Discussion Locked

IT Clueless Company

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I recently just went on an interview for an IT management position with a medium sized company.

During the interview process it was quickly apparent that the executives had no idea on where they stood with regards to their technology.

I posed the question as to if they had a budget in mind or if they had any objectives that they would like to see implemented - you know like support is an issue, or we need to increase server uptime, or maybe we need to get control of spending...

Well, after I asked the question you could hear crickets chirping in the background.

I now I submit to you all, has anyone worked for a company that is "IT Clueless"?

19 replies

by stress junkie

As dpetrak said, have you found a business where the managers aren't clueless? I haven't.

Apparently they need someone who knows their stuff. If you fit the bill then is that bad? They can't know what they don't know. If you get the job then you can slowly educate them and they will say 'Thank goodness we finally have someone here that knows IT.'

by jaqui

if you play your cards correctly, not only do you have a job, with a decent chance of things working right, you have the opportunity to make sure policies and procedures for the it department are set out provide the best solution for stability, security, and cost effectiveness.

that's a dream situation.

by tomsal

I think this is a great opportunity, what city is it in? LOL.

Anyway...this could be good..as long as the company is financially stable and seems to have decent and sound business practices...you can look like a friggin' genius to them, since seems apparent they don't know anything about IT.

Btw, I also think most companies (particularly small ones) are clueless with technology.

lol

by oz_media

Many of these unsavvy companies, will not spend money to build the right infrastructure. THey don't care how much you scream about security, they haven't been hit and see little value in it. THey also don't understand OS changes, AV updating and salary.

The ones I've worked for that were clueless, were good for a no brainer paycheque but you soon get sick of trying to set out policies and procedures in a company that has no interest in either.

It COULD be fun, they MAY have goo dintentions, I'd wanna see the money first though. Give them a spending 'suggestion' and see if they run screaming.

I have been told "Oh yeah, we want ALL of that done!" but when it comes down to paying for the needed tools/hardware, no money to be found. "We don't need that, we have done without it for this long."

Many companies jump on the IT bandwagon with NO idea of what's involved, they just hire an admin and expect him/her to make it all go. In which case you just bide your time while looking for a better job and collecting the paycheque as you get no experience, gain no ability and spend all yoru time using outdated software because they won't see justification in buying upgrades until it's too late.

Be careful but take it for what it is, either a walk in the park with an easy paycheck, or a brick wall you will fight against during your time there.

If they can't give you a budget, I'd be pretty damn cautious about taking them up on their 'network' ideas.

Most of the time such companies feel that MSAccess with a file server constitutes a network.

by techierob

The last thing that you would want to do is be at the mercy of the managers who have NO idea what is involved or required with technology. I'm speaking from my experience here; but I have had managers who have had "bright" ideas they wanted implemented yesterday and it usually involves writing custom databases from scratch - not normally an overnight task.

This is the same mob of guys who think a good password policy is one in which everyone knows eveyones password - just in case they need to use another computer!!

Luckily for me I work in the administrative department - my manager at least has some sense about him and has allowed me to say just how silly these mundane tasks are...

But then again - this same manager was shocked when I told him that they were outsourcing support for windows NT... trying to apply his theory of sales to Operating systems; to which I quietly said "apples and oranges"

If you can guide these sheep to a safe pasture then thats a good thing - just don't get burdened with unneccesary tasks and responsibilities just because you're the only one who knows what they're doing. :)

by louk

Yes, but that's why they hired me! They realised they did not have the skills or the time to look after the new IT systems they had installed so they did the savvy thing and hired an IT manager.

by mlkiely

As with most things the most brilliant don't necessarily run the companies most times it is the most obstinate and steadfast(thick)people that get the management positions by attrition or birthright.As you realised they maybe don't even comprehend how to use the technologies let alone understand it's administrative workings.Now that we have addressed the 80/20 rule get on with the job of squeezing every last cent out of thier budget for your own tech lab and get yourself some new cool tools and set up a huge staff to give yourself a nice big buffer against redundancy as this is how they became your managers in the first place and this they will understand.In other words get a parrot and fly a pirates flag as you are now corporate IT man.

by dc_guy

If you're adventurous, don't mind taking risks, and are highly motivated, then this could be a perfect job for you, regardless of whether any of the predictions voiced above come true.

You're going to be completely in charge of building a state-of-the-art IT shop. Your duties will include convincing the company's leaders that they even NEED a state-of-the-art IT shop, as well as convincing them that the budget and timetable you submit are reasonable.

