Discussion Locked

KDE or GNOME...looking for opinions

0 helpful
35 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

All I need are informed opinions as to which desktop environment would be the better recommendation for a Linux desktop offering and why...would it be a better selection of applications, better resource management, higher stability, more frequent updates or better interoerability between running X apps? Better themes? Lower Windows-to-X learning curve? Tried-it-and-always-stuck-with-it? Anything at all?

Please bear in mind that I may need to install Linux for a number of higher management personnel who have never used anything other than Windows 95 and whose ability to troubleshoot or bypass quirks and whose tolerence for same is essentially zero. Whetever I go with will need to be as easy as possible.

Points will be granted to anyone who can give a reason why one or the other is better. Or if there are any alternatives that should or can be considered, and the link to download (source or RPM, doesn't matter). Thanks to all who can help!

35 replies

by cpfeiffe

For your purposes I would recommend GNOME because it is easier to understand from a Wnidows background. GNOME offers a better application selection out of the box as well. KDE is better on resources, usually the trade off for having less of an application selection. KDE is more stable. Both offer good interoperability between X apps and both offer about the same level of updates. I wouldn't look at any other alternatives. These are the two most widely used Linux interfaces so they are the ones you can get the most information on if you ever run into problems.

I choose KDE for myself more often, because of resource usage and stability. I come from a Unix background so I don't care about the Windows to Linux GUI learning curve andthe available GUI apps, but that seems like it would be the most important thing to your users so I would recommend GNOME for you.

Good luck.

by jay eckles

My personal preference in a desktop manager has been KDE, but it's really just that, a personal preference. There is, obviously, no technical reason you can't install both Gnome and KDE and give the users a choice of which they'd like to run, but obviously executives have no interest in investing time in making that kind of choice.

I think that in a corporate environment, GNOME slightly edges out KDE. I think that the advantages GNOME has are commercial support in the Unix world (both Sun and HP have made indications that they will replace CDE with GNOME on Solaris and HP-UX). The GNOME Foundation also ahs the support of corporate backers in the IT industry, which will probably 1. encourage the adoption of GNOME by these companies and 2. add valuable resources to the development of GNOME.

Both desktop managers have office and web browsing applications, so that's not a big issue. A lot of people are big fans of Konqueror, the KDE web/file browser/viewer, but I would hardly pick a desktop manager based on one application. I'm also not sure you couldn't run Konqueror in a GNOME environment.

The only alternative to KDE or GNOME that I'd consider would be the CDE (Common Desktop Environment). This is the desktop managerI've always seen on Solaris and HP-UX boxes, and I have enjoyed working with it. I can't speak to any specific implementation of CDE for Linux, but I would say that the CDE is much more stable than KDE and GNOME in terms of development, and CDE is much more widely used in the Unix world (but not at all in the Linux world). Here is a link to DeXtop, a CDE implementation for Linux by XiGraphics: http://www.xigraphics.com/Pages/DeXtopGUI.html

Good luck.

Jay Eckles
www.jayeckles.com

by shanghai sam

Looks like GNOME edges out KDE. I prefer KDE, myself, but I also think that Macs are better than Windows machines, and NetWare runs better than Microsoft's NOS, and look what the rest of the world thinks. Oh, well. Thanks for the input, mate.

by cavedweller

I looked at both GNOME and KDE while installing linux for a project. I liked GNOME's admin tools better. For users though, I'd go with KDE. I would install the highest-usage apps on the toolbar and group the rest on the pop-ups. Once novice users have to hunt around they get confused & confusion leads to frustration and rejection.

by shanghai sam

I agree. I prefer to use KDE as well, but the lack of a toolbar and easy to find apps looks and feels just like Windows. May have to stick with GNOME.

by soliboy

I have been using Mandrake 7.1 for some time. It shipped with both, and with the right installation options, I could log into a session for whichever one I wanted. Gnome is good for config control, window managers etc. I would have to say, I sided with Gnome probably because as a tech head, I like to fiddle with things rather than simply use them. I have apps which run fine under both but other apps which left KDE in a hoop. Play with it and see.

by leo.valmores

I am a novice to Linux, but I begin using RedHat's newest version 7.1

I agree with earlier comments on either KDE or GNOME. KDE has more of the "aesthetics" appeal and personally I used it as default GUI interface. However, you can create customized folders or even desktop icons to launch your apps. And I believe that users (especially your top-level users) would like to just click on the desktop icons to launch their apps.

