My point is at least 50% of the time (and I'm being kind), when you need to install software or up to date hardware on Linux your primary resources are MAN pages and google.
You will spend MUCH MORE TIME getting software and up to date hardware to work on Linux than on windows.
Yes, I know Linux has some GUI help, but it SUCKS.
Here's an average home user that wants to install software to use his TV card. He finds something called Myth TV and gets excited about it.
Then the hangover kicks in. He goes to his little linux GUI places a checkmark next to Myth TV and presses "install" or some variation of that.
To his dismay he is bombed with messages about prerequisite software. Messages fly by very fast, the last one he sees is that Myth TV didn't install correctly.
Now he's lost. He doesn't even know where to look. Where are the logs, he thinks. What's wrong? He sees stuff about "missing packages". He goes to goole and searches on "linux missing packages". He gets a general understanding of what that means, but what packages are missing? He further googles and finds oodles of hits on complex RPM commands. Now this guy really wanted to get TV up on this Linux system that is supposed to be so secure, so advanced.
He finds something about MAN pages in google and starts typing MAN pages dealing with RPM management. But wait! The instructions fly by him, he can't read what is at the top! How do I do that? Again he googles and finds something called "less" and something about piping a command.
What is piping, he thinks? Now it's 4am and he still has no TV on his linux box. He's tired, punch drunk.
After a few more google searches, he goes a linux board dealing with Myth TV and is scorched by other users making him feeling stupid and guilty for not reading a bunch of "how to's" that some kind person lists in his post ( and their are very few "kind people" when it comes to newbies"
Finally, frustrated, he says "the hell with it", reformats his drive, installs windows 7 (which my 14 year old daughter can do) and immediately can watch TV in Media Center. Not only can he WATCH TV, listings are automatically downloaded for him, and he can easily RECORD shows - even a series of shows.
Not one error message. Not one google search. Not even the NEED for a help system.
Now you tell me, what system will that home user want?
It's not about MAN pages it's about immature technology for the HOME user to make installation of hardware and software easy and workable - something someone without pretty extensive Linux knowledge does not have.
Don't lose the forrest in the trees. This is not a discussion about help systems or man pages (even though the windows GUI help system is leaps and bounds above any GUI help system included in Linux).
It's about ease of use. Software and Hardware support. It's about USING your computer and not DEBUGGING it every time you want to add a piece of new hardware or install software.....
Keep the focus on the topic - what is better for the home user Windows or LInux. I stand on truth. Windows is better for that segment of computing.... period.
Home users are not setting up servers, or configuring Apache.
They just want their computer to work, and use it for their digital camera's (I won't even GO into that with Liinux), printers, and all the good software that has been written to perform ease of use functionality in the windows environment.
Everyone (except a few here) just can't understand what is best for a HOME USER.
I'm not against Linux, I use it to browse the web, and run hercules (yes hercules must be compiled on Linux to run optimally) - to run my copy of MVS which I use to keep my skills current in the slight chance some doctor is smart enough to be able to heal the damage done to me by two other doctors - I have two serious seizure disorders and have not been able to work for 8 years.
Hercules has been wonderful to help me keep my MVS skills up to date.
I used to get calls from competing companies with offers over $200,000 per year. If it had not been for my family, I would have checked those offers out.
I'm NOT putting down Linux, it has it's PLACE, but PLEASE don't tell me that's for the average HOME USER. That's JUST PLAIN WRONG....
Bob