Discussion Locked

Migrating from Novell NDS to MS AD

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Hello everyone! I'm moving from an NDS environment to Active Directory. The problem I have seen so far is that I have many users with the same login name but located different containers under NDS, AD won't let me create such users as it tells me they already exist. For example, the NDS logins could be: john.humanresources.mycompany, john.finance.mycompany, john.it.mycompany, and each john just logins under novell. Active directory barks right away, even if I put each john in different OUs. Anysolutions (other than changing their login names?). Thanks!

4 replies

by pxttocyob

Look like AD is not as flexible as NDS. What make you want to switch from something which work ok?

by solis

Novell recommends that every distinguished name in the tree is unique, you defied this best practice and now AD is going to make you pay the Piper...

Anyways, my experience with AD suggests that even though it is a hierarchical database similar to NDS, the global catalog is a flat "index" within which no specific context is defined, thus you must have unique login names for each user in the forest - basically a glorified NT4 domain model with more object properties I'm afraid.

AD will getbetter with time, but right now I looks like you are forced to rename every account holder's login ID. Gotta stick with best practice always, you never know what new software is going to force you to bow to it.

Best of Luck!

by jdiaz

we will end up paying the price, after all..I guess I will learn a lot out of all this!

This discussion is closed to new replies.