You're going to get a baptism of fire in project management. Every facet of it, including risk analysis, marketing, networking, requirements gathering, implementation, and user relations.

That's a lot of diverse experience. Regardless of whether your endeavor is a success, you will emerge from it as a wiser, more knowledgeable, and more capable manager. It will improve your self-confidence and your people skills tremendously.

Not everyone would be brave enough or secure enough about their abilities to take on this challenge. I don't think I would do it, for example, and I've been in this business for almost 30 years.

So, are you like me or are you like these other folks? That's the first question you should answer before worrying about any of the stuff you asked. If you don't have the attitude for this job, then don't take it. If you do have it, then by all means get answers to your opening questions. However, there might be no answers to find. It could all come down to who YOU are!

by jeremiah_f

When I hire staf I don't attempt to create redunancy in skillsets, I attempt to find staff that reduce the clulessness of my company. I have staff that are clueless in Finance, Sales, Marketing, or IT. On the other hand, those same staff are highly skilled in at least one of the other areas. this is an opportunity to do a job right, to create a legacy of sound IT practices, and to use your IT skills to support and grow the company. Never mock those who are technically challenged as they are often the ones who have the spirit and drive to build new companies, and the sense to hired trained profesisonals such as yourself.

by jdclyde

In many cases having a budget can be counter-productive. People will make a point of spending everything, because if they don't then some bean counter somewhere will decide they gave you too much and will cut you back next time, when a valid expense comes up.

I just put in for purchases as needed. The company knows me well enough to know that I have already done the following. Researched it and wouldn't recommend it if it wasn't something we NEED. Two, checked products and prices so we don't spend too much for something.

I know what will or won't get approved before I even ask for it. If it is something I feel strongly about, I will almost always get it.

It is good to be king.

by oz_media

I don't care for fixed budgets eaither but SOME spending budget needs to be realized.

A lot of these guys will fork out for computers and initial software thinking that's where it ends and you just keep it all runnign from that point onward.

I had the company where you got NOTHING without pulling teeth, then after a few years they realized that I wasn't wasting money but moving things forward after investigating and costing out solutions. It wasn't worth it for the two years of headaches and trying to get blood from a stone though. At that point I had had enough of trying to improve things proactively and just took a passive stance toward it.

by hockeyist

Lets hope that this wasn't a computer services company.
If you speak to the company management team in terms that they understand then you will be highly regarded and seen as a business enabler. Show them how you will reduce operating costs while impacting the bottom line positively. Getting the executive management involved in the IT decision making process will help push projects through to completion.
The most important question you should ask at the interview is "Will I have support from the management team with regards to my decisions" otherwise you will be just another "annoying" overhead which will be ignored.

by lojic

Sounds like you've got your work cut out for you...If the company is doing well and can spare cash for an IT budjet...then you'd have an interesting challenge. If you don't feel they are willing to make an investment dont waste your time.

by itadmingirl

Follow your gut on this. I was recently in a situation like this as well, only they had to lower their budget in order to restructure their financing. Take into consideration: their current setup, is it a band aid, or is it structurally sound only needing improvements here and there? How far away is the new expenses forecasted and how does it affect the current setup? Will you have an opportunity to sit down with the person you are replacing and does he/she seem a bit disgruntled? If you do decide to accept the position, take an inventory of EVERYTHING, make sure it's still there. Make sure that once you start, you're not spending all of your time fixing problems that were just hiding under the surface before you started.
Remember it doesn't matter who was there before you, and whether it worked or not. What matters is that you're there, you need to fix it regardless of who put it there to begin with....
Ask yourself, is it worth it?

by neferious

I appreciate everone's replies,

I guess in summary, it's a good opportunity, but be careful.

by jimkelly

I would try to find out what happened to the last IT manager. It appears they have no clue as to what they want, what their needs are or what goals they should have. This means they will have unrealistic expectations and since they don't have a budget, they may not even have the money to accomplish what they want or need ! If you are unable to deliver the "needs of the day (and that will change daily)" because of budget issues, company politics, or lack of their technological understanding, then trust me ...You will get the blame !!! Again I would try to find out what happened to the last IT manager and make a decision at that point.

by biggerthanmost

I'm living in your scenario. It can be wonderful or it can be the biggest trap you could ever walk into.

The bottom line is that your success or failure will have little to do with the results you achieve professionally and more to do with less objective measures such as: the phase of the moon, how well you mix drinks at the bar, which customer you please and/or put in their place etc.

It's a risk. You may end up a superstar with the keys to the company cottage in Europe, or on the street with someone?s boot imprint on your butt.

This discussion is closed to new replies.