16 replies
by epepke
Employers are not parents, or at least they don't necessarily see themselves as parents.
I certainly think that it is short-sighted for employers not to provide internships, education, and possibly even apprenticeships for people with no experience. However, it isn't entirely their fault. It costs money to give somebody experience, and so it's only attractive and in many cases only possible to do it when there's a net return for that investment. Big, locally or globally monopolistic corporations can and in many cases will do this, but Joe Dot Com, who is struggling to keep from going Chapter 11, isn't going to give up people-hours to give experience to someone who can just turn around and go work for a competitor.
by bob s.
by jim
Experience... What I did just get my foot in the door is work for little or no compensation. I afford to network homes, small businesses and bring PCs back to life. After a bit, things started picking up... I grew more confident and I had a ton on professional references when I was done. Call it free-lance work on your resume and get some certs. The doors will open up soon for you. It's just that employers don't want to hire someone that's too green. You're also doing the right thing byhanging around in this type of discussion group. You must also demonstrate the verbiage.
Good luck!
Jim
by shanghai sam
What will you be giving them in exchange for your experience, though? Even if you work for free, it costs a company significantly to give you experience.
If you don't have experience, then you probably haven't been much in the position of mentoring and training other people. I've been in the business for a quarter of a century, and I have. I enjoy mentoring and teaching people, and I've been known to do it for free.
But, if I do it under a business employer, then they have to think about what it's going to cost them to have a significant amount of my time and effort devoted to that rather than devoted to helping them make money.
I already know from how you speak of this that you way undervalue how much an employer will have to spend, with no guarantees, to give you experience. What are you going to offer them that will make the exchange attractive to them?
I know that getting experience without having had experience really sucks. I had to deal with this because of making a switch from academia to industry about a year ago. It was difficult, and I was out of work and quite seriously poor for more than a year.
It sucks, but it's life. You are going to have to figure out creative ways to get and finesse experience using your own brain. Maybe you will have to take a job way below your educational level for a while, like work at a college help desk, so that you can hang around the people who do what you want experience with. Maybe you will have to do some one-off consulting jobs over the net. Maybe you will have to buy development systems and play around with them in the evenings. Maybe you will have to commit to working for a company for a year or so after they give you experience rather than just leave and make more money immediately. I don't know what your choice should be, because I'm not inside your brain.
by bob s.
You said ?I already know from how you speak of this that you way undervalue how much an employer will have to spend, with no guarantees, to give you experience. ? I don?t intend to undervalue the Employer. I respect their decision on who to hire and who not to hire. My father is in business and he has to make decisions on which candidate is better suited for the job?s he hires people to do. I apologies if I have offended any person or business.
Thank you for your advise in the end of your statement. I appreciate it and I am willing to do that. I guess it will just take time and much patience on my part until I find my spot in the field.
by bob s.
by epepke
You miss the point. I say you undervalue how much the employer has to spend. I know because you say something like "just give me the opportunity." From a theory of social justice, that makes perfect sense, but now you have to deal with how much that costs.
There's no offense taken and no need for an apology. I'm sure you respect the employer, and that doesn't really matter anyway. Trust me; you'd have to work a lot harder to offend me. And I'm not an employer anyway.
The point is that you simply DO NOT KNOW how much it REALLY COSTS in terms of REAL MONEY. There is no dishonor in this; there is no reason why you should know about it. Society sets up the world so that most of the cost of educating young people is hidden from them. This is done for a reason: if young people had to pay all the costs or even knew about them, hardly anybody would ever get educated. It is for this reason that college tuition, for example, is only a small fraction of what an education costs. Even at private universities, most of a student's education is subsidised.
One of the drawbacks, however, is that young people graduate with an artificially low understanding of just how much things cost. Now you're in what I laughingly call the real world, and your model of how things work has to change.
When you say "I just want someone to give me an opportunity," what it means in the real world is "I just want someone else to spend a whole lot of their money to give me an opportunity, with no guarantees on my part that they'll get anything of value from me in return." That won't fly, and you have to fix it.
by bob s.
Assuming that you are right that I don't as you say "The point is that you simply DO NOT KNOW how much it REALLY COSTS in terms of REAL MONEY." what do I do to gain experience. I am not expecting any company or person to give me a handout, because that is wrong to get something for free. I will give you info on where I am What is going on and if you wish to evaluate, give advise be a critic of me you are free to do so. I am only looking
information on what to do and how to find get a job. I am currently living in Boston MA. I moved here about 7-8 months ago. Before this I was on a mission for the LDS Church. Before that I was in High School. During High School I worked in Retail. So no according to the World I have no Experience in IT and that I freely admit. the only experience I have had is on my own with my own computers as I have installed Software and Hardware. I am currently taking courses in Windows 2000 from New Horizons (WWW.NHBoston.com). My eventual goal is to get my MCSE. I have passed the Win 2k Pro test and will be taking the next two over the next month. After these courses are over I plan on going to take courses from Sun Microsystems in Solaris to become certified. My fear is that as I am learning these things that I will forget them before I can use them and that as the dot.com's die off I will not be able to find a job. This is a dream of mine to work with computers, to become a Systems Admin. I have been applying for Help Desk and Grunt positions so That I could get a foot in the door and be able to be around the industry and work with the people to gain experience. I am not asking to be systems admin right off the bat. I am willing to work my way up.
by bob s.
If I may pose a Question? when you say "Now you're in what I laughingly call the real world, and your model of how things work has to change." Are you saying that I in a sense need to sell my self to the employer, make them feel as though they need me? If I may you another Q ask how did you get you first Job when you got out of school?
