Discussion Locked

My god or GOD ?

0 helpful
312 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

An American newscast the other day was takling about how a student's father had complained about the Pledge of Allegiance should be dropped from the schools due to referencing GOD.

I'm not going to get into some political debate over American heritage but why DROP the Pledge instead of modifying it?

Scouts Canada, I don't know about other countries modified their Cub Promise from "I will do my duty to GOD and the Queen" to "I will do my duty to MY god and the Queen".

The student noted was born into an athiest family, whether or not it is his choice or his parents I dno't know but I think it is fair to say that in MOST cases religion or lack of is usally inherited from the parents.

Do you feel the pledge should be modified or simply dropped from the classrooms? Does it still serve a purpose in making Americans Patriotic towards their country or is it just something that was never considered?

Instead of dropping it completely and causing a Nationwide stir, don't you think that modifying it to say MY god instead of GOD would be more acceptable by those who still believe in the Pledge of Allegiance?

I know that I often refer to American politics but that is merely because we RARELY hear any Canadian politics on the news.

312 replies

by thechas

A number of years ago.
(shortly after prayer was banned in the public schools)

Red Skeleton did a presentation where he defined each and every word of the pledge of allegiance with it's patriotic significance.

He finished with the words "under God", and commented that it would be a shame if the Supreme Court declared the pledge a prayer.

The issue with the pledge and other "value" decisions is the growing schism between what is popular and what is constitutionally correct.

Many people in the US (mainly on the political right) feel that our laws should reflect the majority view on issues of morality and faith.

However, the courts are charged with following the limits of the laws and the constitution.

I find it interesting that many of the people bothered by the current courts strict adherence to the constitution, were bothered by prior courts broad interpretation and activism.

Chas

by oz_media

Damned if you do Damned if you don't.

Just think Chas, if I was a supporter of Bush, I'd be popular on TR, however I'd have nobody to talk to here. I couldn't even imaging going to a bar and spouting that I suported Bush. I'm a pretty big guy (6'1" 215lbs.) but I don't think I could beat off those masses. Don't tell Max, he thinks I'm a "little man"

Do yoo think it is time to reflect and possibly rewrite portions (I wouldn't know which) of the Constitution? Many people here compain about the Constitution either favoring or harming them. It's gotta be dusty by now, maybe it's time to scan it into a PC where it can be ammended easily!

OM

by thechas

There are 2 ways to change the US Constitution:

Amendments

Constitutional Convention

The idea of a Constitutional Convention scares me and most constitution scholars.

The framers of the constitution had altruistic motives.

Today, the special interests would make a mockery of the process.

Personally, I think we should leave the Constitution alone.

The basic precepts of the Constitution serves it's purpose well to this day.

Chas

by road-dog

in the 1950's, it does not date back the the founding fathers. It is not a Constitutional pledge.

I agree with the removal of the Under God (UG) from the pledge, as this IS specifically an endorsement of a particular type of religion with the exclusion of atheism, polytheism, and various other religions that are not based on a central higher power personified.

Many cite the opinions of the founding fathers as proof of a Christian basis for many important documents. After all, the Declaration of Independence acknowledges the creator and derives individual rights upon devine endowment.

The Constitution came later, and made specific references to the establishment of religion, prohibiting the federal government from creating a state religion. There are always issues where "establishing" is defined and redefined in the courts, recently with the removal of a christian monument from a courthouse.

The pledge amounts to an oath of loyalty which children cannot truly comprehend; and therefore amounts to indoctrination via repetition. I have broken this oath down with my children and explained what it means, line by line.

I explained that loyalty to the country is not the same as loyalty to the government. A healthy paranoia budding in my young ones. I tell tham all the time how this program is unconstitutional, how that function of government is valid, and don't expect to ever get a social security check, no matter how long you pay in...

by jennifer.gardner

"Under God" has NO place in the pledge (and it wasn't there to begin with). Belief in God has nothing to do with patriotism. Taking out that wording should not change the meaning for those who DO believe in God, but it would certainly make the pledge more inclusive for those who don't.

In response to the original question: I personally don't think that changing the phrase to "my god" would be any better. That's still making an assumption that the person speaking the pledge believes in A god.

To go a step further, I also believe that courts should stop making people swear "so help me God" before giving testimony.

by infiniteender00

This question as arose several times in everyone's lifetime, and I see the points that the pledge is an act of patriotism for out homeland, and not a declaration of out religious beliefs. Fact of the matter is that the term "under God" has never really been defined accurately. Most times we always came to the conclusion that the "my" was hidden. I guess one point of view that people has was no never specify a type of God. If you replace "my God" then sooner or later someone (more than likely me or someone reading this) will create a new religion with a God named "My" and have a new religion in which their God is worshipped every day. I think the Pledge is just find as it is and that people should just sign disclaimers at the begginning of every school year accepting the fact that by stating the pledge, they are giving respect to their home-country, the fore fathers that created it, and that the term under God does not bind anyone to any specific God.

Whatdayathink?
- Ender

P.S. Just kidding about that "My" God thing.

by oz_media

"In response to the original question: I personally don't think that changing the phrase to "my god" would be any better. That's still making an assumption that the person speaking the pledge believes in A god."

You have a point but referring to "my god" and not capitalizing the word GOD actually does not point to ANY religion whatsoever. A persons god (not GOD) can be his parents or any other belief that the person has faith in. Even an athiest has "a" god, not necessarily a CREATOR of the universe or man but a faith or belief in life.

by oz_media

Damn! I was on my way to selling flowers at the airport ! My GOD! That would be a funny sermon.
It would sound like the preacher was swearing all the time.

