Discussion Locked

Microsoft to lay off 5000 employees despite still making 4.17 B profit

0 helpful
57 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://money.cnn.com/2009/01/22/technology/microsoft_jobs/index.htm?postversion=2009012210

Now I am all for a company that is LOSING money to lay off employees. That's business, that's the nature of the beast. But for a company to lay off people because their profit margin is shrinking, That just plain.....disgusting.

People are paying these investors with their family security, their livelihood, their self esteem. How disgusting is this?

Am I the only one who thinks that Microsoft is going too far? Am I the only one who thinks that this stinks beyond belief and think that they should cancel the lay offs immediately?

Let me know what you think.

TCB

Edited for spelling

57 replies

by jamesrl

and "They" is us. Its mutual fund holders and people who have pension plans (pension plans invest in the stock market). Yes even government pension plans invest in the stock market.

Layoffs sometimes happen on forecasts - lower your costs before the revenues drop to try and mitigate it.

I can't tell MS what to do. They have to do what is right for their business, because they have to live with the consequences. Layoffs do cause disruption for the business, and I don't think they planned it without understanding the implications.

James

by fregeus

I too have a pension fund and RRSPs (401K) and If the company I do business with would ask me if it's ok for companies I invested in to lay off people to keep my returns at the maximum level, I would answer a resounding "NO".

Are they still making a profit? Yes? Then there is no reason for lay offs. This greed mentality is what got us into this mess in the first place.

I'm sorry, but I don't pray at the altar of profit over peoples livelihood. I find this most disturbing, especially in these times.

TCB

by jdclyde

and it is why people start companies, to make a profit.

When is the last time you volunteered to your employer that you would take a pay cut because profits are down? Or is that different because it is you making less?

by shellbot

Not saying MS is right..yes its sh!tty but thats how the world works..

I'd say there are people who have invested who have lost thier shirts on the bank stock and are desperate and if MS can bring home the bacon..well so be it..
If your granny was dependant on MS shares doing well because she lost evrything else in the carnage in the past 6 months you might have a difefrent point of view.

again, i don't condone it..its pretty bad, but everywhere is doing this.. they are tyring to ensure they keep making a profit..

by fregeus

I must admit that I am very surprised by the response. I did not think that greed was so accepted as the norm.

For the record, if my granny lost everything in stocks and was looking for MS to keep its margin for profit, I would explain to her that the margin she is loosing is keeping folks at work instead of at home. It's keeping folks buying instead of selling. It's keeping the economy growing instead of shrinking (because 5000 salaries will spend more than 500 inventement brooker).

I would also tell her that she's too old to be playing in stocks and she should of had her money in Bonds instead, ;-P But that's another story.

When I heard M. Obama talk about the need for responsibility and hard decision in his inauguration, that is the kind of hard decision I was hoping that companies would do. If you make a profit, but you are making less than before, take your responsibility to your employees seriously and take the hit. You (the company) can take it a lot more than the people can.

TCB

by shasca

If this had happened a year ago at MS this would be front page news. That alone would have caused them to pause and weight the consequences. Right now it's a "well everyone else is doing too" mindset.

Wouldn't be surprised if they hadn't wanted to do it for sometime but decided the problems with Vista non acceptance would multipy tenfold if rumors of money trouble had gotten out.

Yer right though it is definetly greed driven. But that is the Capitalismic way.

I think I just made up a word

by jamesrl

I'd didn't say I like it or that I would make the decision. But MS is not responsible to me, its responsible to its shareholders.

Do you want to live in a communistic system? Cause if you start controlling whether or not a company can do what they feel is necessary, then thats where it leads.

And its more the pension funds, than individual investors. So should we tell granny that the pension she paid into for years should lower the amount they will pay her, because they decided to not maximize profit? Surely not.

James

by fregeus

I never said nor do I preach the virtues of communism. Why are you taking this to the extreme. I am all for the capitalist system. But I also believe in helping our fellow man when its needed. Especially if you can spare a little to help.

