Discussion Locked

IT Debate: Security consulting firms

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Gartner maintains that there are clear reasons for when an enterprise should, or should not, choose one of the Big five accounting firms for security consulting services. Can you find the same quality consulting services from smaller firms? If you?ve dealt with the Big Five in the past, what advice would you give to other IT managers who are working with their consultants? You can read the related Gartner article, which will be posted 3:00 AM Wednesday, at https://www.techrepublic.com/article.jhtml?id=r00620001115ggp01.htm

5 replies

by plantogo2000

Any consulting firm regardless what they are hired for is going to work with the intention of doing more work. This understanding (assumption) from the beginning must be considered throughout the contract.

The biggest reason to select a Big 5 company is their experience, ability and consideration for the company as a total enterprise. One must recognize that especially the consulting project manger will be wanting to penetrate the company and report to the executive and not the person in charge of security for the company. This delicate balance is difficult to maintain and in the final analysis there will be effects. Not all of the fallout will be positive and there will be casualties.

Consulting firm employees are looking for opportunities to further their own careers. This includes letters of recommendation from the company being served and the ultimate kudo is to be offered a job in the company. This search for recognition competes with the performance of company employees.Partners of Big 5 consulting firms are partners because they have clients that cannot do without their individual services. Partners are plugged into every contract at its most intricate levels and operate its staff to not only do the best job possible, but to collect intelligence and look for opportunities to conduct additional business. This environment is extremely sensitive and that is why consultants are a breed apart.

It is possible to find quality consulting services from smaller firms. However, the reasons a smaller firm is small will prevail and illustrate itself in resources, talent and ability to react to opportunity and crisis. A Big 5 firm has unlimited world-wide resources and has extensive information of a company?s industry.

Whoever is hired to provide the security service needed is a vendor and needs to be managed as such. The forces to receive the most for the lease is the goal.

by plantogo2000

Any consulting firm regardless what they are hired for is going to work with the intention of doing more work. This understanding (assumption) from the beginning must be considered throughout the contract.

The biggest reason to select a Big 5 company is their experience, ability and consideration for the company as a total enterprise. One must recognize that especially the consulting project manger will be wanting to penetrate the company and report to the executive and not the person in charge of security for the company. This delicate balance is difficult to maintain and in the final analysis there will be effects. Not all of the fallout will be positive and there will be casualties.

Consulting firm employees are looking for opportunities to further their own careers. This includes letters of recommendation from the company being served and the ultimate kudo is to be offered a job in the company. This search for recognition competes with the performance of company employees.Partners of Big 5 consulting firms are partners because they have clients that cannot do without their individual services. Partners are plugged into every contract at its most intricate levels and operate its staff to not only do the best job possible, but to collect intelligence and look for opportunities to conduct additional business. This environment is extremely sensitive and that is why consultants are a breed apart.

It is possible to find quality consulting services from smaller firms. However, the reasons a smaller firm is small will prevail and illustrate itself in resources, talent and ability to react to opportunity and crisis. A Big 5 firm has unlimited world-wide resources and has extensive information of a company?s industry.

Whoever is hired to provide the security service needed is a vendor and needs to be managed as such. The forces to receive the most for the lease is the goal.

This discussion is closed to new replies.