Preist: "We give thanks to thee mighty creator, MY GOD!"

Altar boy: "What? What is wrong"

Preist: "On this 16th day of Cotober 2003, MY GOD!"

Altar Boy: "Why, what's going to happen?"

LOL

by jennifer.gardner

The word itself has some serious connotations. Many people who do not believe in the Christian God are immediately turned off when they see that word. Who will be in charge of explaining to them that, by putting the word "my" in front of it, the intention has changed? Buddhists believe that all answers lie within - would they then be referring to themselves (one nation, under me)?

by oz_media

Personally, I have no beef either way (I'm not even American).
To agree with your point, I think that those that ARE Christian will notice the lowercase spelling and realize it doesn't refer to GOD or HE the almighty creator, however you have a good point, those that AREN'T religious will not really differentiate between 'god' and 'GOD'.

So you can either say F'em and let them deal with seemingly religious references or learn at home or drop it entirely.
Now even with my distaste for American politics and history, I would not like to see a single person cause the Pledge of Allegiance to be withdrawn from schools due to his distaste for religion.

I'm not a practicing Christian, although I was christened to the Church of England but I have absolutely no problem with people expressing their faith. I don't appreciate the knock on my door Sunday morning but that's a different problem altogether.

As for one person changing the Pledge simply due to a distaste in Christian religion, I say let him suffer or make him fight under BUSH.

by infiniteender00

Isn't the definition os satanist not necessarily the worship of satan, but the worship of yourself? Would that fall into the "one nation under me" category? Or would they just change it to "my nation"?

- Ender

by onbliss

..like this. Who ever wants to tell the Pledge with 'God' let them tell, anybody that does not want to tell...not tell the Pledge.

by oz_media

I think the problem described was that the father never wanted his son subjected to HEARING the use of GOD in the Pledge. (Better remove those eardrums, there are religious references in almost every aspect of our daily lives).

What now, "I bless America!" "Someone bless America"? "MY god bless America"?

by onbliss

He must be either lunatic or fanatic :-)

I am SO surprised about the father. Would;nt he want his son to know about the concept of God and decide for himself whether God exists or not and have belif accordingly. It is like keeping the frog in the well.

Come to think of it...the father is ridiculous :-)
If the son the right to not recite the pledge, he should be happy.

Maybe the father thinks God is evil for the children...like the majority thinks Porn is evil for the children.

by jennifer.gardner

I don't see this as a workable solution either. Where I was raised, kids were taught the pledge in kindergarten. I can't see explaining to a bunch of 5 year olds the distinction...

Not to mention how goofed up it would be while they are chanting it in class!

Better to just move the phrase completely. It wasn't there to begin with, and it doesn't need to be there now.

by bchesmer

Exactly! It came during the 50's McCarthyism scare, if you didn't believe in God, you had to be a commy....

by pcnetworktech

Well I am going to tick some people off.

This great country USA is blessed by our GOD. When things are going well, we don't want GOD. When we are in trouble like 911, we pleaded for GOD to help.
If we keep distancing GOD out of our life, GOD will turn away from USA and the evil will prevail.
Take heed,
God Bless our country America

by oz_media

I agree with what your saying but I think it crosses context more than once.

Your country is blessed by YOU and those who inhabit it. When things are going well, only people who closelty follow a given religion will still have a daily faith in their god. When things aer going poorly, EVERYONE needs some reach of faith.

NOW, who are they reaching to by praying to god?

YOUR Christian GOD, a Hindu God, their great grandfather who they have always seen as their mentor, protector and source of faith and reassurement?

I think in most cases the term god is used in a much broader sense than most religious followers like to see.

GOD

1)A being conceived as the perfect, omnipotent, omniscient originator and ruler of the universe, the principal object of faith and worship in monotheistic religions.

2)The force, effect, or a manifestation or aspect of this being.

3)A being of supernatural powers or attributes, believed in and worshiped by a people, especially a male deity thought to control some part of nature or reality.

4)An image of a supernatural being; an idol.

5)One that is worshiped, idealized, or followed

6)A very handsome man.

7)A powerful ruler or despot.

Praying to god can mean many different things to many different people.

Your faith causes you to pray to the Christian GOD in tmies of need. Others will place faith in their own example of god.

by pcnetworktech

That's True

You have a good point,however...there is only one GOD. The god of this world is the Lucifer the devil. Lucifer the devil has a bigining just like us, but he is very powerful,great musical talents. When he disobeyed GOD in the heaven, GOD sent him and his angels to this Earth. The earth is filled with evils spirits because of this, but not for long. GOD will bind lucifer and his angels to the bottom less pit of the earth(hell). GOD will create a new heaven and new Earth, here all those who belived in GOD and His son Jesus Christ will live forever and forever. There will be no evil, no tears, no pain. Life eternal with GOD and for those simply reject him,unfortunately will suffer forever and forever in hell with lucifer and his angels.

by bchesmer

Why recite it at all. Aren?t kids in school to learn? Time better spent reading about the constitution how/why it was written in the 1st place! Don't you think???

by fluxit

One who disbelieves or denies the existence of God or gods.

One thing most people neglect to think about is that Atheist really do have a God. They adamantly pursue a NULL, empty space, nothing. This is what they worship in their flesh. I wonder what will happen when they go before God and are asked, "By what name did you call me?" and they cannot speak.

I wonder how an Athiest explains the origins of the Universe. Quantum Physics has discovered that our Universe is bounded. Where did all this come from? Carl Sagan, an Athiest, thought he knew but his thinking has been disproved and he could never explain the origin of the Universe anyhow. He could only have a idea of what happen moments after it was created. He called it the Big Bang. Where did the stuff for the Big Bang come from?

by road-dog

Those choosing the theological route to dispute Sagan put the onus on him to explain the origin of the "stuff" that expanded in the big bang.