I understand completely that it is the investment firm that are making this request and not the individual investors. But Investment firms are what exactly? They are a group of individual investors and organizations.

I lost 50% of my retirement fund in the last year, and I would agree to see it increase by 5% instead of 7% if it means that 5000 people get to keep their jobs in this economy. That would not of been so a year ago, but it is now.

I just thought more people felt that way, that's all.

TCB

by jamesrl

If you ask MS not to make layoffs, and you don't ask all its competitors to do the same, then its unfair to MS.

The bottom line is that when companies are in trouble, they need to make the changes they need to make themsleves profitable.

I hate layoffs. I've been laid off. But I don't blame the company, they did what they needed to do, and they did it fairly. In some circumstances the choice is layoff now or face bankruptcy later - this may not be the scenario MS faces, but certainly it holds true for automakers, for example.

If you force companies not to do layoffs, then you force them to stay in the unprofitable conditions, and they can't restructure to improve things.

I have no MS stock and I'm not greedy, but I don't advocate for government control either.

The peniosn funds I speak of are separate organizations - they are called institutional investors. The Ontario Teachers Pension Fund and the Ontario Municipal Employers Retirement fund are two of the biggest investors (outside of the federal government's pension management organization). If you want to ask them not to maximize their profits, then you impact my family. What right do you have to do that?

As for communism, thats where interference in the market leads. I'm all for a safety net. I'm not for government control of private companies.

If you want to promote jobs, promote jobs in growth companies by ensuring we have the right economy, the right infrastructure and the right banking system, etc.

For the record I didn't call you a communist, but I did say that interference in the free market is the road to communism. I stand by that. Do you still think I am greedy? Cause in my reading you implied that pretty clearly.

I'm all for a safety net(unemplyment insureance, welfare, retraining funds etc) - how greedy of me. I contribute to charities - how greedy of me.

James

by jamesrl

Microsoft Stock is down 40% - but they cut 5.5 % of their workforce.

Their net income is down 11% from last year - but they cut 5.5% of their workforce.

The MS staff increased 14% since September 2007 - but they cut 5.5% (still a huge net gain over most companies). MS will still be hiring for some positions. Would they be able to do that if they didn't have some layoffs?

James

by jdclyde

Wasn't a year ago, MS was saying they needed MORE H-1B visas because they couldn't get enough people in the States to fill all of the positions.

If they are doing layoffs, I bet they wouldn't have to look far to find someone to do the work instead of using the visas.

I hope someone in government watches over that.

They have the right to size their company as they see fit, but they do NOT have the right to use the H-1B visas INSTEAD of US citizens.

by old-fart-iv

Did you know that the 5000 number doesn't include contractors and vendors (A- and V- badges)? MS only had to report the FTE (full-time equivalents) that were being laid-off.

So now we have a glut of IT workers that were told their services were no longer required. A lot of redundant workers (that I'm personally aware of) were from China or India and either have left the Bellevue/Redmond area or will be leaving soon.

Just got off the phone with another person whose business is being affected by the loss of these "visitors". I wonder how big the spike will be in repo'd cars and homes?

The economy in the Seattle/Bellevue metro area is heading for the tank.

Reference Article: http://blog.seattletimes.nwsource.com/techtracks/2009/01/22/microsoft_layoffs_what_about_the_contractors_contr.html

Edited to add: (1) I am not currently working for MS, but know quite a few current and former MS workers; and (2) Added link to Seattle Times Article on contractors :)

by fregeus

First off, I am against forcing anyone or anything to do something. That include forcing companies not to lay off people. I never said such a thing and I never will.

The government has nothing to do with anything I said in my original or subsequent posts. Government is bloated enough as it is thank you very much.

Second. The point I was making IS PRECISELY that MS is NOT in trouble and making layoffs. Don't compare this to the auto industry, they are an entire different ball of wax, they are not even in the same hemisphere to this. I am talking MS and MS only.

