Discussion Locked

Management want's me to spy

0 helpful
76 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Management want's me to spy on a user.
I'll be using an app that is 100% hidden. Does screen captures etc. My question. Is there a doc out there that I can have management sign to LIMIT my liability. I want signatures from all management stating that they are authorizing me to spy. Thoughts? I have done this before, but this is the first time that have been asked to compile data aginst a user for possible use in court. I have also spoken with the feds and am searching for this form per their suggestions.

thanks

76 replies

by cactus pete

You just posted that question to a public forum with your email address as your alias. You might want to change that soon - Mr. Prescott might appreciate it too, along with Hans, et al.

by 5 o'clock somewhere

Fisrt of all, I am really suprised at the Feds reponse. Do you have a warning banner or user agreement in place that you haven't told us about? All of our users agree to monitoring and full disclosure each time they log onto any machine/web site in our domain. The warning banner alerts each user that he/she is subject to monitoring and that use is restricted to official government use only. If you have some similiar warning in place or have had your users sign an official use agreement then I would say you have no problem. If however, you do not have something like this, you are in a grey area at best. I would get a "get out of jail free" letter from my employer if none of the above are in place and implement these changes into your user's daily routine to establish informed consent throughout your organization. Without it, the user can argue that he/she had a resonable expectation of privacy and your collection of information my land you and your company in hot water.

by datamordechai

I also work for the government, and we have every one sign proper use policies before we let them have there equipment. The other question is, are you a medical facility? Heck, is your company covered by HIPAA? If so you could already avoid a lot of legal concerns because most of this would be covered by the HIPAA Information Security Act. And, if your people are required to sign this policy they are also under the following guidlines. You say How? well if someone is performing connections that could allow an opportunity for any type of remote access into the network, then they could be jeopardizing confidentiality. Remember, anything with a social security number is considered sensitive information, and if they are creating possible breaches in your system then they are liable regardless.

by answerman

And sometimes that's necessary. However, at the end of the day, if it's company owned property, servers, workstations, electric power .....Anyone that THINKS they have ANY expectation of privacy is wrong. Period.

As for my boss asking me to do this...... fuggem, let 'em do their own dirty work. See if maybe there is a "network / client priveledge" (loosely translated) that somehow can be invoked? In other words.. "whose watching the ones watching the ones, watchin us?" (Holy James Bond)

Ethical discussion is this. What if this same boss asking for this, came under suspicion from his higher-ups, and then you were asked to spy on HIM? Wouldn't THAT be a beautifully "karmic" world?

Or here's one even harder.... what if the CIO (your ultimate boss because if anything ever escaltes past that point, other top level managers are either too lazy to get involved, or can't be bothered..... SO...... Your CIO asks you to "spy" on the President of the company.... Perhaps a power play of some kind....

Do you just keep complying with every request? When does it end?

If you have no warning on the splash screens, GET ONE.... If the person under this investigation stops what they are doing, haven't you won? If not, then they deserve what they get. But.... if you bring this up to the management, and they feel it would be "waking the baby", then they are NOT after a clean policy, but rather they are after a victim.... and I would shy away from that.

So once again, fuggem, let 'em do their own dirty work.

by jimhm

First your company lDC should have a law office to assist you. Approach them - if they balk at then contact your own lawyer - and get the info - if you don't trust the company mouths then get your own lawyer - but in any case even if it costs you a few hundred - better safe than sorry and paying someone a few hundred thousand for invasion - and your company using you as the scape goat....

good luck - also I would change to something other than my email address and mark my alais private - just opened a can of worms on a public forum site...

by jamesrl

In several companies where this kind of issue has come up, the policy has always been that there has to be a written agreement between the person's line management and HR before this kind of thing can happen. Everything should be dated and signed before you begin.

Most people have an expectation of a certain level of privacy at work that usually does not stand up in court. In general, emails sent from work, documents stored on a work PC or server are not private - they are the property of the company. However some companies do allow a certain level of privacy - and if they do, there are written policies. You want to ensure you aren't doing anything to break those written policies.

And you need to understand what policies are alleged to be broken so you can gather the right information to build the case.

From the stand up in court perspective, you want to ensure any evidence you gather will stand up. I would tend to put everything in PDF files, and make sure they had the right time and date stamp. Document EVERYTHING, make backups, and take the backups off site(HR Office maybe).

I haver never been to court on something like this, but I came close - I was a consultant to someone who was being sued by one of their clients. I have also fired someone for cause, and had to go through their work email box looking for evidence, in case we were sued for wrongful dismissal(thankfully we were not, the person admitted guilt and didn't contest it).

This is hard. When in doubt, get multiple opinions. You don't want something to slip that causes a wrongful dismissal lawsuit to go through.

James

by stubby

James Linn said .....
> Most people have an expectation of a certain
> level of privacy at work that usually does not
> stand up in court.

I'm not sure where in the world you are, but in Europe the default is that "even" if you have signed a document saying you agree to the company "spying (not that they'd call it that) on you from time to time" then you still have a right to privacy. EVEN if you are using someone else's equipment.

> From the stand up in court perspective

For this side I would personally call in the professionals - e.g. Vogon who can have the experience and the tech and the forensic SOP's to get it right first time. For example, if you investigate my PC by confiscating it from me and simply reboot it, you have technically altered the data since I last used it - in a court of law this would be used to throw out any case. Vogon, for example, take a mirror copy of the unaltered data and only even work on a copy ....

Not that any of this helps the original question :)

by scubaboy

I was put into this situation on two different occasions, spying on a total of 5 users. After the first occasion, I changed a few things. There were multiple legal actions after the whole morass, but I was only directly involved in the last.

James is right - the information and programs contained on a corporate network are company property, with no expectation of privacy. In the few cases where I have seen written policies, they don't really explicitly say what is or is not allowed, especially as to keystroke loggers, etc. What came up a few times in court, though, was the "corporate culture". If there is a cultural inference of privacy - IT guys who set up folders and tell users that they are private as a favor, IT department not cracking down on patently personal software like peer-to-peer file sharing or chat programs, or allowing users to conduct overtly personal business online such as banking - then there could be a defense. In my company's legal battles, the company won all the cases, although it was certainly helped by the spying I had done, and there was indeed legally actionable malfeasance going on by the users. But I can tell you that I made some drastic changes on my network after all of this cultural stuff!

Remember that something that can always work against the corporate "rat" (a.k.a. you in this case) is a jury -- 12 people that may not think this is too cool at all, and are horrified that this type of spying can even be done at all.