However, looking ahead of what your higher management users will use for their apps, I would assume that you prefer to have a suite apps, like StarOffice (which is bundled with Linux offering most of the time). I would assume that there will be less-steeper learning curve if they stick to StarOffice for wordprocessing, spreadsheet, presentations, and even web browsing capabilities.

Bear in mind that KDE or GNOME are only the GUI interface and that your users do not interact most of the time with GUI interface but rather to the apps they use daily.

Hope my input helps!

by shanghai sam

True. But I've seen that there are apps starting to pop up that are written specifically for one or the other...and GNOME seems to appear a little more often than KDE...when it matters at all. I guess GNOME is my choice.

by gmscne

CDE works good, is stable and has lots of support but GNOME is a more familiar looking type of interface for those who come from a windows environment. It's definately a better looking GUI and it is configurable similar to windows for colors and background and such things that users like to personalize. If standard menus and programs are a priority, then KDE might be worth trying.
I like GNOME but then again, I am a techie.

by freetech

personally, i prefer kde. it is more intuitive for me. i do, however, have both installed and switch back and forth easily. hey install both and let them decide.

by shanghai sam

Sorry, mate. But I'm not about to tell a senior VP to just choose a desktop, and good luck. But I, too, prefer KDE.

by jaolson40

I wanted to let you folks know that I'll be closing this question on July 27th, 2001. Thanks for all the responses I've gotten so far! :)

by wydk/vastech, inc.

As your question seeks opinions, I would like to deviate a bit from the norm and offer what I hope will be some sound "end user-friendly" advice.

You *are* going to find alot of mixed opinions here on your choice of X Windows preference. However, something you may see as a constant here is how most techies are learning toward KDE for its Windows-like asthetics, and it indeed does have Win9x-like themes and could very well be more smooth a migration on that basis alone. ;-)

With end-users in exec-management being thrown into Linux previosly from a Windows 95 background, you will of course havet o acknowledge the inevitable learning curve here. There is no solution that will make an administrators job more than "slightly easier" than if he had gone with KDE or Gnome when its six months down the road and a VP cant print. Effictively being able to support this OS in your particular environment is key, coupled with some end-user training, to whatever extent you want them to know that "this is not really Windows anymore". 30-45 days tops.

All widespread Windows implementations to date have been sitting on DOS and just now with Win2000 & XP has MS broken away. Your headed in the right direction if you wish to go across thestreet on Microsoft and do it for the price of a few cd's. Neither Linux nor Win2000/XP are "your fathers Oldsmobile". They are inherantly more complex that their predecessors, and things will go wrong - either way. Linux is a true fortress of anoperating system minus a NSA C2 certification in the works but Linux too has its flaws, with X, KDE or Gnome. Your upper-managers will admire not your choice of GUI, but more likely your well-planned rollout;and this is THE KEY. This, battle will be won in the "war-room" planning phase, and not on the desktop "battlefield". So, KDE has my vote. Email me for any further assistance.

by wydk/vastech, inc.

I am keeping up with the answers and re-reading many of them in search for their relevancy to the quetion you asked - its hard to find. All techies going off on opinion-hauls to limbo... "we're all entitled" right? Something about 2 cents...

I went and did Mandrake and Redhat 7.1 linux install four times - once on each workstation - all P3-500's we have in the conference room, and for the life of me - I am glad I did! It was a long night well spent! I am truly sticking fast to my guns here on the KDE subject, and this comment box wont let me tell you exactly why - but others have hinted at it - Gnome, more techie; KDE more "Windows".

That coupled with a good deploymen-strategy such as cloning desktops and keeping hot-spairs of your drives at the ready for your workstations (or at least swappable spares - if not *hot* swappable) as I played "end user" with my wife, and boy o' boy is Linux REALLY not like Windows at all. Just colors and themes. Moreso Gnome is not any better, yet worse in this catagory. For your management; a training-plan, for you a good crisis management plan/disaster recovery and KEEP the desktop SIMPLE - dont install all the KDE modules that are there! Use only what you need and build your model workstation from that ALPHA. Then you're cooking with bacon indeed!