This leads to a comensurate scrutiny of the opposing view... How and where did God originate? The simple answer is that God is infinite, always existed, always will.

If one is prepared to explain that an infinite being exists, then how is it so unbelievable that matter existed before the big bang?

Personally, I find it more reasonable to believe that a huge pile of cosmic "stuff" was always here than that there is an infinite being pulling all the strings.

In order to explain the origin of the "stuff", the scientific explanation would be that "stuff happens".....

by oz_media

I agree completely, you took the words tight out of my mouth. Then you rearranged them and put them forth as a logical thought process, well done.

by fluxit

Your comment fails the laws of physics; 'Personally, I find it more reasonable to believe that a huge pile of cosmic "stuff" was always here than that there is an infinite being pulling all the strings' What law of physics in this universe has matter randomly appearing and why is this law not in effect today? It seems that it would be consistent through out the Universe and we would observe it here on Earth. Or is matter like interest and just accrues?

The truth of the matter is that God is outside the time domain so infinite is kind of a mute point. In the one of the M-Theory models space-time is only part of a larger system. One can move around in timeless dimensions and look across the spanse of time.

Physics stops at the boundaries of our Universe and our Universe has been determined to be bounded from the results of atom smashing experiments in quantum physics. In fact, Congress stopped funding atom smashing because it was determined that the origin of our Universe is from outside our Universe. What was determined was the non-locality phenomenon of matter and the smallest digital increment of time that bounds our Universe. In short, our entire universe can be reduced down to only information having the non-locality property. Hence, we live in a digital simulation.

It is not in our interest to ask the origins of God since God created us to serve him only. Our interest are to meet his expectations and all will be answered and provided. I believe this is called faith.

Coincidentally, Quantum Physics and the Judeo/Christian bible are mutally supportive of each other. This has been noted by many scholars and scientist. Just the other day an Astronomer on the Charlie Rose show was talking about some of these points.

by cactus pete

Along the line the dog said earlier, let's take your phrasing and see how it stands in the opposite:

[I wonder what will happen when they go before God and are asked, "By what name did you call me?" and they cannot speak.]

What would anyone say when they die if there is no G/god?

And to some of your other statements: If there are bounds to the universe, what's on the other side?

If one believes there is a God, why can't one believe this entity created the universe in the manner unfolding to the eyes of the scientists? Certainly, if God was speaking to someone who [eventually] wrote pieces of the bible, how would that person, in that time and with that science, understand the concepts of solar systems, rounds planets, the gravitational constant, atoms, etc? And how could that person relate it, even if he could understand it, to the rest of the world?

And just what would God do to someone if he or she was 'up there' not answering the question you posed?

by oz_media

"And just what would God do to someone if he or she was 'up there' not answering the question you posed?"

Nothing, apparently god forgives all anyhow. I'll save my hail Mary's until I get in front of the guy myself. I figure it is better to have something to say rather than just smile and await judgement.

by fluxit

YOU ARE ASKING FOR A BIBLE LESSON. I'll answer to the degree that this posting will permit.

IRT: [I wonder what will happen when they go before God and are asked, "By what name did you call me?" and they cannot speak.] We are subjects to God and he warns about the lack of humility. However, his response would be 'MAN' GEN 1:27

IRT: What would anyone say when they die if there is no G/god? WHAT A SHAME? But God is here and there is evidence that he exist. His creation and his word the Judeo Christian Bible.

IRT: If there are bounds to the universe, what's on the other side? HEAVEN - Theological Universe in which our universe (space-time) is inclusive not exclusive.

IRT: Just what would God do to someone if he or she was 'up there' not answering the question you posed? It is not my question. It is Christ that will ask of each human. Then Christ will testify on your behalf before the throne of God. The answer is Christ is my Lord and Savior. JOHN 11:25 Failure to accept this is answered very simply. REV 20:11.

I can go in far more detail on this. The Bottom line is I am extremely analytic having a engineering and IT background. I can hang with the Hawkings and Sagans of the world like no other. And I believe there is a creator. I can answer the question 'Christ is my Lord and Savior'

by road-dog

I mean really. Were they tossed about for us to find? Is this some kind of a cosmic goof?

by road-dog

Have lived and died without any knowledge of Jesus Christ. Are these people condemned simply for lack of information?

Isn't creation and the Koran proof of the existance of Allah?

Is an all-powerful god who is the architect of all creation really desire worship from finite beings such as ourselves? If so, isn't he not all that infinite, and maybe not so worthy of worship?

Assuming that God is timeless and limitless, why the big change of moods from the vengeful God of the old Testament to the benevolent and forgiving God of the new Testament? One would surmise that infinite beings develop stability over millennia.

Isn't it possible that around the year zero, those who use superstition to control others needed a new schtick? People were getting savvy and losing their fear of a vengeful god, and they decided that more carrot and less stick would keep people in line more effectively?

Does God really care if we eat meat on Friday?

Adolph Hitler. Saddam Hussein. Carrot Top. Is God's "SMITE" key broken on his computer?

by mrbill-

A couple years ago a friend of mine asked me "what if there is no God and you spent your life worshipping nothing? Won't you be unhappy about wasting it?" I answered, "If you are right and there is no God, then I spent my life being nice to others and helping them, not wasted. If I am right and there is a God then I will live with Him forever and you will not. What is the better choice live it up now for 50-70 years and suffer forever. Or live a Christian life, no quite as exciting, and live in Glory forever."
I found out recently he is now a Christian.

by onbliss

...you have a high opinion about yourselves.