So the second time around, I made sure that the suits thats were directing me to do this sent me everything by e-mail - no verbal directions. They didn't seem to feel too threatened by an e-mail; I don't know how it would have gone had I brought in a legal form on paper. Somehow, e-mail is less incriminating in their minds than something on paper. So I had e-mails explicitly telling me what type of data to capture on each named employee. I replied with the specific software that would be used for their approval, got OK back by e-mail. The night that I installed everything, I kept copies of my timesheet and garage receipt. I then converted all of this to PDF, burned it to 2 CDs, and stored one copy in my car, and one at home in my fireproof media safe.

The company never denied telling me to do it, but I was named in the lawsuit nonetheless. When I went to court, I was covered. The computer system belongs to the company, and I had all the proof I needed to show that I was doing as directed. It was still a stressful, inane waste of time, one that I wouldn't wish on anyone.

Good luck, and know that there's lots of us empathizing with you right now :)

by markdmac

Hellboy, I ma not sure where you ar elocated, but most States in the US have an Employment At Will law which means that either you or your employer may terminate the relationship at anytime without giving a reason. That should protect you if the person you are asked to spy on were to try and sue.

I've had to do this myself once and had no problem with it. The individual was visiting porn sites during working hours more than they were actually working. In our case the individual was shown what we knew and the activity stopped.

It sounds like there may be more to this story for your individual than we know, is the plan to correct a problem or to fire the person or to gather sufficient evidence to have them arrested?

If you are the network administrator, then I would say that part of your job duties are to ensure that company resources are used properly. So long as it has been communicated to employees that the machines they use at work are for business purposes, then there should be no dilemna in gathering the requested information.

by robertmi

As an employee of the company you risk being branded as a spy by your fellow workers. Unless you have forensic training and can guarantee the admissibility in Court of everything you gather, you are likely to make some basic procedural errors (they can trap the best of us) that result in the target walking free of whatever it is he/she is accused of and your company being sued for their actions. As a forensic analyst myself I firmly believe that any firm that has suspicions about employee behaviour should bring in an outside expert to do the job. IT staff in firms have a difficult task as it is, and rely on the co-operation of end users. Fat chance of that if they are branded as spies by the workers and accused of bias towards management by defence lawyers.

by dc_guy

What you're being asked to do is unremarkable. Many organizations have an entire staff of people with the training, technology, security level, and express assignment of randomly checking what staff members are doing with their company-owned equipment on company-paid time, possibly inadvertently or maliciously representing the company to the outside world over the company-provided internet connection.

They do this to avoid both industrial espionage and damage to the company's image. Catching people observing the time-honored tradition of merely using company resources to goof off or to take care of personal business is generally not a high priority in these environments.

By all means heed the entreaties to discuss this with a company attorney. But I'd be very surprised if anything in this assignment could get you or the company in trouble. This is the 21st century and we'd all just better get used to all that that implies.

If you simply don't want to be a snitch, that is understandable. It takes a special personality to do that kind of work every day and live with yourself. But if your management thinks you're the best person for the job, you'll have to be very delicate and diplomatic in begging them to please not ask you to do this again.

If it helps any, you must understand that if the person you're observing really is doing something evil with the company network and thinks they can get away with it, they're way too foolish to merit a lot of pity and shame on your part.

by thechas

The first place to check is your company policy manuals.

If there are statements about work monitoring, you are likely covered.

Many companies maintain extensive employee monitoring systems.

From video surveillance (with hidden cameras) to full logging of computer usage.

As a general rule, the privacy protections that apply to our homes and police investigations do not apply to individuals on the job using company resources.

Chas

by tampa hillbilly

This should not be an ethical question because you are employed by the company to help it succeed. However, getting it in writing in some form is to protect you from being accused as a rogue agent when the bullets start flying. If you know the person is acting against the best interest of the company, you are obligated to establish proof, as that is part of your job.

by dklandry

If this is a public company then corporate governance policies should already be in place for these issues. Executive Management requests these types of inquiries from IT. In the event Executive Management is being "monitored" then a member of the Board of Directors is named as the approval person to authorize these activities.

I would definitely make sure that you cover yourself. If your monitoring a middle management down then your CIO/Director should be the authorizing person to initiate this. Make sure that this is all properly documented! If you have a strained relationship with a department or the user being monitored be careful as this could be considered harrasment, and may require you to recuse yourself for that reason. Smart managers and executives will understand and not want to make things worse.

If your a privately owned company then a whole different set of rules apply. You will need to have company policy authorized by the owner or owners prior to doing anything. If these policies don't exist then create them, and be stern in educating the owners as to why they are required. When the time comes to perform this the owners won't care about policies, they will just tell you to do it. Then it will be too late.

In either situation just make sure you exercise good moral character before doing anything. If it smells bad then trust your instincts. Consult with an attorney if necessary. Don't be the scapegoat for someone elses dirty work.

Company provided equipment and data should be utilized by everyone in accordance with the companies expectations. If a policy doesn't exist for an infraction then you may have to let it go one time, write the policy to cover that infraction, and then enforce it if it happens again.

Many times we put policies in place at the time of a persons employment, but never revisit or refresh them from time to time. You should make sure that all your users are kept current on exactly what is company polciy. Make this an annual information packet, or require them to renew the policies along with a code of ethics.

by admin

HR or top management can request captires which is documented. I supply the technology, they review the captures and decide the appropriate outcome. I had to sit in on a meeting once where the person was very clearly in violation big time yet denying that they did it, even with captures in front of them. My part was to explain the technology only and how we were positive the screen captures were tied to both logons and an IP at particular times of day when the user was observed at that IP by management. He broke down and stopped denying it when he realized what was in place and sought professional help which the company provided. It was a good outcome for everyone. We have both a policy manual and a disclaimer screen at each logon that explains that this may be done. IT doesn't "spy" though, just provides the data requested to HR who review it. If anyone "spys" they do as they get the screenshots.

IMO IT shouldn't be determining personell issues company wide. HR should.

by jimhm

You bring an interesting point to this discussion - how would management prove that a person is the one at the keyboard going to these sources. So one could of walked by and accessed the internet, someone stole his/her password - hum interesting. How does your company handle something like that - you say this person said it wasn't him - how did the company prove it - if they could?

You comment just made me think - thanks..

by admin

The way it goes down here is this.

