80 replies
by dawgit
New Years resolutions. :D or a good cause for the revolutions. ?:|
But Max, try not to think about it that way, life is supposed to be a chalange. :p
(it wouldn't be fun otherwise :) )-d
and remember it's Christmas time.!. so, a merry one to ya. (and a safe one too)
by delbertpgh
by jardinier
Why do you think there is right wing and a left wing in politics (or in society in general if you prefer)?
Do you think it is inevitable that there will always be a right wing and a left wing?
Do you think it is possible for any society to exist for any length of time at the mid-way point between the two extremes?
I think there are many examples in history and in the world today in which extreme right or extreme left wing societies survived for a long time. But a characteristic shared by the extremes is a totalitarian government -- whether ruled by one person or a single political party.
by tig2
I understand where you are coming from- to me that has always been transparent. I don't always agree with you- but I don't think that this is what you seek. You are willing to set out your opinions and, to me, provide that information as simply that- your opinion.
I don't see you as out to change anyone. Like many of us, you come here to discuss and debate.
I freely admit that I don't always understand but I have also always found you willing to clarify.
No one always gets on with EVERYONE. If they did, I think that we would all go stagnant pretty quickly.
To echo Dawgit, there is joy in the season. May you have it in abundance!
He said: I'm giving up boxing.
I said: I thought you loved it?
He said: I do, but other f-ckers just want to hit me all the time.
You know you love it.
Without radical fanatics like yourself Max how would fat dumb middle-of-the-roaders lke me ever see the far side?
Merry xmas bah humbug and whatever a fanatical muslim would say at this time of the year . . .
by onbliss
by maecuff
Stop being a whiny ass titty baby.
Yes, down is up and up is down and it's always been that way. You have your convictions. That is more than many people have. I admire that in you, even when you're wrong. :)
by jaqui
listing the prerequisites for politicians and accountants is not a good way to start a discussion :p
[ no wonder everything is so screwed up :D ]
by deepsand
"Poor me; I'm so mis-understood that everyone picks on me."
Try treating others with civility, cease with the all-knowing, superior, self-righteous attitude, and you just might find that others will respond accordingly, rather than simply blowing you off.
The ball's in your court.
by jardinier
by jardinier
you have a simplistic -- I would even say naive -- black-and-white view of the world, while all the time most things are in all the shades of grey in between the extremes.
Your pet peeves which you repeat ad nauseum have become so boring that I avoid posting in any discussion which contains them.
I think you are a very decent human being Max, but I think you live in a world of your own making which rarely touches base with the pragmatic view of us lesser mortals.
You have expressed an ambition to stand for public office.
I believe you will get the shock of your life when you learn that in order to be elected, you will have to make promises that you know you will be unable to fulfil, and if you get into office you will have to play the game just like the rest.
There is no place in politics for an honest idealist.
Look in the mirror, dude. When was the last time you replied to ME with "civility"?
I will say this, however. There are only a hand-full of people who are not deserving of my "civility", and you are one of them. You disgust me. And unlike most people who've replied, you also missed the intent of the message. I received TWO peer mails from people, for example, who loved the humor (that was intended). I'm not surprised you missed it. (Disclaimer: As with all humor, however, there is an element of truth to it.)
Do us both a favor, deepsand, and don't read any of my messages. They're not intended for you, nor do I care what you think. I'll go on the record as saying I want nothing to do with you. (This is where you will spew your nonsense about a public forum, freedom of speech, and all your other crap.)
by deepsand
You seem to have overlooked the fact that it is [i]you[/i] who are the first to aggressively attack those who fail to submit to your self-perceived superiority, with the result that you delude yourself in believing yourself to be the injured party.
If you don't want to be criticized for being arrogant, all you need do is to stop being so.
by tonythetiger
[i]I believe you will get the shock of your life when you learn that in order to be elected, you will have to make promises that you know you will be unable to fulfil, and if you get into office you will have to play the game just like the rest.[/i]
... government is evil.
What's the point?
