Discussion Locked

My experience with no shouting

0 helpful
279 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have several non-nerdy friends and acquaintences who have called me with serious system problems (spyware, viruses, worms, etc. all via unsecured broadband). After I undo the damage (sometimes rebuilding from scratch in serious cases), I leave them with five things: ZoneAlarm, or preferably, a broadband router/firewall; Spybot, set to automatically update and scan nightly; AVG from Grisoft, also set to update and scan nightly; Windows Updates set to do its thing automatically, and Firefox. User is advised to stop using IE. I have yet to have anyone call me with further issues after months. Case closed, as far as I'm concerned.

279 replies

by jdmercha

You might want to leave them with one more thing - Education on how the system got messed up n the first place.

by joshy

I would add OpenOffice.org and Mozilla ThunderBird to the list. Email is a key concern for me. Had to give free training on these initially. But I do that for my own good, you see!

by moira

I wouldn't waste time trying to get people to use OpenOffice instead of MSOffice. Outlook 2003 should be set to read all mail in plain text (far nicer anyway).

I do everything originally suggested and more and implement all that for everyone who uses my home network. I don't place any "restrictions" on use the way my workplace does, and there are never any real problems, which proves how much pleasanter and more effective this approach is to the draconian (and counter productive) "no internet use" policy so widely adopted now.

by rocket_scientist

On Thunderbird...if they use outlook express, then yes, I'd offer that to them. Have had great success with migrating private users from OE to Thunderbird. However, some people are really picky about their email clients, though and if they're attached to OE, then swapping clients on them won't make them very happy, no matter how well it works.

On OpenOffice. I've used it, I like it, hey, it's free too. But there is a bit of a learning curve and for most people who are not computer savvy and dislike learning something if they don't have to...and those that already ask others for help with to fix their systems, I have found their reception to OpenOffice very cool. They are 9 times out of 10 already familiar with MS Office and if they've already paid the hundreds of dollars for it, they're well motivated to stick with that.

I have yet to have any corporate clients to desire to switch from MS Office to OpenOffice for this reason. From what I've seen, the only users of OpenOffice are people like myself, who work in the industry, and want to try out a non-MS product and those who simply can't afford the $400 full MS Office Suite. I'd be interested to hear if any one has successfully sold the idea of an MS Office to OpenOffice migration to any of their business users.

by mbaren

I'd like to know if anyone knows if Symantec's Norton Firewall(I have already)can work together with Spybot(considering getting)? Are they compatible or will they interfere with one another? Anyone who knows will do. Thanks!! Matt

by jasono9

Norton auto-protect products generally cause more problems than they fix...

Use Zonealarm...much better!

J

by tyson.technology

I haven't really been a big fan of Zone Alarm but I do use Sygate Personal Firewall Pro which I find it a lot better than Zone Alarm unless someone can change my mind :)

In addition to the SPFP, I use Sygate Home Network which I like it a lot better than any other SOHO softwares that I've tested for my SOHO network.

Ty

by lbiondi

Hi,

I am running XP using Norton Firewall & Antivirus with Spyware Doctor v3.1 and it is working just fine for me.

by house

The ones that the poster quoted in the original thread have free versions that are not limited to a trial period. It's a good move on his part. Regarding the other comment about Norton Firewall and Spybot, I haven't seen a problem either. Personally, I use an alternative firewall - not Norton or Zone Alarm.

by jeffro in berkshire

I have tried just about every anti spyware type program on the market and the best without a doubt has to be SPY Sweeper by Webroot. The only small reservation I have with regards this program is that it can be quite resource hungry - but hey what price do you put on a system that will remain spyware clean.

by Member 28866468

I use the Norton Internet Security system AND spybot on the same PC. No problems with these at all.

The NIS includes Norton's firewall, antivirus, antispam, etc. I still run SPYBOT every few days. The firewall seems to pick up on things I use and initially gives me a choice. Once I choose to allow it, it never discusses it. It can be manually revised in the firewall later, though.

Should be fine combination.....

by desmodeus

I've found the only way to reliably get rid of browser hijackers is with hijack this. However I wouldn't recommend the average user try it as it requires a reasonable knowledge of computers (particularly the registry).

by bywhatnow

We use HiJackThis extensibly in our shop, however it is NOT a program that I'm comfortable with leaving on a users machine. It is an excellent program but does require a little bit of nerd like qualities to use properly. Most of my customers would crash their machine with it.

by roger

Of late, in similar circumstances I have used Norton Internet Security to provide the firewall, anti-virus and email cleaner, together with IE. It can be a bit awkward to install, particularly if other anti-virus packages have not been removed properly but so far there have been no complaints.

Anyone aware of the pros and cons of the two approaches?

by jasono9

Some Norton/Symantec products are great (Ghost, Winfax, Systemworks) but not so for their security products. I have experienced serious amounts of headaches when anything is changed on the PC after norton av or firewall products are installed. eg: change email accounts, networking, new applications, etc. It can make for some hugely frustrating troubleshooting sessions!! I find the norton av and firewall products impact performance quite alot also.