Someone brings a complaint to Management or HR. This can be anyone, including IT if they find good cause in the course of their work. Only the top two people in Upper Management or the HR Director can request screen or packet etc. capture for "Spying" types of purposes. If somehow in routine internet traffic monitoring, for instance, we in IT have good cause to ask for an individual to be monitored- even if we already "know" they are doing something they shouldn't, we report it to HR and they make the decisions- not us. We are barred from looking into it without an explicit request.

Once a request is made, we provide the monitoring at the levels that are requested. Part of the request in that case was to notify a specific top manager, or in their absence, the immediate supervisor, when anything in our filter kicked me an e-mail saying that innapropriate content was actively being viewed. They then walked into the area and verified which worksation the individual was on by name and the time, which we later correlated to the IP address that the screen captures were taken from. The screen captures are dated and time stamped as well, and apparantly were of a nature that caused immediate action by HR and Management. I was then called in later that day because it was still originally denied as a technological glitch by the individual. After I matched it to the internet logs which corresponded to the screen capture information, the individual broke down and I was asked to leave the room. Later they informed me that the company was assisting the individual in recieving professional help. I never felt that there was a grudge or anything after this on the part of this person, nor that IT is seen as "spying" with this process. To me it's an HR issue.

The individual in this case was relying on removal of evidence on the computer and did not think of evidence on the network, even though we have a disclaimer that must be ok'd before every logon. When I can I change one part of this process. I have the notifying e-mail from the filters go directly to the HR or other person. In this case the person which needed to recieve the info does not like to use e-mail much, and they are a top level manager. Also, we ca

by admin

The way it goes down here is this.

Someone brings a complaint to Management or HR. This can be anyone, including IT if they find good cause in the course of their work. Only the top two people in Upper Management or the HR Director can request screen or packet etc. capture for "Spying" types of purposes. If somehow in routine internet traffic monitoring, for instance, we in IT have good cause to ask for an individual to be monitored- even if we already "know" they are doing something they shouldn't, we report it to HR and they make the decisions- not us. We are barred from looking into it without an explicit request.

Once a request is made, we provide the monitoring at the levels that are requested. Part of the request in that case was to notify a specific top manager, or in their absence, the immediate supervisor, when anything in our filter kicked me an e-mail saying that innapropriate content was actively being viewed. They then walked into the area and verified which worksation the individual was on by name and the time, which we later correlated to the IP address that the screen captures were taken from. The screen captures are dated and time stamped as well, and apparantly were of a nature that caused immediate action by HR and Management. I was then called in later that day because it was still originally denied as a technological glitch by the individual.

After I matched the internet logs to the corresponding screen capture information, the individual broke down, confessed and I was asked to leave the room. Later they informed me that the company was assisting the individual in recieving professional help. I never felt that there was a grudge or anything after this on the part of this person, nor that IT is seen as "spying" with this process. To me it's an HR issue.

The individual in this case was relying on removal of evidence on the workstation and did not think of evidence on the network, even though we have a disclaimer that must be ok'd before every logon- which they were ok-ing on this session.

Most of the time I change one part of this process. I have the notifying e-mail from the filters go directly to the HR or other person and create a folder they can directly access for the captures giving them exclusive permissions. In this case the person which needed to recieve the info does not like to use computers much, and they are a top level manager, so it was sent to their printer and I had to notify them via phone.

Hopefully that answers your question, and maybe helps somebody with their process. :)

by kitarnie

Get the management to give you written instructions on what exactly they want you to do, what you are to look for, and what to do with your findings. Then have them list out what responsibility/liability you have and what responsibility/liability they will assume. Get them to assume all responsibility and liability for any and all actions that you have to take (do not take any actions that they dont cover in your instructions) and for any damages caused by what you find. And then Notorize those instructions with a good lawyer. CYA big time. Document EVERYTHING. And keep in touch with excellent legal counsel just in case.
Or, say 'no' to them. Tell them that the instructions contain too much liability for you. But if possible get a copy of the written instructions before saying no. That way you have something to use if they try to burn you. C.Y.A.

by justinf

I send out an email to all my users on a semi-regular basis to remind them that what they do on the company provided computer can and will be monitored and that they should have no expectation of privacy. The HR policies in your company should have something similar in effect. It's amazing how many still go and install games, surf porn sites etc.

by sulls

We have a similar problem but get round it by adding a clause to the employees contract that all correspondance and time used at work is owned by the company and therefore can be used in any way they seem fit. To cut a long story, if the employee is made aware of it and chooses to fight, we explain that they have 2 choices, accept it as it will not change or move position.
If they fight it, they may have something to cover. We also copy every single email(including the M.D.) to an email server for added protection. Can you please let me know the software you use as I have not found one which I like at this point. Unfortunately this is one aspect of nour job which is un desirable but perhaps needs doing.

by afhavemann9

If an employee gets fired and there?s a court challenge, then your going to have to testify, no way out of it.

You must have a fully documented, clear chain of responsibility or you could easily become the "fall guy" if the result looks to be bad for the company or management. Management will defend itself and you could be sacrificed VERY QUICKLY if things start to look bad.

The spy job is legal enough, there?s no right to privacy in a company, but asking management to "sign off" on it, in writing, could become a problem since nobody's going to put their name on it.

I've been in this position too. I've handled this very carefully by sending email to management all through the process, describing their request and the progress. In effect, using email as my documentation in the event I must later testify.

If management doesn't want email updates, then explain that if this ends up in court, then there must be a clear defense right up front and your use of email to document the situation is the best defense for all, including management.

If they still want no documentation, then you can only bow out of the process. Indicate that you will provide them the tools at their request, but they must install and monitor.

There's no easy way out if there is no cooperation, but, take my word for it, if that's the case, your no worse off for refusing because the alternative is to become the fall guy. Either way you could get fired but at least you come away clean.

AFH

by mill3502

This has happened to me on several occasions. My rule is simple, if this is an investigation than I request that a police officier accompany me. Two reason; one to cover my rear, and two, for the proper sequencing of court eveidence. You don't do it right it will be worthless in a court of law. Fortunately we have police officiers on grounds.

by navyair

I'm not a cyberlawyer, but there are numerous issues at play here:

1. Company policy-do they have a written monitoring/consent to monitor policy?
2. Anything on the initial logon screen stating this policy?
3. Civil or criminal investigation? Makes a BIG difference in levels of fidelity/rules of evidence. Downloading music is afar cry from child porn or other nasty stuff. Have had to discipline one employee for the former, and imprison another for the latter.

I just moved from a job as a govt CIO where we had keystroke monitors and surveillance software. My policy (in writing) was that only 3 people including me could authorize its use.

