Discussion Locked

Is this picture false or misleading?

0 helpful
39 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

39 replies

by jmgarvin

The problem comes down to two things:
A) where is the petrol being used? Are we talking consumption at the gas pump or are we talking over all consumption?

B) The US has a MUCH larger landmass than most of the countries listed...So why not per capita or per mile or something along those lines?

by ontheropes

I ran across it while browsing some time in the past and while going thru a picture archive I ran across it again and decided to post it here.

Just looking at it, if it's accurate, I have to say, "holy crap".

In response to A: Good questions. As long as the comparison is using the same measure for every country I don't see that it would make that much difference. Are we using as much in as the entire rest of the world. That just doesn't seem right.

In response to B: I believe I ought to look up the total populations of the other countries listed and their land area. I'll do that later unless someone beforehand comes up with something that totally blows that picture out of the water.

by jamesrl

in America need to drive long distances to work on a daily basis?

I don't buy all of the landmass argument at all. For most Americans and Canadians driving cross country is pleasure not business, with the exception of shipping goods.

Part of it is geographic, part gas pricing, part the size of vehicles. No doubt if gas prices in US were the same over a long period of time as those in western Europe, people would drive less and buy smaller cars. One pickup truck at roughly 15 MPG uses as much gas as 2 Honda civics at 30 MPG.

I don't think that the numbers are right or wrong, its the conclusions we jump to that may be right or wrong.

James

by ontheropes

I had saved that picture for further investigation and should've probably had all of my ducks in a row before posting it. My intent isn't to start a controversy but to come up with a clearer picture of reality. What I'm seeing so far in my little investigations isn't giving me a warm fuzzy feeling for the US and our consumptive lifestyle but that's just me. I'm sure others will see things differently.

by w2ktechman

however Brazil is something like 99% ethenol (sugar cane based). So their consumption would be in the form of large equipment/power plants, etc.

But even still, holy cr@p

by dawgit

That much is certain. The reference is from 2007, but is that for the year of 2007? How do they compute ?consumption?? Based on what? And of course the US uses more of anything than Germany. 300+ mil. vs. 85mil. Population. Definitely slanted to sway somebody's opinion. (poeple will belive anything in a presentation now, won't they? Thanks to MS and their PP X-( ) Question is for what (and who's) gain? Or just to make the US look bad again? Tsk-tsk, what they call journalism these days. -d

by ontheropes

I definitely don't think so just because you say so.

I looked up some numbers briefly and the picture looks fairly in-line with what I found.

by dawgit

Which is the point. I have a friend who has a "Civic" I'll have to ask him what the cost was on his last 'fill-up'. (The prices here have flucuated a lot but have remained in same general cost for about a year. aprox. 1.38 ? / Liter) Than again what is a "Fill-up"? Gas or Diesel? Appels or bananas? No, if it's not going to have established (scientific) methods, it's "Deceptive"! IMHO. -d

by drowningnotwaving

It's only misleading, Dawgit, if it's inaccurate OR if the measure used in different countries is different.

{ NOTE: I am assuming that, given the normal exemplorary research conducted and contested by regular members, that the LACK of anyone screaming about inaccuracy or inconsistency means it it probably neither. }

Or, for example (to pick up on your MS / PP point), if the scale was drawn exponentially so that it was visually misrepresenting.

Your questions are valid but explanatory. They don't make the graph any less correct.

Your point re Germany's population ??

IF the figures are accurate and consistent, it would only make USA's per capita consumption [b]4 times as high[/b], not 13 times as the graph shows (with margins of error of course!!).

I'd say 4 times is a reasonable difference, wouldn't you? Let's say my math are wrong and it's three times. Does that make a point for you?

Many people have made the point repeatedly - the US doesn't really have an energy crisis - it has an energy usage issue.

by ontheropes

That's cool.

I'm not trying to paint the US in a bad light at all. I'm just trying to determine some sort of accuracy so that I know a little bit more about what's going on in the world. If the US is using that much in comparison to the rest of the world it might just change MY opinion about my country. I'm open to the truth even if I don't like it.

by the listed 'g man'

but basic maths would tell us the the more population you have & considering numbers that drive vehicles, the more petrol you are going to use!

If they really wanted you to use less they could just hike the price up like China & the UK. Does not win votes however!

by jmgarvin

However, it seems like the skew is to paint the US as this uber consumer of fuel for ???? But it doesn't explain what the data MEANS...see my points before.

I'm not saying it's wrong, just empty of useful information.