>>I can go in far more detail on this. The Bottom line is I am extremely analytic having a engineering and IT background. I can hang with the Hawkings and Sagans of the world like no other. And I believe there is a creator. I can answer the question 'Christ is my Lord and Savior'

How can you say it is A Creator. It could be multitude of creatorS. godS and not God. You get the drift I guess.....Why just Christ...WHy not others.....

by fluxit

Ok many of you are posing fundamental questions about the Bible and science. All have answers in physics and in the Bible. Surprisingly the Bible and Quantum Physics are supportive of each other.

To the questions and comments regarding alternate universes and origin of matter. Most of the comments I have observed are not complete thoughts regardng the theories. There are M-theory models of 10 and 11 dimensional universes.

The 11 dimensional model is call the Brane World Model. When this model is conformally mapped into 3 space there are spheres and membranes or sheets that sort of flap like a flag in the wind. The spheres are multiple universes. Occasionally the membranes slap a sphere and that universe is completely reordered. It is call a mini-bang or big-slap. Scientist are studying this model closely to determine if it is possible to jump between universes and what happens when branes collide.

In the both models, 10 and 11 dimensional, there are phenomenon such as hyperspacing and dimensional projections that occur. One observed phenomenon in space-time (4 dimensional universe) that is currently unexplained is all particles are in instantaneous communication faster than the speed of light and this relates to gravity. Could this communication be hyperspacing? We don't know at this time.

Now for the Bible. Most of you who are posing these questions have not studied the Bible in detail at all. This is obvious by your remarks. If you desire an intellectual discussion at least have studied the various aspects of the topic in some detail before challenging it.

To the questions regarding the Koran. This is generational from the Judeo/Christian Bible and makes Jesus an insignificant prophet. About 630 AD Mohammad was commanded by the Arc Angel Gabriel to scribe. Mohammad fled in fear then wandered for 2 years before scribing the Koran. This is an inconsistency. Gabriel in the Judeo/Christian Bible was a messenger and never commanded. He always comforted people when he appeared. In the case of Daniel, Gabriel immobilized him before giving him the message since Daniel was scared. Why was Mohammad allowed to flee and it is not clear what Gabriel wanted him to scribe but 2 years later Mohammad figured it out.

Any Jewish person will tell you that the Judeo/Christian Bible can be summed up in two versus that occur in the Torah. Deuteronomy 6:5 and Leviticus 19:18. Contrast this with the Koran in which one pleads for mercy from his God and enemies are infidels that should be destroyed. Two very different messages. Additonally, Allah never occurs in the Judeo Christian Bible from which Islam is built. Why did he change from God to Allah?

'Have lived and died without any knowledge of Jesus Christ. Are these people condemned simply for lack of information?' Some people lived under different guidance - the Old Testament. During this time there was the Taberancle and the requirement for a burnt offering of usually a lamb. Sin has poisoned man's blood (the biting of the apple) and the burnt offering was a means to repent as fire destroys the blood. Later Christ was the offering and we just have to accept this. Under this new guidance everyone will hear about Christ yet not all will accept while in the flesh. However, all will fall prostrate and declare Jesus is Christ and Savior when in front of the Throne during the Judgement. Some will be saved and others will be destroyed.

more to come...

by fluxit

As for the comment about meat on Fridays. One has to turn to the Bible for answers not man. What has happened in many Churches is rituals and ceremonies that are not in the Bible. For example, Baptisms at birth are not in the Bible. However, what is in the Bible is Baptisms as a declaration of faith after accepting Christ and one is in a new kind of person. You should note that Christ stands amongst the lamp stands as cited in Revelation. This means that Christ is in all the Churches but all the Churches are not completely correct. Revelation points this out in regards to the seven letters to the seven churches.

In reference to the dinosaurs, many people believe they are cited in the Bible. There are some versus where they discuss beast that resemble dinosaurs that were excavated. This not in Revelation where they discuss the 7 headed beast. I'll look it up.

In reference to an all-powerful god who is the architect of all creation really desire worship from finite beings such as ourselves? If so, isn't he not all that infinite, and maybe not so worthy of worship? God is transcendent and outside the time domain. He created us in his image and desires for us to make a choice to be with him. The Bible discusses humans transforming (accepting Christ) then transfiguring (after the 1000 year reign) before we are with God and can see him. So we are not finite. Read Revelation 20 through 22.

IRT: 'The creation of matter defies OUR UNDERSTANDING of the laws of physics. The airplane defied "the laws of physics" as understood at the turn of the century.' I am sorry but this is incredibly stupid comment. The concept of bouyancy has been around since archemedies discovered it and flight is a derivation of boyancy. Stability of a log in the water and a plane are not much different. We observed the principle throughout our Universe. Have you observed the sudden appearance of matter out of nothing. It defies the Physics principle of the conservation of mass and energy.

I got tons more but will take a break.

by fluxit

The universe according to some of you told in story form:

Well one day I was sitting at my dinner table eating beans and taters. Fascinated by the bouyance of ice cubes in my tea, I swirled the glass. When there was a loud bang! Before I could duck something smacked me in the head. Several hours later I came too. There was a large chunk of matter laying there next to me. I went to pick it up but it was just a little too hot. There was still dust and fumes in the air that was condensing and little pellets were falling onto the floor.

As I stood up and looked around I caught a glimpse in the mirror and saw that I had a black eye. I sure don't know where that matter stuff comes from but it sure causes damage to a lot of things.

by thechas

I might be mistaken, but I thought I heard that the current case against the pledge was over being required to recite the pledge in the first place.

