Discussion Locked

Legal ramifications of security

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Are you familiar with the legal ramifications of neglecting security, as discussed by Jonathan Yarden in the March 3 Internet Security e-newsletter? Does your organization have a filtering service or actively monitor user Internet activity? Tell us what you think about this issue.

10 replies

by mallardtooxx

I will admit I have not read the article, once again I implore you guys to add a link to said article. However, it would be unlike me not to expound upon it anyway so here goes.
I think it is the job of any IT manager/controller to monitor security and information going from his network to the internet. If more people kept an eye on their networks we would have far less propagation of bad data floating across the cyber canals. As for legal ramifications, how can you really police something like that? The Slammer virus propagated in 10 seconds or less, how you gonna fight that off? As for here at my work, we monitor everything in and out just to keep our end of due dilligence up. The only problem is now you have hoax cites and URL hoping running rampant across the internet. Yesterdays business site is tomorrow's porn pit. Just my two uniformed cents

-duck

by hal 9000

MS no longer supports their Win 9X OS's which are still in quite common use around the place particuarly in the smaller bussines? At present there are Security Patches available {if they don't crash the network or do other strange things} but after March 31 there will be no more updates even though Win 98 SE is still a current MS product. It is all well and good for MS to say mirgrate to XP or 2k or even wait the few weeks till 2003 arrives but some of the specalised programs simply will not run on these platforms and because they are so specalised with few chances of sales the software manfactures are unwilling to place the investment in rewritting these programs. And don't think that these are so specalised and of such a limited market that they will have no impact on you. Even the Medical programs in your local GP's surgery is one of these type of programs. So who will be held responsible after 31 March if someone manages to breach a Doctors computer and gain access to patient records? Simply any upgrade of the OS is not possible in these positions. This is only one instance of specalised programs being not considered for rewriting in the foreseeable future.

by nonsequitr

As a security professional and an attorney, you have other things to weigh here. Depending upon where you live and work, there are states that have determined through their courts that monitoring is an invasion of 1st Amendment rights -- freedom of expression. I agree that all companies need to be aware of the legal ramifications (I'm a public speaker on the topic), but you must also be aware that you will have to argue both sides of the fence in some cases.
...and let us not forget the Patriot Act and the ramifications for not securing a network through that enactment. A whole NEW can of worms.

by Member 30018865

I understand the workplace issue and am an advocate of filtering. No one should crete a hotile work environment. I use and install WebSense religiously, but holding ISP's responsible for home activity?!?!?! GIVE ME A BREAK! Maybe we should sue state and local government for installing and maintaining highways, after all they are used to transport drugs to addicts, right???

by shortarmofjustice

I work for a County Govt., when I talk to the authorities about traffic jurisdiction... the Local says it's County or State responsibility, the County says it's Local or State responsibility, and the State says don't bug me or I'll give you a ticket.

by robert.elliott

When I bring up the topic at the county level I get asked "What would you have us do? ... Increase taxes - (That won't fly)... Lay off three Sherif's offices.. Cut the lunch program.. "
The tax money is not there.

by Member 30018865

Hmmm, I responded with a comment about filtering and a rhetorical question about an hour ago, where'd it go????

by brneyes

We use WebSense for filtering. We also use IronMail to block SPAM, some of which is people filing their taxes online, order confirmations from amazon.com, chain letters, etc. Rarely am I asked to produce reports from either monitoring tool. Our policy is, and I agree with it, that workstations, the network connection and the internet connection are all paid for by our company. Therefore, it should be used for company business, not personal business.
A home PC and personal internet access should be used to conduct personal business on the internet.
Unfortunately, this tends to put some of what should be management's responsibility on the administrators of these tools. If a manager believes that a person is spending too much time on the internet, they should discipline them just as they do if they spend too much time at the water cooler or on personal phone calls. The more technology being used, the less responsibility management wants to take for the disciplining of employees.

by kiwimagic

I chose this title, as there was a case in Australia late last year, where a businessman sued for defamation, material hosted on a US based server (see news item http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/s744537.htm).
Could this indicate that leaked or stolen information could now be used for numerous suits? There is not doubt that any company will be taxed by the costs of defence, let alone the cost of loosing such a case.
The only leverage I see for the IT mgr'/team of a business, is to show that they are protecting the Goose that is under threat, and resources are needed to protect it. The ramifications to me, are obvious. The slippery slope could see you slip passed bankruptcy, and though very unlightly, could end in prison.

This discussion is closed to new replies.