Join the Linux discussion
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by arheil
Linux is too young for application deployment. *BSD and classic UNIX have experience in this task.
Novadays, port collection from NetBSD project (PKGSRC) is frontier endeavor in the free software distribution. I can say that NetBSD carries 2 projects: OS and free software.
The main difference from other port collections is that usually vendor makes effort to run software under own OS only. It's not true for NetBSD. These packages are built from source tarballs under different OSes (Solaris, Linux, and many other). Questions?
1) Easy to use.
You can build your application by running 'make; make install' commands. You don't spend the time in surfing web. Tarballs will be downloaded from net without worries.
If this software has dependencies on libraries from other projects, these projects will be built. Without worries.
You have not to install gigas of software from CDs. The main distro of OS is ~200MB in tarballs (~500MB on HDD, the main UNIX utilities (with gcc and other devel stuff) + X).
2) Free software.
You have not to pay for these programs.
3) Distribute to the world.
You can help to distribute and adopt other software
under this project if you are developer. INHO the goal of this project (PKGSRC) is to resolve trouble of software in the world. The goal is correlated with the GNU project goal. If you are interested in license issues, I can describe my opinion. Both (BSD and GPL) licenses describe free software distribution. BSD is 'technical' license, the main goal is 'install free software which works'.
GPL is 'political', the main goal is 'install only free software'. I'm techie, thus I prefer 'technical' solutions and choose BSD lisence. BTW lisence issue does not resolve the trouble of software distributing by itself.
That's why I have great respect for NetBSD project.
*BSD projects are successful in OS regenerating by
simple commands like 'make buildworld'. Why?
Answer is simple. The *BSD projects are based on UNIX legacy. The rich infrasrtucture of Makefiles. Linux is too young in this field. But this problem arrives long time ago and inspires projects like "Linux from scratch" and Gentoo.
OTOH many users are not programmers and want to install and use software. *.rpm and *.deb resolve this issue. Just install 5-8 CDs and 2-3 DVDs of prebuilded packages or buy MS products. Model is the same, prices are different.
4) Share info.
The classic UNIX books make advice: "If the info are not transferred by protocols in the Net, distribute it in the plain text (human readable) form". I agree. MS office files often are piece of crap. If you want to print document, you have to prepare info for this. UNIX has utilities, the teTeX is the professional publish system.
MS is trying to build docs that ready to print. IMHO overkill. Anyway it's make your own opinion about info exchange.
HTH,
agkhram
What ever happened to the concept of user friendly? The Idea is to make life easier. That's the reason to create any tool.
This concept of making the user fit the machine is, in my opinion, elitist crap.
by bteam
There is some truth and accuracy, but also some innaccuracy,
in what you say.
The innaccurate part is the pronouncement that X == bloat.
You *can* make X, or more precisely, the two most popular
desktop environments (KDE and Gnome) fairly bloated if you
wish. However, you can also make even those two relatively
lean and mean by turning off eye candy.
Now, if you want to see fast X, use something other than KDE
or Gnome. I'd suggest taking a look at IceWM, Fluxbox,
Blackbox, or XFCE. If you like Macs, you'll feel right at home
with the look and feel of XFCE. It borrows heavily from the old
CDE interface, as does OS X. Both of them are much prettier
and faster than anything written with the Motif toolit,
though :-)
If you want to see faster still, try out a fairly new distro called
Yoper. It not only comes compiled for 686 architecture, but
Yoper makes extensive use of prelinking. It doesn't boot quite
as fast a Gentoo system (in my experience) but once up and
running, I found KDE to be faster and snappier on Yoper than
on KDE. However, being a Debian guy myself, I didn't stick to
the RPM-based Yoper. It was quite impressed with the speed,
though.
Also, consider this: on my workstation (a Dell with XP Pro and
512 meg) I would have to reboot once a week (or every two
weeks, if I was really lucky) because there are so many things
that leak memory that after a while the machine would 1.5 gig
into swap and be doing nothing but paging. I finally got
around to installing Linux on it (a Debian-based distro called
Ubuntu; much easier to install than pure Debian) and haven't
had to reboot since, and it's faster, too. Well, I did have to
reboot once: the extra 512 meg of memory I'd had the MIS
department order for me a month ago finally arrived. I didn't
really need it anymore, since 512 was quite enough for KDE
with all the eye candy turned on, but since it was already there,
I took it. So I had to turn the machine off for a minute to
install it. Now I can go as long as feel like without rebooting
again.