MS is not in trouble, they just missed their target profit margin. Their profit is still a staggering 4.17 B dollars. If that's trouble, it's the kind I wanna be in.

For the record, I never said you called me a communist. I said I never made any reference to communism. And since I never called for interference to the natural selection process of markets, I made no reference to it.

These people who are being lay off are people like you and me. Mothers, fathers, husbands and wives, who have children to feed and raise. They did nothing wrong, they did their job. Then why are they in the street tomorrow? Why?

Because MS, who is already making a HUGE amount of money (lets face it, 4 B in profit per quarter is pretty damn good), wants to keep making more. I ask you, is that fair? Really? Don't answer as a stock holder or a pension fund holder, answer as a father, mother, husband or wife. That's what I am doing.

What it all comes down to is this. I am not asking the government to do anything, I am asking the people of MS, do you really need to make those layoff. To disturb these families for a mere 500M$ when you are making 8 times that PER quarter? I am asking for the people of MS to do the right thing and not be greedy like they are showing to be right now.

As for the greedy comment towards you, if the shoe fits, wear it! If not, then just forget about it. I never said you were greedy, I said I find you to be greedy. Big difference. ;-)

TCB

by jamesrl

Thats a pretty fine distinction, more like you are playing word games.

You don't know me. You have no basis on which to judge my values. But go ahead and be judgemental and resort to ad hominems.

I am a husband, father and son. I am the sole support for a family of 5. I don't come from wealth and I was laid off and had to support my family. I never said I didn't have compassion for those who have been laid off.

As for MS's profit being excessive - compared to what? Compared to previous profits, compared to companies the same size? You do know that profit isn't just what they use to go to dinner on, profit is often reinvested in the business, to grow new areas, to do R&D. Does anyone think that MS can just sit on its product base and do nothing and remain profitable?

My company laid off a similar proprotion of workers. We made a profit last year, but we won't make one this year. We know our customers are going to be much worse off than we are, many are in the process of declaring bankruptcy. We did what we had to do to survive.

Microsoft shares lost 40% of their value. That means that 40% of the capital they had for new product and R&D is gone. That was a heck of a lot more than 4.5 Billion.

James

by dr dij

just to have an excuse to lay off people?

based on the size of M$, 4.7B is NOT MUCH MONEY!

That's like saying that, even tho you foresee being laid off or a significant reduction in income, that you SHOULD NOT CUT BACK TILL IT HAPPENS?

Companies need to save money for possible future hardships just like people.

You are the basic problem with this country:
1) you don't appear to understand basic economics
2) you are one of the SPEND SPEND SPEND people it appears

by shellbot

"That's like saying that, even tho you foresee being laid off or a significant reduction in income, that you SHOULD NOT CUT BACK TILL IT HAPPENS?"

I have a job, so does hubby. However, in light of recent events in the world economy I have decided to cut back in case things get even worse. I have cut my spending on "things" and have really looked at my food purchases..am brigning in own lunch ect.. IF i do hit a rough spot, I know I will have a couple months of leeway before i get desperate. By me cutting back, I am furthermore hurting the economy by not spending to provide the gov't with my tax money..but I have to look out for myself.

MS may have a huge profit right now, but if spending on thier products stopped for 6 months, they would be down coonsiderably. They would still have to pay thier employees, and thier health insurance and thier money to the gov't... if profits go down low enough they would then face laying off twice as many..
At least by protecting what they have, they can continue to employ a reasonable level of staff.

by dr dij

people see 4$billion and say 'HUGE'.
Based on their total capitalization, this is probably NOT a huge profit.

And this is really dumb. Suppose you cut the company into 100 mini-softs (mini-me's). Then the profit would only be 1/100th of the total. Would anyone be complaining? but together they would still be the same total.

Same way with oil companies. Each oil rig in the ocean can cost $700 million to billions. Yet we de-cry profit of $50 billion temporarily. Their investment is many times this amount. Plus with oil prices going down now, large investments are being cut way back.

This means, recession or not, we will soon be in for an 'oil shock' again.

Same thing happened in Russia - they used oil as a cash cow during upturn but didn't invest much of the money BACK in production. They won't be ready to take advantage of the next upturn in prices.

Mexico won't let foreign companies invest in their oil wells, or even help increase production. They have been milking their oil monies to pay for basic govt and bloated salaries and pensions for pemex employees. Little is invested in oil prodution, which is declining in Cantarell field 16% a year. Mexico, which is a major exporter of oil tothe US will soon become a net IMPORTER and have MORE domestic probs as they run out of money.

Similar stories at oil fields around the world. The Saudi's have been pumping their oil dry for 40 years yet their declared reserves have NEVER CHANGED and no one outside the oil company is allowed near the fields. DO you really think they can keep up production forever?

Then he suggested the 666 anti-thesis of capitalism: keep people hired who are NOT DOING ANYTHING! Keeping peoplehired simply to prevent layoffs 1)hurts that ocmpany as they don'tproduce anything, 2) hurts the econmy for same reason, keeps them from being hired somewhere else.

by jck

MS has operated in a profit every year for 30+ years, I'd think that MS probably has saved up a lot of money if they're smart.

There's no excuse for laying those people off.

But oh well...

by jamesrl

When Microsoft's stock dropped by 40% so did the amount of working capital that they have to play with.

Sure they have some reserves of operating cash. But money doesn't make a lot sitting idle in a bank account, it makes money when you use it to develop products that people want.

If your small business starts up and you hire someone to help you, and you business falls off, would you not lay them off? Or would you wait till you got to the point where you had to shut down the business and take a full time job.

Intel also had to layoff 5000 people around the world - maybe the two of these companies know something you aren't aware of - like PC sales are falling fast. Thats a major source of MS revenue - both for the OS and Office suite.

James

by shellbot

Nothing personal here..just in it for the debate ok :)

I'm a capitolist..
A company exists to make money, not provide social welfare (in the form of wages) to the populace. I won't repeat what other are saying about reinvesting profit for R&D and such.. but at the end of the day, maybe by MS shedding jobs now, it protects future jobs.
Pension funds and other funds buy stock, to which they hope to recieve dividends and or profit from. Its how us little people can prepare for having money when we retire. I expect those companies to be prudent on how they run thier companies to ensure returns on my investment in the company.
I'm sure it does sound heartless to many people, buts its business.. layoffs suck big time and its horrible, but at the end of the day its a big bad world, and these companies help it go round.
It would be great if we all had jobs for life, and all sorts of guarentees etc..but in times like these where companies are folding fast, they all have to hunker down and prepare for the worst.
That 4B profit amy have to help pay the wages into the next year or so.. what woul dhappen if profits ceased and there was no money in the account to pay the bills?? A lot more than 5000 would loose thier jobs.
At least they are just downsizing to save money.. Dell in Limerick has axed 1900 jobs cause they moving them to cheaper places..

Utopia would be lovely..but untill that happens, I'll have to deal with the one I'm in.

Again..I don't say MS are right in doing this from a humnities point of view, but to be fiscally responsible..they have to prepare for the next couple of years.

by fregeus

But if I follow the same logic, shouldn't we all accept the H1B visas coming into the country (US) as simply companies trying to be competitive in a tight market? If you cut an American from your payroll and replace him/her with an immigrant at half the cost, aren't you just trying to save the company's bottom line?

If you think that the 5000 job lost while still making huge profit is ok, but the H1B visa are bad for American, I'd say your a hypocrite. Both of those thing are bad for the same reason. Greed.

I am all for making money anyway you can. But I also believe that not every cost cutting measure are acceptable.

I totally accept your view of capitalism (cute typo BTW 'capitolism'). I just think the needs to be a line drawn somewhere. I draw mine at this point.

BTW, I don't take any of your comments personally. If it seemed that way, I apologize, it was not. Nor do I give comments to be personal attacks. To me, this is just a discussion.

TCB

by shellbot

Way I see it, a company can hire who they want, as long as its done within the confines of the law.
I beg to ask why the gov allows so many HB1's into the country, or allows so many to be hired?
A company will always seek to save money..again..don't condone or like it.

We had simliar thing here..lots of eastern europeans flooded into ireland, working for 1/2 the wages of the native population..
If I put on my logic hat, ok, the companies were able to hire at reduced costs thus saving money..
But if I put oh my emotions hat..yes..sucked for the people looking for real wages..

This is why I would never ever want to be a head hancho somewhere.. I couldn't make those choices..its much easier to be a bystander and pass judgement ! ]:)

by jamesrl

Ask the government why they chose to allow the H1Bs. Don't expect one company to handcuff themsleves and not take advantage of it, if their competitors don't do the same.

James

by jaqui

configure websites to refuse access to anyone using windows, tell them to get a REAL operating system ]:)

by maxwell edison

In 2007, Microsoft added more than 10,000 employees to it already 90,000 person staff. It laid off the equivalent of half those folks, the details of which are not known. Perhaps some were offered attractive severance packages and/or were close to retirement anyway. Microsoft has created over 12,000 millionaires from its employee ranks because of profit sharing and early stock purchases. Microsoft continually is at the top of the list of the best companies to work for and is one of the highest paying companies in the country.

Instead of the myriad of debt-ridden companies that we continue to hear about - many of which are currently seeking government bail-outs - Microsoft continues to place great importance on staying profitable, not only for its millions of shareholders - many of which are in the form of 401(k) accounts) - but for the future stability of the company - as it should.

Profits are good; debt is bad. Positive cash flow is good; a negative EPS (earnings per share) is bad. Too bad other American companies don't follow Microsoft's model. (Hello General Motors!)

Economies are cyclical, and very few companies can avoid all down-cycles. It's easy to blame [i]greedy executives[/i], but that's such a shallow argument that fails to take all factors into consideration.

Besides, if you listen to the folks around here, most of them despise Microsoft anyway, and would not only like to run them out of business, but run them out of town. Let them wave their magic wand and get what they want, and Microsoft would have to lay-off another 90,000+ people.

by jmgarvin

You are dead on about profits being good and debt being bad. However, revenue at MS grew 2%. Not to mention that MS has dropped the ball on a TON of their products (RRoD and Vista come to mind quite quickly).

I think everyone agrees that economies are cyclical and that down cycles will effect everyone, but I also think it is obvious that MS may not be acting in the interest of the share holders.

Sure, getting leaner is useful, but what are they down sizing, and more importantly, WHO...Not to mention what does the exec bonus package look like if they are down sizing?

by hypnotoad

http://social.expression.microsoft.com/forums/en-US/media/thread/eb64b7b5-541b-44b8-92d2-91101eb5bf0a/

The relevance is, making a customer pay for a fix for a buggy product in this manner is not ethical. If enough highway billboards for schools and jobs have cute catchphrases for taking responsibility, so can Microsoft. (and until that little thread I found, people simply took it for granted Windows users are mere beta testers and made jokes. The joke is the reality of the situation.)

There are valid reasons for disliking Microsoft's indolence, and next we'll be told American employees aren't smart enough to work on the code. And given the state Win32 is thanks to the bloat that was sold as Vista, the reputation is not undeserved.

Also, how can a company survive if it has to wait on delays due to the products Microsoft wants to make a 100% monopoly out of?

Sorry Maxwell, I could go on forever with any number of tangents. But you are wrong. There is more to a company than dollar figures and profits. Microsoft lost its way. A long time ago. And if they are laying off, they can no longer claim there aren't any "qualified" American workers any longer.

by maxwell edison

HypnoToad said, [i]Sorry Maxwell, I could go on forever with any number of tangents. But you are wrong.[/i]

My message dissected:

[i]Microsoft is only doing what's necessary[/i]

[i]What?s necessary[/i] presumes that people and companies are in a better position to determine such things for themselves than outsiders. You would have to be a fly on the wall of every board meeting and privy to every conversation ? and be qualified to run a multi-billion dollar company ? to seriously suggest otherwise. The title implied that Microsoft is only doing what it deemed necessary. Your disagreement is no more than an unqualified opinion.

[i]In 2007, Microsoft added more than 10,000 employees to it already 90,000 person staff.[/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where.

[i]It laid off the equivalent of half those folks, the details of which are not known. [/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where. (Isn't 5,000 half of 10,000?)

[i]Perhaps some were offered attractive severance packages and/or were close to retirement anyway. [/i]

I said, [i]perhaps[/i] because it?s not known who was laid off or the circumstances around it. This is speculation, of course, not a statement of fact.

[i]Microsoft has created over 12,000 millionaires from its employee ranks because of profit sharing and early stock purchases. [/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where.

[i]Microsoft continually is at the top of the list of the best companies to work for and is one of the highest paying companies in the country. [/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where.

[i]Instead of the myriad of debt-ridden companies that we continue to hear about - many of which are currently seeking government bail-outs - Microsoft continues to place great importance on staying profitable, not only for its millions of shareholders - many of which are in the form of 401(k) accounts) - but for the future stability of the company - as it should. [/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where.

[i]Profits are good; debt is bad. Positive cash flow is good; a negative EPS (earnings per share) is bad. Too bad other American companies don't follow Microsoft's model. (Hello General Motors!) [/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where.

[i]Economies are cyclical, and very few companies can avoid all down-cycles. It's easy to blame greedy executives, but that's such a shallow argument that fails to take all factors into consideration. [/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where.

[i]Besides, if you listen to the folks around here, most of them despise Microsoft anyway, and would not only like to run them out of business, but run them out of town. Let them wave their magic wand and get what they want, and Microsoft would have to lay-off another 90,000+ people. [/i]

That is true. If I?m wrong, please point out where. (There's a lot of Microsoft bashers around here.)

Funny that you went on and on with your self-admitted tangents, based your opinion on and about those tangents, and then made the blanket statement that I was [i]wrong[/i] without addressing a single thing I really said.

Oh well, such is life in the TR water cooler threads.

by melissab

MS is just plain acting selfishly. Yes, greed is a given in Corporate America, but we've seen how the unbridled version can be devastating to both consumers and corporations. Does Microsoft need a lesson in integrity? Or perhaps just history.

by jmgarvin

Lay offs like this, especially when revenue is up 2%ish, have a HUGE impact on organizational behavior. The nAch will achieve less due to FUD and the power seekers will start stabbing everyone they can in the back.

It turns into Lord of the Flies (or Lord of the Dance if you will) in the cube world.

Taking pay cuts, if it is in the best interest of the company (eg a rational decision rather than a behavior one) means that company will thrive and out pace other companies.

This layoff is purely behavioral and will hurt MS even more. Their desktop market share is below 90% and they are losing in the server market as well...

Steve Ballmer needs a reality check and needs to get MS back on track or they are going to do exactly what IBM did in the late 80s.

* edit for typo

by nicknielsen

Do you have a solution that doesn't involve somebody from outside a company* compelling that company to retain employees they believe are no longer needed?

*A "company" is defined as all who have a financial stake in that company. This includes employees, management, the board of directors, and stockholders.

by maxwell edison

Nationalize Microsoft, and let President Obama and a Democratic controlled Congress make all the business decisions. Isn't that the solution of the day, now-a-days?

We all know big business is bad, while big government is good? Didn't you get the message?

by jmgarvin

What MS is doing is probably fairly slimy. They really haven't been looking after their share holders. Look at the PR nightmares they've had with Vista and the RRoD alone.

Their revenue is up 2% from last year and I would assume they are like the rest of the software world and predict flat revenue this year.

The bigger problem I have is:
A) MS is claiming their is a lack of talent
B) MS is laying off 5000 employees

There is a problem there...

by nicknielsen

[i]We all know big business is bad, while big government is good...[/i]

I missed the word "big" and was in shock that anybody could possibly believe such idiocy.

edited

by gruntingdwarf

"My company laid off a similar proprotion of workers. We made a profit last year, but we won't make one this year [...] We did what we had to do to survive."

That explains the irrefutable "business objectivity" of your argumentation.
Had you -once more- been on the list of laid offs, then you'd think in a bit less objective way and in a bit more... how you said it... "communistic" way.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]Had you -once more- been on the list of laid offs, then you'd think in a bit less objective way and in a bit more... how you said it... "communistic" way. [/i]

You live in James' head?

by maxwell edison

No more, no less.

Well, okay, it was a political statement observing the troubling direction our government (and society) has taken. But it was a joke based on a bit of reality ? business, in general, IS being demonized more, while more people ARE placing more of their trust in government. I shake my head in disbelief ? Barack Obama, Nancy Pelosi, and Harry Reid ? with strong influence from Barney Frank, Chris Dodd. Et al ? have been gaining so much control over American business and people?s lives. I?d take the leadership in the Microsoft boardroom any day over the fools in Washington.

As to Microsoft, it's been one of the best run and most successful companies for over twenty five years. I?m amazed at people like you who presume to know what?s best for their business based on, what?s tantamount to, an emotional assessment.

Hello broker, I want to buy ### shares of MSFT.

What in the heck does Rush Limbaugh have to do with this? Let me guess. It?s your lame attempt to discredit, pigeon-hole, stereo-type, etc.

by jmgarvin

From an organizational standpoint the FUD that firing generates, productivity will be lost.

The strange part is net loss is really going to be like 1k, but the bad will reduce productivity across departments....The organizational impact can be huge...

by richardwilliams

I totally agree with this comment.

I also thought ?What chance does the humble employee have??, when companies are just driven by pure greed?

Having read that Microsoft's quarterly (yes - just a quarter) profit (yes - that's profit NOT turnover) was down from 4.7 billion dollars to 4.1 like for like on the previous year were to lay off 5000 employees, I could only conclude that lots of businesses are using this, 'the worst time in our working careers' as an excuse to make the rich richer. Sure companies have share holders and need to return profits, but even when they've had brilliant years all that they want is even more... this is greed to me!

Hopefully some shame will fall on the ?Top Bananas? running these companies so that other do not feel that they have to follow their lead. They should be trying to give the normal hard working employee some security instead of the ongoing fear of losing their job. Then we can start to spend with a bit of confidence (we are all too scared to spend at the moment). It is businesses not governments who will kick start this and get money flowing again; we all know it is this that makes the world go around and keeps it spinning!!!

RJW

by peconet tietokoneet

So the Anti Microsoft people do not like Microsoft because they would like the piece of their action.
Business is business, unless you know their payroll, tax, plus other accounting figures and payment systems, then the Anti-Microsoft people are only guessing for the lay offs.
By the way other businesses go along the similar route as Microsoft (accounting etc), just because Microsoft has all that Billions of Dollars in reserve is that why they are the easy target?. Or is it that we/you are jealous?.
Before you take stock of other peoples monetary values, look at your own monetary values and get them sorted (I:E, do you really need to buy that new car, shoes, coat, boat?, etc). :)

by jamesrl

Aparently you missed the many posts where I mentioned that I have been laid off myself in the past.

I will honestly tell you that even though logically I didn't think I would be laid off, I and just about everyone else had the fear. A VP and a director both told me they were worried that they might be on the list.

No sane person enjoys laying someone off. I would have done anything I could to avoid laying someone off. But the options were not open.

James

by jkameleon

They invested their time, effort and money into diploma, which opened their way into Microsoft. They've been conned by Bill Gates himself, among others

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A06E6DE163FF932A35750C0A9629C8B63

"We need your excitement," he told students at Harvard. "Most of these jobs are very interesting and very social -- you work with lots of smart people. I'm excited about the future of computing, and I'm excited to see how each of you can contribute to it."