I did like the CIA Factbook post though...That is disturbing. If we don't cut down our crack like addiction to oil, we're in deep trouble.

by delbertpgh

Petroleum use in U.S. is not due solely to size and population... China is about the same size (if you ignore Alaska) and has many more people, and has lots more people, but their petrol use is way below ours. We use more because we're a lot richer.

The picture fairly shows that the U.S. uses a lot more oil than anybody else, and that we are most affected by anything that impacts petroleum. The smaller inset graph showing the cost to fill a car is interesting; it indicates that the U.S. keeps the price of fuel cheap, which means we choose to accept the exposure to the risks from importing fuel in exchange for running our economy the way we want, and keeping our voters happy.

What it doesn't show is how we compare on a per-capita or per-dollar-of-GDP basis to other rich countries. Stuff like that would introduce questions like, are we making good choices on the way we price and use petroleum? If Germany or England can generate wealth with a smaller budget of imported oil, should we change our ways to stay competitive? Our big country makes long-distance driving more important to our economy than it is for England, sure. Most driving is not cross-country; it's often 40 miles from breakfast to work, though.

So, no, it's not a misleading graphic, so long as you don't try to use it to raise the wrong questions.

by ontheropes

I just put this together in the past half-hour or so and haven't compared it to the picture yet. Reminds me that I need to save my file.



If anybody wants the OO.o spreadsheet for themselves just send me a peermail and I'll be glad to send it to you.

by dawgit

A little more like acurate and hard data. (regardless of the source) The other graphic was too sensational (and lacking 'hard' data) in the way it is presented. "Use" (hard) and "Cost" (variable, -from day to day) are two different criters. (and a "fill-up" is exactly what? not exact.) -d

Your info also seems to discount China, however. That's supprising, since China is a major facter in the consumtion of the Worlds Energy. hummm. -d

by ontheropes

I got it in just the order you see, the same order shown in the picture. I was sure that when I got down to China I'd find information that would just blow the pictures info right away.

That didn't happen. I was really surprised when I saw that the USA beat China by three times over.

I'm probably going to make new charts just for the hell of it. I also want to check oil consumption vs. oil production. I'll never know unless I look.

In my case I think that the picture did what it was intended to do, it made me think. For that reason alone I'm calling it a good picture. Not great but good.

by charliespencer

Ropes, I like your data better because it measures oil consumption and isn't limited to measuring the use of one of many products refined from oil (petrol / gasoline, diesel, heating oil, non-fuel uses). What's the point in presenting the use and price of only one of these oil products?

The original is probably more deceptive than false. What point is it trying to make? It leaves out several factors in both sets of data. Vehicles per capita, taxes per liter (indicating a non-US source of this graph), average miles per vehicle annually, etc.

I'm not defending US gasoline consumptions, which I regard as atrocious and environmentally destructive. This graphic is not making this point (or any other) effectively. "Lies, damn lies, and statistics."

by jamesrl

Western Europe doesn't use as much gas per capita for many reasons, one of which is the popularity of diesels. Diesels in Europe are at least a third of all purchases, in every catagory from luxury cars to sub compacts.

James

by ontheropes

that the cost to fuel a Civic has little to do with oil consumption. I'm a little slow grasping that, what can I say?

The photo is obviously taken out of context. Maybe it made more sense when I got it, hard to say for sure. I should have saved it with a link.

I charted the numbers from the CIA data. This is what it looks like:

My charting tools and skills are pretty basic and rusty so please excuse the simple pie chart.

The fact that the US uses so much oil makes me think about a broader range of topics. I wonder about comparisons in the size of the military, number of jet flights, number of cars, average commute, tons of garbage per household, things like that.

Whatever the reasons it's interesting to me to see graphics showing how much oil we use in the US vs. other large countries. Now I'm a little more aware of the need for change.

by jamesrl

About being Canadian - we use alot of energy, partially because we have a colder climate (heating oil/Natural Gas) but partially because we have a similar lifestyle to Americans. Australians follow a similar pattern.

Americans burn gas because its cheap. Adjusted for inflation its cheaper now than after the gas crisis of the seventies when prices stabilized.

Europeans don't use less because they are virtuous, they use less because their cities are more compact, easier to build transit for, and gas is so expensive, they are forced to drive smaller more efficient vehicles.

China uses less because they have less cars on the road, but don't kid yourself, as the economic boom hits, their patterns will shift.

You could make gas more expensive in the US, but you can't eliminate urban sprawl with a magic wand. And urban sprawl makes it harder to build subway/light rail.

James

by hal 9000

Sure it's right after all a Picture never Lies does it? :D

Though the 1 Drop of Fuel to fill a Civic tends to imply that it's not driven much. :^0

Pity that the picture is Out of Focus though. :(

Col ]:)

by ontheropes

. :^0

The original picture does leave a lot to be desired as people have pointed out. Did make me think though. That's something. Maybe now that I've got that thinking jazz out of the way I can go back to my usual semi-comatose state and get some badly needed rest and relaxation. :D

by delbertpgh

Europeans taxed the hell out of gasoline after World War 2, I think because they were scared that trade imbalances would bankrupt their currencies, and because they had no oil of their own.

Besides depressing consumption, high oil taxes helped fund their expansive governments. Europeans didn't mind so much because they were fonder of city life than Americans. Americans on the average detest cities. They think that driving long distances from home to work is necessary to a desirable life.

Americans also have large oil reserves within their own country, which killed any need we might have experienced to protect our currency 50 years ago. And, oil companies have traditionally exercised great political power in America, keeping excise taxes low.

by ontheropes

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=527728&in_page_id=1770&ct=5

Recently there was some talk about taxing us here in the US another 40 cents per gallon supposedly to provide funding for fixing our highway infrastructure. Oh boy. Can't wait.

I haven't yet checked oil production, reserves, exports, imports blah blah blah for the countries show. It's on my list of shlt to do, just right not near the top of it.

At risk of sounding stoopid I'm going to say that I didn't realize how much our accepted average lifestyle impacts oil consumption in comparison to other countries. I had a vague notion but I wasn't sure.

One thing I did yesterday was to look at the consumption of oil by "pretending" that every other country had the same number of people as the United States. I then used the consumption figures and came up with these numbers:

To me it looks like oil consumption is related to lifestyle unless I screwed up manipulating my data and came up with some meaningless garbage.

Speaking as a citizen of the US I do feel that our consumptive lifestyle needs a do over though I am one of the last people that would force change on people. I think it needs to be an individual effort.

I'm not quite old enough to remember the times but there is an old saying, "Use it up. Wear it out. Make it do or do without." I try to do that in my own life. It can be just little things, as shown below:

by delbertpgh

I'm not in favor of disposable tableware, but the idea that a plate or a spoon re-used is free forever is not exactly true. It takes water (in short supply many places) and produces sewer waste (has to be treated) and requires heat (usually from burning oil or petroleum products) to clean up the dishes. Plus, building the infrastructure, and running the supply chains, to keep the good stuff flowing in and the waste sluicing out. That's the modern life we live.

by nicknielsen

They use different taxes for that. The primary purpose of the gas tax in most European countries was initially to subsidize the national railroad. Since then, this has been expanded to include most transit systems. The much lower population densities and greater size of the US make this prohibitively expensive in the states.

by jmgarvin

Still depressing, but a little more usable and far more informative than the original chart...

by ontheropes

The CIA factbook categorizes oil as shown here:



They don't show coal production at all. Interesting that you should mention it. It was just a couple of days ago on Discovery channel or something where I seem to recall hearing that the US has the largest coal reserves of any country. I haven't looked it up anywhere yet but I'm interested to know how our coal reserves stack up against others. Have any links handy?

by ontheropes

Makes me just a little angry too but then most of the time my sadness is expressed as anger. That's just one of my myriad character defects.

What do you think we, as individuals, should DO about our wasteful lifestyles? I know it's not practical to say we'll all get a job closer to home so we don't have to drive as far. I'm living in a big jobless black-hole myself as are my neighbors. Except for the rare local job opportunity to get anything that pays decent we have to drive 40 miles, if not more, to get there. Most of our local industry has moved out/laid-off.

One of the things I HAVE discovered is how to get by and be happy and somewhat content with less. Being one of the po' folk has been an eyeopener. I get by on a lot less than I used to. Looking back over the years, when I had money, I recall that I spent it on wasteful things and have little enough to show for it. My purchasing habits have changed out of necessity and I think that if I were to land a six-figure job tomorrow that I wouldn't change my spending habits very much. I'd definitely take my wife out to finer restaurants, buy some newer clothes and fix up the house/yard better but as far as really needing to have something I'm fairly satisfied with what I have and it ain't much. Personally I'd be happy living with my wife in some small cabin way back in the woods as long as we had electricity and my satellite internet. The struggle to live the American "dream" can kiss my ass. (can I say that here?) Maybe it's that whole redneck, live and let live thing.

On a separate note: I was watching X-Files yesterday and they got to the episode where Mulder turned over the X-Files to that guy whose name sounds for all the world like Agent Dawgit. I was going to watch the screen credits and check the spelling. It made me think of you every time they said the agent's name. How DID you choose your alias?

by dawgit

Ok, that got my attention. It would have sooner, (maybe) but T-Com decided to go and have server problems yesterday, and knocked out a whole lot of Broad-Band customers. All is well though, the temperatures (as well as tempers) did rise a bit in the Stuttgart Area. :p

Sadness vs. Anger vs. Sadness vs. Anger. Isn't that normally called ?Depression?? And switching between the two, ?Manic Depressive?. No, wait, I'm not a Doctor. I'm a Secrete Agent. :^0 It's ok, than, ( ?:| is that correct Jody?) there'll be no charge.