The "under God" phrase was a secondary issue.

Further, the poor kids father went so far as to say that the option to not recite the pledge was a non-option.
The reason cited was the taunting that the child received on the playground after opting out of the pledge.

Chas

by pcnetworktech

The Bible says
"A fool saith in his heart, that there is no GOD"

In another scripture the Bible says "Every knee shall bow and every tongue shall confess that Jesus Christ is our Lord"

by jennifer.gardner

You only believe those things if you already believe in god. Non-believers don't care what the bible says. Really, would you really care either way if they changed the pledge? This isn't meant to be a debate over the existence of god.

by oz_media

As i heard it, the father had asked to remove the pledge but it was due to its referencing god, as he is an athiest.

by mrbill-

This ?father? has no custody rights for his child, the mother and her husband have complete rights and do not agree with his case. This ?father? is doing this for his own benefit, he is getting a lot of attention and has his own agenda.

by oz_media

Right there, but these things always get turned, twisted and misconstrued here, that's what keeps it interesting.

I mean can you imagine the boredom and redundancy to these discussions if one guy said America rules the world and is the most incredible country in the world, and then I didn't come in and say B.S., prove it?

It would turn into one of those discussion forums for the insecure, pose an idea and everyone else agrees with you.

What makes life interesting are the differences we all see daily. Change, criticism and PERSONAL conflict are what we feed on as people, that is what keeps us unique.

by road-dog

This universe and all matter is composed of matter "lost" in other and previous universes. You are standing on a ball of lost left socks and car keys that is 24000 miles in circumference.

This universe does indeed have it's limits as astronomers are now theorizing. It is expanding, however. This being the case, and "our" laws of physics may not apply to other universes, then matter was not "appearing" in violation of our laws, it may have been deposited in accordance with the laws of another. In other words, somebody had a lot of hydrogen (and other stuff) left over in another universe, and POOF... here we are!

This universe may well have been a cosmic flush of a toilet in another universe.

by fluxit

The most basic premise of physics is that all the laws affecting this universe are within this universe.

All you really did is allude to God as anopther universe.

Wake and smell the roses.

by road-dog

I applied theory as to the origin of the matter that makes this universe.

If the origin of ths matter defies the physical laws that bind and explain this universe, and there is belief that other universes exist, then I made the connection (in jest) that the matter here could have been deposited here from there.

Don't mystify this and personify it. If you want to give a name, a motive, and a plan to it all, that's your business. I alluded to nothing...You inferred it.

People have applied mystic and fantastic mythologies to explain everything from the cycles of the moon to the thunder in the sky.

Now our eyes see farther and our minds know more. Folks still have this need to apply some connection and order to it all through a divine being.

How is Christianity any different from any discarded religeon in the past? Zeus, Odin, and Ra were explanations for the natural world for their times.

Mythology is mythology. Faith is one's particular chosen and accepted mythology.

by mrbill-

HHHMMMM
Where does all that matter go that is being sucked into black holes? Could it be accumulating for another Universe?s big bang? How many parallel could exist on an infinite plan?

by fluxit

A black hole is a collapsed star that has burnt out. The material is inert thus not combustible. In fact, I question if there is any material at the apex of a blackhole. If Quantum Physics determined that there was a digital limit of our universe such that there comes a point of non-locality. Then the material that composed a star 1000's of times larger than our own star is compressed to the size of a pea suggests that it may become non-local or vanishes. I don't think we really know what is at the center of a black hole.

Nonetheless, no matter what model of the universe we develop there is never a true point of origin when matter was created. We only know at an instant later what happens.

I think it is safe to say that the Universe was created by someone - something beyond the limits of our Universe. Most likely a theological universe of which we are a subset.

by pcnetworktech

Non-believers will care when they stand before GOD for judgement.

This is the grace period that GOD has given us, to repent from our sins and belive on Jesus as our Lord and Saviour.

"If we confess with our mouth the Lord Jesus, he is faithfull and just to forgive our sins"

There is only one choice, that is to believe in Jesus or on the judgement day, GOD will cast all no belivers into the Lake of Fire. There they suffer forever (eternal suffering). Friends, this is our chance to believe in Jesus as our saviour. He truly loves us and that is the reason he is giving us the chance.

by cactus pete

All Jews and Muslims will go to hell? [Is that with an H?] And everyone who believes in other religions, they're doomed to the same result?

by fluxit

Yes. According to the Judeo/Christian Bible there is only one way to Heaven and that is through blood sacrifice of Jesus Christ. The Jewish people are not even practicing their faith today as outlined in the Torah (the first five books of the same Bible as Christians). However, God will deal with the Jewish people in a different manner than others since they are chosen by him. This is not completely clear to me and I need to study this aspect. But afterall, they have survived centuries of persecution only to be here today. Other civilizations have come and gone. Some without a trace.

As for the Islamics, the Koran was added onto the Judeo Christian Bible and makes Christ an insignificant prophet. God's name changes from God to Allah and the Koran is actually a warrior code. Jewish people will point out that the Bible can be summed up in two versus; Deuteronomy 6:5 and Leviticus 19:18. Compare this to Islam where they beg for his mercy and enemies are infidels to be destroyed? Why did the message change?

Consistently in the Judeo Christian bible the message is steadfast. In Leviticus, God discusses the Tabernacle with only one gate, then a burnt offering, a cleansing, as one works his way back to the ARC of the Covernant where people get close to God. Christ remarks in the New Testament that he is the only way, the gateway, to heaven.