Bottom line is to keep asking questions until you are satisfied you understand all the ramifications of the particular situation you are involved in. If you cannot use company lawyers, ask to talk to whichever dept lawyer of the public office which is asking you to do the surveillance. Your boss cannot "indemnify" you with a piece of paper if what they are asking you to do is illegal...however, most court decisions have sided with companies on the limitation of personal privacy in the workplace when using corporate services to communicate.

by scubaboy

The other sticky wicket to be considered here is what if you don't do it, and this person is causing the company damage on YOUR network? If there is damage being done, whether it's stealing data or whatever - could you be held liable for negligence, especially damages incurred after you deny the request?

If this guy is doing something, make sure it isn't something that you shouldn't be allowing anyway. You don't want to lose your job because you weren't watching the network traffic or blocking TCP ports you should have been.

If you are sure you are covered on all security points, then go with your conscience and refuse... If you're not, do the spying and keep your job (hopefully)...

by gordon.rudd

Extrapolating from the discussion you do not have a legal problem, though you do want to make sure that all of your management team has signed your get out of jail free card for your current HR department. Once the signatures are in place, your company has assumed a liability and depending upon what the employee is or is not up to it could be a large liability.

by techmail.cmccubbin

Of course you can ask for a letter from their legal counsel instructing you to conduct the "covert" operations. That will make them stop and think abut what they are asking. And when you do get the form for management to sign post it to Techrepublic so all the rest of us grunts can cover our hard drives!

by rdivilbiss

Summary:
This policy clarifies the circumstances in which a request to monitor an employee's computer use or e-mail will be granted.

MIS Policy 200, "Acceptable Use Of Information System Resources" defines acceptable use of the company information systems and notifies employees of their responsibilities. It also informs employees that the company can and will monitor the use of Information Systems. No guidance is provided to managers on what to do if an employee is believed to be using those resources in an improper manner.

Policy:
Monitoring of an individual employee's e-mail or computer use requires approval of the Director of Corporate Human Resources and notification of the Chairman of the Board.

Approval must be made in writing and delivered to the CIO.

Procedure:
Approval to monitor an individual employee's e-mail or computer use may be made in writing to the Director of Corporate Human Resources. This is to ensure all appropriate steps have been taken to correct employee behavior. If the Director of Corporate Human Resources agrees that the appropriate action is to monitor the employee's system use to provide documentation and support for further disciplinary action, the Human Resources manager should so endorse the memorandum and forward a copy by confidential means to the Director of MIS.

The CIO will notify the Chairman of the Board of all such requests. If the employee in question is an officer or director of the company, the Chairman of the Board must also approve the monitoring.

In time critical matters a senior manager may make an emergency monitoring request by telephone to the CIO. If the circumstances warrant, monitoring will be initiated, upon approval of the CIO. The results of the monitoring will not be released until written approval has been delivered to the CIO.

During the normal course of systems administration, MIS staff may have various network monitoring, intrusion detection, and other necessary security programs in operation. These may expose the MIS staff to information normally treated as confidential or restricted. If apparent violations of company policies are discovered, under these normal and routine circumstances, the MIS staff will take appropriate actions to protect company assets and will notify an MIS manager.

------------------ memo format ---------------

CONFIDENTIAL

MEMORANDUM

[date]

TO: , Director of Corporate Human Resources, [Company Name]

FROM: [name], [title]

SUBJECT: Employee Computer Monitoring Request

On [date] I learned that [employee] was using company time and computer systems to conduct [activity that is in violation of the acceptable use policy]. [employee] was given instructions reminding [him or her] that the "Acceptable Use of Information Resources Policy," which the employee signed upon being hired, states:

"Computers are provided for business purposes. The software installed, the use of the Internet and e-mail, is for conducting legitimate company business."

I have subsequently received information which leads me to believe [employee] continues to use company systems for [activity that is in violation of the acceptable use policy] and request monitoring of the computer system for the purpose of [obtaining eveidence of unauthorized activities/criminal behaviour].

Sincerely,

[Name]

by answerman

Yup...... somehow I knew we'd get there.

The problem is, there's just not enough lawyers in the world.... LOL

Wow..... I was reading that letter, and the Hogan's Hero's tune started flying through my head.... now I can't get rid of it.

No seriously, nice form there. But make sure you don't have someone able to claim that they didn't understand..... People don't understand legal-ease, and never will. That's why there is 1.3 lawyers for every man, woman, child, and domesticated pet on the planet.

Now if we could just find them their own island somewhere........hmmmm

by technicaltrainer

At a former employer, I was asked to spy on other employees using screen capture software. Since it was a well-known company policy and since random captures were part of company culture, it wasn't a big deal. My question here, in case anyone would like to respond, is where does off-duty time fit into the whole scheme? If an employee comes to work early, or chooses to do personal computing (email or web) during official breaks or lunches, and it can be factually determined that the employee actually was "off the clock" at the time, how much spying can the company get away with?

by flangston

Off duty time is irrelevant as long as your using *company* resources to access the network and use it's resources. Think of it like company letterhead - you are using company resources and using offical company representation, even if it's a love letter to your SO.

Doesn't matter if your on duty or off as long as you're using company resources to conduct your personal affairs, you have no expectacion of privacy.

Same with phones, most people don't realize that tons of employers (the largest retailer in the world comes to mind) tapes *all* phone messages in and out of the business and scans those voice files for words that would indicate corporate espionage.

by govtech

Because down-loading unauthorized software and visiting sites not work related can compromise the security of a companies LAN/WAN network, there can be no off-duty time on company computer systems. It must be remembered, by all employees, that the equipment provided by the company is there to support the work-load of that company. A certian amount of "surfing" will normally be permitted within published guidlines but "freebie" downloads usually blow big holes in anyones network by installing spyware on a work station. Most of our users are very unaware of IT problems.

by susan

You need someone watching our for you and you alone -- not trying to get a conviction and needing you to make that happen. Spend a few hundred dollars for the peace of mind, good advice, and the right documentation to reduce your exposure. Everyone involved else has other agendas and your potential liability, if any, is a secondary consideration at best.

by gvnmtwrkr

Probably the best first course of action is to consult with the company's legal counsel, with Managements knowledge,of course. They would be best suited and able to provide you with the proper guidance and legal protection.
Of course the real damage starts when all of the other network Users find out what has happened. Then some real damage control needs to be put in place by the Management that initiated this action. If they try to ignore this trouble will begin brewing and then more legal action may take place. Also, right after the news breaks about this employee, don't expect to be viewed as a 'hero'. You will find some that sympathize and another group who will villanize you as well. Seek some counsel for your self to be prepared for the personal side-effects.