But, that's just my experience! I take a similar approach to the guy that started this topic. Just changing to Mozilla cuts 80% of spy/ad/malware problems...and it runs quicker, cleans it's cache properly and has a better bookmark and download system! Kewl! It's worth having a good go at using it.

The norton a/v corporate edition is a bit better than the pc one but it's still clunky.

by shipper

I have 3 computers on a network and have widely used Norton Internet Security 2004 on other computers I perform as well. The only problem and frustration is setting it up to allow certain instances and not others. I find if you just install it and by-pass the parental controls your fine. Mine usually suits itself to the way the user operates the computer. It asks permissions and not off the wall questions. Most people understand "trojan" and anyone I work for I inform about new virus's and such mysterious things as "spyware" "adware" and what is start-up? I also explain MSconfig is a great utility if you know what your doing. I have also used "Hijack-this" I like it very much and there is a site out there that analyzes the txt file for you so you don't have to think so hard when worrying about the registry. I like ad-aware most. I think its pretty simple and takes care of most problems. I have noticed that running spybot finds others also. Webroot spysweeper also adds another chapter to the game because it finds others also. I personally like them all, but for the best bang for you buck I would get NIS 2004, ad-aware, the firefox browser and e-mail utility, and lastly install Netscape as a backup for some sites that don't support Firefox yet. This way the only purchase is $50 Security/antivirus instead of having a dealer or Best Buy tell you its going to cost you $100 to get your system looked at and we recommend you buy this, this , and that. Now you can buy a new dell...($499 special)

by al k

Your right. On both counts. The biggest frustrations come from Norton/Symantec products that have been removed/uninstalled that leave behind registry settings and files that screw with you adinfinitum.

by paul.osborne

One of the most useful steps for home computers which you don't mention, and in the vast majority of cases is not followed, is creating non admin users with full control over only 'my documents'and using these for day to day operations. With this, Norton and spydoctor i havnt had a single problem for 6 months, only logging in as admin to run updates or new software. Even with IE i dont get a single pop-up!

by jdmercha

My computer is connected to braodband, and is on 24x7. I log in with an admininstrator account, run auto updates and AVG. I haven't had a problem in over a year. Before SP2 I used the google toolbar to eliminate pop-ups.

by billbellsr

I have had no real problem with Spybot but discovered Ad-Aware from Lavasoft to be a bit more user friendly. You can also set it to automatically update when you boot up and connect to the Internet. On the new browser, Firefox, you might want to do some research before throwing in with the new guy on the block. It does appear to be more secure and seems to work alright but some recent posts on various sites are suggesting Firefox may also have some "issues" with security. Do a google search and check it out first. I have both but my comfort level is still higher with IE...but that may change as Firefox matures.
I agree with the other selections like AVG from Grisoft. The new version 7 works very well and also can be set up to auto update. And another thing, all of these mentioned are free.

by quiet_type

Firefox 1.0 may just have been released a few months ago, but the product has matured considerably through the many betas over the years, dating all the way back to Phoenix. Moreover, the security issues in Firefox have been fewer in number than those in IE, typically less severe than those in IE, and fixed more quickly than those in IE. In order to achieve the same "comfort level" with IE, one would have to lock it down, so that ActiveX and active scripting are disabled. And, by the way, when you Google "Firefox" you get 23,200,000 hits. Good luck wading through that mess!

by ddissent

"I have both but my comfort level is still higher with IE..."

WOW - Obviously you haven't dealt with too many systems that were completely TRASHED beacuse of IE have you my brother in geekdom - G'head man - take the plunge. Everyone I helped shed the horrendous cloak of IE bought me beer for Christmas. Yes ... I seems to have a few minor issues but nothing compared to IE.

P.S. Service Pack 2 sucks!

by darendjunker

Oh, certainly there are concerns with any program that accesses unknown computers on the internet. But if you check the comprehensive database at www.secunia.com you will find that compared to IE's 76 issues (20 still unpatched) and Opera's 34 (4 unpatched), firefox has the least buggy track record with 6 (5 unpatched). Of course, more will be found as time goes on, but the open source track record is pretty good on fixing things. Open source products that have been around as long as their commercial rivals, including various flavors of linux, usually have few if any unpatched flaws after just a few days or sometimes weeks, compared to weeks, months, or YEARS for commercial software.

Just what is it we are paying for again?

by johnofstony

I have a laptop which recently started misbehaving (it threw up error message boxes about TrueVector) when I tried to access the internet. ZoneAlarm was the culprit so I uninstalled it, thinking it had been corrupted, but when I tried to reinstall it, I got as far as clicking the "I agree" button and it aborted. I'm running Windows XP. Does anyone have any recommendations for alternative software firewalls which allow the use of VPNs (unlike Microsoft's offering which blocks use of VPNs!!!).

by kiwirick

We use the microsoft firewall and have no issues using VPN. All my XP SP2 users connect via VPN.