Again, feel free to email me with any and all questions re: KDE, Gnome, X Windows or Linux in general. I will promptly reply.

Regards.

Rick Lawless

by shanghai sam

I agree completely. KDE does seem to have the support of most people, with some excellent, solid technical reasoning behind that support....but some of the people behind GNOME are citing corporate support for that platform....and I know all too wellthat technical excellence means nothing when millions of dollars are put behind a different product. If Solaris and HP do replace CDE with GNOME, then GNOME is what I'll want to go with. It's not just me, but anyone who comes after that I've got to think about.

I mean, heck. If technical excellence was all there was to it, would Microsoft have the market dominance they have? :)

by sergey kovzik

Both are good and can be used. But for your situation I'll choose GNOME. KDE unified - this is plus, it has integration and same look and feel. It _was_ even more stable and popular. But GNOME gives more freedom and visually it may be a little near to Windows than KDE. KDE following GNOME in protocols and features. And looking for long terms - both created foundations. But GNOME has more massive support from industrial giants. It's like GNOME will be standard for corporations and will have better support.
Regarding other environments... Even if there is something more perfect - you have to support it.

Sincerely, Sergey
Brainbench MVP for Win98 Administration

by shanghai sam

This answer is the reason I'm planting my flag on GNOME. I prefer KDE myself, but if the industry is putting their weight behind GNOME, then so be it.

by nick l

Simple, most driving answer must be summed up by many of the answers received so far.... techies prefer KDE - most Solaris GUI users etc. in my experience use it because of the responsiveness, customisability, ability to tweak. However, realistically if your users are Win 95 users and managers etc, the simple answer must be GNOME. They will not be concerned about a 5% better memory usilisation or in-depth ability to tweak it. They will want to get on with their jobs, with as little conversion time as possible. i.e. familiarity and ease of use must take priority if you want to keep your job!

i would have thought KDE only if they are techies and will support themselves, surely you don't want to be supporting two different environments!Kde only if you find a specific job related application that will run on KDE only.

And as for something else? Well, realistically you going to give your management some unsupported, compiled environment that you have downloaded? You like your job?

In this sort of situation let your head rule your heart, does it do the job? does it work well (i.e. not fall over as opposed to slightly faster)? is it familiar?

by netspawn748

Well here you have it....

I have recently deployed a new os for the company Im employed for... I am a IT manager and can tell you from my own experience, That Gnome is the user friendly one out of the two.. I had to deploy all new systems to meetwith the high demand of our database administration as well as our e-mail marketing structure, anyways if you are going to give windows personell a unix box, better make it gnome.. Its better to look at, has a similar gui interface, and the workers have learned common tasks in amatter of days!! KDE is more of scripting code and nonsense, AT least for my company it was a waste of time....

Hope all of this input helps!!

Chad

by shanghai sam

It did, thanks. Personally, I prefer KDE, as it seems a bit more responsive and appears to run better in low memory conditions (how many times have I gotten the SAWFISH window manager error using GNOME?), but it does look better, can be customized better, and seems to have a little more momentum in the marketplace than KDE. GNOME it is, then.

by schannachie

Hi,
I had a that kind of trouble some years ago. And as I see, now it's easyer than when I faced that trouble. My chalenge was to let windows boys try CDE that is Common Desktop Entvirontment, this software is a standard used by IBM AIX, Sun Solaris, HP HPUX, Digital (now Compaq) True 64, and some more unix "flavors", and I've had a tool for windows entvirontment that was Xwin32. That soft is able to run CDE on windows boxes. Hope you have time enough to try this XWIN32 is a Xwindows clientfor Windows boxes, it can connect to a Xwindows server (You have some different Xservers on linux, and one of the clients is KDE). KDE is a clone of CDE. GNOME and KDE at the end are very similar and easy to use, and with some little extra work (in the installing fase you can have some GNOME utilitys running on KDE). CDE is a standard and KDE is very similar. The main problem as I see is that you have to find a linux "flavor" with which you can feel confortable, as system administrator. And if you are looking at distributions as Suse, red hat, slackware, turbolinux, mandrake, etc, you will find that KDE and GNOME are part of the package. These applications are in the distribution cds all ready. In case that you are downloading a linux froma freesite, you can have a look at these sites :

