Discussion Locked

Microsoft & Samsung; What's your take on this?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Microsoft says Samsung can offer Linux
http://www.linux.com/article.pl?sid=07/04/19/1335224

Microsoft-Samsung pact includes Linux patent 'protection'
http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&taxonomyName=operating_systems&articleId=9017120&taxonomyId=89

Is this how it's going to be? Microsoft made it's legal foothold with Novell, now they are going to push the FUD to make money through a patent protection racket?

Before I go off on a half educated rant; what's your take on this? Are there benifits or details I'm not understanding or is this the other shoe dropping while MS fetches it's coat before another FUD and protection racket campain?

6 replies

by tony hopkinson

as in racket.
Must be more in it for Samsung that freedom from litigation over potential claims to IP, only a total muppet would cough up for just that.

by apotheon

Yes, it's a protection racket.

That's really what any patent or copyright assertion of legal privilege amounts to: a protection racket. That's why I tend to call it "intellectual protectionism".

by w2ktechman

Since Novell, both Fuji Xerox, and Samsung folded to MS and gave MS rights to their patents to keep from being sued over undisclosed IP?
Furthermore, what version of Linux is Samsung offering? I thought they made hardware, not Linux.
I think it should be with a quickness that many other large companies get together and push MS into a corner. I mean if a crapload of large companies barrage MS, MS would have trouble going after each one of them idividually.

by w2ktechman

I think I might know a little from past readings on this. Samsung imbeds the Linux kernal into some of its electronics.
The Linux kernal has the ability to interpret FAT 16 and FAT 32. Last year I think it was, I read an article that said that MS patented the FAT 16 and FAT 32 file systems, but it was mostly unnoticed as popularity for FAT has dropped. Maybe MS is going after everyone for this reason (and probably others) and looking for back compensation as well.
What a BS thing to do in my opinion. However, I may be way off base about the whole thing as well.

by techexec2

.
[i]"...Water can be used to divide up an opposing army, so that their force is divided and yours is strong..."[/i] --- [b]Sun Tzu, The Art of War[/b] (divide and conquer)

[b]Dividing the Linux Community[/b]

When MS makes agreements with certain commercial companies that use Linux in their products (Novell, Fujitsu-Xerox, Samsung), it divides the community solidly into two camps. For example: None of these three companies will be joining forces with Red Hat if it is sued for patent infringement (they have very different interests now). Further, it pits the divided community against itself. After GPL v3 outlaws the Novell-Microsoft deal, the FSF will have to sue Novell in order to stop it from distributing Linux and FOSS applications that are released under GPL v3.

[b]Microsoft's End Game[/b]

MS' main objective is to keep free Linux off desktops in corporations by inducing corporate offices to ban free Linux use. Only Novell's Linux is "legal" right now according to Microsoft.

MS' end game is to convert a free product into a de-facto commercial product that can only be "legally" obtained from a commercial company at a substantially non-zero price. The only companies that can "legally" offer Linux will be those that sign deals with Microsoft. If any of them do still offer it for free download, corporate customers will be too afraid to actually use it (think BSA raids). With very few "legal" sellers and no free options for corporate buyers, the price will be more comparable to Windows. Corporations will stick with desktop Windows unless they want to use desktop Linux solely on merit. Corporations that still want to run Linux servers on merit will continue to do so.

[b]Watch for the twist[/b]

These pacts with the enemy will end in a few years (reportedly 5 years). At that time, Microsoft will be in a stronger position. In particular, the price in revenue sharing will be much higher to Linux distributors at that time. They will have no choice but to pay it. And, they will. And they will charge their customers accordingly.

[i]"...Young fool. Only now, at the end, do you understand..."[/i] -- Palpatine, Emperor of the "Galactic Empire"

[b]The next Microsoft patent deal?[/b]

One of the next MS deals will be with TiVo. High-profile patent-infringement lawsuits against TiVo's customers would quickly destroy TiVo. A credible threat from MS will make TiVo eager to sign. Then, Microsoft will be able to freely use TiVo's patents in Media Center. Such a deal!

[b]The first patent infringement lawsuits?[/b]

IBM, Red Hat, and Oracle are too big, can fight back, and will. Who will be first? Think of a male lion in the grass stalking a herd of gazelles and making his choice. Which one is the weakest?

The first patent-infringement lawsuits against Linux distributors will be Canonical (Ubuntu, Kubuntu; affects SimplyMEPIS), Mandriva (affects PCLinuxOS), Linspire (Linspire, Freespire), and/or Xandros.

[b]Classic Microsoft[/b]

This is a BRILLIANT strategy. It is classic Microsoft. This is how they got as big as they are.

[i]"...You don't know the POWER of the dark side!..."[/i] --- Darth Vader

by neon samurai

I needed a little balance to see if I was just being irrate and reactionary.

I guess Samsung now falls in with Novell on the wait and see pile. I'm sure the end of these "productive partnerships" will be dramatic to watch.

Another theory I heard was that the Samsung Microsoft deal is really a patent sharing contract. MS won't sue; Samsung won't sue; both will infringe knowingly. The Linux inclusion being a small part fo the deal and more so a smokescreen to garner media coverage (yup, that bit's working cause we're talking about it).

I guess we'll see though so far there's been less chatter than came after the Novell Micorosoft deal.

This discussion is closed to new replies.