Zone Alarm is good, but I found users would just click randomly to Allow / Don't Allow when prompted as they had no idea what the questions mean.

by edtoff

I've found that when you uninstall zone alarm, it leaves some files and sometimes the truvector portion installed on the machine. I believe they have instructions on their website for curing this. Then after that try the reinstall.
I personally use a product called Panda Antivirus Platinum 7 which has a firewall built right in
and I have no problems whatsoever. I use Adaware SE pro for the spy and malware.

by kiwirick

Pre XP SP2 - regular spyware hits on my remote users (interstate) laptops. Post XP SP2 with firewall enabled - only one user has been hit since (because he neglected to install SP2).
Call me crazy, but MS seemed to have alleviated my problems...for now. We run weekly spybot scans and nothing has surfaced. Ran MS's beta and that also turns up nothing.

by paul.smith

Instead of AVG, I use Avast! from Alwil software. It's free for personal use. See www.avast.com

I prefer Avast's user interface to that of AVG's, and it does appear to have some features that AVG lacks (at least the last time I looked) such as a P2P AV service.

by harry_gibson

I have used the BlackIce Firewall for several years now and found it excellent (together with a broadband router/firewall (at home) and Symantec anti-virus software)

by house

I have a couple of friends who use Blackice almost exclusively. For a software firewall, I used to use Sygate Pro. I found it to be rich with features that would allow you to counter an attempted hack. I was always able to identify various bots, trojans, and internal threats, with the monitoring and trace utilities - threats that are not necessarily identitfied by any security company.

by paulvn

I use Outpost 2.5 Pro as it performs faster than ZoneAlarm and is easier to support neophyte end users. Mike Lin's Startup Monitor, http://www.mlin.net/StartupMonitor.shtml which alerts user every time something attempts to register an automatic startup, Spybot using the innoculate feature-no auto scan, avast! from Alwil automatically checks for updates several times per day, set On Access Control to High-no autoscan, Windows Update set to notify only so user will gradually get an education by reading the update descriptions, and Opera (currently 8.0 beta 1). Opera is easier to use, faster, easier to set up, and has many features not found in Firefox, including an integrated email client. If email needs are high ore needing security beyond Opera, I use The Bat! currently beta 3.0.2.10.

Open Office is used for an Office Suite. If something mandates Microsoft there is much loud discussion on the vulnerabilities and responsibilities of using it. I use WordPerfect Office for long time users who have difficulty aclimating to the Open Office interface.

No customer has ever been infected using this combination and machine performance is minimally impacted! If up-front protection is in place the autoscans are needless overkill that just wear out the hard drive(s).

by mpalmiro

I allways disable some windows services, like:
server
messenger
DDE
Remote registry
Upnp

by hereinoz

I totally agree with your list, and I would add another - Spywareblaster from Javacool software. Set it up with automatic updates - cost a few $$$ per year - and you will go a long way to keeping spyware and tracking cookies off the machine totally.

Alan

by jfreedle2

If somebody put Firefox on my computer, not only would I remove the garbage off the computer, but they would no longer be my friend, and I would seriously consider suing them for putting that garbage on that computer. As a matter of fact I ran into a computer not to long ago that had the software installed, and it was so messed up, that a clean installation of Windows xp was recommended. The computer had a installation of Windows 2000 on it, but they did not have installation media for that, so I did not perform the installation myself. I have pretty much decided that the only browser that I will be using will be Internet Explorer and if they mandate using Firefox at work, then I will continue to use Internet Explorer anyway and ensure that the software would be removed.

by tsherr

I think you might want to broaden your testing/knowledge before someone at your workplace finds out and downsizes you. A single computer with a problem that has Firefox installed proves nothing. There are hundreds of other things that could have caused Windows problems that were unrelated to Firefox (the fact that they were running a pirated version of Windows would be the first thing I would look at.)
I'm typing this in Firefox, and have been using it for months, with no problems, except for the occasionaly IE-only website.
And "deciding" that a specific program will be the only one of its type you will use is foolish. If you are in the IT field, you should be trying out new options constantly. If you stand still, you're going to be run over and left behind.

T

by blueknight

I've been using Firefox myself for many months including the version prior to 1.0 and have had no problems whatsoever. Methinks bigjim needs to hone his problem diagnosis and troubleshooting skills.

I've been in the IT field for 39 years (and counting) and I'm always learning, always trying new stuff and am never caught standing still... or coming to half-baked conclusions based on momentary observations and incomplete information.

Had bigjim spent a little time investigating the problems on the machine that just happened to have Firefox on it, I'm certain he'd have found something much different than the conclusion he obviously jumped to.