Microsoft didn't succeed because they dumbed things down.
They succeeded because way back when they were tiny, they
were in the right place at the right time, and followed that good
fortune up with some good business decisions and some good
software back in the day. Is Windows dumbed down now,
though? Yeah, kind of. I prefer Windows 2000, and even NT
4, over XP in most respects. W2K is a lot faster than XP, too.
In my experience, it's also more stable. Windows 2000 was
really the high water mark for Microsoft OSes, in my opinion.
With regard to installation, certainly some distros are easier
than others. Red Hat is less easy than, say, Xandros, but it
certainly isn't hard. In fact, distros such as Red Hat, Xandros,
and Mandrake are, in my opinion, easier to install than
Windows. Yes. They are easier to install than Windows. You
read that right.
But even if it's not quite as easy to install, who cares?
Installing Linux, especially if it's a Debian-based distro, is
something that you will only have to do to your computer
once, unless you have a catastrophic hardware failure. For
that one time, you should do what I also recommend that
most users (being that most are thoroughly unknowledgeable
about computers) do: get someone who knows what he/she is
doing to install the OS and make sure everything is configured
correctly and locked down for security. Once that's done, all
you have to do is point and click to update your system with
security patches regularly, something which is a good bit
easier on a number of Linux distros than it is via Windows
update. Not to mention faster. On Debian, for example, you
can either update the system using the excellent Synaptic
package manager, or you can open a command prompt (my
preferred approach) and type apt-get update, then when it's
done, apt-get -f dist-upgrade. All dependencies will be handled
for you. New software is installed the same way, and again, all
dependencies are handled for you.
That's pretty easy, really.
There is one fly in the ointment, though: Linux is still not
terribly good at multimedia compared to XP or (even moreso)
to OS X. That doesn't mean it's useless, and things have
gotten fairly good on many fronts in the past year or so, but
there is still a lot of catching up to do. It's good enough for
people who like computers and have some idea what they are
doing, but for people who neither know nor want to know,
they just want it to work, you're 100% right: Mac OS X is by far
the best choice for them. I love Linux, but I recommend Macs
to people quite often. For quite a few people, it's the platform
that would best meet their needs.
My answer, then, to the question "Is Linux ready for the
desktop?" is "What desktop"? If we're talking about the
corporate desktop, then the answer is yes, in most cases.
The corporate desktop, whether Windows or Linux, is looked
after by professional administrators (well, usually), so the
users don't need to worry about software installation and
system management. A large number of Linux boxes is far
easier to manage than a large number of Windows boxes and
far less prone to viruses, so that's a win for the
administrators. Capability-wise, in a typical office Linux has
everything you need to do your work. Most businesses could
convert to Linux and they'd never miss Windows. Whether
there is always a business case for the expense of an OS
conversion is another question (the answer may often be yes,
but sometimes may be no), but there is no technical reason
why most companies could not make the switch.
For the home desktop, Linux is ready if you're a power user.
I've been using it as my home desktop OS for about 6 years,
and believe me, back than it was a lot farther from being
ready . I wouldn't put up with today, the things I went through
back then. That's a good sign of how far it's come.
Finally, I fully agree with you that Linux is not dumbed down,
nor should it be. I'll go one step farther, though, and say "Nor
can it be." No matter what kind of GUI you put on top of it
(and in many respects, Gnome and KDE are both better than
Microsoft's GUI today), a nice, friendly shell will still be just a
mouse click away. I do a lot of my work from the command
line out of choice, even though there are good graphical
programs that I could use if I wanted to.
Linux is not for everyone, that's certainly true. But with the
Mac available for people who want "Just Works" and peerless
multimedia and Linux available for people who want a more
UNIX-like powerful workstation (although Mac OS X also fills
this role quite well), I see little reason to buy a Windows
computer anymore. I wouldn't recommend it to anyone,
except as a game platform.
by al00880075
It's true, Linux was developed at first, by and for hackers, but it has been improved and now there are several tools that will save you time configuring a system. I don't think it's becoming a windows clone, actually, gui was there (in other systems) before windows.
Installing and setting up a complete running linux system is very easy with distributions like lindows, mandrake, suse and others. Maybe it is (much) harder with some other distros like debian or slackware for the average user, but even these have their own tools to install packages and satisfy dependencies (and keep the system up to date).