for GNOME

http://www.linux.org/apps/all/GUI/Gnome.html

Homepage: http://GBlippie.mini.dhs.org/

Download: http://GBlippie.mini.dhs.org/GBlippie.tar.gz

for KDE
http://www.linux.org/apps/all/GUI/KDE.html

Homepage: http://www.kde.org/
Download: ftp://ftp.kde.org/pub/kde/stable/latest/

Alt Download: ftp://ftp.us.kde.org/pub/kde/stable/latest/

for a free linux distribution :

www.suse.com/us/support/download/index.html

ftp.suse.com/pub/suse/i386/KDE
ftp.suse.com/pub/suse/i386/GNOME
ftp.suse.com/pub/suse/i386/7.2 (LINUX)
ftp.suse.com/pub/suse/i386/X/ for X servers

part I

by shanghai sam

Hi! The links helped, appreciate it. We've chosen Red Hat for the distro (market share, corporate support, etc, etc. You've been there, I'm sure). Looks like GNOME is what I'll be going with.

by schannachie

part II (and last)

Let me tell you some more. As far as I know the best way (of course if you have time to work it out ...) is to let people use a desktop entvirontment at the operating system they all ready know. That is i.e. installing onwindows XWIN32, and staroffice as a sutable replacement of ms-office package. When the user gets used to that soft you will have less trouble, and the useres will demand less help and time. If you don't have the time CDE and KDE are very similar and quite-windows-like. I had to change the mind of 20 windows boys and they are living with 6 WIN NT/WIN2K servers and 5 linux and hardly can't tell the difference, passwords and services are at the both platforms working together. They had a very short time in getting used to KDE or CDE. The most remarkable change is the unix single mouse click, that made people get mad a few days, they had to realize where they were working, that is the reason of installing the X-windows (motiv) client for Win boxes. The properties of the buttons are very similar to windows properties in KDE. You have to measure that there are fans of KDE and GNOME, and the difference between them is how the end useres get used to the new entvirontment.

good luck.For more info feel free to contactme.

slan aghat !

by mark phelan

KDE....

Believe it or not, good ole KDE can, with a bit of work, be customised to look and feel very close to windows.

There are very obviously still a lot of differences, but giving the user a semi faliliar environment makes the transition much easier I find.

The number one most important point here is that the users are happy. Personally I'd configure up a PC, or laptop, with both environments, and give them a demo, using applications they are likely to need to access frequently.

I know that these people are probably going to use the "I dont have time" approach, so whatever you decide, it's quite possibly going to be a pain to get them up and running.

It helps if you have the buy in of at least one senior exec, they can throw a bit of weight behind the project as a whole.

Whatever you decide, Good luck :o)

by mark phelan

forgot to mention,

Since we are looking at a user environment, not an admin environment, ease of transition is essential, thus look and feel is also a key factor.

Further more, whatever applications you provice, access will need to be as simple as they were in the preceding environment.

once again, GL :o)

by shanghai sam

Aye, I agree. But although I, too, feel that KDE would be the better choice of the two, from what I see here, and out on the web on the industry sites, shareware/freeware sites and newsgroups, GNOME is what I should go with for the users.

by juandemarco

Truth to be told, it depends on your own style. I personally use KDE because it is what I'm comfortable with. However, I've also used an editor to incorporate some of the features from GNOME. My friend thought it was easer to use GNOME then KDE. Most of the apps I've worked with work on both sides of the fence, with no noticeable difference. The interface depends on you. However, SuSE has built in several other interfaces including winx95. This one has the most familiar look and feel of the windows 9x desktop. I've used it and have had no complaints about it. In fact, that is what I started with and it worked great. You can get this off the install cd or the download page from there web site. -Juan De Marco

by shanghai sam

Thanks, mate, but we're going with Red Hat internally, so it pretty much has to be one or the other, I'm afraid. I, too, prefer KDE, but hey, I'm also a Mac fan, and look what their share of the market is. Ah, well....

This discussion is closed to new replies.