From one who has been there.

by mfling

I don't know about the rest of the world, but when an employee signs on to work for this company he signs a disclaimer that stats in a nut shell simply that all the equipment and use of that equipment is the property of this company and subject to being monitored. It is also part of the employee handbook. He knows from the onset that what he or she does on company equipment is the property of the company.

by mdp716

It is my opinion that this question is like putting the cart in front of the horse. As the new Director of Information Services for my company (who used to use outside sources for their IT needs) I was well aware in short order that other than those issues which had previously been addressed because of a need, my company had no written IT policy and I set about to write one specific to the unique work environment that we work in.

Included in that policy is a very clear statement that while the company will respect its employees privacy as a matter of policy, the company makes it very clear to all employees that there is nothing which they do on their workstations that is not subject to review and disclosure for the purpose of protecting the company's interests and intellectual property.

This policy was then review by corporate attorneys and some minor adjustments were made but the essence was left intact. Having this policy in place and making it a requirement upon hiring (a document is signed acknowledging that the policy was read and understood) there is no need to have to backpeddle and figure out what can and cannot be done legally to "spy" on an employee and capture their computer use - in fact, all browsing and e-mail is already logged and archived for review for a period of six months.

As for your current situation, you need to be checking with your state authorities as well, as the state may have more stringent requirements than the federal gov't does.

by blarman

Courts are upholding case after case of management oversight of employees activities while at work - including the type of snooping you are being asked to commit. While I understand your reticence, it is highly unlikely that you could be prosecuted for this request. Just to be careful, I would check the employee handbook. If the company doesn't have a clause in there specifying that company employees have no reasonable expectation of privacy while on company property, I would take it to HR and have them add it. If it is in there, only the most crackpot of a judge is going to even entertain the suit.

by kkrause

You probably should be legitimately concerned if your company does NOT have any formalized policies in place that specifies that employees should have no expectation of privacy while using company resources (computers, phones, internet, etc.) Let's face it, the company owns those resources and they have the right to do what they want to with those resources. They have been supplied to their workforce (employees, contractors, consultants) to aid them in doint their job. But the right thing to do (and probably what will hold up in court) is to set proper expectations for employees -- NO RIGHT TO PRIVACY. And if your company does not have formalized policies in place for use of their computer (and other electronic) resources, they need to!

And btw -- I was in IT as a senior level project manager and moved to corporate compliance. I deal with these issues all the time.

by rwhite

As long as the employee is working using company materials (pens, paper, time, pc, etc.)they have no rights or privacy. However the employees needto know this up front and usually HR handles this by having the employee sign a document stating there rights and the company's.

Therefore technically you are in the clear, we are a security company that "spys" for company's all day.

PC monitoring falls under video and audio survillance. It is legal to do so, but in some cases it is not accepted in courts.

by bmente

Better consult with an employment attorney on this matter...not only are there ethical issues at play here, you also could be breaking the law!!!! You also should consider going to your state's department of labor and reporting this. Like I said before, it sounds like your employer may be breaking the law! You have to look out for number one!

by techlizard

If the Feds are involved then why not show an agent how to do what they want you to do and leave it alone?? Law enforcement needs far less legal protection than civilians. Maybe they can deputize you (just kidding).

by mlhco

Your solution is simple. Either management is testing you or they don't think much of your integrity anyhow. Do you see your future? If not start looking elsewhere immediately. What they would have you do others, they will do to you (if they aren't already doing it). If you can live with that, GET PAID! If these guys truely are looking for a scapegoat to take any (eventual) fall for their unethical activities, they aren't going to want to leave a trail and money is slimmy like that when used for these purposes. Since you hace already spilled the beans to the government and put your name in their machines, you might as well protect yourself and your good name. I repeat, get PAID for what it is that you are going to do. Requesting a signature on a written contracts will reveal your loyalties and get you into a predicament over which you have no control. Asking for $1,000 - $10,000 to do something they know or suppect is illegal will get you paid or ignored. If either of the later two cases, you still have your job and perhaps you won't be asked anymore in the future. If they pay you, take it to the same authorities you spoke to prior and don't hesitate or allow temptation to overtake you. If they pay you, and you blow the whistle, you may have the opportunity for a decent life (you only get one). If you don't blow the whistle, you have already shot up flares and started a smoldering fire. They are now on the radar screen but are you also going to be a target by ommission?

by techlizard

But what if it's the user? What if they have a legitimate reason to seek evidence against the user? If the "Feds" are involved I will bet it's something pretty serious. If we all look the other way all the time and pass the buck we cannot be shocked when fraud and terror live right under our noses.

by rmuldavin

Sorry to drop in like this, chose this subject since it was last on list afer reviewing 6jul04 discussion.
Is the requirement that the employee is immune to prosecution, out of the loop.

Thus keeping those below one's place in "top down" decision making, whether in the promoting the general welfare, providing for the common defense, ...(USA Cobstitution), those at the bottom of the chain get the sentencing before those on top.

Take a guess at what your coporation is capable of doing, it could go anyway, before you do. Cheers, rm

by sjefwa

I think you should just do what the management ask you to. There could be various reasons as to why they are getting you into that, they may have suspected some fraud or something simmilar. You know its an Organization but unless a political Organization which if so then do it. All in all do what is right as per your job.

by rmuldavin

Sorry read your original letter after replying to above timed reply.

Ethical behavior, is a personal decision(?)

At times I feel as a scribe in Mesopotoma, clay tablet and wedge sticks, or Urgrit scribe with cuneform to alphabet clay decoder (found in the region).

But to the west, the middle terrian sea, traders reaching vasts areas, carrying paper and skin messages, some to Arcadia, Greece, circa 414 BCE, and near, the the north east of that region, at one time my historial clone, Euipedies was at my age, two or thee kids, wife, and "exiled" to Salima, west of Athens, on a strip of land, an island, housed in a gold mine, with his library, a recluse.

You people facing life, working life, in corporate environment, have a chance to reshape our economic life, save energy and materials, reduce waste, and add your goals to the list of possible outcomes.

But here's the good news: Euripedes was born at the beginning of the greeces's "Golden Age" the "age of democracy", in Salimis, at the time gold was discovered there.

But the "Golden age" only lasted fifty years, Euripedes was born about 485, minus the times of his death, 405, eighty.

Now I'm seventy, got ten years to emprove my writing skills.