It's better to be the windshield than the bug

-JW

by dchamp

I find it very interesting there's no lucid reason NOT to use Firefox. I've been using it on my 2 work PC's, and 5 home PC's since th V1 beta, and it's far superior to IE in so many ways.
Maybe you should take a good look at it again, with no preconceptions.
Also, I highly doubt a PC was totally messed up by a browser of any kind.
DC

by jtnieves

I don't mean to disparage another poster on this board, but such vehemence for one product (IE) over another with very little supporting evidence always makes me wonder what the poster's motive is? Perhaps he feels he needs to protect a sizeable $$ investment in MS? Or, maybe he simply reveres MS in the same way some do the Bible? Or he's a junior public relations person in MS's schill factory hired to raise FUD about new (and better) products?

Having worked in PR myself at one point, I lean towards the last reason. Lots of companies do that to "beat down" the competition.

by rrosca

but it's name won't be Firefox, it will be IE. :)

Having said all that, I'll return to the matter at hand - the tools are all good for now but Firefox will not remain foolproof for long. People will soon be developing for it and nothing is 100% secure.

I also agree that hijackthis is the finest garbage removing software but it's not for "non-geeks".

by it makes sense

I too found it odd that no reason was given. I've using Firefox (and it's predecessors) for a long time on three different machines, and it has become my default browser. The only problems I've had are those Web sites coded specifically for IE (aarrghh!!), in which case I fire up IE and deal with it (grudgingly).

by acousticnut

Utilizing your logic, I've never worked on a system using Firefox that has Operating System problems. 100% of the systems I've worked on with Operating System problems have used Internet Explorer, therefore Internet Explorer must be the problem. I'll be sure to never use Internet Explorer again!

I too use Firefox on my work PC and all home PCs without problems. Be sure to broaden your scope prior to making quick assumptions.

by rawk

This is irony, right? An apparent pirate copy of win2k and you blame the BROWSER?

post your cv here so I don't accidentally hire such a low-brow.

"....would no longer be my friend...." Ha!

by ddissent

If that system was THAT messed up then I HIGHLY doubt Firefox was the culprit - Either that or you have no clue as to what your doing - Only you can know that.

Man - ending friendships - law suits - I can see the headlins now

"Man kills friend over browser rage incident"

by sadler

You should give it a try instead of basing your opinion on one system. Firefox blows IE away not only is it more secure it is by far faster at bringing up webpages. As for your friend it was probably the bootleg 2000 and other stolen software that hosed the system. Possibly not running the microsoft security updates. I seriously doubt the problem came from Firefox.

by americium

I agree that in this instance, Win2K was probably the problem - not Firefox.

However, is Firefox really that much more secure? There is a vulnerability listed at:

http://www.mozilla.org/press/mozilla-2004-10-01-02.html

There are some statistics at the bottom of the page supporting Firefox being more secure. If Firefox was as ubiquitous as IE and we extrapolate those numbers to the number of IE users, I would expect the number of security holes discovered to be larger as well. It appears to me that hackers would find more holes in Firefox if more people were using it.

I have used firefox and like it; but found enough pages that don't load properly to preclude my use of it regularly. It's a hassle to break out IE when a page doesn't look right instead of just using it instead of Firefox.

I believe that the best security solution is not creating more secure browsing software. There two things that will make the computer use more secure. 1. Better educated users (good luck!). 2. Legislation that allows prosecution of malicious, predatory installation of software that the user doesn't want.

My 2 cents. . .

by jdclyde

And one day you will grow up and learn about computers.

You walk up to a computer that you admit wasn't setup correctly in the first place and then blame it on FireFox?

Either you have bu-ko MS stock or very new to the whole desktop support.

Open your eyes and judge for yourself. Load FireFox on a stable system and you will come back and laugh at your own posting within a week.

by bwallan

Firefox was best thing we ever did to get rid of IE induced problems on our PC's. Great product.

Since we stopped using IE we've had ZERO (0) problems with spyware, viruses, etc.

Firefox works!

by ken cooper

I wouldn't disagree with the proposal, but I use Opera rather than firefox. I'm not sure if Firefox has the same 'problem', but some web sites have been designed lazily and have unoptimised HTML. They are useable with IE6, but not with Opera, so the configuration may not be suitable for all users. One some UK sites, it is not possible to get into the site without IE6 or Navigator as the site identifies the browser and refuses to load beyond the front page without one that they know the site works with.

by house

Hate it. I installed Opera for about 2 days, and hated it. I don't like Netscape either. Both browsers have a default installation that is so cluttered... I could never get past that initial impression.

I used Netscape a little bit back in the day, but not now. Based on the browser wars in fourth quarter 2004, with the release of the full MS port of FF, I decided to try Netscape again. I was not impressed, and I couldn't sit around long enough to give it a fair trial.

I installed Opera on Redhat 8 a long time ago... no thanks... that's when I ran into Firefox for the first time... while looking for an alternative browser for my Linux box.

by g...

