves from a perceived 90% of the users who are supposed to be inexperienced, confused or something. Yeah, I know the percentages do not add to 100, but that is my opinion. Why does nobody think these worms and trojans that run only in windows environments are written by people who design software for MacOS or Linux? That would make more sense, and they are a far more shadowy group than the people who sell AV software.

Wolf Halton
http://www.networkdefense.biz

by daniel.ddr

This so-called conspiracy is pure balloney and reminds me a lot of previous conspiracies that have generated so many dire situations. Very often, people tend to hide incompetence if not hate or worse behind such balloney.

I have my own LAN protected by a harware firewall, WINDOWS XP SP firewall, SPYBOT Search and Destroy and AVG anti-virus (both updated every week). On the top of that, I check updates at Microsoft twice a week. I run 3 computers and have been working with computers since 1984. I never ever had a problem. Moreover, I enjoy been on guard since I learn every day new stuff.

By the way, I have banned diskettes since 1990 and will never open something I don't know without running AVG. Also, I go to the on-line SecUser anti-virus once a month. Obviously, I do not kazaa whatsoever but I use VNC for remote work when I need to.

Keep up the good work

Daniel

by rodo

I do agree with some things Mr. Yarden has said about software conspiracy but I don't think (specially in USA) that 90 percent of computer users are ignorants or simply don't pay attention to details !!!!!

Thanks,
Rodolfo Sebastiao

by husp1

Strange, I seem to spend a majority of my time removing spyware from peoples PC's and most have minimal to no protection at all!!!! have you seen how many rely on the firewall in XP only? After removal I install spybot, avg, adaware, and winpatrol, these provide at least a minimal protection base and have a user friendly interface that most end users can work without difficulty.

by frankthynne

Your figure of 90% ignorance may be somewhat high, but I am sure that the majority of users do not understand the dangers they face, even though most are aware that dangers exist.

Given that level of ignorance, the suppliers of vulnerable software should take much more care to eliminate those vulnerablities and, until they have done so, should make it very clear to buyers that they need to service their systems with anti-virus protection and updates, and with their own software updates on a daily basis - and warn them how much time they might spend doing so.

If that frightens some potential users away, then so be it.

by rickb8

...He supposes that a conspiracy would involve reward for virus writers... And it probably would have to, whether it was money, prestige, employment, i don't know.

But a working conspiracy would also involve some exclusivity, ie the virus writers would have to be the source of the vast majority of threats, so that they could coerce the security software companies into reward. This is a flawed theory.

Many, many people look for security vulnerabilities of all kinds. Many of these people are not interested in reward from the anti-virus vendors, etc., but are more interested in the hunt. Others genuinely want to do harm.

In this environment, any collusion between even the most prolific virus writers and the most corrupt anti-virus vendors would fail when other 'freelancers' started causing trouble by releasing new threats.

Among the likely conditions of a working conspiracy would be advance knowledge of specific threats, and therefore a fairly quick (but so necessary, which equals valuable, which equals sales) response, further enhancing the reputation of the anti-virus industry. Slammer, Blaster, and other outbreaks make this very unlikely, so just a few virus writers outside the conspiracy would cause real trouble.

I think there is no conspiracy. There is no need for one. The virus writers have a target-rich environment with the poorly secured software so popular, and the anti-virus vendors have plenty of value to offer.

We are the victims of poor design, not *just* unethical virus writers.

rick

by thinker999

I don't believe that there's a virus conspiracy, as nothing is a secret that more than one person knows, and the bad press upon exposure would be a major mess.. But, back to the original point.

Regardless of the percentage of people who are uninformed as to how things work 'under the hood' it's irrelevant!

I'd venture to say that most people don't know how a cell phone works, but many people use them everday. Many people drive fuel-injected cars, but don't know squat about how it functions, or microwaves, or VCRs and don't know squat about how it does what it does.. And they *shouldn't HAVE to!* We ascribe a certain level of knowledge to someone attempting to use a computer that we don't require of any other device on the planet!

Anytime that a user can't take a basic install and run with it, without having to download, install and configure five other pieces of software just to run the thing safely 'out of the box' we have a problem ladies and gents! We tolerate holes in OSs and we tolerate holes in apps software, product faults, if you will, that we simply wouldn't tolerate in any other product. Perhaps if we held those folks feet to the fire, there's be fewer problems hitting the street to begin with.. And customers are to blame for feature bloat, and rushed release dates.. Anytime the marketing department can force the development side of the house to release a product before it's adequately tested and secured, they oughta be shot! Blame customers who insist on newer, better, neater, and stockholders who want to see products and profits, not necessarily in that order.