I think now it's easier for the average user to to use and even install a linux system and it's getting better every new release.
by crussell
by rindi1
The problem you are talking about arises from the following situation:
Windows is always the same, so the programs you will use there are compiled and ready for use for that OS, that means you generally don't need further Software in order to get that Software to run. With Linux you have a lot of different Distributions, to get the software to run best on your distro, it is also best to prepare the Software for that Distro (Compile it, etc.). This means you will have to install that Third party software beforehand as well. There are a lot of Distributions around now which have Software prepared already, so if you use the Distro's Package Manager to install the software you want, this manager can normally install all the necessary tools needed as well.
by rindi1
Linux Server will need quite some learning to get it up and running, Windows Server almost anyone can support as most people are using Windows on their desktops. Linux on the other hand should be more stable and secure, once it is running. There are also a couple of groupware programs you can use on a Linux server to provide Exchange compatibility (Opengroupware as an Example).
Generally, if you can't afford a Linux specialist, i't suggest to stay with M$, if you can afford a Linux guy, then that would definitely be the better Server OS.
by dstjulien
As I suggested elsewhere in this discussion, sometimes having to bring some Linux expertise on-board or get it on your own may be more affordable than the constant maintenance required of M$ servers. It should be a business or career decision.
At this point there is professional level commercial support available for at least oe distro (SuSE - Novell). There is paid support or excellent active Novell support forums available.
Low maintenance costs, efficiency, reliability and security are the strong points of Linux.
I have a dual boot with XP and Linux. The wife uses XP and I use Linux. I can get to any files on the XP when the Linux is up and actually run several Windows apps under Linux. Some things I like is that Linux doesn't "freeze", choke about memory or BSOD on me. Biggest thing is I DON'T GET VIRUSES! (sorry for the shout - can't underline in this editor).
I back up crucial windows data files to the Linux side on a regular basis.
I also find a wealth of excellent programs available virtually free. I have been donating as I can. Even for rather obscure programs, there is support throught various forums at sourceforge.net. It is rather interesting at how quickly the Linux community responds. They also seem to be very helpful and tolerant of "newbies" or novices.
Be forwarned, however, Linux is the future, both for desktop and server-side. It would behoove you to get the skills now. There are excellent books and info available. Try starting on http://linux.oreilly.com/ There is lots of free stuff here as well as good references for commercial publications. Check ebay or Amazon for the best prices on the books.
(whew - that makes about $.08 USD I've "spent here!)
by joltinjoe607
by apotheon
What you're referring to in your examples are actually distributions of Linux that are geared toward the "user friendly" GUI installations that default the kitchen sink into the install. There's a difference between that and easy software installation.
The major problems that people complain about typically have very little to do with Windows being "easier" to work with in and of itself, and have much to do with users not being used to a different philosophy of computing. Something that must be realized is that to make full use of the power and flexibility of a good Linux distro you must overcome your fear of the command line.
There are distros that make it incredibly easy to install and remove software, including dependencies, using the GUI environment; SuSE and Fedora/RedHat are a couple of these. More useful and easier to work with, in my experience, is a system with an extremely well-developed command line system for package management, like Debian.
RedHat-related distros approach Debian in ease of package management, through use of YUM for instance, but for me nothing approaches the ease of use of Debian's apt system. The apt package manager in Debian does use the command line, and does require a user to learn a couple of shell commands to make it work, but it is actually much easier to master and make effective use of apt to install and remove software (including all dependencies) than it is to perform similar tasks in Windows. For one thing, you don't have to order or go to a store to purchase OpenOffice, whereas you do have to do so with MS Office.
For the record:
Red Hat Enterprise Linux and Fedora both also use apt, though their package archives for apt are not as extensive as those for Debian. Also, Lindows has changed its name (some time ago) to Linspire due to lawsuit issues with Microsoft.
by appo
I have purchased SuSE Linux 8.1 Professional last year and have yet to connect to the Internet. Not having any knowledge or ever used Linux, I went at it cold turkey. I have searched the internet for user groups in hope of getting advice on how to connect, but nothing. I love the screen layout and some of the application that I can use locally, but no Internet. I suppose that if I keep at it long enough I will eventually find out how to connect.
Rudolph Apodaca.
by dstjulien
by appo
I have that problem, If you know what I should do, then please, I need your help.
Thanks,
by dstjulien
Is it through a dial up, DSL, Cable modem or direct connect?
