Discussion Locked

linux will never compete with windows in the home market

0 helpful
283 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

linux is a business OS period. It is unix based and requires a lot of knowledge. The average person cannot handle it's quirk's.

Something is always wrong. Especially if you have current hardware. I doubt very much Ubuntu or any linux distro will support the ATI 5870 or 5890. You won't even get a screen. The display code will blow up, and personally I don't have the hours to spend trying to get current hardware working with linux.

Windows 7, while being more expensive, is LIGHTYEARS ahead of any linux distro for the HOME user.

Keep linux where it belongs, in the business segment. It will never achieve home desktop success. never.

sorry folks, that's just the way it is.

283 replies

by tony hopkinson

Ubuntu is an experiment at an appliance user's OS.

The rest of your argument is rubbish, for one simple reason. Go to your loacl highstreet dealer, try and buy a box with Ubuntu installed....

Can't can you?
Why is that do you think? If you want to know why Ubuntu isn't seriously competing in the home appliance market, follow the money...

by bobgroz

YOU prove to ME that UBUNtU supports a Raedon 5790.

Can't do it, can you? I can't even get a desktop, for crying out loud. Linux is business only - and for hardware that is at least 1 year old if not older. Sorry, Tony, you're just plain wrong......

by tony hopkinson

Redmond?

Hello, anybody in?

Now I'd be the first to agree that it doesn't matter to ma and pa browser who hasn't done what, but for those that would like to unf*ck the situation, appreciating the various motivations, is job 1.

I don't give a crap what drivers Ubuntu has, it's security model is f'ed out of the box, so I won't use it. If that's a requirement I'll stick with winders and get the driver....

by deadly ernest

that kowtows to Microsoft and builds their gear to suit only Windows and then doesn't write a driver for it to work properly using the Industry Standard Commands, and you blame Ubuntu - right, the blame for that is with Radeon not Ubuntu as Linux is designed to work with the Industry Standards, not some proprietary stuff meant to take control of your gear off you.

by jck

You mean 5970?

Ubuntu should load a default ATI driver, and you can get the ATI Catalyst software for Linux from AMD's site.

[b]ATI Desktop Product Family Support
The ATI Catalyst? Linux software suite is designed to support the following ATI
desktop products:
AMD Desktop Product Family Support
ATI Radeon? HD 5900 Series..."[/b]

https://a248.e.akamai.net/f/674/9206/0/www2.ati.com/drivers/linux/catalyst_101_linux.pdf

That's the document to prove it.

http://support.amd.com/us/gpudownload/linux/Pages/radeon_linux.aspx?type=2.4.1&product=2.4.1.3.42&lang=English

There's where you can download your ATI Catalyst Software for Linux.

You should be able to take it from there.

by jck

Two words and one decimal number, bobgroz:

Kubuntu Linux 9.4

BTW, Windows 7 Pro x64 didn't work too well with the ATI Catalyst 9.12 on the 5890 either.

They had to issue a patch. What went wrong?
Seems the venerable Windows is not so great after all.

BTW, Kubuntu 9.4 works perfectly fine with 2 5850s in Crossfire. I know. I have a machine running that config :)

by bobgroz

Mr.and Mrs america don't have your expertise at setting something like that up. I'd ask you to be honest and tell me how many hours you spent to get it to work. By the way, do you get all the direct 11 features in your games? How about depth of field? I highly doubt it. Probably you might get a desktop, but you are sacrificing all the eye candy that really makes the game look hot under windows. Spend the extra money on an oem copy of windows 7, you'll be much happier with your cards :)

by jck

a) worked on and off with Linux since the early 90s in college. I'm no guru, but it's not hard to learn (especially compared to 1990s Linux) to use *Ubuntu distros.

b) Setting up was nothing. I loaded Kubuntu, it loaded default drivers for the ATI chipset detected, I booted in, loaded the Linux package from the ATI site.

c) I don't know if DX11 games work in Linux, cause I didn't try to go get any that featured it. But, I would assume their Catalyst center exercises those features their cards/drivers are said to employ on the Linux platform. And as far as I am aware, DX11 is a Microsoft-dependent featureset.

I think perhaps through Wine or some other interface it might support DXn instructions, but I believe natively in Linux it will support OpenGL2.x and 3.x.

by bobgroz

I don't think so. Check out depth of field on a Windows 7 machine playing crysis. It will blow you away. Linux will look like an old 800x600 display of the game (IF it even runs) next to windows 7.....

by seanferd

If it were written for OpenGL, which Windows used to use, mind you, before MS could come up with something closed and proprietary, it would run just fine.

by deadly ernest

the Unix / Linux model of a decade ago, except they added a some weird graphics to the graphics user interface. There are about 100 time more computers out there running Linux / Unix than there are ones running Windows - what you don't see is that Linux / Unix have the majority of the server market and the embedded system market is there's down pat. The desktop market is mostly Microsoft Windows simply because of the predatory marketing processes of Microsoft with the main retail makers of PCs, and the average user just wants to buy something in a retails store.

SimplyMepis Linux is much better than Win 7 for ease of use and security, as is the case with most Linux distributions. Some have lowered the security down to the Microsoft level in an attempt to get the market that isn't concerned about security.

As to drivers, blame that on the hardware makers who do NOT design gear to work with Industry Standard Commands, but design it to work with a specific version of Microsoft Windows Commands. Linux is designed to the Industry Standards and all hardware (no matter how old) that is designed to Industry Standards just plugs in and works.

by ic-it

Your statement may have left out the word server. ;-)

There are about 100 time more computers out there running Linux / Unix than there are ones running Windows

Perhaps servers but definately not computers.

by deadly ernest

even cars made and sold in the last decade or so have a built in computer, with them running a variant of Unix or Linux; all the household goods with programmable content have a built in computer running a variant of Unix or Linux - in most cases; cell phones, fancy watches, e-readers, GPS devices, etc - most of these have Unix or Linux as their base operating system.

The ONLY place where Microsoft is currently outdoing Unix and Linux is retail desktop PCs, and that's solely due to their predatory marketing practices and deals with the major manufacturers of retail PCs.

In the past even Microsoft used Unix and Linux servers to run their own web sites, at times, simply because the Windows Server software wasn't up to the job.

by bobgroz

See my post above about Z/OS (with it's MVS core). There are THOUSANDS of more companies, the military, etc. running MVS core operating systems as servers than linux.

Can you set up Z/os on your x86 computer using the GPU software called Hercules? Google it. Read about it. You wont understand a thing. Maybe you need to see what serious tech is....

BTW, I run OS/390 here, in my house on an x86 machine.

A feat that perhaps 1% of operating system engineers can perform. The point I am making is I KNOW TECH. Linux does NOT belong in the home.... PERIOD. Not now, not never. Quit trying to make it something it's not. I'm not just talking to you (the poster that I'm replying to) - you are probably a decent guy and know your linux. Hats off to you. But remember, there is always somebody that knows more.

I'm tired of the arrogance of people that know a bit about linux. I look on boards and see poor newbies trying to set up things like what starts when linux boots - getting blasted by some arrogant know it all (at least that what he thinks he is) making the poor newbie feel stupid. Come over to my house and lets play with Hercules - not you personally, but anyone who thinks they are a tech hotshot.

