One of the problems when discussion of centralization occur is that it always polarizes into the control vs. service level discussion.
Centralization doesn't mean everything in one place, or even one business unit. It means no matter how the services are performed it is to a standard methodology. Proponents of all IT in a centralized IT organization cite control and cost effectiveness as the reasons for the everything in one pot theory. Proponets of distributed IT cite response to service requests and better understanding of the customer needs. Both groups are right.
Centralization should mean one senior management structure and a standardized set of IT processes. No two organizations are exactly the same but the function of IT is. If you are a small company one IT group makes perfect sense, if you are a huge global organization it may be more advantageous to have several CIO's all reporting to a corporate CTO with all IT organizations following standardized service, procurement and costing processes. If the company has a strong IT Asset Management team and program centralization through standardization and process becomes easier.
The problems and inefficiencies that arise in a distributed environment is from each IT organization doing their own thing more than being seperate from other business unit IT groups.
Dave Keith
Director of Government Relations and Research
IAITAM
www.iaitam.org