Discussion Locked

ISA Server, Publish FTP on DMZ

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I am trying to publish a FTP server that is on the DMZ. On the ISA machine, when I publishing the internal (FTP) address as 192.168.x.x and the External as 216.210.x.x it says that the address is not internal. To get this to work I have to add 192.168.x.x to the ISA's LAT. But I have been reading that you should not add DMZ address to the LAT. What do I do.

3 replies

by erikdr

Pff.. quite some time ago I worked with ISA, though the general concepts are often comparable with my present fwalls.

First counterquestion is how you've set it up. When having a tri-homed perimeter (DMZ) structure, the 'DMZ' is considered by ISAas a 2nd _external_ segment. This also means that you can not implement rules between external and DMZ, solely packet filters. And what you've been trying to do is putting a publishing rule on the translation.

So if you are trihomed, the only SAFE solution seems to be to put the publishing purely in filters. A DMZ address in LAT does indeed seem risky. But generally, due to these restrictions, I'd consider back-to-back DMZ's better with ISA than tri-homed. They are a lot more expensive (extra machines and ISA licenses) and more difficult to manage because DMZ is 'internal' for outer fwall and 'external' for the inner.

However, if you don't follow my doubts about the product, at www.isaserver.org there are a bunch of ISA fans who posted a lot of detailed how-to documents, they might be able to help too...

Success,

- The Netherlands

This discussion is closed to new replies.