I see lots of critics to both here and I've tested both and none are perfect. But i've noticed 2 things:
- firefox is at first a bit more secure but i think it's due to the fact that it's quite new and not so many has tried to hack through it as IE.
- second: end user like better IE (surely because they have seen it before) but it's true there are holes.
For my part i found avant browser alright for a bit extra properties to IE and can also recommand opera as an alternative.

by lrice

I have found your list is my experience. I have little repeat of problem reports after cleanup, when I leave the end user with exactly your list.

by cozy

I have installed the items described many times on PC's except firefox. Nothing against the other browsers but end users are used to IE and provided you have all the security items in place you should not have any real problems. Education of users and creating non admin users in XP is a good idea also.

Cozy

by bbbaldie

I was surprised and flattered that Tech Republic chose to highlight my post.

A few comments: Opera is a killer browser, but in many ways the feel is unlike IE. Users would face a steeper learning curve and may find themselves going back to IE again. Firefox is similar enough in feel that users seem to slip right into using it.

Turning off extra services is a great idea. I'll add that to my list.

Removing admin privileges is also a great idea, but in most cases I'm dealing with some seriously challenged non-techies who wouldn't know how to deal with switching to administrator to install apps. Someday I'll get them running Linux and show them how easy it is to jump to su and back ;-).

As far as education goes, I provide that also, just failed to mention it. In fact users are warned that if they slip back into their unsecure habits, I'll be back to bore them to death with even more details!

Thanks to all for your comments.

by pcw

In addition to your list of tools I like to run the freeware app called Windows Startup Inspector. It collects all the processes that fire up when the system starts in a list. Then, through a webb link your list is updated with the definitions of each process, and they are ranked such as "required" "Remove" etc. You can then turn off the proesses you chose not to run at the next boot.

This is most benificial with a system that has been so hammered you can't run hardly anything.

by pcw

With most of my residential customers the really serious problem they encounter is their children.

Not only are they incubaters that collect and bring home medical viruses from school, they attract malware like magnets atract iron fileings when they cruise the webb. I highly recommend a seperate parent system that is password protected.

Then I train them all on what they do to attract the bad stuff.

by slade

I pretty much use all of them and in addition to Firefox, I use Avant browser with a built-in pop-up blocker, Ad blocker and tab interface like Firefox. I use Avant browser alongside Firefox because there are just some sites that Firefox is not able to load properly. I also use AVG, Ad-aware in addition to Spybot. Lastly, I put the address of many ad sites to 127.0.0.1 in the hosts file.

by husp1

depending on the type of connection, I add the following:
ad-aware
spybot
sygate firewall
winpatrol for dialup
zonealarm for broadband
spywareblaster
firefox
spysweeper by webroot (trialware for 30 days)
smartfix by einfodaily (a small outpost firewall with additional features)
AVG (the latest version is very user friendly)
And if the person is using ME I also install something called unplugandpray available on major geeks.
have never experianced any conflict with these in any system and usaly find several viri when norton is installed. all in all this seems to keep most of my people happy and I tend to get callbacks now for user errors only. (I deleated my modem and can't get my homepage was the latest one lol.)

by mcys03100

Ihave read with great interest the comments made about this post,and I do much the same thing in setting up a computr for friends etc. But the main thing is to educate them as to the importance of keeping everything up to date,anti-vitus,adaware.spywareblaster, windows etc.
in a recent survey over 85% of home and IT computers
were infected in some way.
The mentality of people is this,"its free" so I will download it the result in a lot of cases is spyware and trojans installed by the usres themselves. The same go's for email attachments,
Poeple are curius by nature (the saying curiosity killed the cat comes to mind)but in this case it's curiosity screwed up the computer.(must be Fiefox!)not me!.On to Firefox,is it 100% secure no , no software is, but for one thing it is not intrigrated into Windows the same go's for Thunderbired
The net result for me is no problems, except what users cause themselves.education is a great thing.

by jglenncrp

I would be hesiant to automatically implement MS updates/patches; sometimes they are as bad as the problems they are designed to fix.

Firefox also has its problems and as it gains desktops, becomes more of a hacker target. You need to spend time setting up Firefox to do things IE does out of the box; your client may/may not be able to tell you everything he/she needs (re plug-ins).

Grisoft's FREE! AVG is fantastic. I use the free Ad-Aware SE app for spyware. Firewalls are a must.

Your clients would be well advised to purge all cookies at end of day; I purge cookies, history, and auto-saved (Internet) files.

----
John Glenn, MBCI
Certified Business Continuity Planner
http://johnglenncrp.0catch.com/
Business Continuity Planning Is Business Survival Planning

by Member 28657969

I didn't see this one on the list but I have used Lavasoft's Ad-Aware an it worked well.
The price was right, they have a free personal edition.
Use the local security policy and lock down there services and permission. This will help getting this junk in the first place.

by tetonbob

I also use AdawareSE alongside Spybot S&D. They work well together, one will find what the other may miss.