Ignorant simply means 'don't know,' stupid means can't or won't learn. We're all ignorant of something, and that's OK. I guess that local vo-techs and junior colleges, and PC sellers need to be teaching a 'defensive driving course for the information highway.' Most people work under the assumption that 'everyone knows the basics' and it's simply not true.. Maybe, at a minimum, when someone opens the box on their new computer, there needs to be text and recommendations as to what the user needs to do to protect their new computer before, or immediately after connecting it to 'the big, bad internet..' Contrary to popular opinion, basic knowledge courses would seem to still be a good thing....

by saphil9

I don't know why fuel injectors work, but I know that I need to update my tag every year whether the old one looks worn or not. I know I need to keep paying more and more for insurance, even though I never use it.
I know people who think the act of first install of their AV software is all they have to do. It is understandable, but it is still your computer, and like the car analogy, what you don't know.. can hurt you.

by jdclyde

To drive that car you have to take a class and get approved by your state to drive it.
After that, you have to KNOW to put gas in once in a while.

Anyone could learn basic upkeep.

The problem is that makes it more complicated than saying to grandma that all she needs to do is plug it in and go. Many people CHOSE not to learn anything more than they have to. Others never hear in the first place and should be told when they first look to get the computer, and again by the ISP the basics when they signup for internet.

by gryfon

However, there is also no incentive for the anti-virus software companies to actually sell products that work. Most of them are riding on their names from years past.

One of the worst offences I've seen is when a 'free trial' is given with a new system. Most users don't even realize it expires, OR that it needs updating. There needs to be a nice bright handout in the package (designed to grab the eye, running it by a pre-schooler might not be a bad idea). This handout should explain how viruses work, what social engineering is, and how to protect the system by avoiding risky behaviour and updating the definitions regularly.

For my senior clients, I explain updating the virus definitions is like a flu shot for the computer. Computers need them every week, though.

There's no incentive for computer retailers to teach their new computer owners how to protect themselves. The high speed service providers are STARTING to take a bit of responsiblity for helping their users avoid problems, but I still don't see a nice big shiny handout coming with the new high speed modems explaining about the troubles and pitfalls out there.

We don't sell cars to folks who don't know how to drive, but we routinely sell computers to folks who think it's just another TV set. Until these issues are addressed, we will continue to see these problems.

But then, that's just my take.
Gryf

by paulj01

No major antivirus/security software company would risk demise by unleashing a computer virus.
A firm with little to loose might release a designer virus, and then "save the day" by being first with a fix. That would attract attention of the legal kind. Plus, computer forensics are rather sophisticated and can almost finger a perpetrator by tracing and matching "fingerprints" in the metadata structure of a file.

Ultimately, hard to hide, unless you are anonomous--which a company that sells software is not. I suppose, a hacker could own/short stock or derivatives (e.g. options) of antivirus/security software firms, and profit handsomely from rallies, dips and recoveries caused by large-scale virus infections. That could be checked by searching stock transaction data in the timeframes (before, during and after) well-known virus epidemics.

Good article: No money trail links antivirus/security software firms with known hackers and virus agents. Examine stock market trading around past virus epidemics.

by sway

Jonanthon has obviously phrased his article to provoke response, as with 20 years experience he could not possibly beleive what he wrote!
Yes thare are conspiracies.........
Maybe or maybe not directly between anti-virus software firms and virus writers, but numerous side-show conspiracies are there.
The biggest is the one between the government and anti-virus companies! This conspiracy allows the market under which all other conspiracy theories are framed. If there was a real unified desire to stop viruses, then the government would be the only authorised anti-virus distubuter, the software would be free, and it would be paid for by taxes and levies from computer sales. In this environment there would be no market for private companies to produce viruses, or anti-viruses, and no market for inflated, costly anti-virus solutions.
As a red Herring point I'll add that I am sure ISP's enjoy the increase in "chargeable" client traffic caused by releases of mass-mailer worms. There is certainly potential for corruption there.
Someone once told me "Where there is potential for corruption, power, money , or sex, someone will and has, exploited it....without exception!" I think this is as true as you get. So for Jonathon, or anyone, to maintain the ascertion that there is not ANY untoward business activity involving virus/anti-virus parties, would be completely and utterly naive.
:-)

by gryfon

Trust me on that one! Having worked through several major outbreaks at the local ISP. The labour cost in support calls is huge, trying to explain to seniors what a 'virus' is, taking vital support staff off of other projects to deal with the overload, the list of reasons is very long.

Not to mention the extra traffic on the network causes problems for folks who are NOT infected, as well. Delayed email, slowed down dial up as well as high speed connections, it's just a major headache.

Using your logic, health care should be free, too. Funded with taxes and levies on the unhealthy lifestyle choice products people choose to subject their bodies to. Hey! That's not such a bad idea.... ;-)

Cheers!
Gryf

This discussion is closed to new replies.