Look, the reason I wrote it, and why it has relevance is this.
Every religion or creed gives rise to a radical element.
In my opinion, that element uses their religion or creed to justify their actions, most importantly when their own self-interest is threatened.
Here's my opinion: It's not necessarily the actual religion or creed itself that says this, nor is it necessarily the belief of the great majority of followers.
Here's my next opinion: In the mind of the radical, they are perfectly justified and depending upon the situation or religion they think that they are also promised the path of eternal glory by doing so.
And here's another opinion: from the outside, we perceive their actions as either freedom fighter or terrorist. Their actions may or may not actually be significantly different whatsoever (they all usually involve death to some extent), and their goal is almost uniformly to return to a status of their own self-interest.
To use your turn of phrase (and one I'd use myself): "Naturally everyone would and should defend their own property".
I think a small and logical expansion of the word "property" to include all aspects of self-interest is a reasonable extrapolation, for the purposes of this chat. But that's just me.
(An example? Your example on the Shaolin temple was an excellent case of where most reasonable people would probably feel that the actions of the freedom fighters were justified. Is it too much of a stretch to see Al Qaeda's position of the removal of the US armed forces base from Saudi Arabia as a more modern parallel to a similar situation?).
I was very worried when you started this thread that it would be another "radical muslims - they're animals / savages" story.
But now I think maybe we are very close in thought: Until we actually understand what aspect of the self-interest of the other party is (or is perceived to be) under threat, we have no chance whatsoever of resolving the situation and getting a semblance of peace.
I think that a very safe generalisation is that the great majority of "moderates" (which I take to including boring old farts like myself) want to reduce war, reduce the threat of terrorism and violence, and live a reasonably normal life to the extent that their surroundings let them.
I am sure this is as true for the muslim population of the middle east, as it is for the jewish population of Israel, as it is for the christian population of Lebanon, as it is for the catholic population of Ireland.
I think the first steps are to a) stop spreading the b*llshit that the entire world threat is based upon Islam, because clearly other religions and creeds are also taking part (the sole purpose of such cr*p is to incite hatred and continue the bloodshed, not to solve any situation); and b) stop giving the radical elements easy fuel for their fire, and thus increasing their sympathy/support from their moderate base.
(And I am fairly certain that calling our current terrorist crisis the fault of Islamic belief (or like pointing out the bad lines of the Koran) will, over time, piss more moderates off and cause more problems than they purport to solve).
Once the larger elements of their anger are taken away, the radical's support from the moderates also reduces and thus the overall threat decreases. (Not down to zero, but decreased).
Evidence of this? The IRA, having been now in a position for some time where dialogue can actually replace guns, has lost much of its traditional financial support. Where did that come from? Oh, the USA. But I guess that is the 'freedom fighter v. terrorist' thing again. Remember, it's only 12 years ago that they rocket-attacked Heathrow and Downing Street, just to flex their muscle.
If, in 12 years, we could get to a realistic position where the current threat of terrorism and violence has been reduced in anywhere near a proportional manner, I'd say that would be a 'result'.
{Oh and Onbliss - don't get me wrong - I wasn't pointing out flaws in Hinduism at all. Just saying that it has it's share of radicals that use it in the name of killing. References - go to google, type in "Hindu Caste Death". But you can also type in "Australian Aboriginal Death" or "Maori British Treaty Death" or variants thereof. Every society had and often still has it's ugly people using good things to justify bad things}.