Best, roger m

by go4gold

Recently, I worked at a Health Board. The (ex-)CEO was a micro-manager and a control freak. He had one of his trusted lieutenant spy on the employees. Incidently, I should mention that this (ex-)CEO did install install spy cameras at his last workplace.

I am not for spy-ware (as you can tell). I don't believe that there is a place for them. I think that these micro-managers and control freaks are very insecure, and may not possess any real leadership skills!

I think that an organization need to have a CEO who leads by example (versus 'do as I say... and not what I do'). That CEO must be able to motivate his/her employees to excel at their jobs. In a nutshell, if CEOs should have (real/innate) leadership talent. Thus, there would be no need for spyware in the workplace.

What is interesting is that this CEO just completed his MBA in Leadership. What a laugh! The guy couldn't lead a pack of dogs!

by rmuldavin

Interesting observations, it happens that as I'm pecking here, to my left is a d-link digital camera, I had it working with home ether, it's wireless, hope to use it to monitor from by farm home down to our marina campground, via wireless less than watt 2.4 gigahertz.

D-link internet addressed digital camers, I cannot get working again, but that is the least of the wireless emperical tinckering I get to do in my "free time"

Resolution does matter, what's the ethics for me?

Bottom line, get to work on local wireless technology.

Corporations, I learn from web and a few I known in wireless technology asjobs and hobby "buffs", are interested.

Michigan State University has sites for viewing our area here in Arcadia, Michigan, watershed, drain districts, government section lines, county roads, others environment views.

I noted the aerial phots seem aabout ten years old, the resolution gross not really an invasion of privacy, but George Orwell's writings and life, advise me to be on "guard".

Case by Case, Person by Person, but generalizations transmitted over distances mean "control by language", by printing here.

If the original starting letter describes a "reality", turn this around, like in the book, "Network nation", they can only take away your computer. Or is there more here?

est, rm.

by aklejo

If it's yours boss (then your's firm is poor in moralitis), then you have a little problems with yours own menagement and you might thinking that's you must talk with yours people that something wrong, so maybe YOU may changed. IT is organization whose not support lies "opinion is only yours" I'm sorry about my grammtik but i learning english

by blueknight

Assuming your company has distributed to all employees a written policy regarding "acceptable use" of its computers, e-mail, internet and the company's network, you should not have a problem. Even in the absence of such a policy, I don't think you'd have a problem, because the computers, network etc. belong to your employer and therefore there is no "reasonable expectation of privacy" where employees are concerned as there is in a person's own home.

If you really feel you must get a release of liability, do some searching and if you don't come up with anything, you might try modifying a "terms of service" agreement typically found on ISP sites. They generally contain some language you could easily modify to fit your situation.

You might also find information at http://www.uhuh.com/laws/elecsurv.htm#III%20Authorization interesting.

Hope this helps some.

-JW

by rmuldavin

Euripides, I just found on web searches several days ago, wrote his last plays around 414 BCE, pyscho-analytical plays, I am slow reading a few, but at about this time the end of the fifty years "Golden Age", at my first approcimation, the "Age of Democracy" came to an end.

And some one thousand "warriors", Atheians, were captured during "invasion" of Sicily, but set free if they could recite Euripides. It appears the Sicilian's were fans of the then seventy year old Euipedes.

Ok, this won't pass corporate muster. But what brought the Greek "Golden Age" of democracy to an end?

Gold (Oil)ran out? It is mentioned in press and e-press that the "wealthy" closed it down.

Now is the time for us all to lower the level of communicatio: Euipedes, bround his gods on to the stage with a mechanical lever of some sorts (I label "propaganda" as in "geese cackling"), he was a student in the modern sense of separate subjects, physics, knowledge, and rethoric.

Our "prop" is the "Internet", it's time we enterainted the "corporate" top-downers with some lines from the "bottom uppers" in the optistimic sense.

Let the show games begin, enjoy the O(y)limpic Competative Games.

Best, rm.

by business

If spying was illegal , even with a manager permission, you still would be found guilty. There is no such thing like a permission to be above the law. None ever got away with such an excuse.

What about your record? Managers will keep a very clear record of your name for when they will be put under pressure. Not a nice position to be, when a manager start making your name about spying on other colleagues. Once your reputation is gone, the permission from the manager will not carry much value. Your name might well end up on a newspaper. Then ? career and reputation will be over.
Either you are hired as a security and intelligence agent, or you shall stay away from spying! Guess why the names of spy agents are considered national security?

If you think declining such request might hurt your career, then you are in the wrong company. If in this company today you spy someone, tomorrow you will be spied upon by someone else.
Change employer, go with a company where spying isn?t needed to stay successful. There are plenty of such companies.

by rmuldavin

Got to run, this the "game board" is getting filled out, thanks for your comments, best, rm

by bhalverson

so the rest is just talk.

Although I don't personally hold this view, however, modern American Enron-esque business practice requires that you do whatever you are asked by your superiors, no matter the consequence. This again is another application of the concept of "perception is reality." If their perception is that they are not asking you to do anything unethical, then the reality is that you aren't.

Applying this same logic, if you are ever confronted by the employee in question, simply apologize: apologize that they have the perception that you somehow double-crossed them, because the reality is that you didn't. That is your reality and the company reality, so that is THE reality.

Of course, a more objective view is that the more corporately ethical view is to have a written policy regarding what information and services are owned by the company, and what measures the company is able to take to preserve its investment in those assets. The companies that take a more forward-looking and proactive view in this regard may be ethically easier to work for.

If your present company does not have this in place, and your superiors do not want to invest the time to do this work, then by persuing this line of questioning, seeking legal advice, etc. you may be viewed as "difficult" and "not a team player." The risk is that you may ultimately lose your job should (a) this perception persist, (b) you don't stand in continual good stead with your superiors, and (c) other "evidence" is added to it. Consumption of large amounts of alcohol with friends outside the company may then be required to soothe the subsequent discomfort of alienation. I'm sorry to say that I have seen this before, and some are better equipped to weather these waters than others. Note: If you are asked in an interview if you would have any "ethical issues with things you may be asked to do by the company", or some such nonsense, take that as a red flag.