Well, he surely got the excitement. A lots of it. Fucking liar.

by maxwell edison

And just like so many other workers with other companies and in other sectors, they got a lesson in life - it might not always work out like you planned.

by jkameleon

The ones that believed Gates and his ilk back then, had just finished their studies. Their lesson: Hard work and knowledge won't get you far. Only lying and deceit will make you rich.

If study is an investment, IT talent shortage propaganda is pump&dump scam.

by nicknielsen

[i]Hard work and knowledge won't get you far. Only lying and deceit will make you rich.[/i]

Do you have any evidence to support this statement? Statistics? Documentation? How many of those that believed "Gates and his ilk" are still in their first job after college?

by jkameleon

> Do you have any evidence to support this statement?

Fact: 4 years ago, Bill Gates was running around colleges, and horsetwaddling about shortage of computer science graduates. There were also a tons of newspaper articles and books predicting imminent critical shortage of computing talent around 2010. Shortage shouting partially subsided only a month or two ago.

Fact: Right now, Microsoft is laying off people, everywhere, except in India.

>Statistics?

You ask too much. There is no statistics anybody could trust.

Statistic produced by universities and industry is not trustworthy due to interest bias. The same holds good for government statistics.

The only thing one can rely upon is the ol'common sense, no matter how unreliablie it might be. And common sense says that in developed world, IT is profession in decline, at least its R&D.

>Documentation?

I've provided links.

>How many of those that believed "Gates and his ilk" are still in their first job after college?

Those that believed Gates and his ilk in 2004 are graduating right now. They must indeed have plenty of excitement looking for their first job.

by nicknielsen

From the post to which I originally responded: [i]The ones that believed Gates and his ilk back then, had just finished their studies.[/i]

From the post to which I am now responding: [i]Those that believed Gates and his ilk in 2004 are graduating right now.[/i]

So which is it? You can't have it both ways; that nullifies the rest of your arguments.

by gruntingdwarf

"Aparently you missed the many posts where I mentioned that I have been laid off myself in the past."

I didn't miss that -- that's where I inserted "-once more-" in my post.
Now to the point.

I can't put in question the needs to cut expenses (spare employees in the first place) by most firms on the market. Your firm as well as its customers and suppliers are just a chain of victims in a mismanaged (or disorganized) system.

But the biggest ones, that's entirely another beast. Those corporations comprise such a huge amount of resources that they DO have a social responsibility -- either they acknowledge it or not in their foundation charts, mission statements, vision enunciates and all that.

If they're unable to prevent such huge cracks, they just don't serve their purpose well. And if you tell me their only purpose is to warrant their shareholders a profit, well, then the whole economical system is wrongly based.

This is where the whole crisis comes down to -- the need to reassess the necessary balance between capitalism and socialism, the necessary private incentives (profit) to keep growth going on, and the necessary public surveillance and validation to keep the overgreedy morons away from the major economic decision making.

The system as it is, has revealed itself as a failure. It failed on the public part (or the virtual non-existence of it), allowing private interests to take over without any control.

What I was saying to you is, the economic production is not all about profit. Production is all about satisfying people's needs. Profit is just a necessary term in the process. If the production system can't guarantee people's needs satisfaction, then it needs to be reformulated. It happened in the USSR (communism) in the past, and is happening in the Western world (capitalism) right now.

by santeewelding

You argue, Dwarf, in regions of large and vital social concern. You argue in a way to attract surveillance yourself.

Yours was a preamble. Four uses of "necessary" and two of "purpose" betray an unspoken societal sufficiency. Which would be what?

by gruntingdwarf

> You argue, Dwarf, in regions of large and vital social concern.

Agreed. Such is the scope underlying the subject of this thread I think.

And this is the only part of your post I quite understood. I found the rest a bit too cryptic. Care to clarify the parts that remain obscure to me?

> attract surveillance yourself

> societal sufficiency

> Which would be what?

Thank you.

This discussion is closed to new replies.