By the way I do realize that collages get money from many other sources than the students. I am also aware that industry dose Research and Development which sometimes involves how best to train the employees and that it takes the time of another person to train an individual. If one person is training another person then in a sense the company it paying two people to do one job. Obviously that is not all of the underlining expenses but a few. I also realize that Yes a company dose take a risk when they hire a new employee. The new employee could be lazy, or even mess something up. I don't expect a Handout because that is wrong to be given something for nothing. That is not what I am asking business to do.
by lasharn
I had attained an Associates in CIS a few years ago. After a few months of looking for a job, I ended up accepting a job of which I wasn't too thrilled about. I did this because it seemed as if everything I came across was looking for a candidate with 'more experience'. I wasn't thrilled about the position I had accepted because it wasn't using a lot of the skills I had aquired in school, the pay was low, and the benefits weren't the gratest either. (It sure beet being unemployed though). I took a chance with them as the company took a chance with me. I basically grinned a bared it and with my drive, was able to improve the tech department. I have since went back to school for some certifications and with my knowledge of NT, I have recently been able to land a job making more money, with more benefits, with better opportunities available, with tuition reimbursemnet, etc.
Point is, sometimes you have to accept a position that you are not too thrilled about in order to make a pathway to a greater opportunity. I'm only 24 and things are defintely looking up for me. It is just a matter of time for you.
Good luck.
by generalist
Another factor to consider is having experience in the right areas.
You can have decades of experience in the IT field and not be qualified for a job because it requires it requires experience in a specific area. Even if you take classes in those areas, if you don't have hands on professional experience in those areas, you miss out on the job. And if your training is done strictly at home on your own time, you aren't even in the running for certain jobs.
Keep this in mind when job hunting and upgrading your skills.
Also keep in mind the 'fact' that job specs are often filtered through a non-tech HR department who may require five years of experience in areas that have been around for less than three years. (XML comes to mind...)
by epepke
Very good questions. Now you're on the right track.
Yes, you need to sell yourself to employers.
As to my first job, I'll tell you how I got the first couple of ones. My first job was in school, because I needed a job to pay for school. It was a help-desk position for just above minimum wage. The way I got that was by taking a short seminar (no credit) in doing large-plot graphics on the University mainframe. Instead of doing the exercises that were given, I decided to make some big 17 by 17 inch plots of mathematical functions, including a 1/r^2 polar plot that was similar to the trailers for _The Black Hole_, a lousy movie that was hot at the time. I figured out how to do this essentially from scratch. The guy who ran the help desk was in this class, and he decided I might be good. I was about 17.
The first real job I got after graduation I got because, by myself, I had implemented a language called Mouse in Z-80 assembler, just for fun. I gave a talk on it at a local computer club, and the guy who ran the Micro Development Group was a member. He was impressed.
The next job I got because I had that job. The group moved essentially en masse to form a new Supercomputer Computations Research Institute. Later I became a research scientist there.
I've never gotten a certificate in anything, and I've never applied for a job in anything, such as I Want to Be a System Manager. But, I've had to *do* just about everything, including be a system manager, just because it needed done, and I was there. One year ago, I made the transition from being unemployed when the University programs fell through (which sucked) and working for industry (at which I'm doing very well).
Yes, this process was highly chaotic, but that's the way life is almost all the time, especially in IT.
by epepke
And another thing. I still don't think you get what I'm saying. It has nothing do to with being lazy or messing something up.
Let's say that you are perfectly average, of the same intelligence as the average person with experience in so-and-so. You're in competition with Candidate Fred, who has experience. You go work for a company for *free*. No wages, understand? For a minimum of the first six months, it is going to cost the company an amount of money about the same as what they would have paid Fred to show you the ropes.
So, now, six months later down the road, and everything's OK, right? No. They're still six months in the hole! In order to pay them back, you'd have to work six MORE months for free.
I doubt that you'dstand for that, working for a whole year for free to get a year of experience, six months of it when you could go and get another job, but that's basically what the deal is. You have to do something else, like get your experience by stealth or convince them that you are so far above the average that they will make up what they spend on you in record time.
These numbers are quite a bit on the conservative side, by the way. Six months is a commonly quoted figure for all industries, and if anything, IT takes longer.
Fortunately, most employers are less insistent on getting their strict quid-pro-quo than these quite reasonable numbers suggest they should be. So, if anything, most employers will give you a better deal than you can reasonably expect to get.
But, ultimately, you have to decide how to do this.
by bob s.
I just might be one of those strange, odd people who would work for free just to get experience. There are people out there who are not in their job for the money.
If they are so afraid of me leaving have me sign a contract that say's if after 6month's (when the training is done) that I have to stay for another 6 months to a year or whatever they feel appropriate. Also if they are afraid of me leaving that means that I must be of some worth to them or at least when they hired me they saw some potential in me.
You must think that I am odd. Who would post a question like this. I mean if you think about it, the question sounds like I am attacking business.
With this I bid you adieu and say thanks for your time I appreciate your effort in teaching me. I guess that things being the way they are in this world that it will take much patience & humility on my part. I will accept that you are right and that business and I do not always think the same, also that the only job that I will have is the one that I create for myself. Such is life. I hope you enjoy your job and good luck with whatever you do in the future. If you choose to respond you are welcome to if not have a wonderful day.
by bob s.
by epepke
You either have a really dry sense of the ironic, or...
I've already given you a LOT of information, for free. Now it's your job to use it.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending