Question Locked

New Hire Not Doing Work They Accepted Position For

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm looking for some advice. I have my own thoughts (imagine that!) about this situation and have been going back and forth with what, if anything, to do. So your feedback will be greatly appreciated in helping me finalize an approach on how to handle this.
A couple of months ago I interviewed a tech writer, explained the job and her specific role in detail, even gave a quick 3 question "quiz" to test her knowledge and experience.
She was by far the best candidate I had interviewed for this position, was available immediately, and within our price range. I made her the offer and she quickly accepted and joined the company.
The problem began with our program being "forced" to take on existing employees from other programs because their contracts expired or were lost. As a result, a mini re-organization was done and the tech writers, including this new hire, were now reporting to one of the new managers we were "forced" to take on.
So naturally, the role I had painstakingly described for the new tech writer was changed, unfortunately to less responsibility, less "additional" duties she was told she would become involved with and/or own. Needless to say (so why am I saying it?) the new tech writer is not happy at all - not with her new manager, not with her current role, and not with her long-term prospects with this company.
I've already talked to both the new manager and our Program Manager about this situation and neither of them seems to share my concern. Perhaps I'm more sensitive to this since I hired her with a specific role and now that she is not doing it and unhappy I feel guilty about it.
So now that you have the background, here is my question: "Do I go to the next level (our Sr. VP) and explain this situation, letting him know we are going to lose this productive worker because of the changed role enforced upon her, and my previous attempts to make her manager and the PM aware of this have been ignored, or do I leave it alone and let her decide whether to stay or go?"

10 replies

by thechas

What you have is a true sticky wicket.

Any way you look at, it is apt to be a loose loose situation for you.

If you had no idea that the changes were coming, I recommend that you clear your conscience and move on. I would not even talk it over with the new employee.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.....when he mentions the obvious lose-lose situation.

It might provide the answer to step one out of your dilemma. Go to her and explain yourself (as I suggested in my other message), and ask her if she'd be willing to explore and discuss ways to find some sort of a win-win out of this mess. You can't go back to where you were, but only start from where you are. What's the best possible win-win that could be found? If there is none, and any possible outcome would only be a win-lose, lose-win, or lose-lose, then she'll probably choose to leave (and maybe retain a lawyer).

Look for the win-win, and therein lies the answer.

by maxwell edison

.....to quit, on the spot, and without notice. If it were me, I'd go to her and apologize for the turn of events and explain that it was caused by circumstances beyond my control, and that it was as much as a surprise to me as it was to her. I'd also say that I'd understand if she decided not to stay, and that I would give both a great reference and an explanation for the time-gap in her employment history. (But of course, the choice is hers.)

I'd then go to the powers that be and explain to them that she feels duped and misled, and rightfully so, and that if she incurred any additional expenses because of the job misrepresentation, she'd have a good case to file suit against the company to recover damages. You just don't hire a person for one thing and then put them into a different role without realizing the risk of negative repercussions.

If she actually quit another job to take that one, you guys might be libel for some big bucks. If I were you I wouldn't necessarily go down that path with her, but is she was my sister or wife, I'd advise her to go see a lawyer.

by wayne m.

Reorganizations are a fact of life in large corporations. Let the new manager take responsibility for his organization and do not try to undermine his authority.

When a transition occurs, the old manager has two responsibilities. One, inform the staff of the transition. Two, give the new manager a quick thumbnail description of his new staff. The old manager should not entertain any complaints from his old staff; the manager should politely suggest that issues be raised with the new manager.

I would strongly recommend against raising the issue up the managment chain, or even continuing to raise it. Doing so would most likely be viewed as a political battle bewteen you and the new manager, no matter how well intentioned your motives may be.

by baquaviva

Thanks for the feedback. If this were indeed a large company I would certainly feel different, but since we're talking about a 25 person organization it's hard to just shrug your shoulders and say "oh well". However, I have decided to drop the issue, mainly because I'm accepting a position with a new company. I'm not sure I want to separate myself from the human aspect of work, so I'll have to keep looking for a middle road in situations like this.

by patriotsbruinschick

I appreciate your attention to the human aspect of your job as a manager. I have been on the receiving end of a similar situation. Worked for Company A, and though there were no mergers, acquisitions, or anything, they moved me from supporting division 1 to division 2. VP of the area spoke to me about it, but never with new boss who knew the role better in the same room. I was told it was a project management position with excellent growth opportunities. It turns out that I got a masters degree to scan barcodes and physically check that bags of merchandise do contain the actual pieces listed on the paperwork. A large percentage of my day is spent 'making work' for myself to 'do'. Fun. New manager in Div 2 doesn't care. Doesn't listen. Div 1 manager is still very awesome & makes work bearable until I can find a better use for my masters degree.

by khongphutu

I totally agree with Wayne. In addition, I would NOT apologize, but simply explain to the new hire the nature of business -- that change is the fact of life and learning to accept it along with learning to see changes as new opportunities is the proper attitude. Unless the new hire plays a vital role in the organization and her retention is a must, this meeting should be suffice. If her retention is a must, then your job is to inform the chain of command the potential disruption to the business due to an impending loss of a key employee. That's it.

I am rather surprise that a new hire could play a role that important to an organization, especially after a reorg with less resposibility. This sounds like that new hire is not in a key role position and therefore key retention should not be an issue.

by jamesrl

In my province, and in other jurisdictions, there is a term called "contrsuctive dismissal" which means that your job responsibilities have been dimimished through no fault of your own, and you have the right to seek redress(compensation).

I would NOT undermine the other manager. That is a way to find yourself out the door.

You acted in good faith. Don't feel guilty. You talked to her new manager and another manager, and so you have made an effort.

The employee you hired has gone through something many of us have faced. It is up to her what she does about it.

I'm serious, you could find yourself fired if you go up the food chain to complain.

James

by erniegs

Let the current Manager do the job of managing his newly assigned staff. You have no control over Higher Level authority, therefore, to continue to pursue the issue, puts you, the new manager, the current staff and the new hire in jeopardy. Let her show her stuff, she can act and speak for herself -- if she is good enough she will land on her feet at your company or another.

It isn't that people resist change so much as the way it happens and presented.

ErnieGs
Columbus, Oh

This discussion is closed to new replies.