Good luck whichever path you choose.

by vltiii

The first issues is that by referring to this as spying as opposed to employee monitoring (which is how I'm sure it was presented to you) makes it sound more ominous than it really is. Many companies monitor their employees activities and this monitoring has withstood judicial scrutiny. I'll assume that if your employer wants you to compile data on this individual there must be a good reason for it. You come off as reluctant out of concern for yourself. What about the greater damage that can occur by not taking action. As far as I'm concerned, when employees accept employment they're automatically agreeing to be monitored. However, with that being said hopefully your company has a policy in place.

by aaron a baker

Dear Hellboy;
I would make the following suggestion.
First of all, draft your own letter in which the word "Spying" is not used. State clearly that, the purpose of this letter is to attest to the fact that as a normal part of your duties, you were asked to look into the possiblity of any kind of atcivity not approved and sanctioned by the firm for which you work. Further,state that you were then asked to render a report of your findings to your Superiors for thier consideration and possible action. State quite clearly that you were acting at the behest of your Superiors and that there was no malicious intent on your part involved.
Then, having added the names of those involved, ask them to sign your affidavit.
If they accept, your in the clear and are simply doing your duty, if they refuse, then I would re-examine the whole thing and perhaps decline to act as you might be placing yourself in a position whereas you could be held liable for any results that come from these procedings.
Good Luck, this isn't an easy one.
"Honesty" is still the best policy" so don't fall for subterfuge or false promises. After all, how do you know they aren't setting "you" up??
Regards
Aaron A Baker

by dakotadon

As an employee you have incurred an obligation to carry out the instructions of management so long as they do not exceed the constraints of your job description and/or violate the law. The company, through it's management and supervisors, has the legal and obligatory right to monitor any employee to ensure compliance with company directives and legal requirements. In this instance it appears that the management suspects a specific employee of using company property and assets in a manner that is not in accordance with the company's objectives or in an illegal manner. You have a responsibility as an employee to assist this investigation in a lawful manner. To insure that you are carrying out management's directive I recommend that you obtain from a competent management individual a written directive that instructs you, on behalf of the company, to carry out this monitoring and insure that the directive includes "exact" details of what monitoring tasks should undertaken, by whom (yourself), for what purpose and for how long. Insure that these written instructions include that the monitoring can only be done on company property using company assets and using legal procedures. Keep a record and/or logs of exactly what you do and who told you to do it. If you are uncertain of the legality of a specific task consult with the company's legal department.

by david k.

Why not have HR decide whether or not the survelience is justified? The managers could direct all requests to HR for legal approval, and HR would then pass on the request to IT. IT could then hand all survelience information back to HR to do with as they see fit.

This looks like an HR issue, not a technical problem.

by djohnson in calif.

After being asked to spy on one Porn collector and having to compile months worth of data I've taken the new tack of giving the tools to the managers and teaching them how to do their own spying. I still have to install the logging software and authorize the viewing software so it can't be indiscrimanatly abused but THEY are doing their own spying and report building.

They learned as I did, that it's a very nasty distastful task compiling a porn case (like free candy in the candy factory, you soon get a stomach ache)

And guess what? requests for spying went waaay down!!

Banners and splash screen notices and signed user agreements are best.

by james.august

In our school districts "Acceptable Use Policy" we state that the district reserves the right investigate miss-use of technology by means of "Remote Access" / "Monitoring Software". With this being listed in our AUP, We cover ourselves legally.
If upper management requests such an investigation, they must supply you with that request in writting. Then you have your task to investigate, document...and I mean document, and then supply your findings with managment. Then you sign off on that task, making sure upper managent also signs off on it, making copies of work performed, and then you are done.
As for it being used in court for leagal issues, you may have to get out your best suit and testify to your findings.
If this investigation delt with a co-worker whom you were close, there is no such thing as a thin line. You will have to do the right thing turn them in.

Ok, I'll get off my soap box now. Glad to give you my 2 cents. Good luck... :-)

by jaytho

While in the US it seems as if the rule of thumb is that the data that sits on the server is owned by the corporation, there are some international ramifications if the spyee is in Germany, for instance. Publicizing private data is much more of a serious issue. Without a policy in place, if you act on any of the data that you uncover, or you act specifically targeting that individual, you will be breaking international law.

Please see:

http://europa.eu.int/comm/internal_market/en/dataprot/wpdocs/index.htm

We created a policy to cover ourselves. I wasn't happy until I got pretty high in the management chain and had checks and balance signatures. HR/Legal/Sr VP above in order to pry open personal files. A manager alone could not do it.

Now, your basic IT maintenance, and upon user request, to attempt to recover his or her own data-that is ok.

by franktech

All our users must sign an Internet and Email usage policy which states they can and will be monitored.
If people are stupid and disobey these policies they deserve to be repremanded or sacked.
As far as privacy is concerned, I beleive if you are doing the right thing by your employer, you should not have to be worried if someone is spying on you.

by farson

In general, there are certain employee monitoring activities management can do that are legal. One should first do some research on the internet; having first educated oneself, one should then consult a labor law attorney. Only after that and on advice of competent counsel should one seek indemnification from management.

by dercp94

I was in a similar situation a few years ago. I researched Philippine Laws and unfortunately I didn't find anything that defines the limits of "spying". Although such things are covered under the Employees Manual (meaning that the company can open monitor PC and internet usage at anytime), I asked the our legal retainer to make a legal document for management to sign. That document, along with the rules stated in the Employee Manual, protected me from legal action filed by the employee (who was fired) at the National Labor Commission. If you can get your lawyer to make you that document and if you know there is a rule in your employee manual that states that management can do the checks, then I think you'd be okay.

by stuart_at_oz

Better you than me I think :-)

I think the two main things are legal advice and documentation. Make sure it ain't illegal, and make sure you get explicite instructions and approval in writing/email (and if you store copies, make sure you are not breaching security yourself by taking them home, etc)

In short, Cover Your Ass.

I'm in the Gov. sector in Australia, and we probably have fairly relaxed useage rules in our organisation, but all internet and email usage is monitored. However, the only reason we would actually look at an individuals usage was if something brought them to our attention (such as inappropriate sites, or excessive use).

We had a system that pinged the top 10 downloaders in a month, but this was often catching our server guys when they built a new NT4 server and had to download a million updates to bring it up to scratch.
We recently changed the system to categorise the sites that were visited (and outright block several) and now I often get questions about privacy. My stock answer is (and has been for some time) that there isn't any. Everything they do on the network, and many things that are done on their individual computers can be monitored. But if they keep their usage reasonable, then no one is likely to even glance their way. If they store alot of big files on the network, the server admins will eventually be asking why, and if they overuse the internet, they will get a message about it. (the first one is just a reminder, but if it continues, it escalates to supervisors and section heads with a 'please explain')

If they have to do these activities for work duties, then this is discussed through a supervisor and allowances made. They can even get access to blocked sites if it is genuinely needed for work.