SpywareBlaster and SpywareGuard I use along with IE Spyad to help keep the junk out.

All are free!

by tonythetiger

I wouldn't call it draconian. You're at work to, well, work. At work, you'll probably never get spyware or viruses on your computer unless you're doing something you're not supposed to (unless you're a web site tester).

by moira

I understand where you're coming from, but sometimes I wonder why our firm bothered get internet access, because no-one's allowed to use it.

I realise you're at work to work, but there are times when using the internet to look up information would greatly help customers and we can't, because the fear of spyware and vulnerabilities with IE has led to a blanket "No Internet Use" policy.

I quite agree that a lot of problems could be solved with the use of OpenOffice and Thunderbird, however in a working environment which measures a person's computer literacy by their expertise in M$ products, it's never going to be a reality.

And frankly, MSOffice is not the source of most of the problems - macros can be disabled, so can html mail. It's Internet Explorer, which gives management a good "reason" to ban internet use so that employees don't waste time surfing the net.

by jdclyde

My boss is a real straight arrow and only goes to legit sites but still gets the highjacks and all.

I have to go in every few weeks and clean it up. NEVER have found anything to even HINT he was somewhere non-business related.

With web sites getting hacked and the warez loaded on them, no where is safe if your using IE.

by jcptech

I agree that without some explanation of how to avoid most spyware/adware the problem will quickly resurface. Educating the client is the most effective way to assure that I don't have to return a month or two later to perform the same tasks. I also agree that Firefox is a good alternative, but IE should not be uninstalled. The use of a simple NAT device like the broadband firewall/router is also a good choice. I do no agree with the use of ZoneAlarm or other 3rd party firewalls, or free anti-virus software like AVG. I prefer F-Secure Anti-virus. AVG while it may be the best free tool it doesn't have the ability to catch the newest threats before they reek havoc or clean up everything that?s there before it is installed. I've been using Spybot and Adaware together to clean computers of unwanted nonsense for a while but have recently changed my opinion with the dawn of Microsoft?s new antispyware software. It works better then both together and can be set to work proactively. One tip would be to run antispyware software with each user account on the computer. I don't like things popping up constantly getting in the way asking users questions they have no idea how to answer so any active software other then antivirus software set to delete malicious code is deactivated until needed unless I feel the user has some grasp of how to answer the questions presented to them. I know of many instances where others have come before me and done as ron_enderland@mckee.com has and it isn?t working and can hinder the use of the computer and confuse the user.
In a nutshell less is better. Pay for Anti-virus software. Disable active 3rd party firewall software and other active scans that won?t be utilized. And, Educate!!!

by robwaybro

You are correct that Grisoft's free version does have some limitation, it is the (IMHO) the best free product out. They also have a very inexpensive version for purchase for the SOHO and it will auto-update, and they produce updates almost daily and sometimes more then once a day, and they will send you and email when the have a virus signature update available. The updates are VERY quick and small, they try to design them for dial-up customers.

It is a very robust and mature program.

There are personal preferences with all software.

The one common thread to all this is also the most difficult, Educate the Users.

by bbbaldie

I have cleansed the system first. That's the big part that takes all of the time. I then take the five steps (actually six, I'll be killing off unnecessary services too). The steps I mention call for minimal user intervention. And as I reiterated, the user gets an education, too. I fail to see how these steps "can hinder the use of the computer and confuse the user."

Great comments from everyone, evemn the ones I disagree with! Even enjoy the Firefox troll . . .

by robwaybro

Have you used the lastest versions of these?

Both are FREE, Thunderbird absolutely rocks, is sooo easy to use, very user friendly, etc, etc. I highly recommend it to customers, friends, everyone.

Openoffice.org will seamlessly import/save as M$ Office formats, is simple to use, although there is a small learning curve but manly learning where the tools/functions/features are located (and generally in a more logical place (but not always)).

No VBscript problems, no Office macro problems, improved security/reliability and more adhearance to established, world wide standards.

In case you cannot tell, I am firmly behind Open Source for both personal and professional use. I will save my company thousands when I quit maintaining subscriptions to M$ Office (and in my office we use Groupwise, it is also rock solid)

by husp1

have you ever tried foxmail? I have used it for months and found that it to is a very nice program!

by mfblankenstein

I have been using OpenOffice for some time now on Linux and Windows. It is pretty good at importing and exporting MS Word docs that are simple. I have had problems with more complex MS Word docs that use fields with lookups and other advanced formatting options.

Thunderbird and Firefox are both good. The only problem with Thunderbird for Outlook or Outlook Express users is with hotmail. Thunderbird will not connect with the Hotmail site to act like a POP3 mail program like OL and OLE will.

The next release of OpenOffice, by the way, will include a relational database similar to MS Access. The release is expected around March. This will provide most of the functionality of MS Office Pro.

by bywhatnow

I really like ZoneAlarm, the reason is that it is VERY user friendly.I own a small computer repair store and I have many "non-geek" customers. Zonealarm works for them without them having to take a class on "how to." I know that there are several very good (maybe even better) products out there. But, Zonealarm with SpyBot S&D, AdawareSE personal edition, and a good (not Norton's) antivirus that updates itself in the background have kept my customers safe and happy. However, just a note, sometimes NOTHING will protect them from themselves. LOL

by mek804

Funny, I just got a demo of DeepFreeze and am about to do the
same thing. Even with limited user rights, my PC users have
somehow found new and exciting ways to mess up their
machines. Guess what? That's not going to be happening any
more. Deep Freeze, I hope, is going to save me a whooooollle
lotta trouble : )

by whodo

Here we use Deep Freeze on approx. 110 desktops and 60 laptops. Some are "older" machines still using 98 or 98SE. These machines are in several different labs that we manage, so no one user has the same machine each time. Deep Freeze has saved us countless times from problems by just rebooting the machine after a user has called and "messed up" their computer. The main complaint we have is the user cannot save to the hard drive. All but a few of these boxes have cd burners installed or have USB ports on the front for pen drives for saving large files and all have 3 1/2 drives for saving small files. We do run the updates once a quarter, just to keep the software current. All of our equipment is running MS software, haven't been able to convince our IS dept head to try anything new.
To change gears for a minute - FireFox has worked exceptionally well for me on my home network. I have four computers that use different OS's - Linux, 98SE, Win2k Pro, and XP Pro. I switched all of the to FireFox after I tried it out on my 98SE machine and saw how stable it worked there (had many, many problems with IE). The Win2k and XP boxes have also straightened up and now I have no problems.

just my 2 cents worth.

WhoDo

by darendjunker

In many environments, the short term training costs and support headaches are a significant barrier to adopting OpenOffice, even though the long term payoff is huge in eliminated upgrade costs. OpenOffice is also somewhat more difficult for most users for database integration such as mail merge.

I agree WHOLEHEARTEDLY on using Thunderbird, though. I have been much happier with it than Outlook Express.

Otherwise Firewall, Antivirus, anti-spyware, and switching to Firefox is a good combo. I would go with double-firewalling, i.e. protect the network from DoS and scanning with a hardware firewall, and protect each PC with software based firewall (I prefer Sygate).

For the really secure environments, a product like ProcessGuard is an excellent addition.

by sadler

I have used Ad-aware and Spybot. I recently downloaded the Bata Microsoft Antispyware program and have found it to be the better of the three. So good in fact that I would consider purchasing it if it comes to that. Hopefully they will keep it free (not likely). Give it a try.

by gratefulblue

I have found that Trend micro's housecall anti virus check is a quick way to clear a broadband connected machine before beginning to install all of these apps. It does not catch everything, but gets rid of all of the basic garbage so that I can begin as close to clean as possible.

by it makes sense

Thunderbird is a much better, more secure mail client than Outlook, and AdAware complements Spybot, each of them occasionally finding things the other misses.

by daydo

On the Spyware side, spybot itself is not good enough, try adding ad-aware your anti-spyware goodie bag. other wise that seems like a good enough list.

Another good peice of advise if your client have XP make sure sp2 is installed. might have to tweak it a little and as someone else said educate them would as well.

by bnordberg

I've found that firefox just isn't very good at running cold fusion or hard core asp apps. That and it has some nasty security holes as well. So why not just secure ie - that way you get all IE's functionality, and as long as you teach the user not to hit yes install on every pop up, they will be good.

by jdclyde

"why not secure IE" he says. That is the funniest thing I have read since the last friday yuk yuk was posted.

How many YEARS has MS been TRYING to secure IE?
How many times have they said they secured it, just to have a MAJOR exploit get exposed within a month?

Good thing SP2 came along to secure our systems. OOPS! Forgot, that had a bunch of exploits within a week, didn't it?

To "secure" IE you need to have all the patches updated daily, turn off active X, JAVA, and all scripting and then run system as a USER with NO system rights at all.

by kontrolsphreak

I think Ron is bang-on with his recomendations.
I do the same thing, and suggest the same products for those people who didn't understand that surfing naked is a bad idea. Corporate IT might disagree, but for the average user, that combination of products will save them much grief. The setting up of automatically updating is important too. The less user intervention required the more likely things will go well.
I might add Adaware to the list since it finds some stuff that Spybot misses.

by bkrateku

I have loved Firefox ever since I started using it full time about a year ago, but I had used some betas previous to that. My new boss came in and showed me Slim Browser, which is presented almost like it is a new browser, but appears to really be an add-on for IE. It does clear up many of the issues with IE from what I've found and also adds some functionality to IE that I think should have been there for ages already. The only glitch I've found with Firefox, which may have been cured in the release of 1.0, was that when I clicked on links in my email in Outlook, and Firefox was set as my default browser, it would open the link, then ask me if I wanted to open the link, so if I clicked yes to that, it opened it again. A little strange and I didn't have time to get back to that to see if it is fixed or what was causing the issue. Slim Browser doesn't have this issue, but since some of the controls are different than Firefox, which I'm used to, it took me a while to get used to the difference. Case in point...Ctrl T opens a tab in Firefox, but in Slim Browser, it translates the current web page. Ctrl N opens a new window in Firefox, but in Slim Browser it opens a tab (although it calls it a new window). Minor, I know. Anyway, as far as my list of tools, I agree with most people in that I use Spybot and Ad-Aware along with some education and if the person is open to it (home user), I recommend using a different browser like Firefox. We've even considered changing over to Firefox at my place of work. I use Zone Alarm and have used other firewalls, but Zone Alarm is a little easier to use, although some may argue it is a little bloated. I have used other products for security and such, like many of the Norton line, but I've found that they tend to be bloated to some extent, especially SystemWorks. Ick. Slows down every PC I've seen it on quite a bit. I just switched off of Norton Anti-virus to eTrust to demo it, but I'd like to try AVG as well. As far as a proactive approach to sypware, adware, etc., one person recommended to me Pest Patrol. I haven't tried it yet. Anyone else know a good, proactive program for that? Thanks!

by jcptech

Believe it or not Microsoft's Beta version of antispyware software ROCKS!! It cleans more effectively then spybot and adaware combined and can be set to work proactively.

by ngl0578

the good thing about microsoft's antispyware is that they didn't develop it. they bought it.. so there's a chance that it will work like it is supposed to.

by darendjunker

ZoneAlarm is good (I like Sygate better)

'or preferably'? I would say 'and'

a broadband router/firewall - check www.secunia.com for open issues on the hardware you are considering, there are many good ones with no open bugs

Spybot (or Adaware, or SpyDoctor)

AVG is less troublesome than Norton (Avast has more features and just as easy as AVG, IMHO)

Windows Updates - absolutely! (or use linux)

Firefox - best option for most these days

I would affirm the updates all around, not just windows and spybot, but antivirus as well.

I would also adjust the settings on Outlook Express to eliminate JScript and preview, or better, go to using Thunderbird.

One other product worth considering is ProcessGuard from www.diamondcs.com.au - even if you get a trojan, it would have to ask permission to run.

One last addition - I have put Registry Mechanic (www.pctools.com) on one of the machines that used to give me a lot of trouble from multiple users. At the first sign of quirkiness, I run it and let it repair the gunked up entries in the registry. That PC now has a new record uptime.

by mmoran3180

Ditto, especially on AVG, for which I have become somewhat of an evangelist since giving up on Norton.

I'd add Spyware Blaster and Prevx (www.prevx.com). And yes, education is a must since your users will be dealing with multiple "should I let this happen" popups as each program learns its way around the system.

You're doing us all a service by turning your "non-nerdy" friends into responsible and educated Internet users.

by jdclyde

First, if / when there are more expoits found in FireFox it has been proven over and over again that OpenSource programs have a much faster turn around time from when an exploit is found to when a patch has been released.

MS has sat on more than one exploit for several months, this is the company that will keep you safe?

As for sites that "don't load properly", does it load if you use ANY other browser? Can you blame the browser because someone used the frontpage wizards to throw together a non-compliant web page?

Any business that writes a page that doesn't load in anything from Opra to AOL just doesn't know how to create a web page.

If I have something to sell, do I want only IE users to be able to buy my product? Heck no! I want all the AOL users with more money than brains to come to my site and buy everything up.

There are things known as industry standards. MicroSoft has never been known for following them.

by house

If Firefox craps out, remove and reinstall. If IE craps out... good luck. I can get it up and running again, but not everyone has that sort of experience with the MS beast.

by pintob

I think switching to Firefox is good short term but I also believe when Firefox gains a big enough share of the market, we will all see an increase in attacks through their service as well. IE might not be perfect, and in need of some serious updates, but it's always the biggest bully who is targeted by the rest of us. In this case, targeted by hackers and virus writers.

by house

Firefox on my profile. My girlfriend on the other hand, still uses IE, so I have left it as the default browser. I've noticed first hand, that when I run a ***ware scan, anything that shows up, shows up in her profile. Of course, I do get a few bugs here and there, but it is a ratio of about 1:20.

Of Firefox will have it's vulnerabilities, but IE is a vulnerability beast that I only like to see in a controlled environment.

by smaug9

I agree: there are a few sites out there that are designed only with IE in mind. There is a firefox extension, "View in IE," That adds an item to the pages context menu that opens the page in IE.

Also, there's a "firefox extension" that adds "view page in firefox" to IE. Love it.

by pcw

There is a Firefox extension that gives you two right click context options:

1. View page in ie
2. View link in ie

These are very helpful when trying to read the occsional page with ie specific formatting