As for the ?Could / Should? Do for the consumption problems the Western World is having, (It's not only the US in this) it's simple. The first step to solving any problem is to first acknowledge there is one. It's seems that as a group, a society, we still haven't done so, beyond lip service, anyway. It always comes down to the ?It must be some else's ........? concept. It's ?Them?! Hey, ?We are the Them?. I know I'm preaching to the choir here, but you asked.

Actually, it's about Responsibility. If people would just start be responsible for that what they do. And recognize what they do directly affects others, as well as themselves, even in the future. Buying a $40-thousand house for $250-thousand is not a Good Deal. Ever. Driving a vehicle big enough to move cargo, when there are only two people involved. Going less than a few 'klicks'. To spend $'s, that people don't have. For things they don't need. Is Stupid. And that is certainly Not some else's fault. (yup, that would be a rant B-) ) That would be my idea, for starters.

Ropes, on your ?Discovery? that you don't really need a lot of money, and that it probably wouldn't change your life. I think that's still called ?Humility?, and it used to be considered a sign of ?Good Character?.

On the ?X-Files? thing. I can only say I've seen it, once. It's on the TV here, but being honest, I don't even have one of those things. (Never had the time to watch it anyway.) So, I'm a little clueless as ?Agent Dawgit?. But, I would have to say that anyway, wouldn't I? B-) If one Really want to know I got the 'nik', it would have to be through a PM. (secrete stuff, and all that) -d

by Former member

Someone payed an advertising firm to come up with a picture that takes facts and presents them in a given light. Depending on view, the picture can be truthful or misleading, but it is an effective ploy for the emotion it is intended to evoke. The truth of the matter is less important than the effect. How many of us have dressed in a suit when we appear before a bank officer applying for a business loan even though in everyday life the suit is in the back of the closet. Appearance does count in perception.

This picture is as important in what it does not say as to what it does say. As examples, population, travel distances, vehicle size and purpose, and the length of time that the data was collected from. If counted from WWII when the U.S. was one of the few surviving economies, the data would be meaningless. If collected from a few peak days two years ago, it would be meaningless. If collected on a daily basis over the last five years (1825 samples), then it might be meaningful depending on the other data used. Just look at the data not presented and ask why. The claim is that the use was for 2003, but for what period, what days, ect.

The point to take away is that it is an ad intended to evoke a certain image.

by ontheropes

It evoked all over me. I had no idea that our fuel consumption was so high in comparison. Not trusting it at first I had to save it as it presented info to me that I knew I was going to have to follow up. I'm glad I finally got around to doing it.

by Member 25348569

the Yanks don't use diesel for cars, only for trucks. All of them use gas so it's just apples. fill-up means exactly that, fill a tank from empty. My Ford Focus now takes $100 US from totally empty to brim-full.

I walk a lot more than I used to!

Neil :)

by ontheropes

You trying to "out" me. :^0

"The first step to solving any problem is to first acknowledge there is one."

Amen to that. In more ways than one.

I had an epiphany last summer while sitting around here thinking about everything. Not the little e everything I mean the all caps EVERYTHING. I just suddenly realized how much "stuff" I have that I don't use and how there are soooo many people soooo much worse off than myself. What'd I do? I cleaned out my closet and my barn and gave a TON of stuff to various charities. What else could I do? Seemed like a good idea at the time. Still does. I'm not really a very selfish person and like I said, I can get by with very little. Hell, I eat a meal of "beans and greens" as my main meal everyday and it hasn't killed me yet. Surprising how far you can go on very little money.

I sure don't go very far in my truck anymore. I have to plan my trips down to the last stop. Gas prices are kicking my butt. I'm an ol' country boy. I make two trips into town every week and that's it. I never go alone either so between my wife and I we get all of our running down at the same time. The bank, groceries (twice-one place has things cheaper than the other) and our "big night" out. We're doing our part to cut down on oil consumption by making sensible trips. It's the smart thing to do. :D

You're saying that about humility is the first time someone has mentioned that I might have a "good character" in quite a long time. :D

I've always said that to know me is to love me. I could be wrong. :^) :|

Oh well.

I just looked it up and it's Agent Doggett not dawgit but I bet I think of you every time I hear him mentioned on X-Files.

This discussion is closed to new replies.