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=205737&messageID=2135818
by jardinier
[i]Here's an offer to you. Ask away, and I'll answer.
The tough part, however, at least for you, will be asking a question that presupposes nothing; is not leading or suggestive; is not an attempt to entrap, debate or discredit; and does not attempt to make a statement or form a predetermined conclusion.[/i]
My question does not fit into any of these categories that you have listed. If you feel I was attempting to ?entrap, debate or discredit? you, then you are reading something into the question which was not intended.
[b]But any question that is born of a desire to understand could be easily and consistently be answered.[/b]
So why did you fail to answer? Of course your initial post was humorous, but I accepted your invitation to ask a question, which no-one else has or had done.
I was asking you a reasonable question which you failed to answer for two days.
My personal opinions of your outlook on life do not prohibit you from answering the question.
Please note the dates of my various posts. I only made personal comments about you after waiting for TWO DAYS for a response to my perfectly reasonable question which did not seek to entrap you or any of the other conditions.
by jardinier
It was you who invited me to rejoin the discussions. Now you didn't REALLY think I would be nice to you, did you? :)
I mean surely you wouldn't want to end our lovely feud which has thrived for four years.
]:)
by jdclyde
because I had an older brother, and grew up to my daily beatings.
The rules changed depending on who they were being applied to, and keeping something that I had worked hard for to myself was not an option.
After I grew up and moved out on my own, I found the Democratic party was very much like my new older brother.
by jdclyde
by tonythetiger
1. Protect us from invaders.
2. Act as a referee when the rights of one interferes with the rights of another (maybe that's covered under your 'removing obstacles'?).
by jdclyde
"Is to supply a safe and secure place to live,"
protect from enemies, domestic or abroad.
Although basic law enforcement should be handled by the State governments, not the Federal government.
If a bunch of scumbag liberal city counsel members want to steal my land so they can put up a mall to increase tax revenues, the government should execute them, not reward them.
Of course, defining the role of government so simplistically will never happen. There's about 3 million global constitutional lawyers that aren't so stupid as to let that $hit fall through the cracks and ruin their careers. :)
Here's a couple of quick questions:
JD: As for your hanging-from-the-trees local representatives, tell me this:
Isn't there some (usually) rich developer with a group of lobbyists who have similarly convinced the council that getting a few houses out of the way is actually 100% PERFORMING your defined role of government, except for them not you?
So inherently you have built a conflicting purpose into your govt's role.
So conflicting in fact that just about every newspaper every day carries a story about one individual's rights being crushed to favor those of another.
Or to spin it around, "a sensible decision to the benefit the entire city, resulting in the creation of jobs and infrastructure and attracting new growth for the future has been made by the council. Okay, a few people got f'cked over and offered 20 cents in the dollar for their homes but that's PROGRESS my friends".
(And here is where the kevlar helmet is placed firmly on the head . . .)
JD MAX TTT: What about those people for whom the government doesn't protect their rights in the same way simply because their right or need was more or different?
Specific Example: It isn't that many years ago, I'm guessing between 5 and 20 years depending upon where you come from, that building codes where amended to enforce access and proper use for disabled people.
Now I remember the howls from developers and building owners and their renters about how this was an imposition by upping the cost of building and reducing in some cases the available workable area of smaller buildings for ramps, special facilities etc.
Now of course we all think it is the norm, we all welcome it, and we all have stories of people with some sort of disability who has a lot of fun making their way and making a contribution.
But it isn't that many years ago that the opportunities for many of those people were hugely less than they are now.
When it happened, was it a good idea or an imposition?
I use that 'tame' example to show where a degree, some small degree, of actually making intrusive rules is necessary and beneficial. We need to sometimes make people go out of their way to act in a certain acceptible fashion.
At the other end of the "rules" spectrum there are the anti-trust laws and similar where the freedom to act in a certain way must be limited when the size of the protagonist gets to a point where their actions negatively impact the lives and liberties of so many.