As humans we are not to look down on these people who are lost but help them move closer to Christ. We can only give them the message and answer thier concerns. People come to God through Jesus of thier own decision. God often relates his relationship with man as a marriage. Would you marry a spouse with love if the decision was made for you?

by pcnetworktech

Yes! That is correct, everyone except those who belive in Jesus Christ, will land in Hell.
The children, who doesn't have the knowledge to choose the right from wrong, will also make it to heaven.

by fluxit

I think this is about God and an Atheist has a NULL for a God while others have a more exciting God.

So the Argument that to remove GOD because he does not believe in God is incorrect because his God is a NULL and he is fighting for him.

Other People have Gods that include sex, money, cars, and other material things.

Nobody is without God.

by cactus pete

I think that pretty well bastardizes the meaning of God [with a big G]. At least, "Nobody is without God" should have been a lower case..

And just beacuse someone worships something, doesn't make it their god...

by fluxit

In the Judeo Christian Bible it clearly states that one cannot worship two Gods. One will take precedence over the other.

Let us see what webster's says about worship, "The reverent love and devotion accorded a deity, an idol, or a sacred object." Deity sure sounds like a God to me.

I would say that an Atheist worships a 'NULL'. He even goes the to extent to fight for his removal from everything.

I think perhaps you should do a little research and learn what the Bible or at least Webster's has to say before blasting me.

by oz_media

Why not? I'm not sayign everything worshipped is a god, but you can choose to sorship ANYTHING and by putting your faith in it, see it as your god.

by road-dog

Neither have I (unless autorotations in helicopters count, and I had my eyes closed and my ass clenched tight)

You are pretty sure that they happen, right? Why? Because they leave evidence and folks have camcorders.

Just because we didn't see it happen, doesn't mean it didn't happen. Actually, it's probably likely that some amazing things happened before we were around to notice, like say, the big bang.

The creation of matter defies OUR UNDERSTANDING of the laws of physics. The airplane defied "the laws of physics" as understood at the turn of the century.

by oz_media

Actually I don't think I've agreed with someone's views and opinions in this forum as much as this before.

Your theory reminds me or a 'realization' I had after coming out of a coma in 1989. I have seen the world through much more casual eyes and with a much greater appreciation of my life here than ever before.

I personally put my faith in myself to lead myself in the right direction in life, as opposed to putting my beliefs in another higher power. Not to sound self centered but that's just my personal faith that keeps me going, I'm doing it for me and nobody else.

I would NEVER deny someone's faith in anything, many times in our lives faith is all one has to rely on. I have no interest in solving the "why and how are we here theory" because I am so contented with my life now, it doesn't matter to me what may or may not happen.

Although I believe strongly in man's evolution over time from a single cell organism, I also hold my self open to any 'final' possibility.
We have uncovered immense amounts of scientific information as to the origins of our existence, yet much is still speculation.

To try and derive certainty in this matter is impossible at this stage in our existence is as impossible as describing the size of outer space. The human brain is simply unable to conceive this yet.

Therefore, although I am quite sure of how "we" came to be, I will always welcome proof or thruth to the contrary.

by cactus pete

...in your religion, perhaps. But many religions have many gods [hence, the lower case 'g']. And many religions with only one are contrued [mis- or not] to have a different God than what you're [probably] meaning.

The point of not mentioning 'under God' is to recognize this difference. The arguement, it seems, is whether or not this matters.

by jennifer.gardner

I would think that most people who are offended by the phrase "under God" in the pledge couldn't care less what the bible has to say.

by blammer

I agree that it would probably be best to just modify, as opposed to drop it. But, I think the modification should omit the religious reference all together as opposed to just changing it. This way, we include the greatest number of Americans in the pledge.

by fluxit

Why does an Atheist God take precedence another God irrespective if the other God is from the Bible, Koran, or some other source?

Just because his God is a NULL and others have more exciting ones is not an excuse.

by oz_media

you should be Crusading to all other foreign countries who believe in a diiferent god and sort them out. (Hang on wasn't that tried before?)

If you're a child at heart wouldn't that count? For someone who forgives all mans sins, it sure does sound liek a pretty exclusive club when it comes to final judgement.

It is a good book though, you don't see writing as compelling as that anymore.

by pcnetworktech

God will judge everyone, but I just want to make sure I did everything right while I am on this earth.

If GOD was going to forgive people after death, then the Son of GOD, Jesus christ's death is invain.

I am telling everyone again, what do you got to lose to beleive a true GOD and Saviour Jesus Christ. It's free, Jesus has paid the price on the cross. Jesus loves you and today is your chance and you may never have the chance again.

I will not argue to prove the existance of GOD or which god or GOD is true. This argument can go on and on.

Jesus is the same yesterday, today and forever. Glory to GOD. AMEN!

by oz_media

"I am telling everyone again, what do you got to lose to beleive a true GOD and Saviour Jesus Christ. It's free, Jesus has paid the price on the cross. Jesus loves you and today is your chance and you may never have the chance again."

There is nothing to lose other than your existing faith and time spent adhering to a new faith that I may or may not feel strongly about.

I don't mean to deny your beliefs and I respect the fact that YOU have found faith.

Being agnostic, I am not willing to put all my eggs in one basket. I can't say you are wrong yet I won't say you are right either. TO this day there is NO concrete evidence of the creation of man and the universe.

There are many reasons to believe either way, I don't feel it is my duty to make a decision based on the evidence we have available to us today and instead choose to simply base my faith in life and how I live each day to it's fullest.

When the time for death arives, could be in five minutes, could be in 50 years, I have no control and THAT has been proven to me. Instead of tomorrow, I focus on today, end of story.

by cactus pete

I wasn't blasting you, honest.