You will learn the most important thing about tech - HUMILITY. None of us knows even 5% of all the tech out there. So let's stop acting like arrogant know it all's. Help out the newbie, if he has an interest in learning linux. Don't make him feel stupid just to make yourself feel good.

Again, sir, this is not directed at you personally. It's a global problem that I'm sick and tired of.

Rant over.

by bobgroz

it's not marketing that keeps windows on the home user desktop, its the fact that windows works out of the box with all the hardware (especially the current hardware) and linux does NOT - especially if you are a home user that doesn't know what fstab or initab or runlevels, etc. etc. are.

Wake up. Linux is just too complex for people who just want to use their computers and not debug them.

You guys get off on debugging. I did too, before a doctor made a serious error and permanently damaged my brain by giving me the wrong medications together. I've been fighting with suicide for years.

I used to work on an operating system that makes linux look like a toy. MVS, which when I was destroyed was called OS/390 and now called Z/OS. The most advanced business OS in the world. You guys who think you are so hot on tech couldn't even begin to understand that OS.

Tell me what is DASD? What is a partitioned dataset? What is RACF? What is JES2? What is HCD? How about Open Edition? What about full posix compliant unix that runs as a task under Z/os? Can you set that up? Can you do an IOGEN? What about IPCS and dump reading? Can you guys read a dump? Do you know what a PSW is? What is SMP?
Tell me, what is CICS? What is VSAM? Can you tell me? How about a sysplex - what is that? Can you tell me what TSO is? How about ROSCOE?

Well, I could go on and on, but Z/OS (with it's MVS core) runs western civilization, guys. Every large bank, financial institution, disney world, the military uses Z/OS for their business, Linux is a joke even for large business. I worked on an operating system that had at any time 40,000 to 70,000 users on at a time. We had well over 800 printers printing concurrently. I'd love to see linux do that.

Can you guys run Z/os on the free open source software called Hercules? I can. I know all about tech. I was working in it before you were even a thought in your father's mind.

I miss it so bad. I've been disabled for 8 years, but I know what operating system belongs where. You are totally deceived if you think Linux belongs in the home - for home users. Wake up and smell the coffee. Linux is for small to medium range businesses -period. You know, things like fast food chains, maybe some healthcare use, maybe a Midas Muffler store - things like that.

Linux could never have supported the large fortune 500 company I worked at. Never.

Learn where Linux belongs. Not in the home. Not in fortune 500 companies (for their REAL computing needs), in small to medium businesses - with linux system programers on staff....

by deadly ernest

the world. It may appear that way in some marketing situations because the companies who bulk build retail computers, like Dell and HP, go to a lot of effort to design their systems to work with Windows and then make a specialised version of Windows to run on that specific model of their machine. They put a lot of work into making it work.

Windows has the retail market due to the fact Dell and HP get huge discounts from Microsoft for Windows by putting them on everything, and they only pass a portion of that discount on to the retail buyer - thus upping their profits along the way. They can't do that with Linux, so they don't like it and don't make buying their systems with Linux easy - hell some don't make Linux versions available at all.

Want to see how Linux and Windows REALLY compare - go buy two systems form a local Mom and Pop computer store , store systems where they put them together from generic industry components - and don't specify ones that a deliberately made for Windows only, like some Radeon cards. Then set them up and start to install SimplyMepis Linux 8.0 on one and Windows 7 on the other. See how soon you have them both fully set up with the right drivers and ready for general use. I can tell you now, it won't be Windows, as you'll have to download some drivers and reboot the system a number of times before you're finished. I know this, as I had to do it for a client with regards to SimplyMepis 6 and Win XP a few years back.

by dhcdbd

acronyms specific to that OS which can be learned overnight.

ie. VSAM from Google: (V)irtual (S)torage (A)ccess (M)anagment.

by bobgroz

show me proven statistics that the home market has more linux machines than windows 7. You made the statement, I want to see proof. I don't care about servers; IBM has many more Z/os servers out there than Linux will ever have.

Show me that people prefer Linux in the Home over Windows, I want to see your statistics and the source from whence they came.

People at home are not running servers. Is this a surprise to you? Most of them don't even own a router.

But they enjoy Windows 7 (as do I) for games, multimedia, and easy computing. I haven't had ONE problem with Windows XP or Windows 7 since I have owned either of them. Not one. And that dates back to 2002. Windows 2000 was awesome as well.

Your interests are not the same as the mainstream home user. I'm not saying that's wrong, but please don't come on here and try to convince us there are more Linux desktops than windows - even in the server market.

Show me the proof.

by deadly ernest

computers running Unix / Linux than Windows 7 because Windows 7, like most versions of Windows cannot run on systems.

Nearly all the DVD Player / recorders run on Linux, none of those that don't run on Windows. The majority of Video records and hard drive based recorders run on Linux (last I checked TIVO used Linux on all their gear), the fancy microwave ovens run on Linux, most cell phones run on Linux, just about anything in the house using a computerised control run on either Linux or Unix, if not, they have a special proprietary system but not Windows.

Then, after all that, you move on to the PC market. The Unix / Linux group has a fair share of home user PCs being used, but they aren't all counted as you don't need to account for every copy used. The Mac uses a Unix based operating system, and I'll let you decide if you want to count that in the Unix / Linux side of things.

As to the total number of Win 7 systems, I'd be willing to bet that there are more home users using Win XP and Win 98 than Win 7. And that's just within the Windows side of the market.

As to reliable statistics, no one, not even Microsoft have any reliable statistics of what people use at home. Microsoft go with the number of licences they've sold, but they also have a habit of counting multiple licences related to the one computer system. Nor do they take off any numbers for systems where people have removed the licence or destroyed the computer.

by j-mart

A desktop OS, in competition with Microsoft or Apple, in a niche market, but it is much more the Swiss army knife of the OS world.

It is based on the Unix model, originally written by some of the best minds in the computing world at the time and has done the job for years.

The big advantage it has is that by being open source, it is out there for those who are clever enough to take this and adapt it to do many different tasks rather than re-inventing the wheel every time they need an OS to run equipment that uses a computer. Servers and desktop machines are only a small part of this.

Using a desktop computer to play games is just one of the many things you can do with a computer at home and there are many who have a home computer who don't use their machine for this purpose and some of these prefer to use Linux as the OS for their home machine.

The only reason that Linux is not commonly used as an OS for awesome gaming home machines is not technology related, but because no one has bothered taking the platform down this path on a large scale basis in terms of releasing all of the poplar games as Linux versions, maybe some day someone will, not that it bothers me one way or another, but because Linux makes better uses of a machines resources, given everything in place, native Linux versions of games, good drivers for high end video cards it would probably work well.

Most don't actually choose the OS for their home computer as the walk into an appliance store and buy one of the shelf, quite often the one that's marked down on special, or the one that's the shiniest and coolest looking.

Those that actually choose the OS of their system would be Mac and Linux users and possibly the gaming enthusiast who will choose every piece of hardware and the version of windows that works best with their games. Most of the rest don't care, they will use whatever the machine comes with.

by slayer_

ATI Catalyst control centre is a .Net2 program, which is why I hate it, what's it do for Linux?

by bobgroz

i don't care about fault. all i know is linux isn't cutting it. you guys always blame somebody else. write your own drivers if the manufacturer won't. sorry, as a home user i need a computer display, and i don't give a crap whose fault it is. windows works, linux doesn't. therefore i use windows. i am not alone in this thinking. you linux heads just can't see the sun through the clouds. do you really think mr. and mrs. america cares whose fault it is because their desktop won't come up? NO! They will just buy the product that works. This is why linux will NEVER, and I repeat NEVER get into the home.

by slayer_

I dislike Linux, who you calling "You People"?

There are drivers for it, just install them, same way you do Windows. Linux will use base drivers so you can see what your doing, just like Windows. Then you must browse to the website manually and download and install the drivers OR just click the distros detect hardware, which seems to, pretty commonly, find the driver for you, give you options as to which version, download, and install it.

Even wireless drivers seem to work good, I tried it, I had a wireless USB, it had both windows and linux drivers, I used the wrapper program to use the windows drivers, worked perfect, used the Linux drivers, worked perfect.

by bobgroz

see my post above about the situation. nobody cares whose fault it is their hardware doesn't work. people will buy what works..... PERIOD. And that is NOT linux in the home.

by slayer_

You currently buy hardware that works for Windows, why not get hardware that works for Linux.

To sum that up, avoid ATI, avoid anything software controlled (winmodem..... *shivers*).

If you get yourself proper hardware, you will be fine.

Hell, even laptop wireless works now, they got this terribly named program that allows you to use windows drivers on Linux for those really really cheaply made laptops.

by tony hopkinson

A couple of distros didn't work for me, but SimplyMepis went on like a charm. You keep saying Linux, but you mean distro. Go to distro watch, look at the popular ones and you'll find one that will meet the hardware needs except for the oldest and newest kit.

If you want plug in and go, windows is your best choice, it isn't mine or a lot of others. It's another choice, take it or leave it.

by deadly ernest

applies to hardware that's designed, from scratch, to work with that specific version of Windows. Change the version of Windows and that doesn't happen. Get an item that's plug in and go for Win 7 and then see how well it works with XP - usually it doesn't, and ditto with the reverse. That's why the little boxes now have the Windows version on the side, just under the Windows Compatible sticker.

by bobgroz

see my post above. i don't care whose fault it is hardware doesn't work with linux. i don't care, and millions of other home users don't care. we just want our computers to work.

go ahead and use linux with your moldy old hardware, i don't care. i'm sticking with an operating system that gives me a display with my hardware. i don't give a crap why it does not work in linux, it just doesn't. it works with windows, therefore i will stick with windows.

if you guys think it's amd or ati's fault do something about it for crying out loud. this has been going on ever since linux hit the scene.

my tv card never worked under linux, never. oh there's some complicated software out there that might work with my tv card, but i have to have a master's degree in computer science to MAYBE get it to work. And that's after hours and days of work.

windows media center found it, installed the drivers, and works perfectly with my tv tuner card.

i want to USE my computer, not constantly DEBUG it

You guys will never understand. You are all brainwashed.

Linux = business; Windows - HOME

by deadly ernest

you want it to because you bought a piece of equipment that has restricted usage. that's kind of like buying some real fancy car wheel and tyres, then insisting no other car is as good as the one you had to buy to put them on, simply because they fit that car.

You have a graphics card which was deliberately badly programmed, and are now restricted to using Windows, all i can say is:

Welcome to the world of MS locked in computing, as in Trusted Computing, and get ready to keep forking out money into the MS bank account while they take total control of it.

please see:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trusted_Computing

by bobgroz

and DO something about it! Quit blaming Microsoft because ATI doesn't work on Linux. Why hasn't any of the Linux gurus written some drivers that work? You're not taking away MY freedom of choice when it comes to hardware with lame excuses about marketing, etc. I don't care. I just want my hardware to WORK.

by j-mart

It is what works for you in a given situation.
As I do not use my home computer for games, windows with its requirement for constant attention to anti-virus to keep it usable, is way too much work to be worth the effort to be on my home network connected to the Internet. A standard install of Debian on fairly standard hardware works with minimal effort. I am not an IT pro and neither are my children, and having Debian as a basic browser / multi-media workstation only requires average intelligence and the ability to read instructions to get working well, and once set up will stay working for years with minimal ongoing time consuming maintenance, much less than required by a windows system.

As I have stated, it is all relative to what you use your machine for, and for a significant percentage of home users Linux would be much better than the Microsoft product. An off the shelf Linux box marketed correctly to this type of home user could be a good thing, but as as the revenue stream, and how to get you hands on it, is understood by the home computer industry. Linux boxes running faultlessly for years and years do not bring in the regular cash as the Microsoft box with its constant need for attention and poor use of a machine's resources.

by bobgroz

i hate to break your heart,, but amd or ati does not have anything to support the 5890 (single card with crossfire capability). You are wrong. Give me a screen shot proving you have this card working. I'll bet if you even DID get it working it took your hours of farting around to do it.

I'll stick with windows for my home use, thank you. It is a good operating system, especially windows 7.

you're blind hatred for microsoft has you blinded to the truth. Modern hardware doesn't work with Linux over 80% of the time. Also, there's the whole games issue that I won't even get into.

I'd like to see a screenshot of somebody playing crysis under linux with an acceptable framerate and directx 10 support with depth of field capability.

No, you can't produce a screenshot of that, because it ain't happening in linux. Not now, and by the time they DO figure it out, there will be new current tech out that won't work. Keep linux in the workplace for the professionals. That's where it belongs. Not in the home.

I'm sure you all heard of the wallmart debacle with linux.

They were selling computers with linux pre installed for the home user. It was a disaster. They have since withdrawn from linux, because nobody bought it.

Maybe 2% of you out there enjoy debugging and troubleshooting. I don't. I just want to use my computer. Period. And that is NOT linux.

by slayer_

If ATI cards are too dumbf**ked to even use common drivers for their own cards, time to change brands.

All nVidia drivers are the same for current generations and many past generations. The same drivers for the gtx295will operate a 7200.

by j-mart

Than ATI have been in recent times and at present provide better drivers than ATI with much less drama. I used to prefer ATI cards but with much better customer support Nvida is my preffered card now.

by nelsonhoover

I think the point he's trying to make here is that needing to run a bunch of command line mumbo-jumbo, just to install some program or change some setting, compiling stuff and making sure all dependencies are there, is beyond the patience and skill level of your average former Windows home user. With Windows, under normal circumstances, all programs come with a simple setup wizard and 98% of the settings can be easily changed via a nice looking GUI. Not so with Linux.
Don't get me wrong, I think Linux is great but, as a Windows user myself, playing with Linux can take lots of patience and Googling at times.
You have to admit, beyond simply running the pre-installed software, Linux gets a bit more technical than Windows (i.e. no nice wizards or GUI's to just handle all the dirty work, etc.)

by bobgroz

You really understand the state of the union. If I was still working I'd offer you a job :)

by slayer_

Require millions of support installs. I still do not install .Net for the same reason, if it can't run on it's own, it can't run. But in Linux (Let's say Ubuntu or example) you check off a program to install, and [thankfully] it checks off 20 seemingly random support packages that must be installed.
WTF???

Even worse, in, for example Mandriva, these support packages won't be deleted if you delete the program. Not always anyways.

And it get's worse.

So far, Linux robustness has not been evident to me. I had a drive start to fail and write bad clusters, Ok, back ups, new drive, all fixed. All my VM's VHD's on that drive became corrupted file systems. An XP machine, a Win95, a Mandriva and a Win7.

WinXP would not boot until I stuck in Hirens, booted to miniXP and did a Chkdsk /R which completely repaired the system and recovered all files. It now boots fine.
Win7, when booted said it had system file damage (said on a balloon message on desktop) and suggested running chkdsk. So I did so, completely repaired.
Win95, booted it up and my icons wouldn't appear, couldn't get to desktop, so I Alt + F4. brought up shutdown, and told it to boot to DOS mode.
Once in DOS mode, I typed scandisk /Surface.
Walked away, came back, it was done, fixed and system booted and ran fine.
Mandriva... dead, I did plenty of googling, tried the install disk, just can't get it back.
This is a video I took of it failing.
http://trevorsarchives.selfip.net/temp/Mandriva%20Demo.htm

Could not fix it, somehow it became terribly damaged, but every disk check showed perfect. It couldn't find it's own damage.

The results were, the XP suffered over 6000 bad clusters (mostly system fonts, a crippling thing to lose in Windows)
95 suffered 4 bad clusters in used memory, 92 in unused memory.
Win7 unknown, didn't read it
Mandriva unknown, it thinks there is none.

Currently I have a copy of Mint on a USB drive with permanent storage so it runs like a normal installed OS. Works really good, good OS, finds my drivers perfectly and performs well. It's only failing really is the weak software you are forced to use (Like Firefox, though nothing saying I can't find something better, but USB is limited so not worth the effort)

by bobgroz

typical experience you have posted for a home user. Yes I forgot about those packages. What a JOKE! Try installing and configuring Myth TV. It's a NIGHTMARE. I'll take Media Center any day of the week. You bring up a good point, linux can and will ruin current hardware. It's very dangerous to run with up to date hardware. Leave it where it belongs - in small to medium business use. Where there are paid professionals to set it up and maintain it. This is NOT for home use.

by deadly ernest

but I've been using SimplyMepis Linux and Kubuntu Linux for four or five years now, and the only time I've run a command line was to do a ping to check something on the network. I use the command line in fixing Windows boxes on a regular basis as it's the easiest way to do some types of trouble shooting.

people who think you have to use the command line in Linux each day, just haven't looked at any of the dozens of retail end user versions that are out there now.

by nelsonhoover

I'm not trying to say the command line is evil, just hard for the average home user to figure out.

And no, the command line is not used every day. But only once in 4 or 5 years? On Linux? Surely ye jest.

Unless you stick to installing/using the programs listed in the package manager and only send email and surf the net. Oops, just remembered, I couldn't even accomplish that without the command line. Had to run some command I found via Google to get Firefox to see and use the Java plugin. (sort of shows I'm a lot more familiar with Windows, doesn't it)

by bobgroz

I don't argue with you on the benefits of using linux as a server. I argue with you on trying to make it a desktop for the home user. It's too complex for mr. and mrs. america, and honestly windows is a damned good operating system for home use. I love windows 7. I also love playing with hercules running an operating system that linux could not even tie it's shoes - OS/390 - now known as Z/OS. Now THERE is a server. An IBM mainframe running Z/OS. Western civilization would collapse if Z/OS went away. All the linux in the world ain't running the military the big fortune 500 companies, the electric company that puts your lights and gives you the chance to even run a home computer.

Linux is a good server for small to medium business needs, but Z/OS with it's MVS core does the heavy lifting and keeps america running.

Unless you are trained you can't even be in room running the stuff I'm talking about.

No, Linux is not the end all in computing. It has a niche, but that's it. And that niche is not mr. and mrs. america's home. Don't force it to be what it's not. And quit blaming marketing, etc. for the problems.

This reminds me of the Vikings demolishing Dallas a couple of weeks ago. The Dallas players were upset because Minnesota went for an extra score to really crush them. They felt it was "unsportsman like". I liked what the announcer said. If you don't like it, do something about it.

That's what I have to say to everyone who thinks linux should be in the home. Quit making excuses for Microsoft's marketing, etc. DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT. INNOVATE. MAKE IT BETTER. QUIT MAKING EXCUSES.

by deadly ernest

over the last few years I've installed a number of versions of Linux on systems for home users simply because they can't do a damn thing on their new computers because they came with (in their own words) 'That garbage Vista' or 'This rubbish Win 7' - they all say 'Nothing works the way it used to and I can't find or do anything.'

Depending upon their own personal preferences, I've installed either SimplyMepis Linux, PCLinuxOS, Kubuntu, Ubuntu, or Fedora when they didn't have the Win XP disc from their old computer available to install Win XP on the new computer, or when they couldn't find drivers for some of the hardware on the new computer.

Most of these are older people who want it to 'just work' and it does, NOW.

by bobgroz

I'll bet they call you - for anything they need to change.

You know your linux, but that still doesn't make it the right choice for the home desktop. Windows 7 is a very GOOD operating system. Vista stinks, I'll admit that, but Microsoft atoned for it's sins with 7. I use it along with Mac OSx for all my home needs. Never have any problems.... Just pure computer bliss....

by j-mart

When you take a bunch of components that you have, and build them into a box, Installing Linux,and getting a system up and running, connected to the net and with a decent screen resolution, is always faster than a Windows setup to the same stage.

by slayer_

If you took, for arguement, Windows 98, and installed it on a machine made with hardware from 1997, Linux distros, from then to now still could not manage that.

Win7 got an edge on linux again, but the edge is already lost as Win7 drivers are old now while linux drivers are always updated. New hardware has a better chance of working with linux than it does with windows.

by bobgroz

1) Use any hardware you want

2) Install a program successfully without the help of google to fix all the dependencies The GUI install managers in Linux STINK. I've tried em all, and your lucky if even half the stuff goes on without needing lots of work and manipulation to get your software working

3) Run the LATEST games in all their directx 10/11 glory.

4) Watch and record TV without painful setups.

5) Even begin to match the sheer amount of software available for windows.

6) Turn it on and it just works. This is what people want. They don't want to have to learn the internals of and operating system, they just want their computer to WORK and use it without needing to debug every damned thing.

Sorry, anyone who thinks Linux belongs in the home is close minded and blinded probably by sheer hate for Microsoft. Those are NOT reasons to make a choice on what you should use at home.

I'd be willing to bet most of the linux users who say they use it for home, have a microsoft virtual machine somewhere on their hard drive.

by deadly ernest

1. Windows doesn't run all hardware either - so null claim; hell not all versions of Windows will run all Windows compliant hardware either.

2. You get the exact same compliances issues with Windows, they just aren't as open at acknowledging they exist, and they aren't as ready to share them around.

3. Well duh, you want to use a game using a proprietary Microsoft software, try running a game in Windows built around Open GL and watch what happens. However, WINE, Cedega, and CrossOver do manage to handle a this issue of duplicating DirectX well.

4. There are Linux applications for you to watch and record TV quite easily. I prefer to watch TV on the television as I can't afford a 36 inch computer monitor.

5. There are huge amounts of software available for Linux and Unix, even some that have no Windows equivalents. But the majority of Windows software available is specialised business stuff, which kind of defeats your case for the home market; or are games that are designed for Windows and can run in Cedega or WINE or CrossOver.

6. Turn it on and it just works only applies to pre-built systems, of which you can buy in Linux as well. If you want to load your own Windows on a blank system, you have to learn some of the Internals, more so than what you need for a modern Linux distro.

About the comment of a Windows virtual machine, yes, you can have that if you want as most Linux distributions include WINE for those who want it to play their Windows specific games.

by nicknielsen

[i]Sorry, anyone who thinks Linux belongs in the home is close minded and blinded probably by sheer hate for Microsoft. Those are NOT reasons to make a choice on what you should use at home.[/i]

And yet you are open-minded and not blinded by hate for Linux? If so, I can't get a single one of your posts to read that way. It my not be your intent, but all I see in any of your posts is fanboy "Windows is better because it runs games" crap.

I run Ubuntu 9.04 and SimplyMepis 8.0.06 on my PCs at home. They installed with no problem and they just work. And no Windows VM on those PCs.

I do have a Windows PC for my son, and he uses it to play on-line games. What you need to explain to me, since Windows is so perfect for home users, is why on-line games that work perfectly in standard user accounts under Linux require admin access if they are to work under Windows. In fact, the vast majority of Windows games require admin access to run; game programmers seem to be totally incapable of writing their games to run without admin access. What's up with that?

by j-mart

An old Toshiba 1550 laptop with Win98 I use to run my collection of old pen plotters (as they run best with DOS) not connected to network. Every thing else I need a computer for is handled by Linux and ha been for about 7 years ago when I went from Win98 to Mandrake 9.2.

by jcoleman86033

At home 2 out of 2 computers run Linux Mint; hmmm that's a 100%.

Wish all my friends ran an up to date Linux distro then they wouldn't be bugging me to fix their Windoze boxes or Internet Exploder.

At work I had a slew of driver sets for our various HP & Dell boxes/laptops to get Windows loaded again when somebody hosed it with Viruses or Malware. Most of the time (I didn't say every time because there may have been a rare occasion) a straight Windows install (XP SP2) didn't have the drivers for the network, video, and sound cards. Ditto for the few Vista boxes we had. Dead in the water.

I was (past tense) fairly happy with XP and careful on the Internet, etc. Then we got some puters with Vista - that's what finally drove me seriously to try Linux and I haven't looked back.

Windows 7 is OK but looks like a handful compared to Mint & Gnome. Still playing with it so I don't get so lost looking for something when my friends start to upgrade and call for help.

Security?? - why does Windows need AV, Malware, secure this or that software??; hmmm. Rare things in the Linux world. I don't run as root and use a good firewall.

Buy a pre-installed Linux box or lappie from an Internet supplier and everything works, just like the big boys, and generally with better hardware.

Just a few thoughts

by slayer_

I don't see an advantage to that type of server vs the many other OS's you can put on a server.

by bobgroz

Wikipedia is wrong, if it says Z/OS is simply a unix OS. The Unix piece is just a thread to run that kind of work. The heavy lifting, the stuff that keeps western civilization going is done by the core MVS base. I know. I worked with it for 20 years. We used very little of the unix stuff for our work; MVS was the workhorse. Check out OS/390 or MVS for a better description in Wikipedia than Z/OS. Z/OS is just a 64 bit version of OS/390. Believe me when I say this, unix or linux or any operating system doesn't have near the power as MVS. That is a FACT that cannot be disputed. Call your electric company and ask them where most of their computer cycles go. If you can get through you will find MVS is doing most of the work, not unix.

They only use the unix piece for running webservers, etc. because MVS was not designed for that. The REAL computing, the printing of the paychecks, the billing, the heavy calculations, the printing, all the running programs that keep an electric company going run on MVS.

More people sit at a CICS terminal inputing data than any job in the computer field. MVS rules. In fact, all of Unix's functionality was copied from MVS. MVS existed long before Unix. Virtual storage, swap or page files, multitasking - all of that was invented on MVS by IBM.

OS/2 was a great desktop operating system. I was sorry to see it go. It's still in use today, however. You need OS/2 to IPL an MVS system. OS/2 was built on the principles of MVS, but on a much smaller platform. OS/2 - had it survived would have seriously kicked linux ass in the server market. IBM just never got behind it like they should have. Their bad. I still have my OS/2 WARP cd's and run it in a virtual machine and it's still awesome.

Open your mind. Linux / Unix is NOT the bottom line.

If MVS were to go away today, we would not be eating within a week. That is, unless we grew our own food.....

by deadly ernest

once since I put Linux on it. I don't do anything fancy with it, but In do use Open Office, GIMP, Bluefish, Fire Fox, Thunderbird, krename, settings control centre, Dolphin,, kaffiene, vlc, kdiskfree, menu editor, qparted, gparted, amarok, media player, k3b, knode, wine - forte agent, wings 3d, skype, and a few other apps - all through the relevant GUIs and not the command line. Only used command line for a ping when checking connectivity to my son's machine recently - he had trouble finding the network after putting Win 7 on his system.

by slayer_

When I see command line instructions for Linux, I just can't be bothered, but in Windows, it doesn't bother me? I actually do a lot of command line in Windows, batch files, etc.

Some strange mental magic voodoo stuff going on...

by tony hopkinson

Plug in and go also included pre-installation, which is THE big difference. If that was possible Bob wouldn't be posting.

by deadly ernest

a Linux that just turns on and go, he can get a couple from Dell as they have a few (five on my last check) that come with Ubuntu Linux pre-installed and all set to run. Sadly, they are only available off their web site, and they're hard to find on it, and also they aren't the top end machines they sell either.

by bobgroz

What a joke! I'll take windows help system over that crap any day. You can't even read the damned things if you don't know the commands to pipe them to more or less. They are about as easy to understand as running a nuclear power plant. No average home user in their right mind is going to sit there reading hours of that crap. Please wake up! Linux is a niche market operating system... period.

by deadly ernest

to love Windows so much, I doubt you'll ever see that. Microsoft deliberately choose to go against industry standards, as a result anything that follows a particular version of Microsoft Windows is non compliant with the industry and other versions of Windows - that is a Microsoft created issue, and no one else's. When a hardware company chooses to follow Microsoft and design the Microsoft commands in at the hardware level, they abet the problem.

With regards to your graphics card, the problem is caused by Microsoft and ATI, not by Linux.

by deadly ernest

the Microsoft and ATI proprietary stuff. Your choice, and you have a right to make it, but that's not a fault of Linux.

by deadly ernest

than I do in Linux - but you'll get that with any system as there are people out there who have trouble changing the channel on a DVD recorder.

by deadly ernest

help pages in the Microsoft manuals, oh, I forgot, they don't supply them any more, do they? As to the on-line help, they depend upon what the writer of the software wish to provide, and that's all up to the individual. But poor help pages can be provided by anyone.

BTW The Linux / Unix man pages do have an equivalent in Windows, although I don't think MS include it any more, and it's just as hard to follow as the man pages as both are written for qualified techs to use. Just get a DOS prompt and type HELP - it's still there in Win XP, but hugely reduced.

by nicknielsen

Picture this:

You're a brand new computer user, trying to find out why you can't browse the internet on your brand new Windows PC. You open Device Manager, double click on the network card, see that it is not working, and click on Troubleshoot. IE opens...page not found.

Now what?

by seanferd

I had to correct 3 mistakes in a recent support mail from MS which were causing the user no end of trouble.

So much for paid support as well.

by bobgroz

I've never had any trouble with the windows help system - especially in windows 7. I type in my query, and the system even gives me the links to where I need to go to do what I want. MUCH more advanced than a MAN page. You will never get that level of help from linux, because linux assumes the user is familiar with things like the etc directory, smb mounts, the config files, piping comands, the bash and other command prompts and scripting.

Linux is great for small to medium server use.... PERIOD.

It will never overtake the home desktop. Microsoft owns that along with Apple (yes I know Macs run on the unix terminal program, but the user doesn't even have access to that unless he is very tech savy).

Windows 7 is a fine desktop system for home use. I use it all the time and am very satisfied with it. All my hardware works, programs install easily, there is a terrific help system, there are mouse gestures, keyboard shortcuts, the UI is fast and light, it makes a great PVR, things like libraries and jumplists make getting at the things I want simple, I'm thrilled to death about it. All my games work and look fantastic without having to monkey with things like wine, etc. to even get them to look half as good.

I'll take a windows 7 desktop for home use above linux any day. When I'm at home on my computer, I don't want to have to research and learn, I just want to use my computer to do the things I want....PERIOD.

Until Linux can do that... and believe me at this point it cannot, I will ONLY use it for server duty .... period.

Bob

by bobgroz

Why would you EVER call for help with something as easy as windows to debug? That, my friend, is an anomaly..

by nicknielsen

Congratulations. You have, as in your responses to others, either completely missed, or blinded yourself to, the point.

Search the web some time for "I have a network connection, but I can't browse". Now picture yourself as a brand new computer user trying to use Windows on-line help to solve this problem. How is this better than Man pages?

by deadly ernest

oranges with oranges. The Linux man pages are NOT the help out there, just as the Microsoft Command Line Help pages are not the only help, but are the exact equivalent of the Linux man pages and are written in exactly the same way.

One of the things anyone does when creating an application is to write a help file for that application, the Windows GUI is an application, it's just that Microsoft have built it into the operating system kernel. They have a second help file for the GUI. Just as Linux have other help files with their applications, one for the KDE GUI and one for the Gnome GUI, and one for every other damn GUI that's available for you to use. And they all operate the same way. Most are better than what Microsoft do, some are not - they depend on who write the program.

Linux is much better than Windows for many reasons, especially Win 7. The only place Windows beats Linux is in the predatory marketing Microsoft uses to sew up the desktop sales in the retail department stores.

Windows, especially Win 7, does NOT 'just work' it never had done so. The only reason it appears to do so is that you've bought a retail system where a tech at the company has spent many hours developing a special cut down version of Win 7 to run on the system you bought. They did it after spending hours carefully selecting hardware to work with Win 7. Anyone can spend the same number of hours doing the same thing for any system. Heck, Dell even has a few Linux boxes they did that with, you just buy them (only available from their web site due to their deal with Microsoft not to put them in stores) and turn them on.

I suggest you take the copy of Win 7 you have and try and install it on another system that's totally different to the one you have and not been specially set up for Win 7 to start with. Then you'll learn the truth about Win 7.

It's very clear you're not experienced with loading software from scratch on a machine built from standard components, and have only used systems you bought as complete retail packages.

As I've said previously, you have the right to choose to pay Microsoft to provide poor systems and service, and we have the right to not pay them. However, since you've made it clear you know nothing about real basics of a non retail Windows or Linux system, I strongly suggest you cut back on the BS you're sprouting - or are you really a Microsoft marketing person trying to boost sales.

by slayer_

Many many game engines are designed to use nVidia's API and even more now to use PhysX.

ATI lost that race badly, they never even left the starting gate.

ATI is so bad now, to make any changes to your video card setting, you REQUIRE .Net2 to be installed. It's like they never thought anything through.

I am currently using an nForce board with an AMD processor and nVidia graphics, the power and stability it produces is impressive. I can do up to a 20% overclock with no stability issues or heat issues, and the tools work both in Windows and Linux. Both versions are on the mobo CD.

I used ATI a long time ago, the "Composite" setting and "Gaming Mode" was particularly nice, it produced great results in the CRT days, but now, it's just pointless.
For nVidia, to supplement those two things, I use RivaTuner, can't even do that with an ATI card anymore. So if game decides to run in 640 x 480, it will drop the refresh rate to 60hz and thus, slide the displayed picture off to the left side of my screen. (Composite screen kept your screen centred, always, Gaming mode kept your refresh rate at max)

I'd like to end this message with, the final choice of video card brand is up to each individual to decide based on their needs.

by jessie

I've got 7 running on my laptop... and just like XP, after about 3 months of the constant installing and uninstalling of programs that I put my systems through, it's booting slower and slower. Tomorrow, I'll be wiping my system clean and reinstalling the OS, then putting all my stuff back on there, so for about three months it won't take 20 minutes to boot... and then we'll do the whole thing over again.

See, the problem here is NOT that Windows runs so much better out of the box... it's that Linux folks don't want to do home user tech support. For instance, Mint would be GREAT for a home user, if it came preloaded with openoffice, firefox, and some games. That's all home user's want. And let's face it, the move from XP to 7 is going to require the home user to learn a new OS and programs so while they're at it, they might as well learn a FREE one. The PROBLEM here is that there's no tech support for the home user to call about their Linux machine when it goes wrong, like there IS with their MS computer... we need more Linux tech support if Linux is ever to be a real contender here. The lack of tech support is what scares people off because there are a LOT of distros out there that would work very well for the new at home user.

by dhcdbd

Fast facts about z/OS UNIX

* It is a certified UNIX system and an integral element of z/OS.
* WebSphere? Application Server, CICS?, IMS TM , Java TM Runtime, Tuxedo, DB2?, WebSphere MQ, SAP R/3, Lotus Domino, and Oracle Web Server all use z/OS UNIX.
* z/OS UNIX applications can communicate with DB2?, CICS, IMS, and WebSphere MQ.
* z/OS UNIX is built for the enterprise where you can prioritize workloads for high performance when running with a mixed workload.
* There is a broad range of ISV applications ported to z/OS UNIX.
* z/OS UNIX has a hierarchical file system familiar to UNIX users.
* Applications can work with data in both the z/OS UNIX file systems and traditional MVS TM data sets. MVS programs can access UNIX files, and UNIX programs can access MVS data sets.
* The SMB File and Print Server enables a distributed file sharing infrastructure for z/OS UNIX files and Windows? workstations.
* Users can choose which interface they want to use: the standard shell, 3270, or the ISPF interfaces.
http://www-03.ibm.com/servers/eserver/zseries/zos/unix/

Linux is a variant of Unix, can you say.

by bobgroz

are not understandable to the average home user. They don't even know the commands to use to stop them from scrolling past the screen. Windows help is much better than man pages for the home user .... period. If you think otherwise, give me what you're smoking I want to feel good too.

by bobgroz

Firsts of all, the machine I use windows 7 on boots 5 different operating systems. I use acronis disk director suite (the boot manager that comes with it) to manage the boots.

I installed windows 7 on this computer myself. Not only did I install IT but I also installed windows xp, windows vista and mandrake linux, ALL FROM SCRATCH. Don't make stupid assumptions you know nothing about.

You are a typical linux head ready to call anyone "simple" or "stupid" who does not agree with your views. YOu assume I bought this machine with win 7 preinstalled.

That's a rip at me, and I don't appreciate it. You have no idea of my computer skills (which I know are about 100x what your's are).

Go google hercules and setup MVS. How many operating systems can you boot from YOUR machine.

Each of the operating systems have pluses and minuses and I use them for their strengths as needed.

I only use linux to browse the web. That's it. I don't run a server in my house, no need for it.

And quit whining like a baby about marketing. If you're so damned smart, put together a distro that works with all my hardware, and plays all my games that look as well as they do on windows 7.

I've installed 100 times more operating systems than you have.

No go set up hercules with the included MVS images you can download, set up a multi boot machine from scratch, and put together a linux distro that is as good as Windows 7 is for a home user.

Geez, you are dumb. You can't prove to me or anyone else that linux is better in the home than windows, so you make blanket statements about my technical abilities in a put down fashion. You, sir, are a typical linux freak blinded by stupidity.......

by slayer_

This should be more obvious, but I will explain it anyways.

MAN pages are to explain in detail, how to use a Linux command. This requires knowledge of the name of the command and the general idea of it's use. If you do not know the name of the command, your SOL.

Windows help, is a general GUI based help system for general help about common tasks in windows.

Man pages have no equivalent in Windows. You would have to search to MS KB to find information on a DOS command.

by bobgroz

I also boot OSx from the same x86 box that has win 7, vista, xp, and linux on using an efi dongle that I attached to the USB header. Can you do THAT? Can you put together a "hackintosh"? Just to teach YOU something EFI is a replacement for the BIOS and is REQUIRED to boot a MAC. There, you learned something from a person you assumed bought a system preinstalled with software. How about that? You learned something from a dummy like me! Let's all clap for Deadly's technical prowess.

Quit blowing smoke up my ass, and quit putting my technical abilities down. I build my own machines and install all my software on them.

I've installed MVS at least 10 times in my life.

Can you install an operating system that supports 40, 000 users concurrently?

No I don't work for Microsoft, I worked for a fortune 500 company based in Manhattan for 20 years. I was named in the top 10 % of system programmers by a journal published by my peers. If, anything, I'm and IBM fan. They wrote software you couldn't even begin to understand.

You're not going to be able to bully me with your put downs and stupid assumptions about what I have installed and how I did it.

Now go build a hackintosh, smart guy, and tell me the steps you used to do it so I can verify you did do it.

I stand on my original post. For HOME USE the best operating systems in the following order are Windows followed by MAC. Windows is first because of it's support for much more software and much more hardware. It's a tie for ease of use between them.

I care about the home user who is trying to learn, and I like the underdog. I've helped hundreds of people install windows - later versions -on their machines.

Any NUT who thinks Linux is better for HOME USE than Windows or OSX impresses me as being a "newbie"....

Bob

by bobgroz

My point is at least 50% of the time (and I'm being kind), when you need to install software or up to date hardware on Linux your primary resources are MAN pages and google.

You will spend MUCH MORE TIME getting software and up to date hardware to work on Linux than on windows.

Yes, I know Linux has some GUI help, but it SUCKS.

Here's an average home user that wants to install software to use his TV card. He finds something called Myth TV and gets excited about it.

Then the hangover kicks in. He goes to his little linux GUI places a checkmark next to Myth TV and presses "install" or some variation of that.

To his dismay he is bombed with messages about prerequisite software. Messages fly by very fast, the last one he sees is that Myth TV didn't install correctly.

Now he's lost. He doesn't even know where to look. Where are the logs, he thinks. What's wrong? He sees stuff about "missing packages". He goes to goole and searches on "linux missing packages". He gets a general understanding of what that means, but what packages are missing? He further googles and finds oodles of hits on complex RPM commands. Now this guy really wanted to get TV up on this Linux system that is supposed to be so secure, so advanced.

He finds something about MAN pages in google and starts typing MAN pages dealing with RPM management. But wait! The instructions fly by him, he can't read what is at the top! How do I do that? Again he googles and finds something called "less" and something about piping a command.

What is piping, he thinks? Now it's 4am and he still has no TV on his linux box. He's tired, punch drunk.

After a few more google searches, he goes a linux board dealing with Myth TV and is scorched by other users making him feeling stupid and guilty for not reading a bunch of "how to's" that some kind person lists in his post ( and their are very few "kind people" when it comes to newbies"

Finally, frustrated, he says "the hell with it", reformats his drive, installs windows 7 (which my 14 year old daughter can do) and immediately can watch TV in Media Center. Not only can he WATCH TV, listings are automatically downloaded for him, and he can easily RECORD shows - even a series of shows.

Not one error message. Not one google search. Not even the NEED for a help system.

Now you tell me, what system will that home user want?

It's not about MAN pages it's about immature technology for the HOME user to make installation of hardware and software easy and workable - something someone without pretty extensive Linux knowledge does not have.

Don't lose the forrest in the trees. This is not a discussion about help systems or man pages (even though the windows GUI help system is leaps and bounds above any GUI help system included in Linux).

It's about ease of use. Software and Hardware support. It's about USING your computer and not DEBUGGING it every time you want to add a piece of new hardware or install software.....

Keep the focus on the topic - what is better for the home user Windows or LInux. I stand on truth. Windows is better for that segment of computing.... period.

Home users are not setting up servers, or configuring Apache.

They just want their computer to work, and use it for their digital camera's (I won't even GO into that with Liinux), printers, and all the good software that has been written to perform ease of use functionality in the windows environment.

Everyone (except a few here) just can't understand what is best for a HOME USER.

I'm not against Linux, I use it to browse the web, and run hercules (yes hercules must be compiled on Linux to run optimally) - to run my copy of MVS which I use to keep my skills current in the slight chance some doctor is smart enough to be able to heal the damage done to me by two other doctors - I have two serious seizure disorders and have not been able to work for 8 years.

Hercules has been wonderful to help me keep my MVS skills up to date.

I used to get calls from competing companies with offers over $200,000 per year. If it had not been for my family, I would have checked those offers out.

I'm NOT putting down Linux, it has it's PLACE, but PLEASE don't tell me that's for the average HOME USER. That's JUST PLAIN WRONG....

Bob

by deadly ernest

You start out with a total BS about Linux not being ready for home use, when it's much more ready for home use than any version of Windows since Win 98 SE. Next you bitch that Linux won't run the hardware you have, simply because you buy hardware that's specifically designed to run a certain version of Windows, well duh, of course Linux won't run it natively. Linux is designed to work with the Industry Standards, while Microsoft Windows is NOT, Windows is designed to work with proprietary controls and requires special command exchangers, called drivers, to allow anything designed to industry standards to work with it.

Naturally, unless the hardware manufacturers who build hardware to the Microsoft proprietary requirement put out drivers to allow their gear to work with Linux, or some third party takes the time to make one, Linux won't work with that hardware - whoopy do.

I see you regard the truth about how Microsoft conduct their marketing is whining, which just shows how little grip you have on the reality of the market situation and the laws. If I'm so wrong about this, why has Microsoft paid out around a billion dollars in fines and compensation for several lost court cases around their marketing strategy?

In all the posts you've made, you've made it clear you have no real understanding of the modern Linux distributions, and you continually try to muddy the waters by comparing the command line Linux man pages with the GUI help screens - two totally different help systems aimed at two totally different levels of users with different levels of knowledge. The Microsoft equivalent of the Linux man pages is the DOS command line help that's still got part of it installed in XP, and it's done in the same way. The GUI help pages you get with Gnome or KDE are the same as the Windows help pages you speak so highly of, and, again, they are both very much the same. Try comparing like with like in future.

All you've shown in your posts is you have NO understanding of what people need or use at home, except maybe a gamer, which is NOT your average home user.

It's clear to me you've got a fixed idea about Linux in your head and nothing will change that, well, as I've previously said, you do NOT have to use Linux if you do not want to. You can use whatevers available that you choose to. Sadly, that's not the case for everyone, as not everyone has the knowledge to go past a retail store where some quarter trained salesperson, whose only interest is their commission sales targets, is all set to push some pre-built and preloaded system with Windows as that's all you can get from a retail store, unless you go to an Apple store and buy a Mac.

Windows has never been as good an operating system as Unix or Linux, for anything, it's just got a better marketing team, but then, Linux doesn't have a billion dollar marketing budget either.

At this point, I'm getting a bit aggrieved with your insults and BS with the smoke and mirror, good bye.

by nicknielsen

There's no having a rational discussion about the object of somebody's worship.

I'm outa here.

by bobgroz

It's always the same with Linux fan boys. I'm tired. I'm fighting with seizures here, and don't want to beat a dead horse.

Go ahead, believe Linux is the greatest for home use. Maybe go to wallmart and find out why they stopped selling cheap linux preloaded machines for home use. Maybe they can get through to you.

I'm not ruining my health over this. God knows I suffer enough with insomnia, depression, anxiety, seizures, tinnitus, intestinal pain (due to damaged GABA and NMDA receptors in my gut). Two smart doctors did this to me 8 years ago because they were too lazy to pick up a book and check out drug interactions. See my website at
www.fqvictims.org , I'm one of those unfortunate victims.

It hurt like HELL to loose the successful career I had, and the plans I had to start a business teaching large businesses how to use hercules to save hundreds of thousands of dollars on disaster recovery.

Now I run a help line from my web site to try and help other victims of the pure poison the FDA and Big Pharma are pumping into american stomachs.

You believe what you want. You're wrong, but believe it.

I wish you all the best....

Bob

by bobgroz

I used to write technical reports (part of my job) justifying huge software investments. It's hard to spell perfectly when you are half seized all the time. It's a miracle I can even write...

Again, I wish you all the best...it's been a blast.

Bob

by jck

I've picked on people before for it, but I look at it this way overall:

I've read a lot of "professional" articles on here with misspellings, and these are by people paid to do them.

I'm here (as you are) to gain knowledge, socialize, discuss, and have the full experience.

If I were getting paid to worry about spelling/typographical errors, I'd worry.

Besides, judging a poster on intelligence on their typos on here is akin to judge Einstein based on his penmanship.

by charliespencer

Most users don't install video cards. If they did, they might have as much problem with Windows as with Linux. I've had some troublesome ones, although it's been a while.

If the system comes with Linux pre-loaded with drivers for all the hardware, like Windows systems from the major vendors do, there's no technological reason home users shouldn't find a Linux system just as easy (or difficult) to use.

by jellimonsta

"There is no reason anyone would want a computer in their home."
- Ken Olson, president, chairman and founder of DEC

;)

by jck

remind me not to piss off Ernest and Nick.

:^0

I got called a troll enough last week. :^0

by jck

Look to all GPGPU / CPU makers to institute OpenCL.

I just hope it ends up being as good as it sounds. If so, I might go from client/server into programming for those.

by bobgroz

You've missed the whole point of this discussion. This isn'ta discussion about help (gui's verses command line help), those points were just brought up to TRY and get it through your thick head that windows is easier to use for Mr. and Mrs. America AT HOME than Linux is.

I don't hate Linux I use it, when I need it's strengths.

You tell me supersmart why do almost all people have windows machines at home?

I'd be willing to bet well over 90% of people use windows rather than linux for HOME USE.

Go ahead fan boy blame marketing, blame standards, blame whatever you want. I guess your just not up to DOING something about it to make Linux ready for HOME USE. But I'm sure you're not that talented or that smart....

by jck

I would like to say in answer to your question of why Windows is on so many PCs:

Because most PC makers don't sell PCs with Linux, and those who do show very little (if any) advertising for it.

As for Windows being easier to use:

Nope. They are both point and click, both have wizards, both have "control panel" type configuration managers, etc etc.

And, installing (Kubuntu) Linux is actually fewer steps than installing Vista or 7.

I don't know why you would think it's easier, other than familiarity with Windows.

by jck

You know...

HP is both a decent laptop/server/PC maker...

And, a tasty sauce I like with my brekkie. :)

by slayer_

It solves the issue of coding on other platforms, but really, that was never much of a problem anyways. I think it's still the DirectX stupidity. Why game engine programmers continue to use such a crappy API is beyond me.

OpenCL "sounds" like a CUDA replacement, not a PhysX replacement. That's how I read the wiki anyways.

by charliespencer

A big industry player in the 70s and 80s. They invented using hard drive space for virtual memory with their VMS operating system, and were huge in a sector of the industry then termed 'mini-computers' (as we called small mainframes in those pre-PC days). They were already on the wane when Compaq bought them in the mid-90s. Compaq pretty much abandoned what was left of their product line, and the merger with HP was the final blow.

by jck

OpenCL is an effort to develop cross-processor, where as CUDA is designed to take advantage only of parallel computation on the nVidia GPU platform.

That was just my take on it tho. I didn't get to read all the white papers and such.