( I got pinged for excessive usage once, and a good chunk of it was from Tech Republic - Damn those banner ads!)

Good luck!
Stu

by schetty

If your employment contract specifies that you are responsible for the wellbeing of the computer systems infrastructure, then you have an obligation to carry out whatever task that may be demanded by your employers, naturally their requests must be in writing.

It may be a good time to check the company's Accepted Usage Policy and use that as a guideline to proceed with your investigation. However if none is available, then the written requests of the employer must suffice, but you should warn the employer of the lack of such a policy opens them up to legal recourse.

Seeking advice from attorneys is advisable, but at the end of the day - even their advice cannot be treated as "gospel" - as it can be easily overturned!

BasC

by net-engr

Many of the posts have good points. Here's a boiled down version. Been there before.

Advice: approach this rationally and helpfully. You CAN come out of this on top. (Make sure that HR is involved so this isn't viewed as a personal attack.)

1) Tell you supervisor that you are willing to cooperate, however you want to cover some items first.

2) Meet with your supervisor and his/her boss. Remind them that your ability to produce court-admissible evidence is limited. If they are serious about this, you strongly suggest they hire an outside forensics expert who is trained in providing court-admissible evidence. Offer to help them find someone (be part of the solution). (Web search for "computer forensics expert court")

3) Follow up this meeting with an email confirming the conversation. Hold on to this for your records including read receipts.

5) Request that your supervisor or someone else in management be present to cooberate your evidence gathering.

4) Do your best. That's all the company can ask. Make backup copies of anything that you find cooberating it with statements from the individual's management visually confirming they saw the individual on his/her computer at the time you were doing your work. Store your backup copies with HR.

5) Present the information from your investigation to HR management with NO judgement. Your management should also be present when you hand over the information. The judgement making is their call. They will ask you to help interpret the information you presented. Do so in the presence of your management if you feel that is necessary.

Looking forward:
- HR should have policies in place that explicitly authorize monitoring of employee activitiy by company representatives. If not, see that those are started immediately.

- Warning banners at login further emphasize "consent to monitor" (seach the web for "Legal Banner" for your OS to see how to implement this). Again, this is forward looking for next time. Any banner wording MUST be approved by corporate lawyers.

- You MUST be covered (legally) by the company in the event the employee sues. That is, the company must guarantee that you (as an individual) cannot be sued but will be acting as part of the corporation.

- The best option is to hire an outside forensics expert, particularly if your company expects to go to court. There are VERY stringent rules for admission of evidence from computer investigations and it's VERY unlikely that you could meet this. Make SURE your management and HR understands this.

Bottom line: be part of the solution, not an impediment. Be helpful while covering your bases.

by :0)

If you can display a general disclaimer to ALL users who logon (using Group Policy in Active Directory for example?) which says something like...All users who logon to this network are agreeing to this companies security procedures. This includes the possibility of being monitored in order to protect the Companies intellectual property and prevent system misuse. This includes web-sites emails and other electronic communication being used on the corporate network. Anyone found to blah blah may be liable for disiplinary action and/or prosecution.

make it as vague/general as possible so as to not draw attention to any particular statement.

By logging on your users are agreeing to the possibility of being monitored.

by soulman918

Our company has a "code of ethics" book that we require employees to sign when they are hired. This book covers a number of gray areas such as accepting gifts, expense reports, and internet and email access. It states very clearly that employees cannot expect any degree of privacy in regards to the use of electronic communication. It also goes on to state that we have the ability to audit employee actions online and that these audit logs can be used if necessary in civil proceedings.

by justmakingit

I have taken a class on business laws as related to IT professionals. What I understand is that equipment belonging to an organization is theirs. If they want to monitor user activities they have the right to do so. This is coming from a Canadian perspoective so I can not be sure of laws in the US, but I am sure they would be quite similar. As for your boss asking you to do they monitoring... that becomes an issue of ethics (if it is not part of your job description). What you do is up to you but remember there may be consequences. Better to be sure it is not your job before you say you are not going to do it.

Cheers,

Dennis

by bewernick.andrew

I agree that since it is company property and company time the data on the computer etc. is company property too. The user is responsible to work for the company and not him/herself.
I disagree that the management should be asked to do their own "dirty work". I would think this a reasonable expectation of the IT dept.

by sleepin'dawg

Approach HR and ask them to have a senior manager provide you with a notarized authorization. Get two (2) signed copies of this letter. Next determine the length of time you are expected to perform the surveillance. Third, select a machine with two reasonably large capacity hard drives in a Raid 1 setup in effect one drive being an absolute copy or mirror of the other. Do a full DND delete on both drives and then reformat both drives. Fourth, reinstall all necessary software and encrypt all passwords even the screensaver if present should have an encrypted password. Having established yourself as the system administrator select one other person as a user and provide them with an encrypted password. Fifth have an UPS and encrypt this as before. Sixth quarantine the machine where it can be hardwired into the LAN
and let it go about its work. Make sure the keyboard is locked. It's no fun being asked to perform this duty as it makes us all feel uncomfortable since we ourselves would not want to be under this kind of scrutiny but you have to assume something illegal such as theft of company proprietary information or military classified marerial or worse yet someone downloading kiddie porn which, as far as I'm concerned the most reprehensible of crimes. I know you don't want to do this especially if the person to be surveilled
is a friend or acquaintance but if by any chance it is a kiddie porn situation do you want that kind of scum as a friend. The company has no need of a search warrant as it is their equipment and the individual has no reasonable right of privacy
however he does have a right of privacy from you and the authorization letter establishes you as the company's agent in this matter and thus you come under the same legal protection as the company. We're called upon for this service from our clients from time to time and we're usually covered by a PO but every company, so far, has provided legal authorizations unasked. Another thing to think of is your surveillance may clear someone under suspicion so it's not totally negative. The rigmarole with the equipment is the main points of preserving the chain of evidence and should not be considered complete. Regulations in this vary from state to state.

by pr0x1

Not their property, the company can do what they want. I would also assume that all employee's signed a useage policy for assets... if not, create one and get it approved/distributed, along with a login splash screen reminder.

Answerman is also right that, its more of an ethical issue than anything. How do I know this? experience... trust me, it happens, and careful cause if you don't CYA, it WILL come back to bite you in some form. Just make sure you CYA as high as you can go, and that others are dictating the action taking responsibility for your actions..

This discussion is closed to new replies.