But now...

Perhaps you should look up the meaning of the word "Or" as it is used in the definition you quote.

For that matter, let's finish the entire definition:

The reverent love and devotion accorded a deity, an idol, or a sacred object.
The ceremonies, prayers, or other religious forms by which this love is expressed.
Ardent devotion; adoration.
often Worship Chiefly British. Used as a form of address for magistrates, mayors, and certain other dignitaries: Your Worship.

by cactus pete

"Why does an Atheist God take precedence another God irrespective if the other God is from the Bible, Koran, or some other source?"

The point really is that, as far as the government is concerned, no god should be promoted above or have precedence over any other one. or lack of one.

by cactus pete

this IS a tech forum, after all...

I'm just saying that to worship doesn't necessarily mean you praise what you think of as a god. And that if you don't think of things as a god, then that would apply.

by fluxit

Agnostic: One who professes IGNORANCE, or denies that we have any knowledge, save of phenomena; one who supports agnosticism, neither affirming nor denying the existence of a personal Deity, a future life, etc

Why be ignorant? I suggest that you study the Bible, Koran, and other faiths and make a decision. Speak from a position of authority or knowledge.

General Krulak made an incredible speech in 1993 called 'Tattoo On Your Soul' to the Naval Academy. In his speech he talked about people who were principled based having something in thier blood racing through their viens that made them rise above others and distinguish themselves. You need to soar like eagles build yourself principles for your life. I believe this comes from wisdom - the kind of wisdom you will find when you seek knowledge.

I have given you a few verses here. check out these sites as well http://www.khouse.org and http://www.activeword.org. Both are faith based. However, khouse.org can get a little technical.

by cactus pete

n.

One who believes that it is impossible to know whether there is a God.
One who is skeptical about the existence of God but does not profess true atheism.
One who is doubtful or noncommittal about something.

adj.
Relating to or being an agnostic.
Doubtful or noncommittal: ?Though I am agnostic on what terms to use, I have no doubt that human infants come with an enormous ?acquisitiveness? for discovering patterns? (William H. Calvin).

by cactus pete

There is no decision to make. By definition, if you are agnostic, there is no way to know, no way to make a decision.

by fluxit

Ok let's bring this around to the digital universe. Time is a physical property and has a digital limit of 10 to the -43 seconds. This is coincidental the speed with which the Retina responds to a photon. In truth our universe is a digital simulation and we may very well live in a holograph.

I need to sudy this more but if any of you have any good gouge on this, please let me know.

by oz_media

Your definition of agnostic is one interpretation.
I don't plead ignorance to religion, I just don't believe in a single religion as the way I wish to live out the rest of my life.

Studying Christian or Koran beliefs will not solidify this for me. The bible, as good a bok as it is, does not prove anything to me. I understand how people put their fathin it, I also understand how people will CHOOSE to live thier lives via biblical guidelines, but I do not.

My CHOICE to not believe in a single religion or creator does not make me athiest because I don't DIS-believe in anyones theory of how we got here.

In your eyes it seems that if we do not choose YOUR beliefs, we are athiest, if we choose not to believe in YOUR God nor DIS-believe in YOUR God, we are ignorant?!

Almost as double standard as I see most of the bible.

I worked with a man last year who was VERY religious, he listened to sermons at his desk all day, in his car he read the bible and carried it at all times as he was an honorable Christian.

He is also a salesman who as most salesmen do 'colored the truth' once in a while to get a deal, therefore sinning. He was assured that his daily prrayers would leave him without sin on his judgement dday.

He also bought and smoked quite a bit of weed! Now is this a hypocrite? No, becuase in HIS eyes, he was again preying daily and being forgiven for his sins.

He is atill a practicing Christian and feels he does no wrong because he believes in the lord. Yet according to our laws, he is (WAS) a criminal.

There are too many 'exceptions' in Christianity to allow those who sin (and then repeat the same sin)to be forgiven. Yet, unless we all believe in God during our life, we will be cast into a fiery pit when we die. Why can God not forgive our disbelief in the way religion is practiced?

How do YOU know what we can and can not be forgiven for? Is that not decided on our final judgement day?

Like I say, too many questions, too many double standards and too many conflicting opinions on what and what cannot be excused. Your ideals may differ from another Christians, yet who is to decide who is correct?

Until someone captures God and an autopsy proves his existence, I'll be skeptical of ALL theories as to how and why we are here, especially when other theories make more logical and factual sense. Having spent a fair amount of time with native Canadian indians, I tend to like thier theories over Christian ones. As much as I don't believe in the fire god or that the crow is a god, I do believe that we should be thankful for the ability to make fire and praise the wildlife
that we see and interact with each day as opposed to a supposed religion written by a supposed witness to God's existence.

I've seen a crow, I've made a fire that fed and kept us warm, I haven't seen God (well there was that one time at the Iron Maiden concert but I'm pretty sure it was just a halucination).

by oz_media

That is like saying all fish swim, therefore anything that lives in water is a fish!

by pcnetworktech

Well..I understand you don't belive in GOD. God will not force His will on you today, but everyone will ultimately will be judged. This includes, christians and all.
Why not give GOD a try. Ask GOD to reveal himself to you and who knows, if you are sincere, HE may prove it you.

by cactus pete

Does your god want you to force others, who don't believe in Him, to recite His name in rote vain every day? Would it not be kinder to all people reconstitute the pledge to its previous form?

by oz_media

This is based on OUR understanding of time. In the same sense that we used to belive the world was flat (or banana shaped as Monty Pythons put it).