If it is a modem, you may need a different modem. winmodems that come with most newer pc's and that make up the bulk of the modems available won't work in Linux. The reason is that they rely on dlls and other links in the M$ window system to work.
It MUST be a serial or bus connect (PCI card) modem to have any hope.
There is hope though there have recently been some generic modem drivers set up.
Visit this site if that is your problem - http://www.tldp.org/HOWTO/Winmodems-and-Linux-HOWTO.html
If that is not the problem give me some details and I will try to help.
by cfields
by peter_es_uk
I have a dozen PC's running versions of windows, linux and freeBSD Most of the PC's have 350 - 500 MB ram. My son scanned a drawing he did and got a 240MB file - no windows program would touch it(photoshop, photodraw ...) on any version of windows (98, 2000 pro, XP Pro -it froze them all even after had turned off ALL other applications).
My linux m/c runs Postgreql, mySQL, CUPS SAMBA and performs the duties of the PDC. I loaded the picture into the GIMP - problem solved! Linux rocks BIG TIME!
by apotheon
Here's a useful guide to installing without a CDROM drive or USB boot option.
http://marc.herbert.free.fr/linux/win2linstall.html
This explanation includes information specific to Fedora Core, as well as to other distributions (including my personal favorite, Debian).
by apotheon
I don't have a Knoppix v3.3 handy to work with, but I've got Knoppix v3.4 here. What I find upon booting it is that on the desktop there's an icon that shows opens the already-mounted hard drive so that I can browse through it.
If you want to find where hard drives partitions are located through the shell, I recommend opening /etc/fstab and examining its contents. Knoppix automatically sets up fstab with entries for all detected hard drive partitions to make it easy for the user to work with hard drive data. You might also try typing "mount" at the command prompt, minus the quotes, with no arguments — this will show what partitions are already mounted. It's probable that, with Knoppix, the hard drive partition you're looking for is already mounted somewhere.
by apotheon
That was very well phrased, and I tend to agree with your opinions in the matter, in addition to having comparable experiences. I, too, am a Debian user by choice, and I too will fall back to MacOS X for the rare individual for whom Linux isn't the optimal choice.
The only reason, generally speaking, to choose Windows over another OS is the popularity of computer games designed for that platform alone.
by apotheon
by gorto
by ben_furns
I am thinking of changing from windows to linux but will my software still work if taken from windows and used on linux. I have some software that came with my mobile phone that and got a data cable to download stuff.
[url]www.dontpayretail.co.uk[/url]
by masinick
I think the problem with ease of installation is the level of hardware support available. More hardware vendors need to get on board to make support easier. As far as differences in packaging, who cares? If that is confusing, the best thing to do is to find a system that works, learn it well before moving on to anything else.
If systems won't install right, I recommend downloading Live CDs, such as Knoppix, Kanotix, Linspire, SUSE, or Mandriva (in Live CD format, these vendors also have full suites that install immediately to disk). I have particularly good results with SimplyMEPIS, others find different packages work better for them. But with a Live CD, you have little risk. If it fails, all you lose is a CD (unless you use CD/RW disks, in which case, just rewrite a new one).
I use Libranet myself, they just came out with a new release. In your case, though, first I'd make sure I could find something that works, then I'd experiment and learn how to use it effectively, asking questions after diligently reviewing as much as possible.
by laredoflash9
Yeeaaah riigght! I have found SuSE Linux from Novel to the the easiest to install. Simply install the 1st cd and boot. No problems for the most part. SuSE takes care of all the stuff. You just say yes. It works great and is solid. 10.1 is cool sadly they removed some of the wireless drivers and now my usb network adapter does not work...guess I'll go back to 10.0.
Rod
by javenlim
I think we need to remember that it is open source that we are talking abt so we cant be too chosy on this.
Also, Linux like Unix requires a significant level of skillset to implement it and manage it. It can be very powerful and much more powerful than MS Operating Systems. The only down side is that everything is very commandline based. In MS OS, u will never know what is actually running on the background even with the task manager. Registry is always a failure and processes like svchost is another pain in the ass. But I must say that the support that u can get from MS is definitely alot better than open source but still I think Linux and any Unix based system is definitely more powerful than MS based ones. At least in terms of stability is alot better.
by jaqui
not anymore
get a new distro and you'll find out that working with linux is actually easier than working with MS software.
and far less security issues to deal with.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending