Discussion Locked

Networking 2 buildings together

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am not even close to being considered a networking guru. I know little about it, and Im currently taking a college class dealing with networking. My problem is I've got a final project coming up soon, but I don't know what to do.

Basically my particular netowkring assignment is to network 2 buildings together. There are 40 computers between the 2, and they want both buildings to share the same inventory database. They are both warhouses about a mile apart, with houses and a creek running between them. Not to mention a large forest behind the houses. Both warehouses are on the same side of the road.

I don't really know which options are very viable, the only one I have right now is using a satellite connection to link the two, but even that sounds like a poor idea.

If anyone out there has a suggestion, I would appreciate it greatly... I don't need the specifics, but I need a nudge in the right direction.... thanks in advance!

19 replies

by stress junkie

Take advantage of the fact that the phone company has already done the wiring and offers frame relay service. Note that frame relay is not available in all locations.

Long ago Digital Equipment Corp. had a product that used microwave transcievers for cross-town links. They called it Metro-Link. I imagine that sort of thing is still available but I've never seen it in use.

I hope this helps. At least it should be food for thought.

by mrb398

I also forgot to mention.... my instructer gave explicit instructions that LAN only solutions are not acceptable :-p

by stress junkie

Neither of the two suggestions that I mention would be considered LAN. They are both wide area technologies.

I think that most professionals would go with frame relay. It is also called point to point leased line.

by jdclyde

A frame relay is a WAN connection.

Another affordable and simple solution is VPN over Cable Modems. Get the cable modem at each end and then create the VPN giving you a virtual tunnel over the internet to each location.

If you have covered VPN, I would STRONGLY recommend this, if not then go with the frame relay.

Good luck in class.

NOTE: you only got hints from people because you were up front about this being for your class. Lots of dweebs come in here and try to pass it off for a business solution instead of getting people to do their homework for them. You won't get a step by step here, but you will get pointed in the right direction.

by jbaker

If both locations have some type of broadband access, you could create a VPN tunnel between the locations. This would be cheaper than a leased line solution.

by johnnywatt

I'll tell ya why;
You are relying on the public internet. Although, I have never worked for an organization that used this method, I would hate to recommened this. Anyone feel me?

by tomsal

I wouldn't use it as my first choice to be the prime link between buildings personally. I'm a huge fan of dedicated connections for such tasks myself.

However I find our VPN highly stable and very reliable for our afterhours staff, and for myself and the other IT members who get calls on the weekend or wee hours of the night to re-boot a server, reset a service or "take a look at something" at 2 am. Beats the heck out of driving 30 minutes to work at that time of morning!

by jaqui

it's uses, but not for the proposed problem.
remote admin,
remote working yes.
wan, not the best solution.

but use vpn for project teams, that's an intended use.

frame relay, or, with the distance being about a mile you could also use laser to link.
the lowest cost for a proper connection for a wan would be the frame relay,
then the microwave tranceiver,
then the laser.

benefits:
frame relay you have someone else to chase to get the connection problems solved. ( the phone company deals with downtime )
the microwave solution, you may get interference with the transmition from later construction, weather, or even sattelite phones being used in the area.
or, worst case, one or both buildings are in a microwave zone, where they are getting microwaves beamed past them for ( usually telco ) other companies communications

laser, most expensive, most finicky to set up the hardware, you may need to get a third point between the two buildings to put a relay station up. future construction could remove the line of sight needed.

by tomsal

The terrain you speak of...the forests..the creek etc. basically meaningless in this case.

I'd agree with the first guy/gal that posted about the WAN connection that would be the way to go. Simply get a leased line T1 Frame-Relay.

The VPN broadband connection that was also mentioned is a good idea as well, but keep in mind you may not get some "perks" that you do with leased lines.

Leased lines are intended for businesses, that's what they are for. Period. They cost more money but you have an SLA with them. Comcast doesn't guarantee you any level of service and they sure don't guarantee uptime -- Verizon DSL doesn't either. I don't even think their "business plans" do.

With a leased line the bandwidth is dedicated and its guaranteed, if it goes down you have the right to emergency service to fix the problem and re-imbursement (financially) of course it all depends how your SLA is written, ours has language in it that says we get compensated for down time over x amount of time past with our connection being down.

by cbsmith

Working for A CLEC, I get this type of question on a regular basis. there is more than one way to achieve your connectivity goals.

Layer 1
Leased line. typically a t-1, fractionial is possible. the benfits are low latency and security. The cost a only a mile is problably fairly cheap. the LEC would most likely consider this a "zero mile" connection: both ends of the circuit terminate in the same central office. the down side is that traffic is dedicated to these two locations ( the remote location can go through this pipe to get somewhere else). The other part of the exposure here depends on the distance from each premise to the CO.

Layer 2
Frame relay. this can be a good solution but will be more costly at this distance and number of locations. Besides both ends would terminate on the same switch.

layer 3
IP VPN/ site-to-site VPN/ CPE based VPN. this is what most people think of when the term "VPN" is mentioned. uses the internet as transport but with encription to secure the communication between the two sites. Can be inexpensive to deploy ( DSL or cable IP bandwidth is relatively cheap) the SLA issues brought up above are quite valid. there are also possible performance issues with DSL and cable due to oversubscription. Off the shelf CPE that can handle this is cheap, too.

MPLS VPN layer 2.5 or 3.5 depending on your point of view
This is technology that moves the security from the CPE to the provider's network. It is like layer 2 (frame, ATM) but at layer 3 (IP). this would probably be more costly than a pvt line at this distance and number of locations.

WIMAX
this is a new wireless technology( 802.16 / variant of 802.11x)that will allow distances up to 25 miles. gear is just starting to roll out.

other wireless
There are other wireless solutions that use licensed or unlicensed spectrum.

hope it helps

by tomsal

Informative post cbsmith. Though, personally I wouldn't choose WIMAX for this for the three basics reasons of security, expense and just the fact its a very new technology.

We use Frame Relay over T1 (actually we have multiple T1's now), which works well for us.

I'm guessing they are most likely looking for cost effective and secure solutions.

by jbaker

In my previous solution, it seems that everyone is assuming that I am recommending the sites to use a consumer level broadband product. I am not. In my experience, a pair of T1's (which could get you an SLA, if you negotiate it into the contract...remember you are the customer and they want your business), with identical routers and a secure tunnel (VPN) would be cheaper than a pair of 128 KB ISDN lines (what the leased lines usually end up being), in addition to the added bonus that you would get static IPs, enabling you to host your own webpage, if you so desired, and giving the users fast internet access.

At least, that is how I would do it (and have done it several times in the past).

by stress junkie

... mentions that people are being helpful because the poster was honest about this being a classroom problem. I was thinking the same thing just before I read your other post. Just contrast the reponse to this question with the reponse to the "5,000 computers to network" question.

I notice that your penguin is bigger than mine. I'm not surprised. That's exactly why I stopped going to the health clubs. Seems like everyone's penguin is bigger than mine.

by jmgarvin

I would install directional microwave. The only problem is LOS. Another way to do this is via psuedo satellite.

If they can't be on a LAN you have to do it through a WAN? Why not just lease a T1 and have a secure tunnel connect the two sites?

by doug m.

I work for a school district with two buildings and we use a T1 line between the two, although that is slowing down lately and we're adding a second T1 line.

by johnnywatt

You definitely account for the estimated amount of bandwidth going to be used and plan for future growth. 35 workstations could easily work on a fractional T line and later expand for example.
One org. I used to work for started with this solution and expanded to a full T.

by jellimonsta

The kids are sick and you are unable to make it into the office. It is great to be able to work from home (even though I only live 1 mile away) :)

This discussion is closed to new replies.