Using available information and a little specualtion we have also created what WE consider time to be. We could be awfully wrong in the end but I don't believe any of us will live long enough to know it.

Man at one time has thought many things, only to be proven wrong in the future as we develop our minds and abilities.

There seems to be a lot of specualtive suggestion here, the bottom line, no matter HOW long this thread gets, we will all arrive at the same conclusion, we were right all along.

Christians will feel correct and may pray for those of us who seem so mislead. Those feeling strongly about evolution or any other theory relating to the creation of mankind will feel the same. NOBODY REALLY KNOWS THOUGH!

When I was in a coma I was declared clinically dead at one point, I didn't go down the tunnel and toward the light to see my family members waiting for me (that I am conciously aware of).

When I was awakw and could comprehend who and where I was, I was looking out the window and realized that the trees looked greener than before and were almost superimposed on the world surrounding them (good drugs right?). This in itself, gave me hope and I became increasingly aware of those around me and cared for mankind a little more than I had before. I had a new found appreciation for nature ( I have always appreciated the world and nature but this was a stronger feeling than before ).

Some may surmise that this is God's way of giving me a sign, others say it was all the medication.
No matter which is correct, I am happy to be alive and am happy everytime I find myself awake to enjoy another day.

So whether you feel this makes me an athiest or agnostic, it is not an IGNORANT outlook but an open minded outlook that focuses on today and all that surrounds me, not just a reason to wait until I die to actually live in peace and happiness.

by jennifer.gardner

I always resented the implication that to be christian and to be a good person were mutually exclusive. I can be kind to others and live a moral life without being scared into it.

by cactus pete

I resent the "...or else you'll burn for eternity" line. If someone cannot defend their belief by just positives, it seems more as though it is just an attempt at brainwashing instead of a truly sincere source for 'good'.

by mrbill-

There is only One God!

That is not my call. It will be up to God. I can only say be ready. God will ask you: When your brother was hungry did you feed him? When I your brother was naked did you cloth him? When your brother was sick or in prison did you visit him? If you did not know your brother then you do not know God, and God will not know you. You will be removed from God?s sight. You do have a hope in Christ, who if you accept him will intercede for you. But if you truly know Christ then you would have said yes to the other questions.

by cactus pete

You stated:

"That is not my call. It will be up to God."

Then:

"...God will not know you. You will be removed from God?s sight."

You say you don't know what God would do, but then you say you do know what God would do.

Which is it?

Why can't someone just be a good person, without believing in your God, yet still feed the hungry and cloth the needy and heal the poor? Why is it prerequisite in your mind that good people are likely to go to hell lest they believe exactly what you believe?

by onbliss

I saw people refering to God as He or Him. Well, does God have a gender. I think God should be it, or why not She?

Thoughts to Ponder?

by cactus pete

God is supposed to be too complex for any human to comprehend, but many people appear to be experts, and very strict, at that.

Everyone should just be nice and honest.

by jennifer.gardner

You ever notice that christians are really the only ones who seem to force their beliefs on everyone else? Not very "christian" of them if you ask me.

by jennifer.gardner

I am, actually. But does it really matter? Regardless of my personal beliefs, you would insist that yours were right, and that I should be forced to say, "One Nation under god", "so help me god", "in god we trust" and on and on. You would continue to tell me that I'm going to hell (which I also don't believe exists) just for not agreeing with you.

by cactus pete

I was just bringing this back into the context of the begining thread - the Pledge of Allegiance and the words "under God". If you weren't posting within that context, I was mistaken on your intent.

For the record, I am a confirmed Catholic.

by cactus pete

But in the western countries, they do prevail. But yes, it doesn't appear very "Christian" at all.

by cactus pete

You aren't answering questions. You are saying that one will go to hell is one does not believe in Jesus, and you believe in Jesus so you won't go to hell.

That doesn't really explain much about your point, though it certainly explains a lot about something else.

by mrbill-

Do you believe in heaven? If you do then hell is not being in heaven. Whether it is a burning fire or just not exsisting anymore it is hell.

by mrbill-

In Islamic countries it is illegal to preach anything but Islam, no one forcing a belief system there. Although in most "modern" nations you can still believe in other religions, you can note talk to others about it.

by mrbill-

If you don't believe in heaven you cannot believe in hell. If you are a "good" person you may still go to heaven. It is up to God.

by mrbill-

I am NOT saying good people will go to hell if they do not believe in ?my? God. I am saying it will be God?s decision, he says so in his Book.

?Why can't someone just be a good person, without believing in your God, yet still feed the hungry and cloth the needy and heal the poor? Why is it prerequisite in your mind that good people are likely to go to hell lest they believe exactly what you believe?? You do not have to believe like I do to do these things. If God asks you face-to-face if you believe in him you would still say no.

by oz_media

It is a common scenario due to the feeling of not neing needed anymore.

It seems that even if this father was highly religious he would still take the athiest stand just to be able to control a part of his sons life. This is extremely common in first vs step fathers. It is a natural bahavior of man to be in control of his family, when the family is broken many fathers resort to violence in an attempt to regain control of those who have "betrayed" him. Often this leads to retaliation against his former wife, or her current boyfriend/husband. It shows power and that control it ous of her hands and still in his. It sounds very irrational and testosterone fed but this is a natural state of mankind, jealousy and insecurity.

I don't think the Pledge is the focus of his efforts more than the victory of winning at something that will control his childs life.

The saddest part to any situation such as this, the father may or may not gain a little security and self satisfaction but the child is the ultimate loser. Not only are his beliefs now being controlled buy someone who doesn't have a role in his life, it is now causing strife for his mother, her partner and the son.