{...and whilst very few people are gutsy enough to say those laws should be overturned, lots of folk come out of the woodwork at every single specific example pointing out how IBM, Microsoft or the Big E (to name but a few) shouldn't actually be [i]subject[/i] to them}
So even to meet your definition/s there is a massively complex juggling act that has to take place, and clearly not all intrusion and control is bad.
Now will that lead us closer to synergy? I suspect not. But it's interesting as fundamentally I share your definition and desired outcome. I just get concerned that too many people use that kind of definition as a free license to f'ck people over in every sense.
edited - speiling
by jdclyde
Your rights end where another persons begin.
When "government" starts passing legislation "for our own good", it is slippery grounds.
Years ago I had an acquaintance that worked at a major retailer, "KMart". No, he did not have medical insurance, but most young guys at that time didn't bother with insurance because we of course are going to live forever. Enter Democrats and the "feel good" crowd. They passed a law saying employers had to give full time employees health insurance. Results? My friend gets his hours cut back to part time, and now has to get a second job to pay his bills. No, he didn't have any other training, and he made enough to live acceptably (before the cut). How did this new law of telling people how to spend their money help?
Handicap accessible. A good thing, to a point. Our local library system just spent a lot of money "modifying" a historic library to make it more accessible. We have two other libraries in town, one is a one story and completely accessible and one is brand new and very accessible. With the option of the single story and the brand new BIGGER one available, it was a major WASTE of resources to do what they did for the third. Yes, they are only about a mile away from each other. Now the library system is running short on cash, so they are having to cut back on available hours. Yeah, that WASTE of money on the renovation really helped everyone, huh? Some things are taken to a stupid extreme, and it was in this case.
If a neighborhood is run down and a blight, it is a very different case than if it isn't. The cases I followed were nice older neighborhoods. But if it makes you feel better, save room on the limb for the developer. Rope is cheep.
We have a seatbelt law here in Michigan. When it first passed, it was a secondary offense, meaning you could not get pulled over for not having it on. This is because privacy advocates didn't want cops to be able to use this as an excuse to pull people over to look for other things. Well, years later, the "government" took it upon themselves to change this to a primary, so they now will actually have "check points" looking to make sure you have your seatbelt on. And yes, Michigan is run by a bunch of liberal weenies.
As soon as you start spending someone elses money, you have to tread carefully, and THINK instead of just FEEL. That is the main difference between a liberal and everyone else. The liberals just CARE so much they feel that the ends justify the means.
by jamesrl
Along similar lines, I was hearing this morning on my drive radio program that the Ontario government is looking to combat high school drop outs by taking away drivers licenses from people who leave school. They can get them back by starting up school again or when they are 18. They have modelled the program after those in many states; the interviewer spoke with someone from West Virginia where they think its been effective.
Personally this goes too far. I grew up in the country, and there people need to drive to work. If parents want to take away priveleges to induce kids to go to school, or if the boards of education want to run stay in school programs, or re-entry programs - thats all fine.
Where it crosses the line is that it is punitive. I'm all for getting kids to stay in school, and if parents want to punish, thats one thing - its entirely another for the government to take that approach.
James
by shellbot
but wow guys...
i think some people need to lighten up? I thought Max was showing a bit of humour here no?
"where history is fantasy and fantasy is history"
I've been thinking about that exact thing for a while now..how much of earths history is fantasy? How can an archeologist look at a bone and tell me that a tribe used to live there and they ate x, and did y. No, sorry mate, you found a bone..and yes, maybe a tribe lived there, but don't suppose your thoughts as fact..
anywho's..thats my inane drivel for the day :)
Peace
by onbliss
...won't they be consuming food from that area? Unless the bones belonged to people who were traveling; looking at the flora and fauna in the region maybe it is possible to tell their staple diet and how they got their staple diet (hunting, gathering, farming....)
:-)
ps: How's the MCSD/MCSTS thing going? I just bought a book for 70-536.
by shellbot
bones..tribes..food..meteors..dinosoaurs..
agggggghh
yes, the MCSD thingy..slowly. When my kid was messing around, i had to take a bit of break from it. Back into it now, finished my VB.net. ADO.net (course 2389) is keeping me awake at night right now..just started it, but its ok as i used regular ADO for a good while and I spend so much time connecting to databases that its easy enough going...(i'm sure by next week i'll change what i'm saying)
Hows yours going then?
Some people couldn't see humor if it smacked them right in the nose.
(Although I did expect some serious side-discussions would result, because this "humor" has that element of truth -- and the truth sometimes hurt.)
by gadgetgirl
You've been getting into disagreements?
Really?
I hadn't noticed.
When was this? What happened? Who was nasty to you? C'mon, babz, tell GG all about it. You'll soon feel better.
GG
PS: by doze! thomething hit by doze!
:p
by onbliss
by puppybreath
but I'll venture a shot.
Now first Max, I reject your conditions. I see no reason why my answer should guide all further discussion. I have seen lots of duplicit answers (including your good self)and can't understand why I don't have the same privilege. :)
But here goes the dare:
Yes there are myriad situations where a person should be "forced to serve another".
* where the rights of one person are impinged by another but the former has neither the knowledge or resources to fight/contest/debate with the latter.
eg: Any company knowingly dumping their waste in public / open property, lake, ocean or air. Regardless what that waste is. Regardless of its toxicity. If you create it, you must pay the costs of dealing with it. You pay for filters. You pay for removal. You pay for recycling. You pay for the mega-high-temperature incinerators. You pay the whatever, according to the nature of the waste. And no, dumping it 200 miles off shore into the ocean doesn't count as a responsible manner of removal.
As an individual "I" shouldn't have to find out about it. I shouldn't have to complain. I shouldn't have to take a case to a court to get it stopped.
There should be an automatic onus and responsibility enforcable with jail terms that individuals or companies "clean up after themselves".
So there are a whole category of areas where social responsibility, if left to everyone's self-conscience, has proven to be a failure.
And if you want another example? (Sorry I can't recall the name of the act but there is . . . ) An American statute that governs the acts of american-based corporations around the world.
(and please i'm not US-bashing it's just the easiest example to use - I completely acknowledge that it happens here as well daily)
It is unbelievable, unfathomable that companies who have found and agreed that their products are (in some fashion) dangerous, and remove them from one market, then go on to continue to sell them in other markets / jurisdictions. And in many cases they accelerate their efforts!
That activity is completely akin to the person who can't have child sex so gets on a plane and goes to Thailand to try to get around the laws.
That is another area where 'self control' has proven to be ineffectual.
And, uncontrolled, it often simply causes death.
So there are a couple of (I hope) non trivial answers where I think regulation works very much in my and your favour.
-0-0-0-0-
Yes there are myriad reasons where that should never ever have to be the case.
And the classic case in my opinion is conscription.
Forcing someone to fight for freedom seemingly defeats the purpose.
I also think the raft of 'anti-terrorism' laws throughout the world have actually reinforced a level of complete control by government at the expense of our freedoms.
Unfortunately, I don't think we'll realise this for a few years. Governments and their police forces will commence interpreting and using those laws in ways that they were not intended but are actually allowable and predictable.
A government effectively reducing our freedom, in the name of our freedom, is very suspect.
-o-o-o-o
I take very much JD's and your point Max that there are examples where the laws are overused and abused. Yes, my tax paying dollars should ensure that every government building has reasonable access for all people. That includes ramps. It also includes signs in multiple languages for complex meanings.
And I also agree Joe Restaurateur should not have the added expense of the ramps etc. It is his decision whether or not to target that market. I operated a charter boat and (about once every two months) had to turn away parties with mobility-challenged folk 'cos neither the boat nor my staff were adequately prepared. (luckily boats don't have the equivalent of building laws).
But that is the pendulum effect - it rarely sits properly in the middle. If it did, you wouldn't have to continually embarrass yourselves by saying you are Republican voters, now, would you? ;)
by puppybreath
[i]"And assuming that is not taking place"[/i]
... well the problem Max is that it is, it does, and when pointed out to the republican movement it either gets washed asied as you are attempting to do, or it gets defended in that corporate need and greed exceeds my rights as an individual all the time. For the better good or something.
The individual gets called the complainer and whinger. Or (god forbid) a Greenie. Like that is the worst label.
When you think about it, defending the right of the corporate entity and the greater good, over the right of the individual, is actually quite socialist in a way.
And hence your simplistic and insubstantial definition of the aim of government is basically unworkable in reality.
And when you say "now why don't you define the role of government in one or two sentences", assuming of course that such simplistic definition is mandatory, you automatically assume a moral / debating high-ground.
However hats off to you on the disabled stuff. First person with the conviction to stand up and say you think overall that the rights of other individuals should not be impinged to create a positive impact or environment for a minority.
I don't agree with you one iota but at least you've got the guts to say it.
I'm not ashamed of it!!! I said it Max. I gave examples of it.
Your specific response of:
[b]"when one person does not "impinge" on another"[/b]
... implied your agreement.
{NOTE: I took your lack of cohesive argument against the specific points as tacit agreement that such situations do exist and hence government action is allowable. Your very first post gave me that privilege and goddammit I'm taking it.}
Thus there ARE situations where governments have a right and duty to make rules/laws to make us or companies do things that we may not automatically wish to do.
If they're not too simple questions for you, how about these?
Q1. Who wins? Some person who quite properly who wants his house, family and neighbourhood protected, or the 'company' (made up of course of individual people inside and as shareholders) that wants to build value, jobs and future prosperity potentially to the benefit of many people?
Q2. Is it possible to answer such questions with one succinct response that becomes the foundation of every future response you'll make?
sorry edited to make a proper question
by deepsand
Well Max it hasn't taken long . . .
In the space of 2 weeks good old obnoxious Max is back.
You put forward a statement and thus it becomes gospel.
When questioned directly about the correctness or actual practicality of that statement, you completely ignore the questions.
You aren't actually prepared to engage but when someone else tries you go for the head-shot.
And just counting, I got at least 8 examples of you performing your 'original' points/behaviours from your last 6 notes. So happily that does indeed make you a fully-fledged TR threader - just like every one else.
Things are indeed back to normal.
Oh and by the way, great place to launch the new thread. Highly effective.
No, that's called a little book with the title:
"There's a Liberal underneath my bed"
or similar, if I have the title slightly wrong.
Or is that just opening up the eyes of kiddies to the dangers of the world?
So difficult to see the distinction sometimes.
Question - who died and made you god?
For someone who believes in Freedom Max I could find a fair few examples in your posts of lots of ordering around. Lots, in fact.
And, you simpleton (said the gnat), the 'definition' of government is not really the issue. It's the way in which they aim to achieve that outcome that causes the problems.
Your post is more revealing than you perhaps think. You're all for freedom at any cost, even at the cost of other people's. Then they simply become gnats.
True colours shine through.
by dr dij
all his posts are dissolving into nothingness, being changed to blanks!
Good luck with your future world where torture is condoned, global warming is made up and freedom of the press restricted to what the gov't wants them to say!
Please don't call yourself a Libertarian.
by deepsand
by deepsand
by dr dij
who didn't lick his feet.
I still haven't figured out how he got 1132 thumbs up unless he was link-sturbating! He had zero answers to other people's questions.
(not on TR!!)
He seemed kind of fossilized.
Well, he probably needs a new job and was covering his tracks. I don't think he was dumb enuf that Maxwell Edison was his actual name tho so why bother?
I guess he realizes his posts are kind of fossilized and stupid sometimes?
by deepsand
by tig2
But I can tell you that no matter what- you bring a voice that must be heard.
Let's just call this a "do-over". You are welcome here, in this place.
Good to know you, Max.
by av .
Didn't he? Thats what it says in the post.
AV
by dr dij
Shows how much he believes in what he said to go wipe out his posts a year later.
I agreed with his positions on personal responsibility. Too bad he doesn't want to take personal responsibility for his contributions to pollution.
I once mentioned that the WSJ editiorial staff had pretty stupid last gasp / grasping at straws opinions on GW 'just like Max' and he said something along the lines of 'well, how do you know it's not me?'
http://news.yahoo.com/s/huffpost/20071206/cm_huffpost/075636
so maybe Max IS Jenkins?
Anyway the gist is they can't deny GW science so they are denying it based on the perceived solution (redistribution of wealth). Frankly the problem is independant of the solution which could be any number of things.
And also, if the industrialized and developing worlds are causing the problem why should people not help solve it proportional to their contribution to the problem? Why should a farmer in the Africa have to pay for something he not causing?
by av .
I think he did it to emphasize that he has nothing more to say on TR. By wiping out his posts, he made his point.
Lots of people feel just like Max did about GW. GW is everyone's problem regardless of how it was caused. Theres only one Earth.
AV
by dr dij
(not about GW but Max's opinions)
"Lots of people feel just like Max did about GW. GW is everyone's problem regardless of how it was caused. Theres only one Earth."
I got the feeling from his posts that he felt it was unlikely humans caused it and even if they did it was not his problem to solve (he needn't take responsibility).
That's why we were so ticked at him. 1) deny the evidence because he doesn't like the solution, 2) deny responsibility even if there is evidence of warming, say it's natural.
BTW, there's some good news on the horizon. A plant is opening, probably in 2008 for nanosolar, which will be producing solar cells for cost of $.30 / watt eventually. ($2/w with silicon currently). $1/w is competitive with coal.
They get this cheap by NOT using ANY silicon, and simply printing the cells in 5 layers on aluminum film. from popsci
by av .
I see your point. PS - in case you read this - Fred Thompson is not going to be our next President.
AV :^0
by dr dij
Oh, I miss the Daily Show and their making fun of everyone. I think it is a vast conspiracy, probably by our veep, (or any number of other poly's) who they've likened to Darth Vader. I was impressed by Mrs Cheney showing up on the show and giving John Stewart a darth figurine, pretty funny!
I sure hope the writers can work it out but I think it's unlikely they'll get any money from the internet because everyone steals the content.
The writers are on strike over Internet profits. We all know Al Gore invented the Internet, so Chaney is obviously opposed to it. The Mrs. was actually on Stewart's show to let the writers know the Veep backed the strike. The strike reduces the number of media attacks on the administration. Since the web is the source of the labor dispute, the left-leaning Hollywood elite irritated with it and turns away from it. Since all liberal bloggers do what Hollywood tells them, they too abandon the web. The reduction in liberal bloggers weakens Gore's global warming position, thus benefiting Chaney's buddies in Big Oil.
See how nicely it all hangs together? Where's TheWebNinja when I need him?
by deepsand
by av .
I think Max felt that the whole GW thing is a scam designed to take your money. He had some interesting arguments that should make everyone think, given the government's or media's track record.
I can't be mad at anything Max had to say even though I didn't agree with him sometimes.
I never heard of nanosolar, but anything we can do to get off oil is a step in the right direction. Our country needs to pursue alternative energy.
AV
by ripvan
by deepsand
Might it not be the case that he either wishes to continue using the same alias elsewhere, or otherwise have reason to avoid having another not yet familiar with his past posts here come upon them by way of a search on his alias, with the result being a less than favorable judgement of himself?
In othe words, he may just be trying to expunge his record before it becomes more widely read.
by absolutely
I wanted to record his statistics.
He had the best verifiable research for the goofy, libertine ideals I have in common with him.
I hope he's as old and fat as the rest of you sound, I need those data!
by deepsand
I haven't been able to float for 34 years!
Hence, at Annapolis, rather than being in the regular swimming class, I was assigned to that called "Sub Squad."
As for max, I'd hesitate to call him a libertine.
by absolutely
Except somebody else had already used that description in an earlier post, so I decided to underscore the error by repeating it.
[i]As for max, I'd hesitate to call him a libertine.[/i]
by deepsand
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Junk posts
Sort by Trending